← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/1752/2017allowed

State Of Haryana Thr. Fc And Ps Govt Of Hry, Health Dept., Chandigarh And Others v. Nishi Bala

2020-02-12Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma,Mr. Justice Harinder Singh Sidhu8 pages

       

   

    





  !

" #  $ % #     '((    "

&*    

  !"! #    ! !! 

  +

( ,* #  '   ' -   % #      +)$& .

'   ///  !! #  $  % #  &    & 1



  '(( 2   & 3"2.

  445

    &*  $ % #    67&

# 7 ( 

# &  7      3   & %  &   $  &    8% 7 2"  4   $& &   & 7 ( &  22 &   5 49 :

;7&

#  .   '  .

  & 

  4   .  7   & 2 " &

   &   & <.

 &+7 #0 27&&7  

  ( =" ' $  " " 94;9 ;

'"  

2  " 

$&  ="  & ="   5 

 & 7          '

5   $ % #  &  .

 & % #  $ 9'"  

2  ;" 

 ' $  "  7 & &  #  & 2   ' $   ( "

7 >

  

 

     

       

 

 

! "

#  $   

! " 

!

 "  "

   #

     

  

   

 

 



     

     



    ! "   



  

!       ! !

 "

!

  %&''      " "     "

      ( 

   !

   $

 ( 

   

! 

   !

 $

 ( 

  

  

  ! 

 !

  ! ""

!      ! !

 "

  !

  %&'' 

 !

!



"



! $

!            & 

      

       

 $   

 

 

! "

&#  $  



! " 

!

 "  "

  $ &#      

  

   

 

 



     

  

$ 

        !

!

 "

 !

  %&''  

   ""     "

            (  

      !

  $

  ( 

   

! 

 !

 )       (  

     



    ! 

 !

  ! ""$     !         !   !

 "

 !

  %&''$

  !

!



"



! $

!  

 "       

""    

  " "  ! "  

 !

!



 

 % *

" 

 

  

$



 "      "  

         

!   ! !

 "! "

 

     

     

      "   !

"  +  !

        !

")  ,     !

      

 

"!

 !

 

   $  "   "

  "  

     -

 %  '( " 9; " 9; (     7  ##  2"    #  =" 

2 ! $ ' $    #'( " 94;9 ;

- .

  & "

 

(

 < &2& (  '( "

94;9 ;

 & (     #  &    & " 

"  8 '( % #  %  & "2

    1 #  % "  ?

  9- "(:;  $  "  

       

 &   ="     <(   ( 

   "2$    "  ./ 0/1   2    

 0  /   0 ) 

 3!

       2      "

 

  ",  56  / *  +!  

2 ) / 3 2 /  7"

4    "

 1 2 8    ) / 1" !

7  " ")- 0&"      ="     ( 

    ="      +7

0 2 . 2@ A  "

BC  # 5 0&"   & 

("

# & (     (  ="  +7

0 2 7 

#  &      C   "  &      7  # &     +7

0 2  

 &     7       (    ="  "& ="   1$2  &  7 "("

 &    #

   $  & 

( (  "2 &   .

  ! . &  7  "    (,  &

.

 2  +7 #0 2

7&& "  &    ="2 & ="   7 & .

  ="

 #  

  '  A 7  #  "   (   &  &   "  ="

+7 0 2 ( 5 A 7  &"&  &  &

((    "    ="  +7 0 2

< 2 &

  ' ' 2# 7   0&

 ' <" :7    0&   7  <

  ' &  .( 2#   

1   "   (( 2   

&     $   % #   &  & 7 2# " 7  (, &

.

 2  +7 #0 2   &  &   7   (" 2  &

   &  7 & .

  %  &  &  "    ((#2 +7 # 7   %   &  .

  ## "     . &   -  %  &$ 2  .

   " +7 # "2 &

# 7 (   & (    "   

 . &   -  %  &$

% #     $"2

 ( +     % (  '.

?   *&7  %  *?% (  !  E

 & +  $"(    % #  $

F$A% (  ! 

(  D 2 &E'+  $"(   B$  +   

-   % (   % #   $   +     AB B +      .." #%  &   B . #%  &  

% #  $  ="2 &  

 2 & " 

    &     $  7 ,2"          2  &   ((       &  +7 #     + & 

'( .   ((  7    7 & &

" A 7   (   &  ((      "

 4 

7 "

   .(

 ((  7 "

    "2 & #  &1 '

  &  ( 

     .    "      48

8  9':;

 8

9':;



9':4;

 9':;

49':;

549':8;

49':5;

 49':;

59':

; 89':;

85  9':;  5  9':;     9':4;

    2 ((   2$  +7 #   *

     445& 

 7&& & 

  & "

.   ((   8

 $  +   -  % ( 

7   2&  .

 %  .

7 

..

  & 

"

.   "    4

 7      & 

 ( 7&& &  &  ="

 ((  +7 #0 2



8 $&

&  ((  +7 #  2  8 " 

 

   + &   &7      2"

 , "

      A  $

 

 &  7 # 5  ((      2 7&&"  &  .

 $& 7    (  7 &   D"

0& + &  $

 &7      2  A      &   ((  7



 &   .

  2$  +7 #    &  &  "    2  ((    7  

"2&    $   & % (   &  & #7

& , 7 2  

"&2   7     #& &

 (

2

    & & & 

2

    +7 #0 2 (  ((#2

 .

A & 7 ( & & &  2  &   

7&

#  .   '      .(   # 7   0& 7 ( 7 ( 5  " "

" .

7&   & 

(    72    ' 7 $& 7 2 

 # . , (     2   "

  4 A

  "  7&& & ((   &     (  2 (&7  &  . #   & & "

. ((   2&   2

" &  ="

 & 

 % # ((  &   < 7  8

   &  <(    ((  7   

& 

"

 

 '  '( "  ( 2   & 7 (  & &     7   ( 2 &  ".

. #  "

     "  7&  &     " 2  &  +7 # & 

2    ' $    &  & & 

  ( 2 (, &

#7& 2  2  '

   #22  <  . # "

$   +" :

"( %  & ,   A 7 &

2  &  &

((      ( # (, &

 (" 2$  +7 #0 2



 "  . &

A  ((  &  &    2" #"

"  2 ((   .  "

2 ("

 +7 # 0&    ((# 

$&  ((

#    8    &    .

 7   "     &    &   $

 8 ' 2#  & ((   0& 3"2.

1 $2    0& 7 ( .  ("! ) ( !! )      *+,-.,/ #

2  & $( ,2B  G & 

B