High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3620/2013dismissed

Saroj v. Matu Ram Etc.

2018-11-20Mr. Justice Fateh Deep Singh12 pages

!"#$%&'

##('&&"

" " !

# $%"

#' ))))) #('&&"*$ (" # $ ! !"

$$& & )*& !

# ,- " $ .! *& / 0"1 1",- $ # ,- " #$

2# & )*& ! '

# ,- " $ 3 $

*& . 4"

* "

, " $ 3*"

, $$1 )*& ! '

* $,-"#2#$

1 ! /,

"#2#$

"1 #"5

2''

6 $", $ 9+95!*,-0 : ! ! "*&" 4 # *& !

9+7# ! $* 9+7$ ); * + 9 9+9 ! " ,

" *!## , $$& $ *$$

,&&" "#$

$ ,$, < # - !=* $ $ # )*! & $ & " * $ " , )*& ! 9+7 / "

0 1 1 # " 5 28" "

$ *& 7' $ $ " $ 6 $ $ " #$

#" 1 $ "#< , =* , #*!"

& " * $ & " $ " "

!# " < $= 1 ! *

" & * ! & * " #$

,*'> " & $$"* $ ""#$

61"

, $$& "* $ "#$

* ,-*

&! 9+7 * + 1 $ !

("! 9+7 $ ,$, "&* $ "

$-$ 6 #$ ! ,1 " ? "

#>5& &""*$ ?" $$&)*& !"*$ *

, 6! 1 & (" 2 $& 1" " !>

$ )1 #$ -,)! $ > ,$- "*?$!* !

* ! )*! >) ) # #$

,& &*$-

## !"&"3*1"*!$ "

,-*##&"*

!/1 "

1 1 *$ ,*" 1 &

9+7. 5!*" $$& $

* " #$

< 1 1 " * $ "

* $ 1 $ " , ! 9+7 ("#$

$#$!

&" 6" #$ ! $$& " 1 (" ! -,1"# $ & $$1&*>

@"" " #$

1 # #*& $ 9+7 # 3 $ * 9+7 * + ! " , )*& ! $$& $ *$$ $ ,$, $$&" #$ A

@"" " * ,$ " #

A. $ * :#$

5 "$ ): "11 < &" !*$ "# "$&" $ ! $ $3* 1* & "#$

,* * 1 ! "

* "*&" * $$- " * 1 1 &* B$& && & " )*& ! # ,- " $ 3* * : #$

# " $"

, $$1,-" ##$$ 3*

1",- )*& ! " $ 3* 1 *

$,-"#$

2#1 ! 3*$

1*$

&* "

" #2#$

6"!$ 1"#=* *$ *&

6 $", $ 9+9,- & "

" , #*!"

/ &*"

!8 "( #- ! ++ " C(D "

1 # $- ,$1"

5##$! "# ,$##- " " "

6 * !

! &

" 1"$ ! & " #1 " " ##-/ *" &*"

# " #$ 1" " #$

$$& , #*!"

*!"#$ "

, "

0 : "

5##$! ) *"E& "$$"*##-B*" &*"

1"& , =* $$&$- , #*!"

* $ " -=* , #*!"

" $$& #! !

" * *"- 1"*!"=*-1 $$&$- ,- " #$

/ *" &* "

" " #$ " - "

"#2#$

!$" < $= 1 1""#$

## !" 5 &"!

-*!" *

,5 *&"!* ! / &*1" "!"

"#$ &# "#$ ! *!,-"#2#$

! ,$" "#$ "

" , #*!"

*$ 1"!" $- ,-

! 9+7# ! $* 9+7/*## " ! " "

$ *# )*& " 3* !"

!#!$%% %!%& ' (((%!)*+,- , #& ./) %0 %&1%'%&%! 2!$ '%03 %( % %3%) %4

$ % !) ,5/6 * "

.*,)0 2!$%&4 %!)*++7 -

#& 776) (%% % ! 2!$ 8 1% % !) *++9 - #& .*/) %:% % %:% 2!$ 3%! %%!)*++6 , "*++ ( $)*& "##$$ 3*"

9+7*

" *$ !$$* &*"

"#2#$

$ !"

$$& " ! ! !*$ , !"

$$& ,- 5!# "&*"

" ,- * # * &!/*## "! " "

)*& <D,$ " *# 3* 0 # % !2!$ % %0%%)*++.

#& )-+-! "

! 9+7 =* & B*" !"

, )*& " 3* # 1% % %2!$% %!),55+ , "

--7 $$ )% ! 2!$ %0 1%%) *++- , #& .96) %# 1 0% 2!$ #

%0; %0)*+++ , #& ,**$ 3*$ #& " #2#$

*## ")*& !# ,-"3* $1""*, "

#! !#$ "

, ,-"#$

" , =* * *" 5 * ! ,

#*!"

&*$ 0 / &*"

!$$* ! ! $* 9+71 # 9+7,** " , ! 1 ! 9 9+9

" $

9+91 5!*,-

"#$

$-"

* - 9+9 $$ *&+6 $ $ * $ *,)! ! 9+7

"#$

" " $

9+9"

,!"

$$&,-" $$ * ", $1 ! !" 9+9/ *" &*"

" ! 9+7 ! " * ! *$ " * ! *&* 9+9 " "& !*&& "

"#2#$

1 "

)*& ! # 5!* $

9+9 *!"$# -!

,!" & !,-"##$$ 3**#"$&#$ "#2#$

" , #*!"

! 1"*! " *, ,- !*$ "

9+7"*$ !$$*,1" / &* "

" 2 " D *&" > " "1 =* -

$-$"

& , " ", 1"

9+7!*$, ,-" B*"*,"

# & " ! 9+7 0 "

5!* "

9+9=* $ *&+6 $ $ "! $ 9+9 $#*

" #$

(" * $ ,- " #$

1 )$- ! ,- "

"- $ )1 "*&"$ 0 " 1 ,5 $$- 1""$ "$ ##*- ! 5 " #$

/ "$- &* "

6& ! !*! " " ##$$ 3* "

&"$- "$ "

9+7"*$ !$$*,1" 1" !

*$"#$

1" , #*!"

"*$ B"#*# !*$"

!!' ( /"

" !*$ "# #*"# #>,6

! 0 &"*, ,-!*$ " # ### !

#*$ !8 "( 5 ! "*> F8 ( ,-,$1G@" 1""! 5##$ "# ,$ ##- # " ,$ 1 *!" ##-

" ! " "

$$ , ,$ " &* "

" 1

*" 6# "

6& ,$!

! "

" "

#1 6" "

"H !!&

# # 1*$ , ,$ 1 " "

5# #$ ! " # ,$##- *!" "

$$,"$, ,$ " &* "

*"- 6 # "

" "

6 * !

! &

+ 1"$ ! &"#1 " " ##- 3*$ " "

$! -)*&"

" &

" $=*#$ # "

",$1 "

5# #$ ! " # ,$ ##-("

! 5#! -,#$ # "

,*"#$!!

$-, "

! ! ! (" " #$ " # "

& 5# ! * ##- ,- (" =* "

$$ ! 1"" " #$ & ! *

! ,$" !$ " #2#$

" "

6 * !

! &

" 1"$ ! &#1 " "*##-(" # "

$$& # "

" , =*- 5 " *! < $= 1 , #*!"

&" *$ "- 9+9< "1,5 "#$ ,-1 - *$-1

@ /# "

" !!*I5 1"!"11"*

-,)! "!&# - * 1 *,)!! 5 ,*"!"

$$&"-1"& " "

& =*- < $= 1 * ! , #*!"

& " * $ (" $ !"

$$& "#$ "

" !

61 ,*"! 9+7)* ",

$& "*1"" $6" $$ & $ $ ,- !$ &",1#" ", 1" " #$

=*- < $= 1 !

61"

9+7"

,, "3* J%$,- - !$$*,1 #"$#$ 1 # !*$ #"

*!"

$$& !5 * "# !&# - ("#1 6" < $= 1 1"" ! - =* & 5 * ! , #*!"

&"*$ I "1 -,#,$ " #," < $= 1

# 1 !

! #*!"

* $ (" # ) : "1,5 !"

' 9

<-!#!**$-$"

"#$

! 9+7, #*!"

*$ - "

#*!"

* $ # 61$& !

9+7 ("

,& !

$- , "$ "

" #2#$

*!! *$$- ,$""!$ 1"& ""

& , =*##*!"

*$ " ! 9+7 -# 5!# 1 ", * "#* $"-

7/" & !!* ! " !

& " ! " *" 1 #!*$

!!* ! $ " / <! (%! *# %0 %& 1%'%& % ! (%! *# 0 <! (%! *# " 1 $ - & $5!###-=*1 $ "!!* ! "3*"$"

"*,=* !

6#! !8 (1"", "

*,=*

" $$ & *!" ! $ & $$-61"

, " $$ &/ ")*& $*#,-!*$ " "

,"$"

!$$* ! # " !!* ! " # !

1*$ $ , 61"

, " $$ & "-" * !1"& ! ("!"#!

,-0

) 1" *&" 0 " )1 ,

$- 0 /"& !

!*$ !!#"

=* $!

$##$ 1*$"

, !=*!61 ,**!" ! & "#$ "

" , =*, #*!"

$ (" # " "& !

#! " "

# $=*5!* 9+9 0 5!*

" $

9+9 #! # $ *,)! ! 9+7 * ", $ 1 ! !" 9+9("* ", !

9+71 !

)*&* 9+9(" # * 1 * ,- " #$

" -

7 ) "

$$&" $

9+9", * " # * *,=* " / 1 &

! !!* !

!*$ !!# ! " "

)*& !# ,-"##$$ 3* !!#&#$ " #$

, #*!"

*$ "*

$$& $- # - 1 & !!&$- & "##$$

3* !!#&#$ "#$

,, #*!"

$ ,$,

!!&$- " #! " !"

$$&")*& ! 9+7 # 3 $ * 9+7 / # " * "

1 & ! ", " )*& !"

!=* &" " #2#$

#! $ *& 6 $ #*!"

$ 9+9 3*$ " # ,- 6& ! ' ( "

*&" "

!"#$ "

" "*$ *("##$$ 3*"

"$"

!"*$ !$$* ,1 " " !> " # # ! / " !

" #2#$

- &" " * $ ,& *!! 0 # #>5& &" , " )*& !

9+71 # ("#2 , !

#*&" ! " 5 &" "

, ! "

* =* $ *& 6 $", $ 9+9 K#*$- )" *&" 0

*", !, "3* ("! ##-,-0

)* ", ! 9+71 ! # *&* 9+9 / "

, # ! "

9+9 0 5!* $#! $ *&+ $ $ !#&6"

97 1"!" $ # !

)* ", $1 ! !" 9+9.#"#$

& $& =* "

! " -

7 ,- $& " *

$$&" $

9+9$$ $-" ) 0 $ )1 !!$ " #2#$

& ",- "

"- "

!$$* &"!

*1& *$$"#1"#*!"

$ *& 6 $

6&, =*=* $ " /" 1 " !

$-,"$"

9+7 1*$ , !=*!

$ " #2#$

=* $ *& 6 $", $

9+9!!*!"

& "##$$ 3* "

! # # ! "

/ 1 1"

,!*" , & " $ ,* *,)! " , ", ! 2 *+)*+,/

C.%*$ D @""# 6&2 -2 @""# ,$ -2