Estate Officer Excise Area Ambala Sadar Cum Deputy Commissioner Ambala And ORS v. Somawanti Aggarwal And ANR

 





     
 




   



!"

  #  "

#$  

''(( ) *  

+ ,, +(  %%

& 

'

%     





-   )  .& %+/"

%



 * 0"



%

 & *

("

%



11111111 


 2& ,*(  (% ''((%% & & ((% 4& ''((4

&((, /*%, %     '% ( * "

% ,

'( & & ((% 4 '

4 +(( /*%, % 

 '%   ''(( +& 3"

(% 

% % ( , ''("

''( (% 

6 !

%3

. (3"

 & 

#299 !

 

'

 .*,(

:.

*%  
%"

( % "

, *% ;<
; ( <%
,  * 3

:7"

( 8 &(%


 % ;; ;

 

; (  % 

7 !:

(%  %

,  +3

**& >%  *  , '(&  "

  (%

?'

 , %

''(("

&  *%  ( (

%(  '  /* +&( ,

 (*

+

 &(%

 %  4(% ; 4 ((,%

%

'* &%

(*( % 

.

)& .&,+

% , % ( %% @ :  

*  

 %  */%

((,% ;;

7 !:

 ' %

&(%  

*  

%

*

 ''(%

*

&%

*% 

"

 '* &, ' 3"

 *% : ' !

&(( *'( *( & ,, & * $

#  9

A 3

,&

' 3"

4(% ; 4

 %  ( *%  

(

 8 ((,%

$(*%%

8   &%%



A 3

% *( ( ( 8 (

  "

((,%

#$ ,  ((,%   */%

   %   '  &'



A 3

%  ((,% ;<
"

 %

"

?

=% +

(%( 



A 3  ,*  3+& 

 

A 3

,&"

(

   &(% *% ;;

7 !:

"

;;

7 !:

 ''((

( 8 ( 8  

.,(

 

A 3

#    ,&

, ,



&4

 % ((,% ;<
' ' %  '(3

* "

/*     3 

(&

( 8

8 , 9 #  ( 3 #  

 ((,((3 %

  *

+ 

' 

,  %% & 

* "

, 8 <% %  
*("

6"

&*"

 %% + 

% *%   ' * 

((,% ;<

'( (,( * "

*

(* (3,

 ' ' %  5

+ 

' 



* ' 

''

(

 

8 (

 

%

% 

'*( 

 %

@

$%  

( %

(3 A 3 *'(  ''(("

& 



%(

((,% ((,(  * ( ,

'(&  

&,



 %  %

'( ' ;;

% !:"

*% (* : ''((

(3

' "

'

4; 4

, % *% (* 6

*/



4; 4 , % *% (* 6  "

&  "

*% (* :

$

, % , 

&  "

&*

% '  %

((3 $ 

*%

  4 ; (  % !:

 ( *"

$&* *% +  5

, %

@ ?'

"

'' % (% & +   5, ' (  3

/ , %,

(3





 "

%%

 (* *((

+ 

 

*  

'   '

("

& & (  "

/ 3,

*'3 ,&

(3 + ;<

 % ' ; ( <%
, "

% 

=%"

(   %



A 3

% $ ,  6  77

+ &'

, ,  %%

6



# 

%  

% 

B(

    3

A 3 

% (  

#  %,%

% 

!76!

, %,

  (,( '



(+

 %

(

,& +&

(% 

*

,  '(&   (

 % +3

**& >%  *

% $ ,  &((,% (( %3 % %*(

'*(

=% &%  %*% + (% (3

7:"

=% ,  ,*%(

%( 

 &

%

'(

, %, 5,

 %% (3

B=
( %,% %

$%   ( 8 , *& 3

,  %% ' * 

%

* ( 3 #  ( %3 *

*,( + ( 8  



;<
;;

7 !:

 3 +(( ''(( ( 8 ' 

?

=%"

 % . & # '  & *( ,*( ' 

@7

=% '% (% (3

8 =%

% (

7:

(3

*'3 ,&

(% (

+ &'

% 

A 3  $ ,  "

 %'*%

(( %3

(( *%

: 5  (

&((,,

% +  %%

'(

+   (%

'(%,

' "

* +    % (%

& '   '' , %"

( % %

%"

% *'&(%   ''((

/*%, %  '%

& *  ( &((,% & ,*( 

:

)  .& %+/"

*( '' ,

&(

 ,* *  ( (%

''   %

*,&

$*

 %%

"

(* 

&

+ &'

( %% @ : %"



$ ,  6  77 (&%

+

%% *  ( (%

''  '3

;<
#$ 



(

 *



 !

8 

 ,*% & 

*  3 %

(



*

% (%

'   (

%% *  ( (% *'

'  * (, + '   ' "

(* (3 % + ' * , %

+ &'



*

, %, ''( 

''("

 ,*%



,*( 

7

% 

%  "

' *& 3

% %

,,  3 ( &%%

%(, ( 5  (3 0 .&,+"

+&

*((3  %

 %%

+,

 

% %(, ( 5"

%,

 "

+   *%

& "

*(%

*,&

5 +(%,

''(("

%  

(,& +& *C* *  (3 * % ,& < 8( 5 / %

&

 &  

'* *, '  %'  ( %, , % %(C* '( 3  (3 0 .&,+"

(, 8( 5 
%  * 7

 !

&

 ,*%  (

* % %*

% 

*,&

% *''

&  "

& ( *'

/*%, % %




   

%  !" !#$$ "!%  &'( ) "



*%+,-. /  00  -  "

 * 0"



*(

"

% & *

("

& (3

''

  ,* % *(

 ,*%

& *  "

 % ,

 (

%"

,&(3 % %

%%  ,* "

%% % *(

''(("

%( %( *  (

*%

*

   *  %, * %



 C*

 %"



*(

 ,*  & '((3  %

! ' 

(  (%

* * * + , 

$ 

6 !

%3 %% &, '(%

% 

(  ,, *( &%

 (

%% %

 &%%

%(, ( 5"

 % ''(  '* &  &  ''( 

'  *

 , +&% + ( 3

(  &

  ' *(  (  %  ,*% ,(,

' 3 * * *

%  ''( 

*''

&  ,* "

*(

% ( *'

/*%, % % 1!  '$  2  
     '

" '

 '  //    13!!' !

 %!

4! 4' ! 1!'$ 5!

!

+/0613!!' !

)'

 !*!

! 4' ! .

+!4 7 4 .  !4 4 ' !/013!!

' !

!

= & % *(

'   & *,&  ( /*%, (% *'

 ( * "

+&( % ,

"

&(%   #$ -6 ,"

((,("

   3

( % %"

&  "

 % &(%



 % & 

  ,

%,

( +     ''((



  "

  #$ -6 &((,% %

*

*%

  #$ -6"

&(%

4   % ;;

7 !:"

*%

  (%

 

, ,



&4

'3

(*

*& >% *(%, (% (3

*(%

 

=%"

 3

"

'*( 

&(%

( *  *(% */%

*%    * "

%

 

=% # % "

!7

%

* %

+ &'"

3 D  

  

  

           



                 

        

= '  "

& (

+

%(3"

& 

''(("

+&

%3,

 (* *((

+

 

*    "

'  

=% # % "

*

+

(

&  & +   "

%

&%

(3

*'3 ,& (3, &



 5E"

$ 

  ; ( <%
, @  "

 

=% + (%(

* 

& (% 4 ,& +

(% *'

  5"

' '  3 ,&

 

=%  3

 '  $%   +    %

 

A 3 '  3 ,&

8 .

 % '

$%   +    %

%  

"

*/

% % &   "

,( , ( (% , %*% 

 1 3!'%70 . '!

- ) '9!&!2 % !

  :;

 4' ! %7 / '-)+!3+!/< &(%   % #$ 

; ( <%
,  (% *'



& * *(

%& , * %

(



   #$ -6  %"

*%

*, &,

"

**& >%  *   '(&   +& "

%*%

4

 % & 

3 '

*''

&   , %  %%"

(%  %"

 

,(

%*%

B* & "

 (  * "



= '$7 4  1  )

'& 4'

4  ' ! 

:) 8   & '$ &(% ((,% 

 %'* &%  %   (

  % *(%

 5 +(%,, (

  "

+& % '%(3  , &3

+ 

(% B* & "

$ 

F 0 .&,+ +

''(( *''

 

+&  &

% & 

 %% &

 & %% 5

3

+& %"

 %% , 

&3

%%

, 

 %

4(% ; 4

( 6  77

, 

 * %  %  '(G

3 '

"

 % #$ -6"

'(%

2& 

% ((

*  ;; !:

*(,%  %  

.,( 3"

(

''((

( 8

( 8 

.,(

2&  (

%

% ,



( %"

**& >%  * '(&   $%%"

 % #$ -6

?% &  * "

 (%

(&



&3

+ 

"

 ,* %%  *(

( ((

% %

2&  (

''( 

6 !

%3 ''("

 ,(3 % 

%

*%

% 

%  "

' *& 3 &% % %

( ,*( 

 

& "

( &%%

%(, ( 5  (3 0 .&,+"

+&

*((3  %

 "

%*

%,

 *(%

*,&

5 +(%,

' *& 3 &  

(,& +& *C* *  (3 * % ,& / %

&

 &   (

 % ''( '  %'  ( %, % , % %(, ( 5  (3 0 .&,+ * 7

 !

&

F&(  , & "

 (

@ (% ' '( *% 

<  "

(,&

 "

'(3

$'(

(3   
*(

( 



% ,&

'  



% 

 &%"

''( 

%(3"

  *

%"

&  "

& 

* ''%% & ''( *''

 &

2& 

%  '%

' *& 3 ((

%"

+& 3"

 3

% %

,,% B* & "

& 

* ((

+  ( &%%

%(, ( 5  (3 0 .&,+

+& & *' *%

   ( (3"

* %*%

+& * % ,& < 8( 5 / % '(

% 0 .&,+

&

 &   <5+"

* %*%

+& %'  ( %, % , % 0 .&,+

 

+&& *

&

2& 

(3 (%

''( * *  3 % *''

&   "

(%

 '% '(  *& 2&

% %

' &"

*% &  * "

* *

*

 .*

&  /*%, % % '$ 





 %  !" !

#$$ "!%  &'( ) "

 *%+,-.  3 (% *'

*(

''(("

 ''(%

'*(   * 

   %,(3"

& 

* *

*



6 !

%3

+

"

& %

((,(3

'  3 *  %,

%%

& *  ( 

C*

(+ C* , %    & ,*(  (% ''((%%"

 

B* & "

* *

*

 %(3"

''( 

% (

% %

:

 %




  !" #$%&'(       F&& '5,9  % H9

F&& '

( H9