← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1373/2016dismissed

Kanwar Singh And ORS v. Samey Singh Deceased Th Lr Deep Chand And ORS

2017-04-21Mr. Justice Arun Palli18 pages

   



!"# #$%&%'(  )



         

   ( *++ 

   

  





    

,-!""!'%'./0

  

    

!"  

   

  

 

    

 

      

#$$%#$$&  

! "  '

(  !





   

 

  !  

  



 #"!  "

 )*+!"

 ,$$!"

 )--!   

   ! 

.  / ''

 

  



  

    *!  0 1" ! 

        

2$!$$!$$$3 !

  

 #$$%#$$&  

            

           



!   

5 

 







 



     



 

  ! 

5  

 



 !  

 $)$-#$$+  

5   

  

2*$-#$$+!  

#2$-#$$+ # 6 



!  2

,   

  "  ' 

      

  0 !   

7   

   4

!

 

"

    

(

(44 8 !/ ''!   



  

     

   

"  



    7 



( 7 !      



 

 ) .   *!  0  1" ! 

       



 !  

  "  

"

 9

 



     !

 

  

 , 6

   !

   

  (/  . !/ '':

;2  <   2

,

#$$%#$$& 

  





  * 

   

        

2$!$$!$$$3    2!$$!$$$3 =011 # <   

   

  

    

       

5

#$$%#$$&=011 ) <  

   



 

 =011 , <  #$$%#$$&

 = * <      

'

 2

,=01.

%

 > 

#    



 2!$$!$$$3 !  2 *



5  ?( @ !   



!

#



      !A    5 1A"@  9 !  !1<2

% 

5 1 





   )6 A !   5 .A  '!' 



  !

(

)   ! @     ! A  '    01" !.<2

&  % 6    !  (/

 '

(   

!,!12!&/3+!4,%'!1!5!'!'6"/#1& #$2,#?/ -#, !

 

 

   

 

! 

  

 

   !

  

 !    #2$ 

  4       !  2&++! 

! 

  7    

     !  ' 

   



  

 5  

 

  



' 

   7

   

   



  !

7 

    '

 (  /5!,!-78,!1538&/%-78,!1.!19!-  #$$-2 (

()#2 - 0 

 

! 



"

  

! 



  

 



 

  

 

!1  !.<2!   5 !  



  !

6 A

  

9         

!

5  

:

"9 ! 



  



5   "  !  .<#  6   A !      )     #! 

  

  

      

   



 

  

     " "   

   

" 

   !      

  B

!   (   !    

  

        

  

( C !  

!



    ( 9! 

     !   

  



  " & .<,'!







  

  !



  





2!   !  5 !

" 





"    "

"

 

 !





 

     

   ( 

  2  8 !     

"

   ! 

   +    





   

!   





 !



      



  !C51D9!  

7 

7

    

 E !.<#! )6 A !

 5

    

.<&!   

5      

.<&

  

    .<21  !

 



  

   !C51D9 !0 1"  

         

   



 

5

 !  

!       ( /



   .<& 

 

  2

,

  !C51D !

 '  



    



   

!

 2$ F5  

    5 1<,!   (/ !



    

 !

6   9!

  !  

2$!$$!$$$3   

 

    

 !

   22



!5  

 

    



 

  ! 

      !    

  

2#

!         

       

      



!   

5  

 

#$$%#$$& 2)

         ' 

.  / !/ ''! ( !



    !    

 (/ ! 

   '

   

    

    

  ! !C512!   



   

   

   !



 



 



  

     

   !    

   ' 

 (  2, <  

 

( !@  ! 

 ! 

  

   

!C512!     

2$!$$!$$$3 

 !  

      

     9   

   !   

 5

    !   

   

           

   5   9!   

   

  

  "   !



"   !

! 

G!



;

"    "!



5

 "!    9 

 "  





5

   #2$-#$$+! 2) 

     

 2* 6 (  

!@( 9B !

   !     

  

  

    !  

'

 

 ! 

         (  2% @B  

  5 

        

  

!  





 



! 5     

 

   5    

  !        5   2)   9 



   

    "

 ( 

(

      !  ! !  "     2-

    

 ( !

 

     

<   !'  

   

   

  

    

 !    

 !1<2?( !  

2$!$$!$$$3   

 #!6 A !

5    

9 !  



   6 A      

 

  



5 

    5  



! 

#!

       



!   

   

  



 F5 !  ) !1<)! A  !

   !  



!  !

        

      

   2&  

  



  !01" 

    

"! 01"    

  



  

!    " 5    5 5

  !.<)!    !

C51<)3A!   

6 A 

    

 #$$%#$$&E ! 

   6 A 





5  

 

 

      !

    2+        !         

   

     !       !



 



  !

  

        !    ( 7 !  ( 

   

  

5    

  

 #$ 4 !   

 

7

 

  



!





    5      5

 

  3



  2!  !       



2$!$$!$$$3  !  '  

5     

  

   !     

   "           

   #2 F5     





   ! 

   

       ! 

 !C512!



5    !

  

  ##    

.<&!   

  

!      

(  /          

    (   !     

  #) ? ! 



(   

 !    

  7

  #, 9    

  '

(  ! 7

 7

     (   

           

 

 #$$%#$$&!C512



 ( !   

? 

  

 #2$

4   !2&++!

   

  

  

5

  !        

   

!   

   !             

        '

(     !     5

 # 2$  )*

  !2&++!

 



 :

;#.   4  !       '  5 > 55555 55555 55555 2$  ;( >! ; >  

       !  

   !                

  

 4   2 

H 2 AI! J>  55555 55555 55555 :'&"18,#'"&'"68-5&"!,=#6%'!6,%&&%>-#%'#3%6#'$#0 #"$KF       

 

     

 

 

 !    !

      

!      : 1  K   

    H

 

5 I!   5  

  

! "    !  '

' 5 ! 

  

    ! ! 

  

  

  7

" !

  

! !

    

    

5 !

7

  

 J   

            !

 !     !    

   ! 

  

    

 

    J     

" 

     

 

  



   !      

   J  

   

       (( !

     (  D44 (  DDD4

(

(1  !2&+&*

2&+&J 

   

   (    5

  

%%H %-H8  II     

( 

   )# 

  

 > 4



  !   

   !        

!  

  !  

   #* (  

 ! 

    '    ! 

  

 )%

 !    !

  

     !       

          !



!                

      7  





   )%  :

; 6,%&&%' %'&"18,#'"9/#1#'"">#?8#&"%'#6K <            

    !  

  

!5    %2! 7    

      

  > 4   !  ?



 :

;2*

!

 

!5 2++*

 

  2*2

(

(1  !2+$&  

)

    2% # #$$* 

       !    





!     

        2- # #$$) 

 /  9 (    

(   



  

 

(  !   !   (   

  

@  !2+,-

  !   

  

  !

     

    2+,- 

(   

  

 !   2+,- !

 : ;0

 " 5        

 5    

5    5

  !     )% 

          

 0

  

 !



 ! 

 

  



 

 

 



'    

   

 '  > 

    ! 

!      

  

      )%   

        

      4   

 

    

 7



  

  

7     

 



4  

   



   

  

 

 !

  '

    9 

   0'            

  

 !  !

:

 7

 "  

   0 '  7 7

 

' > #% 



 

7 

5 2++*!  

  2-$##$$)!   "  



2-$##$$)! 

   !  2%$##$$*4   !   "  

 

  !   !  ?

 

 

 

   

 ! 

   !

 

 '

    #- 4  !   ( /      

     

 

 !  C512!    !

    

(

           

    

     

 

 9!    '     

    <

  

( 

 

 !  

( !  

 '   !  

C512   



  ! 

(  

   

  

(/  #& (  

   

     

      

  

  



  !

(  

   

 (   < 



 ( 

  

(   



6 A ! 7 



     !   5 5  !.<).A  '! !

6 A    !   



5

  !

  



 !

  

  (  ! 

 

6    !.<#! 

     9  

5   

 

5 "  "

   " 

    

 !  

     #)

  '

(/  . !/ ''

!

6 A .<# 1  !







   '.<2 , !

  

   " 7 !

  !           

5   !  

 #+

7    3  



        !  "   " !

 

= 0  !4 

  

(/   ( !  

.<# A !

 !

       (

 ! 

( !

"

     

   !



 .<2!1  !



 

 

 " "!

 .<,' 





   "!

 " 

(   

 



   

 4   !4     



 

 !  

C512!   

     

   

    !     

!      !    

  )$ (   

  

  

 !

 &01" !

 



6

!



   

 01"    

   !

  ( !01"  

 

  5   !  -3-) )" 2)

 



  

C51D

;

   "

-

 !



-) 

)" 2)!-)

 -  

 -

   !C51D!

  2,$-#$$+!

 "



 

! 

  "      &



'

  

      9!

   !4   

(     )2

!    '

(  

  

( ! 



(   

  !4 

   7 #$$%#$$&!

 5 



  

"

    5  7

!

 

  

   

  

 )# ( 7 !      '  

(  !  

2$!$$$3  =1%- 0

 +



 2< " 3  = B #<  = B