High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/1852/2017dismissed

Shiv Dayal v. Industrial Tribunal Patiala And ORS

2018-02-01Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain,Mr. Justice Mahabir Singh Sindhu4 pages

#!$%& "' & "

&()* &*+,-

./0&(1(2 33*22() 4*5,6,

76,)5(2 586(29()(2((7()/*5 "*,37*), "- :%"$!.

"$.

% &

:%"$!.

%. 5*,*)- 5.68/(,/;6<(5970+()*

5)/*(33*22() ===== %. 9$ /(22*>* )/, )5(?+65) (33*(2 , ) 57*5 7()*7

9 3(,,*781)/*2*(5*75)65)

5(1*5@(,

5,*))>(,7*)/*(@(57 )/*2*(5*7(86565)(7 557*5> 5*,)()*<*) )/*(33*22()@)/8(+A@(>*,(7+,*B6*)(28** ),

%5* (+), )/*+(,*2*(7>))/* 2> )/*35*,*))5(?+65) (33*(2 (5* )/() )/* (33*22() @(, (33)*7 (, *23*5C(865*5 ,)(82,/<*) )/* 6D(8 .+/2 76+() %(579 .. (>(5 /(2/*5*( )*55* *55*7)(,)/*%(57(7@5A*7)/*5*(,,6+/

33*22()+2(<*7)/()/,,*50+*,@*5* 22*>(221 )*5<()*7

@)/6) (1 )+*9 +/(5>*?,/**)9 *B6515+<3*,()))/*)<* /,)*5<()9/*@(,75(@>

C? 3*5 <)/ /* 5*,37*) %(57 @(, +0*5*7 67*5 )/*

76,)5(2<321<*).)(7>57*5,+)92*( )/*(33*22()

@5A<(8* 5*)/* 76,)5(2 586(29()(2(/*5*( )*55* *55*7)(, )/* 586(2 @(, )/() )/* 5*,37*) /(7 (2*7 ) +<321 @)/ )/* 35+32*, ()65(2 D6,)+*9 /* @(, 6*<321*79 @/2* /, D65, (7

5*,/ (33)**, @*5* ,)22 @5A> @)/ )/* 5*,37*)?%(57 )/* ( 5*<*)*78(+A>567935(1*5@(, 55*,)()*<*)@)/+)6)1 ,*50+*(78(+A@(>*,

/* %(57 )A63( ,)(7 8* 5*)/* 586(2 )/())/* (33*22() @5A<( @(, *>(>*7 (, 7(21 @(>*5 2(865*5 )*<35(51 8(,,

)<**))/**E>*+1 (77)(2@5A2(7(7@(,3(7(, 3*5 & 5()*, +*,,() *E>*+1 (77)(2 @5A 2(79 /, ,*50+*, @*5* 2>*5 5*B65*7 @*

/* %(57 ), <**)> /*27

/(7 7*+7*7 ) 5*>62(5F* )/* ,*50+*, @5A<(*>(>*7+)5(+)C7(21@(>*8(,,9@//(7+<32*)*7)/5** 1*(5, ,*50+* (7 @*5* 522, (,

/*5* 5*9 )/* @5A<(@(,)+,7*5*7 55*>62(5F() ,*50+*67*5)/*(80* B6)*7 7*+, )/* %(57 /* @5A<( /(7 5*<(*7 >( 6221 *<321*7765>)/*@/2*3*57

/* 586(2@/2*5*D*+)>)/*32*( )/*%(57)/())77) (22 @)/ )/* 7* ) )/* )*5< :

76,)51:9 )/* 8(,, +5,,?

*E(<() ??.(),/;6<(59/*27)/()0*@ /,(7<,, )/())/*@5A<(/(7@5A*7@*

/*27)/() +<3*,()+627)8*7**7))/*@5A<(0*@ /,/(0> +<32*)*7 7(1,,*50+*)/*1*(5<<*7()*2135*+*7>)*5<() /, ,*50+* @*0*59 )/* 586(2 77 ) 57*5 5*,)()*<*) 86) <*5*21 (@(57*7

C? (, +<3*,() ) )/* @5A<( ) 8* 3(7 @)/ 7(1, )/*3682+() )/*(@(579 (2>@/+/)/*,(<*@(,

57*5*7)8*3(7(2>@)/)*5*,)GH3*5(6< 5<)/*7()* 3(,,> )/*(@(57)225*(2F()

/* (33*22()C@5A<( +/(22*>*7 )/* (@(57 @)/ ( 35(1*5 5 <7 1>)/*,(<*8175*+)>5*,)()*<*)@)/8(+A@(>*,*(5*7 5) 65) )/* 8(+A>567 )/* 3*))*5?@5A<( /(0> 2*7 7*<(7)+*B6()*5<()7()*7

9/*27)/() 5*,)()*<*)@)/+)6)1 ,*50+*@(,)@(55()*7(7()8*,)9)/* 3*))*5?@5A<( @(, *))2*7 ) */(+*<*) +<3*,() )

C? ++57>219 (@(57 )/* 2*(5*7 (865 65) 7()*7

@(,<7 *7))/*,(7*E)*)

/*@5A<(/(,+<*63(33*(2+/(22*>>)/*57*5 )/* 2*(5*7.>2*$67>*7()*7

*/(+>)/*+<3*,() 5<

C? )

C? @)/ ( 35(1*5 )/() )/* ,(<* 8* <7 *7 81 57*5>/,5*,)()*<*)@)/ 6228(+A@(>*,(7+)6)1 ,*50+* *(5*7 +6,*2 5 )/* (33*22()?@5A<( +)*7*7 )/() )/* (8,*+* )*5<() )/*(33*22()/(0>8**57*5*7(++6) 02() 5)+2*,(7 )/*,))6) 7((7)/(0> 8**/*27)/()/*/(7,*50*7 5<5*)/( 7(1,9)/*(@(57975*+)> 3(1<*) +<3*,(),)*(7 5*,)()*<*)@)/8(+A@(>*,@(, 2*>(2216,6,)((82* */(0*+,7*5*7)/*,68<,,,<(7*812*(5*7+6,*2 5 )/*(33*22()?@5A<(7<))*7219)/*(33*22()?@5A<(@5A*7@)/ )/*5*,37*)(, *23*5C(865*5 5<

5( 3*57 (335E<()*21)@1*(5, /,+5,,?*E(<()9/*(7<))*7 )/() /* /(7 ) 8** (33)*7 )/56>/ (70*5),*<*) 5 *<321<*) *E+/(>* (7 65)/*5 )/() ( )*5 )*5<()9 /* /(7 5*<(*7 >( 6221

*<321*7+*)/*(33*22()@5A<((7<))*7)/()/*@(,(33)*7 @)/6) (70*5),*<*) 5 )/56>/ )/* *<321<*) *E+/(>*9 )/* ,(<* +() 8* ,(7 ) 8* (++57(+* @)/ 5)+2* )/* ,))6) 7( !768)*721 )/*(33*22() @5A*7 (,7(21 @(>*5 5 (3*57 (335E<()*21)@1*(5, @*0*59)/*)*5<())A32(+*)/*1*(5

*<5*)/(1*(5,(>*+((2,)(A*D67+(2)+* )/*

(+) )/() @)/ +<36)*5F()9 )/* **7 5 /*23*5, )/* %(57 /(, 5*76+*7 )/*+5+6<,)(+*,9@*(5* )/*0*@)/())/*57*53(,,*781 )/* 2*(5*7 5) 65) 7*+2> 5*,)()*<*)9 @/2* */(+> +<3*,()3(1(82* 5<

C?)

C?981)(A>)(++6) )/()(33*22()?@5A<(@5A*7 5(335E<()*21 1*(5,7(21@(>*,9 8*,7* 5* *5*+* 5*<(*7 3*7> 8* 5* )/* 586(2 5 +2,* ) 1*(5,97*,)@(55())*5 *5*+* ++57>219 7>)/())/*<36>*757*53(,,*781)/*2*(5*7 @5)+65)7*,)@(55())*5 *5*+*9)/*(33*(2,7,<,,*72<* "$.

% & %. $!& $!& #*856(519

5(D*,/AA/65(( /*)/*5,3*(A>C5*(,*7 - '*,C /*)/*55*35)(82* - '*,C