← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1648/2016dismissed

Pt B.D. Sharma v. Joginder Singh & ANR

2016-10-24Mr. Justice Arun Palli15 pages

   !"   

 #$%  %&'(')*   

$ +#,-#")'.%,('$/ %#0$+&'%)&%( +$#1$+,23+'$( %3'($,#, 44%00#)$ 5(

3')6%,')3+#)6#)$+%,    %(4)6%)$( * 78 8  

   

 8" 8 



 

  

  

  

  

 !"

  "

#  "

#  $ "

#%



      !"

  &  "

 

#    

  

   

   #  # 

'   #

#





 #

# ' 



"

#   ( )*+++,- +) +. /+.0

1 2



#

  #

 

 .+ +. /+.0

33+  #  4    

5    +$

    6 "

7+8   # 

*+8    #

#

 "  

#"

  "

,  "

"  

- / 

 

# "



  -   "

# 

 



"

    



#  

!

9



!

( /++++++,- ##  :

  # ;

%    ("

9

# 

   #



   .0 +/ /+.0 "

  #  6 

 

# 

 



""

-

 

"

#    ""

#   

""

  ( & < #  #  

 

/

   

-

 

   # "

#  &  



     

   

&

< # 

9

 !"

&

< # 6  

&

< #   "   



&

< #     

 &   



=      #   "

 > 1 

 " & :

,   

""

  ;

=    # ?%  1##



1##  #"

 /0 +. /+.0 



 

   

#   ## "

  



>-1 

' 

   .0 +/ /+.0 "

 

# .) ./ /+.3 4 / 





"



  @

   " "

   #

1 A "

A  4 ( !- :.

B   



 C @ / =   .

       & 



 C @

B   

C @4 B 



      C @4 ( ;

% # #

B-.

 "

 #

- :?% .

 E #

 F ?% /  1 # .0 +/ /+.0F ?% 3  1 F ?% 0   #F ?% D

G  1 " ##

#"

 .+ +. /+.0F  !-  1 ' F  !-G  1  +0 +. /+.0F  !-H  1  .+ +. /+.0;

- % #  4 



 !

( #

4B-.

 "

 #

- :?% 4.

   F ?% 4/  (  +D +/ /+.0F ?% 43  1

# ?%  1  .7 +/ /+.0 "

   # ?% 4D  1 ' F

: ?% 4*  1  E-.,/+.+,*/7)

/3 +7 /+.+ '

# 

 .F ?%  1  E-.,/+.+,D07.

+$ +7 /+.+ '

# 

 .;

*



 "

  

 "

" # 

 # 1 A "      "



- % # 

#  !"

 #    /

  " > 1  &



#

2  1   

 ?% D

  

" ## #"

 .+ +. /+.0

&

< #   /



    



 =       "



 

# 

 # 



   #

  "



 & "# 

4 I  1  '1,#-;%%$')3+  )') )6'##)6#)$+%, /+.3

(1(

1 )$ #

    &

  

    





 >-1  &"

 



 "

 " 6 6



1 A "

    "

 # 





   

1'    - #

$ =

 

 

 

4 A " ( !

 "



"

& "# 1 A "  

  >-1  &





 ##   1## 

?%  1   #"

 /0 +. /+.0  

""



   # #





       "  >-1 



 &

  

""

  "

  



 >-1  ##  

 1##  

 ?%  1 

 



' 

9  ?%  1     

""

 



< ##  1##





>- 1   



) @  

 

   .

/  

#

"  

"  #  ?"  #     

% 

   

  



 " % 

       # #

   / 

    

 

 #

    

 &"

 

 

 



 /

1'  "

& "# 6

# 1  )') )6'#  ')%(+)3')%%,')3,4,#$')

/++.

$

0).  

?%  1   



.+ =   



 

# & "#   #

 /+.*

 

       "



"

  

 /D ./ /+.D

    '   





 1 

..





 & "#

 1 A " 



  -

   



  $  "

#%  #

   

  #

./ B 

  #  "

  1  /* +0 /+.*  

#  1   "

6  6 /D ./ /+.D

 &   "

  

  1 

"

1B J .7 /+.* 1'  



&   %   #  1    

4 I





" #   

"



J

   4 I   

 +D +. /+.* 

  

 :

;

 ! 

 5     

      " # 

  

 .+ .. /+.*

     '  # 

& "# 

 

   '   

 







  

   

.3 

     

- #  "   -  "   7+8

*+8 # 

 #

#     

 /

$+8

)+8 



= ## 

     #

 = 1  

.$7/ # 

K     

& "# 6

# 1  $$#, ,#6%(+.#(.#-5'1#( #,'(+#6#)6$+%,(  - #,1#(++#,-#

/+.3

.$/   

" #

.0  (   !    -  .

  # #

 

 "    "

"  

    "  

!  

  

 #  %

  

## 

       

& "#

- I  1  #,/#)#$#$%0%&$,'&'$/#,6 

#)1#;>2-#,%%,#;>2-#, .))0

.

(1( D)0

9   # 

    >-1 



 ##  "

1## ?%  1   # & #

  

""

 

9    

 #   .D 

 

" #

& "#  

 =    

  "

  

#

     >- 1 

- 



?%  1 

 = - #,1#(++#,-#(7&#(%

    

   "

  " % " '



  #   #

 

    "

"

 " # & "# "

 & "#

# 1  %%,2$ %.%04-%)$2$+,'$/  ((&'#$') #)#3%-%)$ $26'%( /++) *

.7. 

 K  "

"-

    

         

      

     

  

           



   

           

      

 





       

    



   

    

       

        

  

       

  

           

      

          

  

    ! "      

 

  



     



 

  

  

 

     #              "  $           

     

   

   

  

  % .*       6



# 1 

      "

 "

  - - "

 "

   





   #   

 





#



.*- 9 

   



 & 



#



1 A "  

   ?%  1 

   



  "   '     " 



   

    

      "

# % *+8 7+8 





     

 

 "

1 A "

 



  " 

  #



  &

>-1    

 



 ##  ##  ## 

  "  4 A "

  /  ' 

  )+8 %# #     # 

$+8        #

#  1##   ## 

  / 

 

' 

# 

  

   %   '  %# #    0D8

(



   

 

9   

  ' 

   0D8 (

&

   '    0D8

#  ##

     "

"  

 

 ##





>- 1 

 



 

9  ?%  1   #"

 /0 +. /+.0   #  # #

 ""

 "

  

"

   

  



4 A "

"

   

 

 

?%  1   "

>-1   #

   &



 

.7   '   

 #

   & 

  &

 -     # 



 .-    

   

 # 

H "



   & #

  

& 

# "

## 

"

9 ##

#

   >-1 

 ##  

- #  & ##    ?%  1    #

 "



 

.$  1    #

 

%    &

  # "

    '  - 

9 

 

   "

1##  ##   

"



#



>- 1 

 ##  ' 

  

&    1 



= ')%(+)3')%%,(7  

   

 K

- :   

           

        

  

                

  

    



              

  

         

 

          

          

   

 

 

   



                    

! "# 

 =   1 

      

 '

      ?%  1 

 "



  #

      ""

     

""



   

 ## 

## 



>-1 

  = #     "



  #   #

   >- 1   



 





>-1   

  

>-1 



 ## 

"

##

.)    



  /

#    /      

 

   

  =      ! #

 - # 

 %  # 





" 

  /   

 % 

 

      



 

   /       



 



  



 6



%

 



##

"

##  



 #

  "  " 

: "



  #

      " % 

          0D8



=  6   %    

     0D8 



 #





  



1    = 

    " "



    /+ 1'   

    "

#

  # 

 ( .++++,-

8    @  /0 /+.* , B  !", 

H B (

H