High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO-M/56/2018dismissed

Rama Dutt v. Arvind

2019-12-06Mr. Justice Rajan Gupta,Mr. Justice Karamjit Singh6 pages

VIRENDRA SINGH ADHIKARI 2019.12.06 16:54

" # !" !"#" $ % &'!

"()*" #+* ( % &-" *" #+* #" $ ( .+( /#(0"/ "" 1"2.(

"! !+3"/*3(00 *#)!

/( !!# ,!"2.( 4 "*,# 5!

/"! #

6787!87!8#,(9!

!/+*:: (

!/#,( !) "# 4 22.)2#

##,(!)"#+52("!" # ! ) !

!/( 4)!,"# ( #,(!,!.)!(+ .( ") "! !

# + " ) #" !

;(07'0 8 , #

< # : , (

!/*( ") "#5(!

,!.)!((!#;(02(!#( 4!

4)#20+"#(

: = *(2 #,( 4)!,##5( #;(0*)( ( ">

/)!(( "( 2( !# ) .

< *)( "+#(! !/* (!

!"(!, ! "* & " +(!

*2( 4)!, ,"

# (,##"( 4)!,!

"( "!

+#,(!, ! " (# ,"#+2 & +(( "!)!

)!( ( " ( !/( !

/ 2)

? 1 *( 4)!, !"#+#!!+!"2. /!

( ,2() "2.( "!

.*( " ( # ( , * 4)!,,.

!!+"( "(! !

+ +( !

#6"" =1*= #,( "!

$ #" 7( !

" # @ $@8* $#!+ !# ; ! (

" .",# "+ #,"! # +# (/ "#,+ .

"" (!!# )+# "2.( 4)!,*)(#,!") !

/ " +/# !+. " .!

/ ( /!# " 2. (

"9#) *("!"(,+#,

!/ #("!

/*,##)!

/!) , "2.(

# 2#) A(( ( 4)!, +#!" + . # ( !!# 4(2 "B$$ A(( 4)!," "(!!# B$$ A(( (!!# ! !"#"+ #,"! #

6787!8 "7!28#,(9%+B$$ = C #,!

+.2# 4)!,

=#,(9%B$ : !,

% ( " D!

" (!, $A " # D!

"(! !/(2# $A* ! "(!, ! " $A6 (

"# #"+""#+ D(!2!$#D(!2!$=!

# #,(!+ (#( ( "* 4 "!

)! 2#DA= "#D!

" #",,!+ #,(+#+# .

A "#D!

"A*)(# #"+"( . +# "#,(

" A6*("#,(+# +# +

" # " *D(!2!:* 2 / #6 "" 4)!, # #"+" +#.#, "#,*D(!2! , +# !" /("!

/ "( !" +""+"*( ! # #)"(!!# !

/"!!,!"2.(0"/ "" 1* ( 4)!,(,!"(! E

" +# ,# ( 4)!, ( +( /" ( !/ ""+ #,"! # +"" 1 !+# ""(!)( + 2( !# #,( "*)(!+(+#"( 4 )!,# ( !# !(# # #,(!+# *

+# ,# (

" # ( !# . #, A=4 , +(#2 "#(!# .#,A64 "* ("*!

# #2!(( #6""

= *=1 $) /! "/!

( #,(!,!.+#.#,(!" !D(!2!: !, ( +# ""(( #"#2(!

(,# !"

+ +*( ")+>!"2 ("# 2 ,!"/!

(# #,+>!*! !" , #D(!2! !

, ( +# "" ( ) " #,!, " + 2!+5

& 2) ((2 ")!,+

# "+ .!

( "+#"( 4)!,# ( !# ! (#A(!+# +"!

/( / *

"+# ,# ( # 2!"(( "(! 2.,!"# # (/ #,+ . "" /!

4)!, (#( ( "*

"+# ,# 2!"

(( #!/!.# !.!

(!/ "0"/ "" 192!"(( ! !" +# +# "# # (/ "#,+ . "" /!

4)!,E

+# ,#

"#(!# .#,$A#$A6*!

# #,(! / E

"+# ,# )(!

/#( 0"/ #,(9# @2D# "!

'(')**+,)- .

!" @,/' ,0,1'23, ",1405 61 ,/' "7/++), ,/'@ "+!"" #

*2!"(+>!#,((2 " =1 $* , +# +!# #, !*!,# #+#,+ ."# ((2 2.(!)!,E

"+# ,# , ( +# ""(!

( "* ")+>!"#,(+( /

= "=1 $2.(# #,""!!# (!,3"!+!%/! * 3(00 *! !" , #(0"/ "" <7D(!2!$4=8 #* (!"# #,+>!*!

+ + = =1 $*# #+#,+ .2.()!, A( ( "+# ,# ( ! " "( +# + ,. ( )

"#(%"!!# "# +!!!#

#,(!# ,# "!!# 2) ( !2!,!" ( ! # "! / "!

/ ( ,+ ( ( /#

!")!(( # " 4 22.)2#

# #, (! )"#+5 " # (. ! !

/ . !

+ # "(,!""! # +!!# # (/ "#,+ . !" ##!!# ( ) " #,

!"!, ! !!

!!# ">

#2 "+ .9#) *!

+* ! " # " ( #"/" #6 ""

= *=1 $/!

#,(!,!., !

!/!# *(#!+ "+( /4 (/!

( ", (+# +!# #,( !*( "(!

) +>!" 2. ( +# #,

" ""!!# (!, 3"!+! %/! *3(00 * !"0"/ "" <7D(!2!$=8( "!(/!

(!"# #,+>!(2 ,!"2.(

"(+#.#,(/ "#,!D(!2!9#) *! "(,# !"# #,+>!!2!!

/ (,# !"+ +*( 4)!, " !#/!# ( )( !

/!!+! !# )!( , ()!""#) 2.

(9# @2D# !

+7 8*!! ( !!# ,# .# #,!+#!

# #"/ #+!# ,# #,(!

( / ! + "#"/!

!# # ,# #,, + " #"/!

/+#!

# +

#2 "+ .;)( " /# !!

)(!+(((+>!"#,(/!# #, #,, =1 $* "2.()!,/!

((2 "*! +

#2++"( #+ .!"# ((2 " #!

(!+*( "#,+ . " # "(+#,)!,!

,!!

/,# !",

+ +/!

"# "# + .

(!+*

!/) "# " !/# "# ("! # +!!# ),!"# 6 =2.( " !# #( #!+!# ,# !!# #,+# 0/ !/() # "2.( 4)!, (+ + !

/##,,

=1 $*( 4)!,,!"# # (/!# #,+ .

((2 " /( 2.((2 "# "( )!( !

#2 /+#(2!!# .# " #*(/ "#, !#2!("!

(!+/!

( ,# *( !( ". . !!

(!,# ( # #,5!

/"!,, !), #( !)5 2.(

"! !+3"/* 3(00 *2.!

, /!

(! 9 +*( !( 2.

"!!"*(#/()!(# .# #+# 89 8#"9 .

"(!5 A(( 5!

45!

- A(( # 2 -?