High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1270/2016dismissed

Jai Raj & ANR v. Shyam Lal

2016-09-19Mr. Justice Arun Palli7 pages

!"# $% #$&' %'( *++

$ $,$%$&-'. //'00$&) 1'.)2) -3$45$0 ')/%'&

.')'&* .$4 &6-2.$$7%1($&'7

.&-'$//'00$&) 5 7 .$0

!3&- )$//0 ($& 7&-'%$&' -'$.

8 &- )$//'$0 ))28-& &9'$%1$('%7&-'8.2%&-$&:$..$&) /))')) -$1'9'' ))2'%7

';'(2& /.(''% 8) ('& (':$))& 00&9' ))2'% &-'$//'$0 &)'0 7&-'

$//0 ($& )$(('/&'%$%&-'$//'$0 )&$<'2/ .-'$.

8&%$3 &)'0 &- )$//'$07&-'%'

'%$&)7:-$.'&-')$%%$28-&'.

0$: &-'.')/%'&

7)''<.'1'.)$0 &-',2%84'&)$%%'(.'') &-'0'$.'% 0 2%8' 2 .# 7"$42$$8$.$& $8$%-.

7$% &-'0'$.'%%% $0# )&.

(& 2%8'7"$42$$8$.$& $8$%-.

793:- (- &-')2 & &-'/0$

:$)%'(.''% $12.$%&-'$//'$0

0'%$8$ )& &-',2%84'&$%%'(.'':$)% )4 ))'% ='.39.

037&-'.')/%'&

)>)2 &)28-&$%'(.''

4$%$&.3 ,2(& % .'(& 8&-'$//'00$&) '%$&)&1$($&'$%-$% 1'.$(&2$0/-3) ($0/))')) '.4&-'

.)& 0.7 (02% 8$

(44(2.&3$.%7)&$ .($)'70$&.

'$%9$&-.47 $%290')&.'3'% .') %'& $0-2)':'%93&-'/0$

7 2003%')(.

9'% &-'/0$ &

0'% -'/0$

-$%)&$&'%&-$&-':$).') % 8&-'8.2% 0.

&-')$ %-2)'$%&-$&- ))$%%$28-&'.

0$:7 '&-'%'

'%$&)7 :'.'?2$..'0)4'$%:'.'% ).')/'(& 20&:$.%)- 47&-28--':$)@ 3'$.) $8' &:$) 2.&-'.)&$&'%&-$&%2'&&-'4 )9'-$1 2. &-'

'%$&)7-'-$%$)<'%&-'44$3& 4')&1$($&'&-'/.& ((2/ '%93 &-'47:- (-$((.% 8&&-'/0$

7&-'3:'.'((2/3 8$)0 (')'')$% &-$&-'-$%'1'&2$003)'.1'%$& (' .)2(-1$($& @ A93 .'8 )&'.'%#/)&7$0)$)< 8&-'4&/$34')'/.

&&- 4$ &'.';/ .3 &-'& ('/'.

%7B) /'.4&- A

/& (' ))2'%&&-'47&-'%'

'%$&)-$%

0'%$, :.

&&')&$&'4'&%'3 8&-'(&'&) &-'/0$ &$%)&$& 8&-$&&-')2 /./'.&3:$)$(&2$003$(')&.$07:'%93&-':

')>) )&'. -.

--&$ 5$078.$% $&-'. &-'

.)&%'

'%$&$%4$&'.$0$2& &-'/0$

& :$) 2.&-'.(&'%'%&-$&)-'-$%$%/&'%&-'

.)&%'

'%$&:.803 &3/'%$)/0$

&-',2%84'& &-'0'$.'% 0 2%8'$%$) )2(--'-$%9''0 8 &-'-2)'$) &):'. & :$) )& 00 2.&-'. /0'$%'% &-$& &-'

.)& %'

'%$& -$% .'()&.2(&'%&-'8.2% 0. &-')$ %-2)'4$3& 4'):

&-- ):

2%)$%&-$&&-'

.)& 0.:$)':03()&.2(&'%93- 4))2(--'$% - ):

':'.'0 8&-'.'$):'.) &-'-2)'$%&$)0 (')'')$% $(&2$003&-'/0$

-$%(('.:

&-&-'/./'.&3 &:$) 2.&-'.(&'%'%&-$&%'

'%$&:$)0 8 &-'

-2)') ('-'.4$..

$8'$%$))2(-7 &:$)-'.4$&.

4 $0-4' :- (-

A )-'-$%8 1'9 .&-&&-'

. 2.(- 0%.'7 :-4&:-$%9''4$..

/&-'/0'$% 8) &-'/$.& ')7&-' 00:

8&: ))2') :'.' .$4'%*

D E-'&-'. &-' /0$

) '& &0'% . &-' .'0 '

4$%$&.3 ,2(& $)/.$3'% .F E-'&-'.&-')2 & )&4$ &$ $90'F#G @ -'/0$

';$4 '%- ):

'$)E$%- 4)'0 $)E '$0).'0 '%2/1$.

2)%(24'&)7 (02% 8$0'8$0& ('$%$/)&$0 .'('

/&7$)$0'%''% .%27$&.$)0$& &-$&)$0'%''%%$&'% @+@+7 $-2)'&$;.'('

/&$%'0'(&.

( &39 00)

).'8$.%)&-'%'

'%$&)7%'

'%$&/.')'&$//'00$& &')&

'%$)#E$%%'

'%$&&')&

'%$)#E7:

&-&-'4

2.&-'..'03 82/%(24'&$.3'1 %'(' &-')-$/' $:'%% 8($.%7 .$& ($.%$%&-'

.1&'. %'& &3($.%)

/$//.$ 8&-''1 %'('$%&-'/0'$% 8)7&-'0'$.'% 0 2%8' 2%&-$&$)/'.&-')$0'%''%; 7%$&'% @+@+7&-')2 /./'.&3-$%9''$(?2 .'%93&-'/0$

$%&- $(&:$)$0)$%4 &&'% 93%'

'%$& )(.)) ';$4 $& 7:-$0)$%4 &&'%&-$&&-'

'0'(&.

( &34'&'.:$)& )$4'$%&-$&&-'42 ( /$0.'(.%$0) .'

0'(&'%&-'/./'.&3&9' &-':'.)- / $&-'.7&-'/0$

'('7 &:$)((02%'%93&-$&2.&&-$&&-'%'

'%$&)& -$1 89''$90'&'

&-'.% )/.1'&-')$0'%''%.&)2//.&&-'

.)&$%

:'.)- / &-'/./'.&37&-')2 &/./'.&3:$)$(&2$003 &-':'.)- /

&-'/0$

C H -28-&-' ))2' &-'%'

'%$&)9'

80 (')'')7&-'

0'$.'% 0 2%8'-'0%&-$&$)($&9')$ %&9'$0 (')'' &-'

/./'.&3 $&-'.7-:'1'.7-':$)91 2)03 /'.4 )) 1'/))')) &-'.' $)- $&-'.)>)792&:

&-&-' $&-'.08'.:

)- 8&<''/- )$%%$28-&'.

0$: &-'/.'4 )')7)2(-/'.4 )) 1'/))')) '%'% $%$))2(-7&-'/0$

:$):

&- ).

8-&& ))2'& ('2%'.'(& &-'.$) '. ./'.&3(&7HH7-'9'

8$0%/'.):--$% $.

8-&&',3- )/./'.&3/'$('

2003 + )'?2'&037&-')2 & &-'/0$

:$)%'(.''%7% .'(& 8&-'

'%$&)&-$%1'.&-'1$($&/))')) &-')2 &/./'.&3&&-'

&- &: 4&-) &-' %$&' &-' ,2%84'&7 /$))'% C -' /.')'& $//'00$&) '%$&) -$1 8

0'% $ $//'$0 9'

.'&-'0'$.'%

.)&$//'00$&'2.&7&-$&2.&$0)7$ &'.% )(2)) 8&-'

$(&)$%&-''1 %'('0'%7$)$0)&-',2%84'& &-'0'$.'% 0 2%8'7

2%&-$&&-'/))')) &-'$//'00$&)&-')2 &/./'.&3:$)&$) :'.)92&) 4/03/'.4 )) 1'/))')) 8.$&'%&&-'493&-'/0$

:- (-($4'&$'%:-'-'$)<'%&-'4&1$($&'&-'/.'4 )')7$ &'.

:- (-&-'3:'.'&'& &0'%&.'&$ $3/$.&&-'.' )'?2'&037&-'$//'$0:$)$0)% )4 ))'%70'$% 8&&-'

8 &-'/.')'&)'(%$//'$0 .$4 &6-2.$$70'$.'%(2)'0 .&-'$//'00$&)7)294 &) &-$&$//'00$&-$1 89''9. &-')$4'-2)'-$%$.

8-&& (& 2'&.') &$%&4$ &$ $4 03&-'.'

/)/'(

(?2'.393&- )2.&7$)&:-'&-'.&-'$//'00$&)

@ -$%9''$90'&/.1' $34$'.&-$&&-')2 &/./'.&3:$)$(')&.$07 0'$.'%(2)'0$%4 &&'%&-$&&-28-)2(-$1'.4'&:$)4$%'7 &(20%& 9'/.1'%&9')'$0)(20%&%'3&-$&&-')$0'%''% &-')2 /./'.&3 $12. &-'.')/%'&

:$)-'0%&9'/.1'%$%&-'

&-'.'

.' 2%&9'&-':'. &-'/./'.&3 $1 8() %'.'%&-'$ .')$ %7

%4'.

& &-'$//'$07

1 ': &-' $(&&-$&) 4/039'($2)'$(- 0%(& 2')&.') &-'

/./'.&3 $&-'.7%2.

8- )(- 0%-%931 .&2' &-'01'$% $

'(& $%/$.'&$0%2&3 &-' $&-'.7$%)29)'?2'&037 $%20&-%&-'

$&-'.$00:)- 4&(& 2'&.') &7&-$&%')&(.'$&'$.

8-& &-'(- 0%&(0$ 4&-'/./'.&3&9'- ):720'))7 (2.)'7 &%'101'% 2/&-' $&-'.$0)$)$(')&.$0/./'.&3 &-'/.')'&($)'7&-'.')/%'&

-$1 89''/.1'% &-$1'$(?2 .'%&-'/./'.&3931 .&2' $)$0'%''%; 7 &-'3'$.

+@+791 2)03 &:$)&$(')&.$0/./'.&3$%.(20%&-'$//'00$&)

'%$&)0'$%$3'1 %'('&/.1' &&9') '('7:

&-&-' $&-'.&9'

8-$//3:

&-&-'(%2(& )$%%$28-&'.

0$:7$%-'08'.:

)- 8&-$&&-'3)-20%(& 2'

& .') %' - ) /./'.&37 &-' / &- ) 2.&7 &-' (& 2'% ((2/$& &-'$//'00$&)7:$)93/'.4 )) &-'.')/%'&7& 00)2(- 4'$)-'$00:'%&-'4&.') )-2)' A -2)7 $(&7&-'0'$.'% 0 2%8'-$)'..'% -0% 8&-$& &-'$//'00$&):'.'&0 (')''):-'.'$)7$)$4$&&'. $(&7('&-'

.)& $//'00$&$&&$ '%$%20&-%7-':$)&9'() %'.'%&9'$0 (')''7 :

&-2&$3 &'.')&(.'$&'% 47?2$&-')2 &/./'.&3

0 (')' )%'

'% '(& @ &-'% $$)'4'&)(&7 HH7$) 00:)*

D@ E-'.''/'.)8.$&)&$&-'.7 .&$%'

&'249'. &-'./'.))7$.

8-&&%7.

(& 2'& %7 .2/&-' 441$90'/./'.&3 &-'

8.$&.7)4'&- 8:- (-:20%7 &-'$9)'(' )2(-.

8-&7 9'20$:

207$%)2(-.

8-&%')&$42&&$'$)'4'&.

$ &'.')& &-'/./'.&37&-'.

8-& )($00'%$0 (')'G -'.'

.'72/$//'00$&-$1 8$&&$ '%4$,.

&37-'

8$00:'%&(& 2'&.') &-'-2)' $&-'.7-'$(&2$003 :20%9'$0 (')'' &92&:

&-.

8-&(.'$&'% &-':'.)- / &-'

/./'.&37 &-'$9)'(' $3%(24'&';'(2&'%93&-' $&-'.7(.'$& 8 )2(-.

8-&. &'.')& &-')7 ' $//'00$& C ).'8$.%)&-')2 &/./'.&39'

8&-'4$&.

4 $0-4'

$//'00$&72%29&'%037:- (-'1'.-4')-':'& &$%.') %'% :

&--'.-2)9$%7:$)-'.4$&.

4 $0-4'"'&7931 .&2' &9'

8$ 4$&.

4 $0-4' &-$&.')/'(&7 &(.'$&'%.

8-&.& &0' &-')'(% $//'00$& '%$&&9'$:'..( :'. &-'/./'.&37) 4/03 9'($2)')-')&$3'%&-'.'931 .&2' 9'

8-'.-2)9$%)>)/2)'7:

&-&-'

-2)9$%- 4)'0 &-$1 8$3.

8-& :'.)- / &-'/./'.&3 @ &'.4) )'(& &-'% $$)'4'&)(&7HH7 $0 (')'($9'.'1<'%'

&-'.';/.'))03.'1'93$3$(&%'93&-' (').8.$&.(1'3 8- &'&&.'1<' &&-'/.')'&($)'7&-'

-$1 8

.)&.$003$)<'%&-'$//'00$&)&1$($&'&-'/.'4 )')$% &-'.'$ &'.-$1 8 ))2'%$& ('&&-'47%203/.1'%9'

.'&-'0'$.'%

2.&)9'0:791 2)037&-'0 (')'&((2/3&-'/./'.&3)&%.'1<'%

44'% $&'037 :

&- .

8-& &-' $//'00$&) & (& 2' & 0 1' &-'.'$ &'. 1'&-'.:

)'7-3/&-'& ($0037

.$3.'$)&-'$//'00$&) :'.' & & 9' &.'$&'% $) 0 (')'')7 &-'

. /))')) (& 2'% & 9'

/'.4 )) 1'/))')) & 00)2(-& 4'$)&-'3:'.'$00:'%&(& 2'& .') &-'-2)'93&-'.')/%'&

7$%&-'.'$ &'.7&-'.' $3 ($)'9'

8&'1'$/0'$ $%1'.)'/))')) .$ )'%7:- (-:20%9'

(20& .$)&.$ )'&-'.:

)'$0)7&-'$//'00$&):'.'92%& 1$($&'&-')2 &/./'.&37&-'3-$1 8.

8-& &7('&-'& ('/'.

% :$)1'.72/)'.1 (' &-'& ('%$&'% @ A7;72/&-'4 '('7 .&-'.'$))$ .')$ %7

%$9)02&'034'.

& &-'$//'$0 5'$.'% (2)'0 . &-' $//'00$&) 0$)&03 )294 &) &-$& &-'

:$..$&) /))')) 4$3&9'';'(2&'% . %$3)7&'$90'&-'

$//'00$&)&)''<$0&'.$& 1'$((44%$& )'?2'&037:- 0'% )4 )) 8&- )$//'$07';'(2& &-'

:$..$&) /))')) ))&$3'% . %$3)03 & )4$%'(0'$.&-$&&-'$//'00$&):20%-$1'. 8-&&)&$3 &-' /./'.&37 $ &'. &-' ';/ .$& %$3) .4 &%$37 ' & H+ .%'.$)&()&) ++

E-'&-'.)/'$< 8.'$)'% "') E-'&-'.'/.&$90'

"')