← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/2046/2017allowed

M/S Hindustan Everest Tools Ltd v. Rajbeer & ANR

2023-02-09Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia,Ms. Justice Harpreet Kaur Jeewan7 pages

    

 



 

  

 !

"#

!$%&%"'(

)**+ 

        

     (

 ,  * - *-*- .

 ,  -* -  / .





 ! "

!

#

$ % &

! "

!

#  '

! "

!

#  () *-*- .0 * * 



 



  # 

,"% +     

     # 

     -.  / . 

01)020)3  *4 (251)6#20)2  +!

  

    "%

#2!00!000, . 

  7 89  %#%

#

   "

  :

!

 789  %  "

  

.

%

#62!1;5, "

   +#"

< #

 -./ +. 

 .%  

      

 !!"#  "

.

  

  %

  

  +  +% #.

+2!00!000, "

   +#"%

 .% =

  % #2!00!000,!609#

"%

 "

+     .   "  #  %   + 

  ", 

  >"

  50)020)3   -./ ? ""

#

?% %+ )10@)@31

 .

#  +  "   "?     "" "" 

03))2000*

. 

  %

"

 ?  #% " 

% ? 

+! "    

500;2006A  " 

 -. /

"% + 

 " ")6)220);

+!

# . .

 

 < +

   "

%

   %% +%    .

 +

 ".

 ?%    

  #%" )6062020

"% + " !

% . 

   

 !" #

 % +

%

  

 %

 +!

""  



" #%+%  !

#!

"% +"   

 

 +  "#" #" #



 ?"

"

 "  609 

 

 . % % "" 



?  "

" #%+%  A #-"

2"#

A  '

"

!)@13  B

"

B! C"  

%

#"#  ?% 

.  #"  

  "

%  !

!  C"  #%

+  "

   A   

%

 

       %

+   +  5!532, "

."

# .

"  

*  .

 . 

  

+              

 

200120)2

  #"

?

" +   

+  #    "22;  223#

*

#A  "

  +

 #

  #

 %   "

 );032006C  , 2  -"

2#

"

   .   

#"

%

%

 

 500;2006C  ,)

 "  . %

  ""  +"

"

" +A

 "   #!         "  

  "

  #   020;2006#%

D'' %

"?.' % A 

#

 ?%

 #

 # 

 %

  +  ""

#

"% + .. %

"  "" 

 "



"    A

.  ? 

! 

%

 ""

#

 + ##  % #-"

)1 #* # -

 .

= #

"% +! "    

#. -"

2"#

"

  A "#"

+%  

.

"%  %

6+ "!

 % #.



 "

   # ..  

 "

  %   " +  #

,"

%, *"

=##"C  ,5 "

 "#"

+% 

.

 %  #% 

"  

#

  "" 



  A "" .+  

"  # #%!

.

 "

?-% 

?   

  

  

%

  %+    

 "

"

"

C   ""

#

 "

  



"



A$ % &

  '((% ))# 

!!*

!

 

, #

" #%+% 

C+#

"   %  "

% 

+!

  #

*

   

C*  C"   -"

2

#

"

 

"

%

#" 

,/ .>"

C*  + ,-

  .    +   &/!  (  /    ))"   !! 

!  

   %  "

%  

"



+!

  #

 

 *   #  

     



  

,     

     

    !

   



 "  "##! 

$ % 

" "&   ""  '          

  "" $ % !  &    

      ! (  !

 ! "&   

"  

 )"         )

    



* +        

##  "    !             

    !  

"       

      !        

"!

 

   *  !

   

!

  

!     !        

##        (  /      +01/2 )#3

4 )#3 !!

4  6-   ( 

 1/2 )5 -7!

)4 )5  !!

, !!     &    $ % 

"" 

  &     ! ##      ! (  

       -!

      



  "!    

     ! (          & )       "  

   "

     

   "     



      

       

"  

 "  "

"" $ %          

 

     



"        

     

.

 /0   

 

 "

(   - 

  1 $  %2-3

         

      

   

4 A ""

%

"!  #

"  

  -./   # . .

#  

.

 

 #



"# + +

 #

 A

% .

  

 

 "

!

 C"   

4 * "%

# .

 #

 .

+



###%.

  

A 0 70

 

2      

5!! )

" % #

  *   "22;  223#

*

 #A    

   

 % C"  .+   #

  * 

, 

*



 #



    #"+ 

 .  "

#

#  # "

""

  -% +!     8

 , 

    ( 6     

* )!!   

'>"

   "

E

#

  "

C" 

 -./ .  #  



!"   "

 



 %    C".

C   +    "

  "22;

#

*

#A  #. 

,/ .>"

 0 7  

!    

*  2!2! 3 A 6  +   $ %%  2   90  $ %%

%'



6    

) 

!!3)*!  

  



#"  % ""

#  "

 



#"#

"A

"#

 -./

."  

# .!      # 

  "    

      "  # #"

    #

?. % 

 

#

*

>"

 0 

      1/2 )3"!"## A



!



 

# #    

# "#

" ! "

""

  *

 ##

  * 

C".  "

 +  "

  

* #  

+!?. 

!  #

"  

 

   

 #

 -./

 01)020)3 "" .+   !"609 #

"%

%

   !   

+"  #

 "

"% + 

 " !

"

 #  ""

%

""

 ?%  

 "

    



E 

  % !    %#  "

#  #

  % $--('4A /F'$ 0@022025  

&F/

4(   /F'$

   ?.

G



 (