High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3679/2013dismissed

Bimla Devi v. Diwan Chand And ORS

2023-04-17Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan8 pages

!! "

#!"$ !

%%$$

&' ( ( % + , ) %!-(.

( %%$$ + "!!-(.

(% /

#!$1

(

%$ ! "

1( !2)!).3) + 4 (2."

#!"$ ! "

5 (+" 5. $$! 6'/ .

(!( $$ . # ., 8'-( - "

1 )$$ %"

!5' - ! *( (!)!"

!9"

# 81.8 (! 6' /&:::; . (!( $$

"84 / - . # ., $.

!-!'

! ! (

%! (('( !- <='

1 ! !-

" % ' .'$$1 !8! (( !

(!( $$ . # ., !!-

""$!(!- !- 1 % (! !. 1) $!)81>% $#!( !-(. '!8 ( / ?>% $ +"

5 , (! ". % !! ( %$ ! ! -! $

'" .

;$!!-

$%! (!"?

(+" 5

, $4 .

(('!=' !!! '%

!(! #!"$ !. ('-(

(('( 8!(!

81 $$ !? 8'

(1 8 !$!- !#!"$ !( ( %! ('!=' $! $!"!

)" (! ) (!('.)(! (! !

) ( (! 1? ( '

((' $!%! ( ) )( (!)(') 1 '%

! (! !-. ( (!('.)(! (!!

) (!(' !=' %$ !/ '%!('"

!.)( ) (! $! ?' (('!!

) ( ! '!

1?%$ !/$!%! $! )!

1% 1" )!

( $$ (@+" ? =' !"

((' ( (%! ("8'

( (( .

"$!(!- 1? !- $- $ !

4!- (" ( (

("8'

A(. !8'-( !=' !

! . ( !$ )!

" !- ( '!

!!- %$!"! 1 85 !

$ '

! !$ ? ) "

8$?

!( ! 8!- ? !) %%"!$!- (% 81 (!)

A( !

)

1 %! (" >% $ ) ( !- ( )(!% ' ( 1

($ " +" 5 !- ( . ( 8' ! ( '!

1) -!%%$1? "

1) )81 / 1 $B '

81 >% $!! !='

!-( '

!- ("

!!-

$$-

!. % 1!"! $ /%$!

!) !$ (%$ !- (% !.

$$)!-!') "

C( ( ( %$ ! $ "

1 !5' ! !- ( (

%! ('!=' %"

!5' !!- ( " "$!(!- ('!=' !D ++ C( $ '

! '

!$ (% D + C( ! "

8$! (% "D + C( %%"!$!- (% 81

(!)

D + E $! E A(% !$! !'%% (!% ! $ !"

'!- ( ' (!! . !B "! "

#!"$ . +C 8! !- '" FB+ FB+

:8'

B "! .

#('( ,'"

C . " *(% C. '! ,'"

.*'"*$4 C.#!5,'"

.G:%

CE 6 !!-(. "

CA( $

!! '" FB

FB ( !-$ '$ (% !. ( $*'

*!!$ 3'- 3 !. , $ 81 -!!- !')! !!- ! 5'-"

!"! ! < G$!- --! 81 ( ! 5'-" . !$ $! (*' ! 3'-., $.)(! ( ) !- !

! 3'-., $.)(!5'-"

!"! " !$$$!-!

!!. !/#!"$ !( 4 4

( (!*' 81) 1!$!- -'$ $ % 1!-

"8 % . (!"%'-5'-" % 81 (*' 8$)8 ! 8

/ ! ( $ ) !' % ; 6). $1 % / %'

('-( '$

:( ( $ '$ (% !8!-!-

('-( ( :!

( $! 8$'

$1)!

A( $*'

('-(

!$ !

!( 8

8 !- (! $ !" $ ! ( 8B '

81>% $! ' (!% !! +"

5.().!

#!( !-(

(>% $%$

! (

>% $ 1?! !

! $ ()"' (%% 1#!( !-() ( !- )(

)

$#!( !-( ' ()(

)!"! (%% 1 #!( !-(. #!( !-(( $ 1$ ,'

!.)(! (! ( ! (

#!( !-(( $%% +" 5. ( $>% $!

% %!"!()! (!

%$ %' 81 !.

! ". 8 (#!( !-(!()!%! %$ () !A( $*' ( ' ( !

#!"$ ! !- +C (

1) "

81 8'

(1 8 4 "%$

) "

81( (%$!

!"A( $*' '

!- "

1!5' !( !-8!$

(1 !!- !) 8 81$!"!

( $ 88

( $!'% !' '" $!4 $ ! !

18!$$.

() (!%!

@ !

! 3'-., 8

! !

! %

>% $) )!%! '!

1.( '$ ( %!8$1$ " +" 5 !- ( -'" 81 $ '$

%%$$ ;%$ !.$ !

! 3'-., $!%

/ E(!5'-" ( 8

)( %$ ! (!%$

>!(' ") )

(.!

) !(!

! " #!( !-( )( ( )(! ("

!'$) !(!

81>% $?' (" !$

8$!(

1( 8-! $! 81%$ !/!

." (1 ( 8" !! (%$ !- %$ !#!"$ ! !- +C (

1 (!-!

- / '" ()!- %!'%!%$ !/ 1( 8 %

% .)(! () B "!81$ !

! 3'-., $) )!

(- '!

!5' !$ 81

! " - ! ,'

! ! )(! ( #!( !-( ) !"%$ .()$

(! ") -

$ :

! "( %$

('( 85! $1 %81(!" )$$ #!( !-( #!( !-(( $%

(!( ,'

!A('!

) $

( )81 !@ !

! 3'-., $!-( $15 ' (

!! 8 (%$ !-!

- )$$ (

!$ 8!$!

1 (! !

% @ !

3'-., ' (8

( ' ! %!-

(

! ".(! # 81(

(%% 1! ' / ! FB

( / !!%! ) () (!- ()

) 1

E :

18" !(

'!- (% 1

$. %%$$ ( !$ %%$!

! !

$ ! $ !

$! %' !! %1 !*!!$'!

/< < ! < )$$ %1

< !

%$ !$ 81

( 6).

%%$!

!) $$)

A(')!

(8 ( (*' 8$)( !- ' '

!!-

%$ ! ( !$

8$!( (! $ ( '!

8$!(

(1( $$) "! %! (('!=' $!

$! ( 8 4. ( ( ( . !

8!-

8$!( (

!%! )( !- ! ! (' ("$. !) !-( $1!"!81

$*' ' (5'-" ) $1 !"81 G! %%$$

A( !!- -!81 ( *' 8$) 8 '% %% %% !

! %

!$ )# ( (*' ( 5 ( $ !" !: 1 ! -)!

(*' 8$)

4 ! !) ' ! )!

(

< !"%'- 5'-" A( 5'-" '%($

< /'8

$=' !$ )

!! (! $

A( $

!"!)!

( !-$1 A( ! !"

% 81 (! *'

! !-

% ( $$ ' $!

( - (

' 1. (' " ! ("

! $

!"!. ("! $$ '

%%$!

.! 1.

!% !-$1

#!5

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#