← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/2001/2017dismissed

Shiv Parkash v. Rajesh Kumar And ORS

2018-03-01Mr. Justice Rajesh Bindal,Mr. Justice B.S. Walia6 pages



      

  ""# $%&&'( )*" +,- $./$(, 00&11$ % 2&.(3(

$4&(,536$.$ 7%,&.(  &(0 7& %(   )  8

 + +  8

 ++!

.&(& %)

.4%536$.+,$.6$97-'$%&.

. $7$-97-'$%&.%,&$00&11$ % ::: +!9   %.$ '3.%;$00&$1 ,$( <&&  1&7 $=$ (% .7&. 7$%&7 *> 7(6(( = %,& -1 !.% &%%  ?3$ .&(0 7& %@0&%% &. ( $ 7 * A,1& $11A = %,& ($6& ?3$ .&(0 7& %@0&%% &.  ,$11& =&($1(%.7&.7$%&7#*90$((&7  (#BB$ 7 #B;!

  #9 A,&.&<C %,& $001'$%  1&7 <C %,& $00&11$ % . 601&$7 = ,6 $( .&(0 7& % * $ 7 . .&'$11  .7&. 7$%&7 *>A$(7(6((&7  .&$'%(%,&'$(&1&$7 =%%,&1 =%,& (%$ %$00&$1 $.&%,$%.&(0 7& %(%*$00.$',&7%,&!.%3.%<CA$C! ""#  9 ',$11& = = .7&. 7$%&7 B  &D3.& ;E 9 0$((&7 <C .&'%. +&' 7$.C 73'$%  $.C$ $9 ,$ 7=$.,&.&(0 7& %>9-7&A,',9%,&CA&.&.&-&.%&7.6%,& 0(%  +& . +'$1& +%& =.$0,&.( % %,& 0(%  3 . +'$1&

-: 2 :-

+%& =.$0,&.(9 .&',&'/ =%,&.$ (A&.(,&&%(%C0&%&(%$ 7 7 = %,&6%,$-&6$7&6.&6(%$/&(%,$ 0&.6((<1& *

&(0 7& %(%*A,,$7?3$1&7%,&%C0&%&(%A&.& %,&.&30  0.6%&7 -7& .7&. 7$%&7 *> $ 7 #> #E#"9%%1&7+,- $./$(,-(+%$%&$.C$ $A$(1&7 <C%,&$00&11$ %.?3$(, =%,&0.6% .&(0 7& %(%*$( A&11$( & $ 7&&0+ =,.6%,&0(%+& .+'$1&+%& =.$0,&.(  %,&<$((A.%%& %&(%' 73'%&7<C%,&'$1.&(0 7& % >> $ 73.%,&..7.&'% =%,&'$1.&(0 7& %(%.&',&'/%,&A.%%& %&(% ' 73'%&7 <C %,&6   >>  .&(0 7& % ( % * $( A&11 $(

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

-: 3 :-

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

&(0 7& %($ 7* E A&-&.9%,&$00&11$ %1&7$001'$% #BB$ 7#B; #..&'$11.7&.7$%&7*>$(A&11$(.

-: 4 :-

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

36(%$ '&&D(%A$..$ % =  %&.&.& '&A%,%,&.7&.(7$%&7*>$ 7#*0$((&7<C%,& !.%3.% B 76%%&71C9%,&$00&11$ %A$($'$ 77$%& %,&%C0&%&(%. %,& 0(%  +& . +'$1& +%& =.$0,&.9 A,', A$( ,&17   >> !,1& .&(0 7& % ( % * '66%%&7 FG F*G $ 7 F>G 6(%$/&( .&(0&'%-&1C9%,&$00&11$ %G($ (A&.(,&&%A$( %$((&((&7 $''3 % ,(,$- =(3<6%%&7 '601&%&0$0&. %,&<$((7.&'% (((3&7<C %,( 3.% 7$%&7 #*"   !

 #E#  "9 %,& '$1 .&(0 7& %( A&.& 7.&'%&7 % 1/  % %,& .&0.&(& %$%  6$7& <C %,& $00&11$ %$ 7%0$(((0&$/ =.7&.( $''.7$ '&A%,1$A-& %3$11C9 ' %&60%0&%% A$(1&7<C%,&$00&11$ %1&$7 =%.&;',&'/ =%,& $ (A&.(,&&%(.&(0 7& %(%*,&.&$%&.9 ' (7&.$% 

-: 5 :-

.&01C(3<6%%&7<C.&(0 7& %(%*%%,&(,A'$3(& %'&9%,&. .&-&.( A$(.7&.&7  ,& .7&.  .&-&.(  7$%&7 B A$( ',$11& =&7 <C .&(0 7& %(%*<CA$C!

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

3'% ( 7$%&7 BB*  &D3& 9 $( 0&. A,',9 %%$1 6(%$/&( 0&.6((<1& A./&7 3% $% ##9 %,& 36<&.  6(%$/&( '66%%&7<C.&(0 7& %<& =A%, %,&6(%$/&(0&.6((<1&9%,& .7&..&-&.( .&(0 7& %0&%% &.A$(.=,%1C(&%$(7&<C %,&!.%3.%  &(7&(9 !

 #E#  "9 1&7 <C %,& $00&11$ % A$( 7(0(&7  -7& .7&. 7$%&7 #*" <C 7.&'% = %,& '$1 .&(0 7& %( % 1/  % %,& .&0.&(& %$%  6$7& <C %,& $00&11$ % <C 0$(( = (0&$/ = .7&. $ 7 %,& ($6& 1&$7 % .&;',&'/ =  %,& $ (A&. (,&&%($11%,&'$ 77$%&( '137 =%,&$00&11$ %,&$ (A&.(,&&%%,& $00&11$ % A$( % &-$13$%&7   $''3 %  ,( ,$- = (3<6%%&7 $ 

-: 6 :-

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

""#$ 7%,&($6&A$(7(6((&7 #*$ 7%,$%%6& . A./ = 3% 16%$%  A317 (%$.% .6 *>  .&$(  ,$( <&& 6& % &7 %,&$001'$% 3 7&. .7&. 31&%,& 1&7 <&.& %,& !.% 3.% $( % A,C ($7 $001'$%  ,$7 <&&  6-&7 $%&.  .7 $%&7&1$C''.7 =1C9A&$.&%,&' (7&.&7-&A%,$% &%,&. %,&.&($ C6&.% %,&'1$6%,&$00&11$ % %,&$00&$1 .(3'& % '$3(&,$(<&& &(%$<1(,&7($(%(&&/' 7 $% E7$C(G7&1$C  1 =%,&$00&$1''.7 =1C9%,&$00&$1$(A&11$(%,&$001'$% ($.& 7(6((&7A%, .7&.$(%'(%(   +  +!

$.',9" .$4&(,//,3.$ $      !,&%,&.(0&$/ =@.&$( &7 )&(@ !,&%,&..&0.%$<1& )&(@