High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3942/2013allowed

Naresh Kumar v. Pritam Singh And Others

2017-08-18Mrs. Justice Anita Chaudhry7 pages

! "#$%!

&&'' (!

$

)!% *" "!

&

)!

!)!% +,

!"&&'' !( "*'+,

!! &

)'

*$'! &&'*

"-$*% &

./'!

&&''1$! )'

' $ ! & &!

!% *!%

' 23 &'"" ! '

! +4 +

5 3 & !* 3 6 ! 6$ !* ! " ' . &' 3 *! . ' '

6$ *!* !7 / %&3! *"&'

3""&3!

' +%!**+ '+6" * '

6$8'' &'

+3"3 "3 !+ " $ *!$ ""&3! !

/6$

+"

. ''96$ "*!% '' 8''3! $!"!

!""" 6$ ' ,$!

! '' 7)7

!

/ ' &!3! % :"/

'$ !'%"

" !* *"&

" $&!&!/",

!$ "+!% .$ !/3'' ;!

!'$! !&&! *", ,'.'

" '+!" $ !"' *""*!% '' " &/% '

! &!, :" '

3 "'.''*'+ $''+, . $& "!*"

'" !

&&';!

&&'' 1$!" "-$*% ! "!'$!./

''3 *!

&! " *!% ''+ "" ,!"!* ' ' &'

+"3,!+" ! ' " . &!$./ )'

" &!$ &!,". <

% $ "3 &/% ! '

! 2&&!

"$ !"*!. 7 !')3!

/+" $! 3!<

.' <&&!

"! !*!% '' 8''

! .' <&&!

! . &$!" !

:"-$*% ! "'!

&&''1$!

" . "'' *./"&&'' " *$'! &&':"

$.

'=$

'33""! "&! ! $ !

8""!3! *!% ''$'/ ./"&! .$../"1$! %''

.!! "!', > 8""!"0!

&&''1$!" ' &&!", "&!&!&!

&,> 8""! .

&' " !. &$!" !

+"$! !$!

*&!$'!'/3" "! /

$ " . !% !, " . '> ;!

$

' ! " &&'' " $.% " " *!% '' &!, " ' * 3

" .

6% ?" $.%"&'

'/6$

*!% ''.$'

6$7 /+96)

" '+3"" $'/!* !3""$.* !!%&3! *" &'

3"''"!*" 3""3 !" 3"! & . '

$.-%! *!% '':" ! &3! !

/

% $% .! * &"*!&" 3''

&'

;!

$

' !"&&'' " $.%" '

6$8''

3"! & ' &$ . &':"! !+" "$!! . $& -$! $!% ""!" +'!

$

' ! "! & "

$.%"8'' !* !+'"$*" %&

!! " " %/7 !' )3! /6$ !* !?" $.%" &!*!% ''!* '

' "$'. &

.$" . &!$./ ?" $.%""&'

3!3!< * " % !/ +"! !+ *, 7 / &'

? $.%" '/3"!3' +

5 !%". <" . &!,./" &'

!"

!# $%"&# $'

# $() ) *) +* "%,*

- "!

.. ,"

&/0 ) 1%*

2%"/ ,"!* &/0) !

*!" -%..%/ **% !"

") !*%. 3 & "2 # $() ) *) 11 ..% !

*)% 5% .

&!

%11* 2 % ) 3 & "2 ") 1*!1 *1 2 3 %/

!& +"-$*% &

./"'!

0!

&&''1$! '.'. &!*!% ''+"

'3 " ,!"&'

+.$" %" . &!$ ./" , 23$' %<"*!% ''

3! *$'/ ./"&! $. $' :"*!% ''

3! *$'/ ./"&! + ./3 *3

:" " &!$ /, &!,"*!% ''

! $' !$:"$!" ,!'<" " " 6$ *!% ''+ && " &'

" 7 /+3"" !* !$% 2 '

./"&! +&"*!&"

6 &!"! !%+ "'

6$8''

3"

4 ! &" %' &$ :"! !+ "&! ,!3"'% *, +3'' .!!$."!!

* $

"*!% '' :" "'!

&&''1$!! . $& -$! +3""%$ . ;!

0!

&&'' 1$! " $!"! "' " " *!% '' $ &$

" '&!," 3"!3' "%$ !%". < )'

3" &&! 3

.6 """3"!3 +

5 !%"$

" "! @1A <+?: !% *%$ 3 .!!3./"%

!%" &"3 !$% +

. "&'

" ' &!,",'.'/ $ 3""% "/ *!% ''

6$ ;!

$!" $!"!"'"&&!

3"'6$ 7 /+ $! %*"".

< .' <&&!

:" $! ! 9 *' " :" $! ! .""&* "*!%

'' " '&!,"" $! 3!<

".' <&&!

+"! !+" * "'!

&&''1$! . $& &! $%&

$%&

!"!# $'

() ) * "%/

"2 !51.

%& ", )%& "&%"!

6 %"&7%* /!"%5 & 1 *2)%

) 2!

*2%"*

*"%5 "& ", 1%* 2 .%*.0+) ""

) *%"0

)% /

"5*%- &"!* 3 & "2

)% /

" ".

&4 ;!

&&''1$!3"$"!. * /&&'./

B !, &!/! " *" !. &$!" !

+ " * "

! & ;!

&&''1$!3 -$ !,!

*"

*3"$"!. * /"'' *" ! * "&! , ! & 0$!"!+ ", "!&'""/ !. &$!" !

!"/",' /, " !*! "!3 &' +"! !+

$3 !%./"!'

1$! " &)'

3 !=$!' *,, &!," 3! < 3'* "*!%

'';!

&&''1$!3! *'/&$" $

&!," "< 3'* "*!% '' !"2.

!"' 3! ! &!,. ! .3 "&! 3" !3'' ,' +"$! "$'.,!/

'3$.* $

$" !:" %'' !

% "3

!', "$' *, " 1$!$."* $

"3! !$'/ ./" &! $!

+ 8''+"&!&$ ! .$ &'''

$ &$ !$% +"3,!+ $"&! &' 6 3"

%,*$!""!3! ! ,3 " $

%.,+"=$

'3

!%!

3! "&&'' 2 "'""1$!

"$'.,!/ '3 * ! *"3! !6$ $'/

./"&! %'' !

"!', 2

$ ""'!

&&''1$!" '

!

", "&!&!&!

&, ,3 ".,+" *$'! &&' ''3 "-$*% !&

./"'!

&&''1$!

"-$*% ! "!'$! ! !

#

$ 8""!&< *5!

C

8""!&!.'

C