High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/1839/2017allowed

Uco Bank v. Hardayal Sidhu And ORS

2025-02-20Mr. Justice Sanjeev Prakash Sharma,Mrs. Justice Meenakshi I. Mehta10 pages

?%@ !" ,"+ # $2&2&2A

B--"! 9#&

"# "#- "!#

"#"!$ % %

%&9&:&:! )* +!", !

"--"!& %&& &'()* +!", !

""#- "!#& ;;;

& """+ #"!".!

, , !

""#-"+!

*"-!

"#& & " + "." !

# --" # ! !

" './"! -##" 0 !

. "."!"1&21&23)( " "0 ! ("!

"( -",""0!

"( " "" <<1)+ ".

"- / !

.!"! !

""#- "!#& 4& 5"" + #"--" ., !

" --"!=0 #0/ !# !

! "'./"! -##"0!

"""

." ." #. #!!

"(,+!# # + !!

! !

"#"!!"- + -"# ,#!!!

! !"-"!!

#("#!

/ !

+ "!!"/"! , 6 / / !,, #) !

"", ") ) ##! 0"

"""# ,(& 7& " / !

+ "!!"/"

"! (# *" ! 0"!("" !

"+ . 8" #!

"/."/"! ,!

"0)(

+/" ! , +"

CD <11 ,, +"#(""! 0"- / !", /+" ++""/" !=+/= #" ! + " 0#" /# 0! " 0 !

" + !" !

" ( !!" !"#!&#-" #"4&E& !"=4 ,!

"!!"/"!)!

"+ !"#( -##" "!"#!( 0"" !

"0# # ,/# 0! " "( !!"!"#!& " 0# # , # . #!) !

#" # (

"" !

/"# , !

/0" , *++ "# "+" 0 !

" 0) + ! 0" + # "" , - / !

/" !( 0"-"-" !

"0# # ,..".!"/# , #+ + !"##"+" ( !!"!"#!)#"* +"F , +!

& !"# ( #"+"#/"/0" ,/#)( 0"" ! "0# # ,!

!"#"#" !!

"( 0""/-"""+"- / !"&! # #0/ !!"!

" #! ,#++"##,+ !"#(#, 8"++ .&! #

##0/ ## !#!

"( "#+ !,(

"/0 ! , ""!

/"#!

"/0" ,*++ "#) !

"0# # ,!

( !!"/#)!

" ("" #!", /+ # "!

, - / !

&! #/ !!"- # ! " /# 0! " 0 !

" ( ! -"!

"# ("" 1 "## ! , !

/G //AA/# !"* "(&! ##0/ !!"!

"! ! ..".!"/# ,!

"( "#(""

">(

+"( !!" !"#!)#"* +"F , +!

@)!

"+ !0"- / !"#!

" ! ,(

"8 " ,+ # "!

, - / !

& A& 5""+ #"#0/ !#!

"( " * .--""

"( !!""G/ !

( .,("!

! #,"0" " !

"" !

/"# /0") # + "." !

" # !"=4 --"" ! " 4&E& ,!

" / !

+)(

"+ ! *" "#,!" -!

-!" !

" #""+!

- +"##) " + ! *" !" "."!

"+ # (, - / !

&5""+ #"- !#

C4D !!

"'./"!#(""+ !"( ".! !

"# #-"+!0", "!

." ." # # !" # !

" # './"!# ! #0/ ! !

! -"# + ! 0" (" ! + "." + # !

(

+ !" -!

-!"# , - / !

- +"## ,!" # ,

/#",! 0" #!""!

#"+ #& E& 5"" + #" , !

" --"! # !" !

# ! ! !

'./"! -##" 0 !

" ""

." ." ! - ! ! !

! (

" !

." ." # /" +"! 0#"*!

# "!

. ! !

" !") !"=4 # !0""#!+ () #- !"!

""! )!

"( " #0"" "+!"! 0"-+"-- - !" "#""+! #!! - / !"

/! !

- #! , %."/"! " +"= , / !

" !"

# ' # ("" - / !"! .

/+ #"F"!

0"", !#& 3& 5"" + #" #0/ !# !

! !

" ( ! -"!

" 0"" #0#"F"!- / !" 2&2&22# %."/"! " +"=)

")!

"", ")( !0""!

!"! + /

#- / !

, /" " !""!

"#/"- +& 1& "+ !)""+ #", !

"( "#-- !#!

'./"!-##"0!

"""

."."#0/ !#!

!# +"!

"( ! -"!

" #"+" /+

" /# !

" + !"# ( *" 0"" -+" "#""+! #!!

" -"!

, !"=4"#!# 0 ! "## "- *"#

"/" ! #-"# , /#""+!

&! #

##0/ ## ! !

" ( ! -"!

" #"+" A4 /# (

" !

" -"# # ( 4E&A /# *" 0"" #""+!"& " ( ! -"!

" -##" !

" ( !!" "G/ !

"",!"!

""(# ++# ! ""-

/ ! ,8 ",

C7D + # "!

, - / !

#..".!"/#("" /+

"& <& 5"" + #" # # * !" !!"!

! !

0#"*!

#/"0!

"""

.".")( ""

) "## , !"=4 # ", !

"( "( ",""+"! /# 0! " "( !!" !"#! -"# # ( #"+" ..".!" "## /#) !

" - + -" , / " + !0" -!"H "", !

""# #!

!- +"## , !"* "(/"!

# !-"#+ 0", !

"- #! , %."/"! " +"=& """

."." #)!

#) 0#"*"!

"F"#!

,# ! #!

./ " "# ! #"& 2& 6" *"+",+ # ""!

"#0/ ## #& & !( 0"-- # !"! F !"!

"- +"##/ " ,#""+!

( "- / !

- +&

" # $

" &

'%(&# ' )

,, !

# +

'- !

. +

+ . / +

0 -, !

# -, !

- !

" 4 +

" *5 3 " 4 +

CAD !

#6%%(10

% %

(! & % & %%

+#7 3 *3 *&

3 " 4 +

+ ", 8 !

"" " - 9:;1#6..

: .

-#&

'%(&#

,8' *; 8# # .

) +

"" " !

)

; !

"" " !

; " !

"" " !

+ .

. . & ! # --"! !

! !

" / !

+ -"#+ 0" ,,""! /"!

#, #""+!

,/" !=+/=#" !+ "#" !+ "& "/"!

, /" !=+/=#" !+ ""F "#+ !"! -## ( !!"!"#!(

# *"/G //AA/#& ! !

!),!"!

/# " 0! " 0 + !") , ,!

" + # "!

# + !") "/#!, "(

"/0""F *"!! !

"" /"#!

"*++&

CED 4& ! # / !!" - # !

! !

" ( ! -"!

" ! , (

"" !

/"# !

" *++ "# ) !

"", ") " (# #!" , / + # "!

"#"+ #!."/"+ !

"..".!"&+ !" ( #"+"#/ "/# ( !!"!"#!0!/ !#"+""F!"/# #"* +" F , +!

) ( #!

0"-+" !

" -") ("*") , -"# "# !,(

""!

/"# ,!

"*++ "# &"& " . #!)

"/#"+"

"/# #"* +"#("#"+!

F , +!

) 0! ( 0" #!"& + !" (

# 0"" -!" # ! #""+! /" ! #+ !"# /" ! ###"##" # . !

"0# # , ( !!" !"#!& " 0#"*!

# , !

" ""

." ." !

! # !

"" #

!"* "() !

" + !" , !"=4 ( 0" #+"" .) # ( , "& - ) ! #! ##"##!

"/" !!

"( !!"!"#! # 0""+ +!""*" ,+ !"/ *"#"+"/ ///# 0! "/#!,(

", !

"-- #" ,- / !

& " !

"#" !+ " "# !"F "+ !"! -##( !!"!"#!& !

!." #.

*", F , +!

#"!

"#" !+ "& - ) !

"" # 0"" " + # " . !

" + !" , /" !=+/=#" !! +"!

"( "( !,(

. #!&6"# !

+"!

"'./"!#(

(""+ !"0", "!

."."("" !"G/ "&! ##"!!"(!

! +"-"# -!

-!"# ( -" ""# -!

+ #""+!

! / 0" , "+! "+ !/"! - / !

) "+ !0" ("! ! + "." "# + #,!" ", #!

! #, "! -", /."!!

""*!"#!& + -" ,-- 0!""- 0!"( )!

"", ")--

#+ + +/#!+"#& " ( # 0"" #"!!" # # 0"" + !" 0 !

C3D "" + #" 0", " !

" ""

." ." (" ! ( 0 ", ","! !

"# './"!#& 7& !" # $" # %&'$" ())* + +,+)!

" I0"-"G ! "#"$= < .

; ..

" ," ' *

# " ' *

# .

+ ; .

+) ..

)

; .

+ " )

" 6

; .. + ".

" .

)

+ .

+ " ) .

%=>:

@>A>:

B'CC,# /DE 6.0

+F%

! ..

+ - +

) .

+ ;

C1D

! "

F , "'%- .

# %&'$" !" &&$ %/ ' # %&'$" (),0 , 1(()!

" I0"-"G ! "#"$= ;..

. .

. %

. .

. "

;

. ..

; .

.. . G E& 2! '%#' #%&'$"!"'$&&$%/

.3 "'

#%&'$"()(4+ 5$40*)!

" I0"-"G ! "# "$= %

+ " !.

" + "

;

.. .

. " .

+ .

;

+ )

" !.

;

C<D "

6 " "

" " " + " .

. + )

G 3& : # *#&# *"# !2>4@

" I0" -"/" ! # "#"$= --7 + 5

( .. " .

.. ..

+ "..

+ "

. "

" ..

H" "@";5

( + " .. + " " @" " + H" "@"

.;5

( " +

%? .

" CII 0.

" +

" .

. "

" J "

G 1& 6"# !

+"!

"+ +""( "-!

-!" "#""+!

- +"##. (##""+!" 22,!"!

"" "#""+!

(# *"& !

" "( #""+!

(

(# + +!" !

" #/" / !

+ (# * " ) !

"", ") # # (

# +F "#+"+"

C2D -!

. "#""+!

- +"##& "# #-"+!(# !+ # ""0 """

."."& <& * "(!

""! )(""0"! ++"-!!

"* "(!"0!

."."("++ . (!

"--"#"!# "!

'./"!!"1&21&23& 2& -" ./ #+&-- +!

>#@# #! #- #" ,&

67 2&2&2A '"# &6 "!

"#-" .H"# "J $ "#H &6 "!

""- !0"J $ "#H