← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3939/2013allowed

M/S Machhi Ram Kishan Singh Sidana v. Sham Singh & ORS

2015-09-02Mr. Justice Arun Monga9 pages





          !"#$"%&'

&(

( ((()*)*"%&)+ ,-.

-/(-00 10 20 #$ -33$!43 #$ 33 #4$5! 637 (((

33 8!9

0 20,0! (((  # "(

( ((():;*"%&"+ ,-.

< 20,0!

(((

33 8!9

0 20,0! (((  #  !"#$%&' ()%)(*$+&',-% &( 400!  !!33  != 335#0<9#2> "(  !!!#0  !!!> )( 400!0<9#2093# ! !#02>

!

-!( ((22!53$#?50 -!(1903$#?$ !0

33

()*)*"%&)( -!(@( ( #09$#?$ !0

33

():;*"%&"( -!( 73=$#?$ !! #(&; 00

3( AAAAA )(*$+&  = 0  !#!$   #    #     5  293!  # 

3 !2()*)*"%&)#):;*"%&"0 B935#?3?# 00

3!0(



 293!  #  

3 ():;*  "%&" 0  3#  = 

33C2##("#)# 293! #

3 ()*)*"%&)0 3# =-/-00 10 20 #$

-33$50!#0? 9!0#0 !=9!2&"

73  &&  !3  ?#  5   !  3  ##  ##  )&(&("%%'  # "'(&("%%D!?39 3#!!0##(0=0? 0332#0<9#2##!##'('("%&"0@5!

33 9!$50! =0<9#2##!##;(&&("%%* # =0 ##3?39#2+ !?.$33 #$093# =0 ! #C 3!#3!0 3###(ED !5!< 3#9!2&;73$(($"/;0! 33#9!2'*73*!3#! #09#0 <9#2##!##&:(&%(&**) #?3 9(:*%C&## &)(*(&**)3#  20(8!9 20(#533 9  !2  (&E";D  #  9!9    0  !# <9#2 2!93!9#$!#! !$0  ##(  -!(@( ( #09$  3!#  93  

!2    03    0 

33C##  ("  #  )   

  ():;*    "%&"  # -!( ((22!53  #?  #  =  -!(  1903$  #? 

!2   03    0  

33   

  ()*)*    "%&)$  (($ 9 B9?#$9 00 92#<9#2##!0 @5!

339!9!!3323=# !?!=093# 0=!"%%)$(($&(&%("%%)033220<9#2##! ##&)(&%(&**)5   !!#0!=!B9!20



900929$"%%)$(($ = 20 = 0< #$0 320 2075 90 #!#$0!!$09$!#$53##(0!3 9!!203=##090 !00 33#  300!009!$90$00 !9#$! !#!0#  !?#($0 3325!9 !?00<9#2##!# =0!#9?=203!!20? 3 != ?9!!! 0332# =0 !$500#9!#0 ##!!F9#0#90#9!!$5075 0!95000332#!9#$!#9#939 0  !#9 0 =0!!(0=9!0!9 00 !39!$0 0!3##9!=?#$9#0

00!  20  0#  9!#  5      &)(&%(&**;$      0

!3 =#0# 20!=20 20(0

3 5!!=+F(&.##&*(&(&*;;F9# =20

20?9! 200#?! !?7##9!203 !!9!20#!!330#0(0=9!0!9 0 20 20$#9!203$##03320#!(3= !3 =!$090 3#(  0  

33   

  ()*)*    "%&)  0#  9!0#  0

!=!0#309$5005##;(&&("%%* #$0!!$0#!



 593#

3=(0 3 0?3##0!20 9!#?2#9#! &%&0 ?3 !#9!#$903$?#!9#!!$ !

.

0 !? !#!: 93E $0 3#/ !?#(0=9!0!

9 00 30?7= 300 5!!= 52?3=!020 !=#$0!!$0 5!23= 9# = 20$903$ 20!2!# 0 5!2? =20 20(0 30?3# !?0!

< ?!09 !=#9!=?#0 !2!#0#  !?#(#0= < $0=593#0? 75 90<9#2##!0##5! 9 0=3 0 !=!0#0#!

#0=!&**)(?0950!2!#0#!0 #0=!"%%&#090# 3#0=!"%%)(  -!( ((22!53$3!#93

!2 030 9 B9?#9 0 =?!903$0 0

!=0#3 0##?!#053!3#0 < #!0=!"%%DC%*$09$ !=0033529 3 B935!!#! =09! . 400!$ 0  3  0?    3    !?  0 !2!=#!9# 3## =0> . 400!0 30?  3 !?0!

?!093#> . 400!  0  3  0?    920  !3  

20##$500!0!9!#! #3! 3> #.400!$0@!# !

339!0!# #!

!#0 3#2#?#!!#>

/

. 400!  0  3  !  32  #3!  9 #3!20<9#2##!3323933#?# 3#500!=!!0#<9#2# #! !!3'D@>  -!(   73=$  #?  

!2    03   ! #  (&    ;    0  0  

3  9   0  0  3 B9!#0753#20<9#2##!##&:(&%(&**)?# F( ""*(D("%%)#095!#23=3#  !$"%%) 509=9!0!#3=#$0!!$090 =35 3(0 5!!=?9!093## !0 29!    20  20$  90  3$  0920  ##3=  0  5! 0# 3# 03 00##$(($20 20 # 20(0@5!

339!0#= 3323=# !?!=2C#0<9#2##!0!3 9!$50! =0900 30# ##( 4C& !< 20 B9 90!CF #000#3#=9220 20# 20 =9!#3!3=  20#< 203##3= 92 20(9!0!9 00!3323=#

!?!=0<9#2##!0@5!

339!$90 3$0

3#?3?=9 3B935( 0?0!#03!#93!0 !#

!#0

 ! 7( 0!09!?300! #C 3920 #3!50!2!#0!!0!?9!!##3

0

##$ 9 33#03? < 03#$ 50!0!!=$0!?9 !!#!305!0  ?9!  20$< 20# !< 20$0#!C03#! ?3 9(:*%C&##&)(*(&**)#0##0 !9 #095#&D(&("%%%(0 35!

03#?!0#020 20(0=3# 7=!2C#0<9#2##&:(&%(&**)! !# =!(?0!5$093# 9!0# =0

33

()*)*"%&)9!2

!F3=&"73&!3$ 50!20 20# 205#D73&%!39 3&;73#$0!!$!33# 9!

$0

35!22!?#$0=93#0?9200!3 ! 0 00=5!C5!32500!5!$ 990 !30 920(05!+F( :.##;(&%(&**)5 3# 0320 200# 20?9! 3

 20$< 20# !< 20 20( 00!

209!#5&)(&%(&**)$0 !3 = #0!0 =20 200 

3 5! !=##&*(&(&*;;+F(&.(0#

3 5!!=$ #9!20320 20$5?!!?7#( !#! 300!$! !#!9#$ 3!B9!3500 3#20? !# 50  !#!  :  93  E   ($  9  0  3#2  !    9(  0

30?#0!532#0!209 =3#2 #!$  2  #  ?  ?#(   2  ?#  ?CGC?

1

!$! !#!9# 3=#9 20 200# 

!?#( !0!$090# 3#0=!"%%)$50! 0#!0# 9!#  !$&**)(20 20$#9!203 $0#0332#0#!(50  !0332 00#933= 0!9#B9$ 903$! !

3=#9 0(0?#0#  3 !?020 20$ #9!203$!?7#0 5!!=?9!20

20(0?# 3#!!# !?00 0

!=9!2&;735?9!0#!C03#!$(($ ##(&)0 !9# 3?3 9(:*%C& "%%&(09$!33# 9!

$0 30#0753#2 0#!0=5!0?20 #0!!3 ! !#=!#?720<9!#09! =32 09!#3!02 92!##!#52 ( 90 !090 33 3 

# 0 9##!203=$0!39!$0 0!3# #9!=?###09(# 209!# 0 !3 =#5330!=20

20$00293#0? #!(9!#5$ 0 !3 =#0!!=20 20(0!  # =!9# 3=#9 20 20( !205050=!0 3  0 =< #!32 !#=!(F 30 5050!! 20 =0< # "*(D("%%)9##3=(

2

=?5$09 !!# =3$!$ !

!3'D0@$33=0!=!(0 #2 =0@5!

339!093# 3##9!2 0!F0 300=0#0753#2$= ?5$!!#2!0!0#9F( &3$  !?#00 35! 09 !=$ ?CGC?  0  #!(  0=  0#    7  !  =  72   !

0#0=  09 !=(0<9#2 ##!! "/;0!03#9!2'*73* !32?!970!9 !(020 20# 00!

205!C5!0F&/;0!(09$0#20 @5!

339! =2C#0<9#2##!## &:(&%(&**)0F&/;00!C5# =20 20$= ?5$0!!#20@5!

339!0 #0

3 3= !?!3'D0@( $0 3# =0 3 #$00!593#  #032(?!=9 9#=#0

!?0@ 3=!9?#( 90 !$ =?5$093# # !#(  !0!!#$0B935$#  ?$!5!#?9!0

33C###20 ! #C 3(  = ?5$ 0 #2 !#!# = 0 @5! 

339!9!!3323=# !?!=# #0 

!!3##9!=?# !920!!#(  0 92#<9#2##!##'('("%&"!0! =



C##09!#23=##( 0

3!335#( 0!033 !#!( 345

+/ )(*$

467 &',-%