← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1431/2016dismissed

Prem Thru Lrs. Kitabo Devi And ORS. v. Umavati And ANR.

2018-10-25Mrs. Justice Anita Chaudhry6 pages





       



 ! !"#$ %  & '(!)!"!#! *(+,**#-# *!(#

..!// # 0!(#+# ) 1)2  *!(  !#.! #     

 '(!#! $ (  3 4(,(56(  2" !5 * (  "*!26 2" ! ( *!..!// # ( 723+)( ,,(5/6 2" !

( *!(## 87!" (#(!#.! # 

 

: *#7+,)! 6!,+/(!" ..!/#5!//#(##

87!"  /! *!(!#*//# #.#!

;*#..!/*#8!! /!8:!

'(!) *(+,**# /!,/*!(# <("2!!"!6 *!.( !#5+/8!(! !((!8: *!()!

'(!)!=!"+ !(!,# !(!#/!!!5 *(!#.!"  /)!#+(,> ?/#)(/# ) 1)2 5 ! @/!,* ;*!(!5# #)! :.,(.*"/!((( *! (!#(!,# !(!#/!!!*!"!

#+../!)! (:!!5#!=!"+ !8:'(!)   &"?5/!,, *! (# #/!!!,2,! /# "((!" !?*#(+)8!(# +8*#* # '(!) !  6 /!#+  (.##!##8:5: #+.!((

(,*  .(!

!).  '(!)5# )./!! # .( :

! '(!)6 ! ..!// 6 "+(#!5!6) ! *!!=!"+   *!#/!

!! ;*!#+  /!8:+8*#*#A= 'B5*!(!#5( !#  !)!

/!  8:  '(!)  #  A= '

  C5!2!(6  + ( + !/:  *!  #/!  5#   "(.( ! *!(!2!+!(!"(( *!(!2!+!(!"(5# +. ! ""("!5 * *!#/! /65*"*(!#+/ !  *#/ ,  '(!) 5*/! ?, *!2 ,!  5(,! (:6 (# !((! *!.(.!( :

2+(    *#  ##   !  !

!  #      8:  (!/!#!  !!   !  !

! #   +( *!()( ,,! *!.(.!( :

!

!  > *!8##  *! (!#5(,! (!# ;*!

1)2 6 *!.+("*#!( *(+,*(!,# !(!#/!!! /!#+ #!!?,  !"/(   *  #*!  #  5!(    .##!##    *!  .(.!( :

.+("*#! ! >?/#)(/# *!(!/!#!!!#5!//# )( ,,!!!!=!"+ !8:!

!   !

! #   (! 8,*!((,* # ;*!./ 

/#.(:! (!"(!! .!()! 7+"   ! #   /! *!(7 5( !#  !)!  .(  () ?,+#+/87!" #6" !# ! *!#+ ./!! *  *! #/!#(!#+/  (+#'(!)5 !/: )( ,,! *!/

!(/!, *!!2!"!6/!(! (/+( #)##! *! #+ 8:,2,# (,!(!## C5!2!(6<(#  ..!// !+(  !((!

..(!" , *!!2!"!6*#!"(!! *!#+ !"/(, *!./ 

 8!

5!( C5!2!(6 *!<(#  ..!// !+( *#/#(! +(!" (" (:

,#)+"*#6 !(!"/(, *  *!./ 

#5!(.##!##  *!#+ / *!8##  *!#/!!!*#/:.( /:!"(!! *!

#+ 5*"**# ("! *!./ 

  /!"(## 87!"  -!(!"+#!/ ( *!..!// #+8) ! * #.!( *!

(!2!+!(!"(6!

!  #(!"(!#5!(.##!##  *!

.(.!( : C!#+8) ! * !2!"!*#8!!/!8: *!./ 

  .(2!*!(.##!## C!"!6*!(#+ #8((!#.!(.(2# !" 

 *!.!" "!/!

" C! +( *!((!5 !   *!+(   *!

,  *!<(#  ..!// !+( 5*!(! *!D+!#  .##!## *!.(.!( :#.+ !*#8!!*!/*# 2+( C! +( *!(#+8) ! * #"! *!./ 

*# ..!(! *!5 !## 8=6 *!(!

(!62!(#!

 !(!"!#*+/8!(5,# *!( C! +( *!(#+8) ! * .!"/ '5!( (!:5#!=!"+ !8: *!./ 

 *!(*+#86 *!(!#+ *(E  ..!(!2!"!*!(8!*/ *!"!6 *!(!#(/!2!"!8!*/ 

C! +( *!(#+8) ! *  *!.!"/'5!( (!:6 *! " +)

8!,  .##!##  # ) ! C! +( *!( #+8) !  *  *! #+  /! 8: *!

"*//!,, *!(!/!#!!! ! #8((!8: )!

6 *!(!

(!6 *!..!/#*+/8!""!. !  *! *!(*6/!(!"+#!/..!(,8!*/  (!#.! # (##  87!" (#  *#  #+8) !  *    *!  #/!  !!   ! %   > 6 *!.##!##  *!.(.!( :5#!/2!(! *# " # #.!" "//:(!"(!#,!8:'(!),* C! +( *!((!5 !   *!+(   *! "  * 5*!+8*#* /!#+  (.##!##8:5:

#+.!(((,*  .(!

!). 6 *!.##!##

(!#.!

(##87!" (5#) !'(!) #.+ ! *  "  *!

 (!#/ ,  C! +( *!(#+8) ! * '(!),**# ..!(!

!2!"!6 *!(!

(!62!(#! !(!"!# 8!(5,# *) ;*#+( *#"#!(! *!! /!#+8)###)!8: *! /!(!"+#!/ ( *!.( !#5 * *!(8/!### "!,! *(+,* *!7+,)! #.##!8:8 * *!+( #8!/5

#(!,(# *! (# #+8)##  *!/!(!"+#!/5 * (!#.!"  .##!##6 ):8! ! *  *!,(!2"!

#  *!!

!"  * #"!(!2!+!(!"(*# 8!!"((!" !# .!( *! (!,# !(!#/!!!6 *!(!

(!6 *!#.+ !*# (#!  // +( *!(6 *!

! (!#    *!  (!2!+!  (!"(  *2!    .(!#+).     (+ *  5*"*  (!

(!8+ 8/! F *!.(!#! "#!6 *! (!#.(!#+). # #(!8+ ! 2!5  *! " +) !/2!(: .##!##*2,8!!(!"(! *!

#/!!! !%   > /# ())## .##!##8:'(!) ,* *!.(!2+#/ ,  /!8:+8*#*  // +( *!(6'(!)*# ..!(! !2!"!  "!"(## !=)  C!"!6 *!./ 

#

+ 8!.##!## ;*!!

! '(!)*# /!:(!/8/!

!2!"! .(2! * *!#.##!##6.(  ().(+", *!".!#  *!(!2!+!(!"(

#(!,(# *!(,+)!   *!/!(!"+#!/ *  *!

.!"/'5!( (!:

A= 'B !=!"+ !8:./ 

 *!( *+#86*!*#8!!+ *(E!  ?!.##!##6 *!(! (!6 *!+( )+# ##+)! *  *!./ 

# .##!##6#/#5 *+ #+8# "! 8!"+#!5*/!.. ,*!(*+#8#.!"/'5!( (!:6#*!*# ,2!  2(+#  .5!(#    *!(  .!"/  '5!(   (!:  "/+, + *(E   ?! *!.##!## +"*5( *!.!"/'5!(

(!:" 8! ?!#)##

 * !

!

%

 #.##!##

#(!,(# *!(,+)!   *!/!(!"+#!/ *  *!./ 

*# ..!(!!2!"!*+#85# ?5/!,!  *!

" #6 ):8! ! *  *!.!"/'5!( (!:6#*!*##  ! * #*!#//: .#  ")!..!(*!(#!/  5 !## 8= *!*#.. !*!(*+#8#.!"/'5!( (!:

5**# /: "! *!"(## !=) 8+ *#8(2!/:5 *#  *!

"(## !=)  -!(!"+#!/ ( *!..!// # (5 *!

 !   *!+(  :.(   *!!2!"!5*!(!@/!,*6*+#8

*# /! #5!( *!D+!# .+ 8: *!"+#!/ ( ;*#+( *#!/ 5 * *! (!###+! (5, 2!(#! !(!"!! / *!7+,)!   

 

                

   !"  # $   % F *#8!!*!/ !((!/:,+. *!2(+#7+,)!  CG8/! *!+.(!)!+(  * 2!(#! !(!"!" 8!(5+/!## *!+( ")!#  *!""/+# * #+

"! !2!"!# 2/8/!

!= (,+)!   *!/!(!"+#!/ ( *!..!// ##  *!

!"  *  *!.!"/'5!( (!:6 *!./ 

*# + *(E! @/!  ,*6  *!(  *+#8    ..!(    !2!"!    *!(  8!*/  F  *!

"#!(!2!5  *#+( 6 *!(,+)! # " +//:"((!" 8!"+#!

*!./ 

 *!.!"/'5!( (!:*##.!" "//:5( ! * #*!8!,//:#+8/! ..!(!2!"!6 *!(! (!6#*!# .. ,*!(*+#8#.!"/'5!(  (!:

-# (,+)!   *!/!(!"+#!/ * #+  /!8: *!



#8((!8: )!#(!/!#!!!5#!=!"+ !

5*!(!# *!#+ 5# /!



>6#/# 8! "!(!7!" ! 8!"+#! *!./ 

5# (!D+(! "*//!,! *!(!/!#!!! ;*!

*#.(:! *  *!(!/!#!!!# 8,*!((,* #8: .!(# 5*  5# *2,     /! C!"!6 !2!   *!(! #  .(:!( ( ""!//   *!(!/!#!!! * ##+(./+#8!"+#! *!./ 

5# (!D+(!  /!#+  (""!//   *!(!/!#!!! !()# !" 

 *!.!" "!/!

" *!(,* /:.(:! (!"(!! (!"/(  * #*!#5!(.##!## *!(!/!#!!!# 8,*!( (,* # +"*#+ " 8!*!/ 8!8((!8: )! F2!5  *! (!#! /!#"+##6 *!..!/ /!8:

..!// 6##)##!5*!(!#(## 87!" # /!8:

*!./ 

(!//5!!"(!! (!"/( #.##! *!./ 

 * #*!#5!(.##!##  *!.(.!( :(!/!#!!! #5!//#)( ,,!!!(! 8,*!((,* # 

// *!.!,)#"!//!+#../" #6 :6(!#.#! 62!5  *!82!#7+,)!

  



   "#$%#$&'($)*+,-.&$)'/,$01 $'./ "#$%#$&&$(/&%)23$1 $'./