Chander Kanta And ANR v. State Of Haryana And ORS
!
"#
$# %& (
" !
) * + ,+
' - ..*
/+ ,+
" ' 0
++1122 34
( 5 ++1 "*
6&7 + %#5
"
$7
!!
" # $%&'
#( %)%* +, -.*/ %)*$0 12 3 4 5
$78 %+
+ $-* * * 6 7 2 ''
+7 , "
7
70 87 7
* % 8
1.
Date of Notification under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (in short '1894 Act') 15.01.2008 Date of Notification under Section 6 of the 1894 Act.
10.08.2008 3.
Award No.
06 dated 08.09.2010 4.
Total land acquired 202.40 acres 5.
Purpose of acquisition For developing residential Section 6 by Haryana Urban Development Authority (in short 'HUDA') in Villages Agroha and Mirpur.
6.
Market value assessed in the Award passed by the Land Acquisition Collector (in short 'LAC') Rs.8,00,000/7 per acre.
7.
The RC has dismissed the petitions filed under Section 18 of the '1894 Act'.
31.07.2015 Note: Subsequently, the landowners were offered Rs.12,00,000/7 per acre. Ultimately, the landowners were paid Rs.16,00,000/7 per acre by the government.
* '
7 7 7 2
"i. Rectangle No.30 ii. Rectangle No.31 iii. Rectangle No.50 iv. Rectangle No.51 v. Rectangle No.52 vi. Rectangle No.115"
* & 7 7 7 2
"i. Rectangle No.93 ii. Rectangle No.94 iii. Rectangle No.95
, iv. Rectangle No.96 v. Rectangle No.112 vi. Rectangle No.113 vii. Rectangle No.117 viii. Rectangle No.118"
* $ 7 7
9 9:
7 ; 7
5
+7 = $ < $ = %$ "+7 0 "+7 0 = *-) / = = %) "-)$ 8 0 = &/&)
> = ') %$
> ( = % $& , = *% (
, = *% < *% = *&& ( > = ,
> = ?
, *))
> = ?))
, = ) *%$ = ) ))-%$))* = +7 = 99!
2 + &.- -* % * 5@A
B5 1C
!
; 2 2 7 2
% %
+ *$$ $9
17
( 2
( 2 77 27 17
3 5 7 #7 + ( 17 D 57
D *) " BD5 *)C0 2 5 , 2 7
7 ! 2 (
#
% '
(
: 7
PW71 Jai Singh PW72 Bhup Singh PW73 Sita Ram, Patwari PW74 Hoshiar Singh PW75 Ram Sarup Chugh PW76 Jaipal PW77 Rajesh PW78 Partap % &
7
Ex.P73 The Imperial Gazetteer of India Ex.P74 Haryana District Gazetteers Ex.P75 Copy of Award No.6 dated 08.09.2010 Ex.P76 Copy of Award No.7 dated 12.01.2011 Ex.P77 Copy of Award No.8 dated 27.01.2011 Ex.P78 Copy of list of rate land within municipal limit Ex.P79 Copy of letter No.2036 dt. 17.11.2008 Ex.P710 Copy of letter No.3890791 dt. 01.10.08 Ex.P711 Copy of layout plan
Ex.P712 Copy of Jamabandi for the year 2011712 Ex.P713 Copy of Jamabandi for the year 2011712 Ex.P714 Copy of mutation Ex.P715 Copy of registration letter of society Ex.P716 Copy of lease deed dated 13.11.2010 Ex.P717 Copy of affidavit of Sh. Salig Ram Gupta % $ +6
+
: 5@A 7
Ex.R71 Copy of Award No.6 dated 08.09.2010 Ex.R72 Copy of Registry Ex.R718 Layout plan % - 7 2
57 ' '
$'#" '
&(
7 '9 5 5+
+ :.;. 52
4<; '
2
. 0=
2 5>+ (
. >+ ?+ 1 >+ ?
. += $
. + 3.22@ 52 ..
. + * **.$'
%- % %)).
%.
- ?)&-$'.9
*-$*- $
$&. .%9
%-$)?-& /9
% % *%??%
%' ' %)).
/ ) '**))))9
&/&)
-&% $-9
'*)???) &9
*/ $)$$
%' ). %)).
) $ %&))))9
*-)
*$))9
.%-))))9
& *?
*?*'
*) )- %))?
) $ &)))))9
*-)
%$))9
*%*)))))9
$ %) %$??
%? )$ %)*% *- %%$))))9
*)/-
%).' .'9
*))'-/$' %9
57 ' '
$'#" '
&(
+'
?').
%% % %))- *% *- -.$)))9
..&&
/. *-9
&%*/$& &9
% +& &-'$
*% . %)).
% *'
'%))))9
*-)' %$
*?? $?9
?--)*$ -9
+$ &-'&
*% . %)).
.
** '/))))9
&$-. .$
/'
*?
&)%-'?-)9
& +- &-''
*% . )).
- .
'*.$))9
'/&* .$
/% -&9
'???.. -9
$ +.
$&&-
%. . %))- - ) %%$)))9
'-')
-* ?/9
%???/' %9
- +/ ?'*-
%% *% %))- *?
) /'*$))9
**&?$
.% '&9
'$)*%$ -9
.
+?
*))$*
*& *% %)).
- ?
'%%$))9
'?)% %$
/% -&9
'???.. -9
/ +*) *)$/*
%/ *% %)).
%$ $ *%-$)))9
*$%.- %$
/% ?$9
&)))%-9
?
+** $)*$
%. . %))- - ) %-$)))9
'-')
.' *&9
'$'??. -9
*) +*% **')'
*? * %))$ ) %%$))9
-)$
'. *?9
*.???? -9
** +*'
&-')
*% . %)).
*) ) $)))))9
-)$)
/% -&9
'???.. -9
*% +*& $-&'
/ / %)).
/ ) *))))))9
&/&)
%)- -*9
?????% &9
*'
+*$ -&??
'* / %)).
% ) *)))))9
*%*)
/% -&9
'???.. -9
*& +*- *)&&%
%% * %)).
- / %.))))9
'/.%
-? .'9
''.&?' %9
*$ +*.
**%%$
*' % %)).
*?
**?.)))9
**$/$ .$
*)' '%9
$)))-/ /9
,+ @4< * ' *
C
2
2 +, -/&/ %)*$ !7 # 7
ELetter of allotment issued by the Estate Officer, HUDA, bearing Memo No.309 dated 04.01.2018 vide which the land acquired measuring 194.68 acre have been allotted in favour of the Nuclear Power Corporation of India Ltd. (NPCIL) at Agroha, District Hisar, at the total amount of Rs. 162.02 crores (Annexure A7 1).
ii. Index Plan of Proposed Controlled Area Around Government High School P.H. Centre Agroha (Annexure A 72).
iii. Final Development Plan 2031 A. D for the Controlled Area Around Govt. High School, P.H. Centre, Agroha dated 23.01.2019/03.07.2019 Drawing No.
3672/19 (Annexure A73) showing the acquired land in YELLOW Colour, Agroha Medical College in RED Lines, National Highway in BLACK Lines, Transactions Exhibit p71 and Exhibit p72 in RED Colour, Commercial area in BLUE Lines and other important places showing the potentiality of the land for residential & commercial purpose, Abadi of the village Agroha has also been shown.
A iv. The Applicants also want to produce in additional evidence Exhibit P71 and Exhibit P72 (Annexure A74 & A75) the sale transactions which has also been produced before the Ld. Reference Court and have been ignored being of the acquired area and those are proved one being genuine one.
v. Further, to substantiate their case, the Applicants also want to adduce the location plan, Agroha, Hisar, prepared by the Landowner (s) on the basis of Final Development Plan 2031 A.D. for the Controlled Area around Govt. High School, P. H. Centre, Agroha (Annexure A7 6).F ' %
7
7 2
G: + */ :
G: G: % G:
2 +# ' '
5 2 G: % ' & C 2
& B*/?& C
*?// 87 2 7
*??) 5
7 7 2 ' $ 7
#
2 +#
+ '.4. 2?.* & * H
7 7
2 2!
7
8
& % , +# 8 2 ; 7 +# ; G: + *&
!7 2
D 57
G: + *- G: + *.
# G: + *& 2 & '
(
+7 D **.
8
G: "%' )' %)).0
+7 D **. D -
: : *) 2 *$ )* %))/
I 7 2!
2 7
- 5@A
2 7 7 D 57
7 +7 D *'$ , 17 27 & & ( +#
G: + */
I
2 (
G: + */
2 G: + */
/ G: + *&
2 +# +7 D *)?
2 27 +7 D **%
7 A7
7 7 7 7 7 %$ 7 7 D * 2 D
G 7 ! 7
G :
7
G
6 2 ! 7 D
G ( 2 ! 7 +7 2 I +7 D **%
2 ***
2 **'
, 7
G +7 D **%
2 +7 D ***
6
2 +7 D **'
5
G: + */
& $ ( 2 7 7
& B*/?& C
*?/) 8 +7 D ?) ?* ?% ?. ?/ ?/ ?? *)? **) *** **? *%) *'& +7 D *)?
*%) D5 *)
+7 D *%*
8
7
7 7 : $ 7 *%$ I G: + *& 2
'Barani' ( 'Barani'
7 2 7 6 4
+7 D **. D -
& - I G: ** 2 5 # 4
6 6! 7 2 ( 2 :7 7 +7 D *%* 7 D 57
( 7
& .
5 +#
G: + */ & / BChahi'
Bchahi'
7
7 2 G: % : 7 7
7 2
2 2 BNehri'
G: + & + $ + - + .
G: + /
$) 2
G: +
7 5 +7 D %.
'&
: G: + ?
+7 D *.?
2
G: + *) + ** + *% J + *'
: 2 2
2 +7 D *.% *.- *?/ %)) & ?
5 G: % : 2
2
+ '**))))9
D
2
;
7 & *) 7 *)
2 *)K 2
2 #7 5 5
! 2 + '&%*)))9
& ** ( 7
7 )& )* %)*/ 5@A D # ( 7 *?& -/
2 2 2 *) *$ )* %))/ (
%'"*0 8 2
& B*/?& C *$ )* %))/ A D "0 "0 :
%)'*
%- )% %)).
%' )' %)).
:
2 G: G: % 5 7 2 2
& *%
7 2 7
7 2
: !7 7
+ '..* $ * 6 2 + '&%*)))9
7
2 $ % 7
/ 8
$7 Ayub
%#'!
Whether speaking/reasoned :
Yes/No
"
+ 1122 1
" ' 0
(
5 % +, -$)* %)*$
@GA
(D45 J I+
33G I, 5+>D J D+ +, -$)% %)*$
+ H( DA I+
33G I, 5+>D DA
D+ & +, -$)'
%)*$
H56+
(D45 J I+
33G I, 5+>D J D+ $ +, -$)& %)*$
+
(D45 DA I+
33G I, 5+>D DA
D+ - +, -$)$ %)*$
H H(+
(D45
33G I, 5+>D DA
D+ .
+, -.*) %)*$
+DA5(+
(D45
33G I, 5+>D DA
I+
/ +, -.** %)*$
H H(+
(D45
33G I, 5+>D J D+ ?
+, -.*% %)*$
A5 J I+
33G I, 5+>D J D+ *) +, -.*'
%)*$
5(
J I+
33G I, 5+>D J D+ ** +, -.*& %)*$
(
5+>D @+HD
AG1G IGD3
@35I+(3> J D+ *% +, -.*$ %)*$
(DA+63( DA D+ 5+>D @+HD
AG1G IGD3
@35I+(3> DA D+ *'
+, -.*- %)*$
H 5(
(D45 J I+
33G I, 5+>D J D+ *& +, -.*.
%)*$
J D+ 5+>D @+HD
AG1G IGD3
@35I+(3> J D+ *$ +, -.*/ %)*$
@4
A
J I+
33G I, 5+>D J D+ *- +, -/&& %)*$
+ H( DA I+
33G I, 5+>D DA
D+ *.
+, -/&$ %)*$
+ @+
"AG#G GA0 35+I@45
+
DA I+
33G I, 5+>D DA
D+ */ +, -/&- %)*$
+3 DA I+
33G I, 5+>D DA D+
, *?
+, -/&.
%)*$
H546D A
"AG#G GA0 35+I@45
+
DA D+
33G I, 5+>D DA
D+ %) +, -/&?
%)*$
@DAG+
(D45
"AG#G GA0 35+I@45
+
DA D+
33G I, 5+>D DA
I+
%* +, -/$) %)*$
+ @+ DA I+
33G I, 5+>D DA
D+ %% +, -/$* %)*$
H5@
(D45
33G I, 5+>D DA
I+
%'
+, -/$% %)*$
+ (
"AG#G GA0
35+I@45
+
DA I+
33G I, 5+>D DA
D+ %& +, -/$'
%)*$
+1GGD @+ DA
I+
33G I, 5+>D DA
D+ %$ +, -/$& %)*$
+ (
"AG#G GA0
35+I@45
+
DA I+
33G I, 5+>D DA
D+ %- +, -/$$ %)*$
H 5(
(D45 DA
I+
33G I, 5+>D DA
I+
%.
+, -/$- %)*$
(3
(D45 DA I+
5+>D @+HD
AG1G IGD3
@35I+(3> J D+ %/ +, -/$.
%)*$
H H(+
(D45
33G I, 5+>D DA
I+
%?
+, -/$/ %)*$
H 5(
(D45 DA
I+
33G I, 5+>D DA
D+ ') +, -/$?
%)*$
H(+H
DA D+
33G I, 5+>D DA
D+ '* +, -/-) %)*$
@+ GG3 DA I+
33G I, 5+>D DA
D+ '% +, -/-* %)*$
+3 DA I+
33G I, 5+>D DA
I+
''
+, .*& %)*-
5+ 4+ (D
4+I5 #I IG+3(1G
33G I, 5+>D DA
I+
/ 8
$7 Ayub
%#'!