Ravinder Kumar Dogra v. Haryana State & ANR
! "
!"# $ % #
$ % & ' " $ % ! " &" $( ") & )& ! %& *$+ ,-.* , !-/!
"
'
.0 1" 2
" ! 01 3
4
'
"
"3 3!"
* , & & "&"
33
( '"3&*$
' !-/!
"
+,55 ,067$1
8"
'
3 4
'
' .
1 9"" "
3!
:
! " " "
""3 3;
' "
<3 '" "' = 19"""
" ' ; "
" "
! = 8
'" 4
&"" '
" " ! 3
"
"
,"% !&>3!"?
*
#
! ) ! &
% &*" "' !
' " , 8"
" " ".
" -"
63& >>>
.
8"
@'6 ") ! " !
! " " # & ! &# "< - 3!"
" &"
* +5> "** %0% 1& ' "
4 ! ;
!
"
"
3 !8"
" ; +3& 8"
"
"
' "
3!; >" & ,8"
" 3
'""*
" "
"
" ! " !
; 8" " ""'
3!"
"
""
"3
?(+>/ /"
63& >>/8" 4 ! ' " "
"
' 8" &
3 " 4 !' '8"
" ""' "; "
" 3!"
8" 3 '" ; '" "
!
! ""
8"
'
! "#
"
8""
'
'
.
&8" "
" 3
+$" ?( +>/ / >>/ / :, " # ;3 B2 & #
3 "
2
"
"" ! 8" " & A 3
@
! &'" "' !
3!" $ < " ) "&" " 3 %&
5 >>&"
"@ 3 !) ! 3! " " ' 4 ""
"3 " ,8" " A# C ( D 3! " +E "D&""
'
* %& , >>&"
; ! "
-8""2 ; "&
A % "D ,5(#*
?( +& >5 >> & # * !&
' " " ! " 8" "
3
"
& " &
!& " 3
! D / 8 E""
"
3 <"
0 1""
3
?(+>/ / >>/F01""
"@ 3 & ! ' "'
!F0,1""
* .#
C ( F 0-1"
'"2 '
3 ! ?(+>5 >> ( " "" &"3 '! "
2
3!"
"
'!
!:
#3 # "
!B2"" "G'" " "
2.
H "!3 3 ' " "
" !
8"! .
A8 8"?
*
7# !) ! & 6%
! 3! & &0C
1: # & ! &# "< & !
' "
I"3
3 .
8""! ( 3 "('
!
# & ! , ..
>> "
/! (" " ! " !&
! ' " E '< $! "(
" '" (
3
" <
! $!
'
3
.
*" + +
J
?(+>/& /.
.>/ 8"
' " " +$" & ?! $ & # " "$' "&%$(* .
.>/ ( "
*"&
"(
" 3
$ +$" ?(+ >/& /.
.
>>/& # " / :
:,-B2 8" " 2 #9.
J" @ + 3 #9.( "' "+ 3 ( "3 ! 3 "#9.
J"
@ ' "'" " ?( >/' <
3
>>/&3! "$' "% $ ( *
& " *" ( "'
" + 3 ' "!'< # '" "" ' ( "
'!& " #9.,& '"
"
"( "
2
" ' 8" & " '"! !
( "'
#9.-&( "' ""
"'
" !
" 3!
" " " "
2
" ""
4 "
4
"3 3!" 3! "'
"' < '
( "
'!#9.- ""
2 '"! ( "
3 " "
#9.- '"
!3! "
B2#B ( "
5
>>/"
'
"
3 " ! 3! "
"
( " 3 " " !
"' " 3 ! $
+$" ' 4 ! 8"
4 ' 3
# ;3 "
) 4
>>/ !' 3' "
!
" ) ( "
" ' " "" ! ' ! 3! " ! B8*3 +!
' $ +$" 8" '""!' ' ! 3 "'< " ( " "'
3 ##; !
"
" 3
( "
3 "'" "?(" 3 "
3!" K3 "*(" !!
3
"
3 *"+$
@ 3 & ! ' "'
!
.
) 8" ' 3! $ < " ) " 3 % 5 >>& !
" '
!
(" !
'"!@ ! ' " !; "" 2 " "@ ' "" '
8" K3 @ !
!< ( 3 "'" " K3 @ ! " !
" '
& " 3
"( "
8"
"(
"@
'"
! ' ( 3 " '" " ; ' ' " !
" 4
'&"@ !
" "
! & '"
4 " !"
3
3!@ !
2 ( " ! '
3 4 !( "3!! ' ""
""
' (
3 " "
4
"
" " 3; " ; 5 >> ("
"'
""; "'
" ' 4 ; " ' "
(
3 " 3
@
' > >5- '"" " " ! ! 3 " ! " '
' / >5/3!"
5
>5/3
"" ! '
, >55" !' '
" ,5 >5> , >>
"?* ! 5
>5&" !
"
'
,"; -" ; & ) ! 4 + "
3
@ ( "
'!"
!' 3
@ " !" >> (" ' ""
3! ) - " ; "; ! " " ;" "
!
! "
>5>, >5-'
8" "
" ;
' "
" ! )
" ' !
3 ") #
3<"
" ) ""
" "
( !
'
" ! '"
!3; " I " " < '
"
"3 ! $ "" 3 " 4 ! *"+, (
# C ( 8" "
" 3 "" ' ' !3!" , >>
'" "(" "
* ;
(" "
!"
'
" %& ( "3 3 " ##
( "
"
3!" " ! ' 3"3! " ' "3!8"
"
*" - B2 '
"3 ! ?(+>5> "
" "3 ! 3 "" " ! "
!" 3 ( !
< 3! " '"
" " !
' ""
+ 3 ! "
2 #9.
$ 3!" (
'4 "" ! " "!##<"'
" 3 " "
"
! !##$&""
!"" !
' "" $ * "!+ 3 #<
" ! ! " ; "
'"
#9.," ( "" ! """ " " 8"
"
"
"
"" 3 !"
" "
"## (
3"!< " "
" "
4 ! " " 3'
" , 8"" #9. "'
"
4 !3 ""
! " ! 4 ! ' "
"
!" ' " ( "
'!&"
B2#./ '
"" B2#.
/ B2#.& 3
' - 8" " 4 !
" " .
' < 3! " %
' " ' "< ! " 2
'"
"
"
3 "
3 !&" ' "3
3"! " " ( &"&
! !""
3
(!< !32 "" "
!!< !3 ( "
3 " "
!3 D 5 8"
3 "" " ' " 3
(
""
"3
+$" &?!$ &# '" "$' "&%$(*& 63& >>/ ?( +>/ /"63& >>/8"
"#9.
J"
@ &+ 3*' "'" "?(+>/' <
3 63& >>/3!"%$(*& 8"
"
" " !
&"' " 3
3!" ! ) 8" 4' 3
# ;3 " ) 4
"63&
>>/ !' 3' "
!
" ) (
"
&" ' " "" ! ' !
3!"! B8*&3 +!'
+$" 8" '""!
' ' ! 3 "'< " "&"' 3 #3 #
"3
""?("
3 "
3!" "*( &"
3
> " " "
"@ 3 & ! ' "'
!
3
8"
"
' "" ;
" 3! $ < "
) "& 3%& " '
8"
' 3!@& ! "&
3
""
"@& !
"" " "" '
* 0# C ( 1& "
" 3 !
"" ' ' 3!" , % !& >>
'" ""
"
" ; 8"
"
!"
' *" %& ( " "" 3"" "
" 3 " + ' 3" 3! " &"&"
" 3 " ""
"
' " !3
""" "2 '
' "3 ! ?( +>" & >> &"
"" " ! "* "!"#3 # (
!&#< 3!"# '"
" " !' ""
"+ 3 *""* B "'
"
.
2 " " "!"#3 # <'
" 3 " 8"'
" ! "!" #3 # * !
' ""# $ * !+ 3* #< " !( " ""
" "
8"
! 3! "
.
< !
" "" !&"
" < 3!"
" "
8"
&
<3 '" "
'!'< " "3 "
; 3 !8" """ " " "
3 3
! ' " "
) # #3 # '" " 3 2
3!" * #*""8 ! + $ " " &0 1 ** C ( " %"& ( >> * 8"
' "
"
$ % &"
"
'"
"3
"
* "
&-/" 8" .
A ; 2
3
< 3 33
' F" < " J "
"
( 3
3! " 3; " 2'" "
3
! '! " "
" !"
&!"
&!"&!" !
!" ( " "
3 ! <3 "
" '" " 9"
" ! " & '! " < '
!3 ! ! & 9"
" '
3" '! 3! "
" "3 "
' 3 ! 2 '" "
' " "
3 " 3!
'& ''
! 3 3 !' " '
" % "3!
" '" " " ! 3 " 3 ' '" '" '
3!"
3 '3 ' " "
"
( " ' " !"
'
"
#
'"
3!
" '" 3
"
"8"
"
" "" "
"
" F"
"
!!
' ""
!" " 3" ' "" "3 3' " "
3< LLL LLL LLL LLLLLL - '"
" !"
& " "!"
! 3 !" ' " "
""
3 3!"
; "
<
!3 '
"%I
& "
E
& "'
!& ;
(
3! !"
"
'"3" '"3"
'! "
"" ''"
2 '" ' 3!
"
3 " "
& 33"" " !8"
3
'
" 3!" "
"'
&3 &
"
"%' ""
''""
" ! / $ % * & ( " %&
M
6*
&( "@' & , ,
A8" 3 "
"3 "
&"
"
; F3
""" '""' " " '
< '
!
" '&"'
'
" &"" 3 " "
'
3 " "3
4 !& 3 & !"" 3" " ; " *'
"
'" " ! ! ! "" " ! D
, & 0 1 ""
4
'!
!& " '" " &
! &
& "
"J* " *" " A
" 3 ""
8" " 3 3 ' " 3 3D( '"!" "
! " :##'"
'< ' "" ) "
3 " < *'"
" ' 33
( ' "
< 3 &" "
3 "! '
- ("
'" 4 3!!
" "
" 8"".
" 3 3 "
"
" 4 ! ! & 3 !
( & "
" " 3
3!"
!" ! "
! 3 ! 3 !
""
" ' "
<""
'" "
. 4 !
4 ;
"
8" 24 4
" '""
; " !"A D 8"
'
" ! " " &" 3
" B "' &'" "' " ""
"
&
' "
"" <
'" "' ' "
'"#3 # & "
" ' ""
' "
!
"
""' & '" "
" &" "
" " "&
&3 !&2
"2 " "<
"
"*8"" 3
<
"
!" !
"
" '" "'
""
8"
'
" "
)
!' "
) " "
8"
' "
"
3"" !"" " "
/ 2 "
' ""
"
" ' " ! &(" "
'
"
" 3
" '" " " 8" 4
" "
'"
!' '"
! ; !&" 4
'
" "
? "
& "
' 8" ; " 3 ' +3& >" & ,
! 8" ' " "
4 4 "
"
" '
' !
<"
"
'
3; "
.
3 "
" "
" '" "" "
3 2
"
" !" ' "
' "
" 3 * "
&'" "!"3 3!"' ! "
" &'" " !"
! "" "
*!3! "
5 * 3 "
3!" ' "
" "
" !"
& "*"
&'" "
'" "
" '
" N
E
> ( " "" '
3 ! "
3'
3" '" < "'
<
"
" 8"
3< 3!" ' "2 " "3 '"
< " " " 3
"
' "
2 "
" "*' ""
"
"'" 3 !
" 3 "& ! ! " 8 ! " 3 3 %
) +