← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/44966/2024allowed

Gursevak Singh And Another v. State Of Haryana And Others

2025-10-30Mr. Justice Jasjit Singh Bedi18 pages



             



 !"# $% #&'('$) * + + , 

        

           

 -. + /  / /

 

 

 



 !"    

  

# !!  $$$$$ / /

 

+ 1!2 *  , % 

"   "

"  "     &''()')* +!

, -.'/  

#    0"  

0 ,"  % 1   " 

 % 

       "

23) 45

)')&   

   0 1   )&'))'))    !

  6   1 +!

, -7/ +

   #   8 % 9:/

;< 5&3.  )('7)'.'  

"  .== &27 &32 .)'-4 <9  "  7 .&     9 !" 

" 

>

 ?

 "  1   ,  #

 " "

 ""    % 9   " 



1 "    #

 ? 9<? 

"  

  "

        "  "1   "

 # 

# 1  ) %   "   "    ;< 52'=  '*'()''(   "  2)' 2=* 2== 2=3   .)'-4 <9 

" 

>

  1 "1   

  

 "  < 1 ?

   0  +"1

   "/ 5  1 0  1 1   ?   9   % "     ;<  "  !

, -.    & !  

  "

    ;< ""   0  1  "1

 

 1 ?

< +"1

;< !

, -./ 

 1 9   0 1 9  



1 9     

 ?

  #

  1 

1  9   6  9   # +  5./  9     +  5)/ % "1

 #



   ?

 9<? 9 1 4 "  "        '('=)'.'

   < 1 ? 9   

1 9   

  9   0 #      "  #      

   ;< % "       '('=)'.'

 "  !

, -&    2 4   1    '('=)'.' ;< 5 &3.  )('7)'.'   "  .== &27 &32 .)'-4 <9  "

7     9 !" 

" 

>

  1



"1   

 

 < 1 ?   

"  "

 #  ""

 " ;< 52'=  '*'()''( +!

, - ./ 1    0  " #  "  *      "   " "

  # 1   # " < 1 ? 

     % 1 # ""   " "

   ')'3)'.' # 0"     .2'&)'.. % 1     "



    9    0    

59 - -.'=..-)'.. =

 #

 ;< 5&3.  )('7)'.' # 



   ?

 9<? 4 "  1 #    # 

"    ,    @

  '(.))'..

 .'.))'.. +!

, -2   -* "  / ;

 

  )).))'.. +!

, -=/     #   "



"  7 % %

;< 5&3.  )('7)'.' " 

 9   

 9   0 9   

1  < 1 ?  % # " "     "   9  !

  6   1   0 1   " "      "  )&'))'))'('&)')) % "     0 1  "  !

, -7     A

 " "

 1  ""  9   "    "   "



 1  

  < " 

 9   6         +9   #   9  



 /  )3   6 1  #     1  "   -  

     

     

      

            

        

  

     

    

 !  " "   # $  % %  



   &        

 "' ( 

  !  " 

  

    )  %  

 

  & 

    

      *  %

  %&

         +   ,   # -

    +   ,   #   &      

    

  

  

 

       



    " .    ,     &      

 

     

      &    !

  !     .  .

/

      

     &



       +   ,   #     

   *   &

     

       %       &  

&   !

  !     .  . /

 0 #

,  

 







3 % 1   "  

 )3   0 1  +!

, -7/   "



    



   

522(==-)')2 ( %   "  

    "    

 "   %  % 9 "   11   ""   " .(& 99    1  

"

@ "    "



 "  "

  "   "  

" &.( 99 %   " #     % 9 <    "   

   "

   % #

 " "

 "-""  "      "    1  "

 1

 0 1  +!

, -7/ 

   

 9   + 1 <<< 9 <     =/  "     1   1 

         "

 #  

#

 

"

     

1"         "

 # B          "   

 

"   "

 0 1 



     

!" #$ % &'()"     * 

%+"

,,- )". /*   ,0 0

%3 1 

" ('      /*         ,00

2  3  

% 1

$"4  "           

#    1

  "  

 )3   0 1  

)&'))')) +!

, -7/ 

   B 1 #

 "   "-""?

 

   "    B    &''()')*

9 - -.*='2-)')) +!

, -.'/ .' %    "       " "   "     

"" " #     

"



1"   % 9 "     " .(& 99  " &.( 99   #    "         %   "  ""       .. <      "      .) 4 "

  #      ,1

 %

 9   + 1 <<< 9 <     =/ # "    - 1!3- 3 35)3 360 

& 

  , ,    

  - 

   ,    %  

    & &%   #   %  



    

  &    %    

          

  $  &       

     %  ,          & 

2           % 

    % 

3    

    )   

   &      &    &

      

  &      ) 



 & 

%3 

   +   -   &%      %       2

&    &  %      % 

  %

& 4 



        & 

% 

  %  5   

  ,    

  , 

  

%   %   

   

      

 .  5     

    " !

 

  & 

%   % 

   !

 6 

  $  783+3 90:';<=9   '=  '790  

+      

    



     , 

      .  5 )     

         !

 

  & 

%   %  

   !

 

  $  '==3 >:???3   '; @&  '790A .& % 0 1        "        "  - %  :

 1 9  <



     

!" #$ %B  

C3 '; @  

  

  !



  &      

     

  

 *       & 

 

  D# % 5  $ " '70;

<89 E

3 + 

F      ,    

  

  &    &    1    

   * 

 &  

   

 

  4

   2    %



 &



     ,2         

          %



A '= ) 

         

%

       "G (, % G

 % E'7<=F 

;00 E3+ 

F2 G /& % H G ,

E'7<F E 3 + 

F2   % &

, E88=F 0

<0< E3+ 

F2   5 # % $ 

 E8''F '

07 E3 + 

F   G    % D   

 

 (   - E8'F =

='' E 3+ 

F '0       

            

   %

 

        





               

  &    % 

      '<       % & ,  4       

  4

 ,             

  

 &   

  %

 

     % ,   

 3 &     % E    F     

   4

 

' )  

    $ E F     *   

          

 % , ''   &       , % 

  



 &  

 







 &       *  & &        

     IJK IJ $  # , % &  G E'70F 

=07  3+ 

2 &  G  " %

  - E'77=F

 E;F

'07  +  &

2 5 5  % #  G 

 E'778F 

=992  3+ 

K ' ", & 

 

    &  %  &  

          I7JK     

    &  

%I'8JK I7J % $ , # % 5 5%

% E'7<F '

<2 3+ 

K I'8J G    E FK '9  



 &       

  & &    , 1      % 

  & %  &   >

    

  A2    1     %

 

 



  A         1% ,  

 

   :

 





  





 &  AI''JK I''J H G ,

E FK



'7 G   & % 

       

4

 ,  & 4  &  !

  

C L '7'  





 

   

   I'JK2 I'J . " &  %   "

'70;

'2  3+ 

K '7 -       &        &  & 

    , 

     I'9JK2 I'9J . "&  E FK '79    !

 4         &

&%C '79' ) !

  



 %

   &   %     

 &  

   

    4

 ,             

 &   I';JK I';J #



 % D  $

  E" '7<  '79   

&  G E FK '79 )

 

4  +     

  &%  1)    !

  

              &     )      

   

 ,   

  ,   2    

 &  



  %     %      4 

 





 



  1#

   &

  

A ) 

 

  *    %  )   

  

  & 4    &     6 I'=JK3 I'0JK I'=J 5

 %  E$ )  .F 8'8 0

'2  3+ 

K I'0J MGB  +   -  E FK 8 )   

   &  !

  

   %

  

 

* 

&    & %3   

   %    >  

 3           

 

    

 

  

 '

*   & % 



          



   

    & % 4

  &%

    

   &  !

 4    E =F %     8'8'8 

# $  '7787  8'8   5: , )

 % )   #

&     @  

           

   @"       



%  :

 1 9

8&' ()"     * 

%+",,- )"

4     - ;            !

      !

 



      N  4     

       *   



&



 '79   '7= #        



'' #

    

4N 

    

 

           &

    &   

  !

 

 % 

    

 "   

 

            

 &  &   ;9 ) !

   &     %

   

4 &  &   %

 &   &

 

 *

%   @" $ ==:7<        +



  #   EH43.0:F     

  . 



  #   ) !

   ,  



   &   

 %>  

       

4           

 

 H%       

4 

  %          &



  4   

  

 )    !

 %   %

%



9<0EFEF 

 &  



 &       &  &   ;; @  

%



9<0EFEF #   

  & 

  



        

 &  

  &     & 4  



          & '9  8'9 E   %    8988'9F      

   

      

9<03.  

%

 

 

 

&       

       !

%        %

9<0EF #  %   

  N

    *      

 

& 

          



          N )

 

  %    

     



     

   4 

  

    

 

     

 

 3

 ;=            !

         & 

    ) %

%

3

  $ '  ; E  $ 77:887F





9<0EFEF #    

 

     

   ) 

 3

 $ ' 

;     %     

,      %     

       & ,

   



  % & 

   &

 5 #%

 %   &

  & 



 ( % 

  

&   

 :

 %  9

 "  .  /*   ,00

%3 1 

"4      - 7 H4 

        

  %  &  

   

 +         

  

 

    , 

 

    

    

 

  &     4

   &     

 

    &     )



 

       &  4

     % ,    

6

   

  

   )

   



  







 , 

 &  

 % & 4

 '8

     , 

 & 

 +  

  <878'

4  #3<    

  4

    

    

 & ,



         %  9

8('   /*   ,00

23 % 1

$"4     - D

   

    %       , % &  &  

  # =0          C3 N=0  *   & % 



       

 &  

 %  

     

    & %

 &

     

&   

 

    &    & #'' 

 

 

5- &     

   

         

      %  &  

        %         

   

        

     *  

   &  %       *  

  ! & &

           & 

  #3'' 

      &

  &

,   

 

  

 

       

 

     

  

   & 



 % 

  

  

          

   %

     

        

    

           

 *   &      % %   

 

  

 @ &

  

 

A ) 



         +   %   3 

   4 

  

 &  ,   ,    

# =0      & %       





&

 

 )            &   #   # =0 & %      

     

    %

   &  ,   ,    )    ,      &

     

    

    



  %

   

  &

    

 

5-  %   >

 &

    

   &

  



      %     

 

 )   

 &   ",     

  # =0      9898'  & 

 

 + 3

3

  +  G     & A



.2 !   % 

 9   + 1 <<< 9 <     =/ +/ #  #    " "  

"  "     "    " "

@    "

   

   " 

 " 1 

  =    

#   "   0 1  B       ?

 "

 # #  #   

 

 9 ""1

   "





 "   1 ": 9 "   .*'2.(&= 5 " "   

#



  "    % 9 #

 " "

 ""  "  1    "

        "

    "1    "

 # 

') 1  %  " 

#   % 9   #  # .* ;     0 1



    7   5"&'()"

     *  5".  /*    5" ('   /*    5"#  #      

  "

    "

 1 

 

  

 ,

   % 1 

   



  " #     "



 

      

  .= C #    % 9 

 "   %

  "-""  "1   " "

            " %  #

" .(& 99 "   



     1  

"

@ " 

  "-"" 

" &.( 99 "      #  "

  " # 

" 5    " #    % 9 .7 <  "   "-"" 1  ?

 

  " 

 )3   1

 0 1    B     &''()')* +!

, -.'/ .3 < #   1   "   "  

 )3   0 1   )&'))'))    !

  6   1 +!

, -7/   

 " B

"

  

1   B B    .( %        

  1 )' % 



" +/    

     ""

  / /

 

&"$3#1 * 0  ,

  A 

  D5 A   D5