High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3962/2013dismissed

Piara Singh And ANR v. Saudagar Singh And ORS

2020-05-21Mr. Justice Amol Rattan Singh23 pages

!"#$%

&''(( # )##

# &#' # *$ + (%,#"*( #$ %%- ."

/ %#*

# %0!

/ % . ."

#' 111 *( , 0###" '' ( ( /

# # # ##' 2'(

3 /"# " '#### ( # (( #"

'( * ( (" # " '* ( " #

# 2' * #' # # '' (3 # * * ( 4" "* "5 #(

0" #' '(

3/ # (/ ( , 2

# #' 3

#( '(

. ( # # "# #

4 /'#### ( (# (. '(

/ #

# 8"(#. /#' '#### ( #'" /". *

.." /.

, #( 4 #( #6

/ #"*' # (

. ( ( #( '(

/ # 8 #

# (( (( " (

#'#### '(

*#'' '* #4 #"( * #"

* ( 9

: ;" ##

# '#

# '' (" ( /# * < # ('(* "# ( "<

" " (/

# 9//#'#### '' / '(

# # / " " " *

(# 0 /#' # ( , /

* 2'# (

. #3 / # . < '( #

*# = ( (#" / # " '(

'.#( ( #

( #

# #

(#*. ''("

'.## = (# /"/ #*##

'' ( ##" #*## (

(# #*##

: 6 = *# '( / # " #

/ #(( ( (( . /"#

8" #( *#'# *

( , / #8" * <.

( #''/ * # ( "# "#5( # / #(

( # # ;8 / #" #/# * ,

8" .

(

. 2 6

3 # / /(( / ''# # )(( >

(# *

. ### 08" #/ # . * 8" 2 #+

.3 '(

" * # " 5 #''

## #

? #/ '" ## /" / ('" *# "6 0 '" 77 : '("

( '(

/ # * ((/###/ * ( ("$ @3 A'(

#( '#### #''

## # #

B= 3 A '(

# ( ( '* " #' B=

6 3 A #

8" ,

. '(

# (( ( (( . / "# ##( *#'# B=! 2.3 A '(

( '##B=! 2.3 A'(

##'' # " " " ( '##B=! 2.3 A##''.

( ''# "

# "B=! 2.3 A # #

*# "## '

#B=! 2.3 A##

= ( " B=! 283 A

# '" ## " 6 0 '"B=! 83 ( C

# ' * ( "# (/ '(

8 * *#( /### "( #/## # / ; * - *

)(( >

' " "* . " "( # # 2D83 = #

# 8 * (# E * ( / '# </ , # ## '# (( ,

#( # ''####'#"6

. (# #

"' # / (# ( . " # D8! / (' " (" 9 . "#

# . " ( ( " "

*""(# # D82 #D84 #* '( "#3 / ##/ (# # ;* ( /' '# '

# /### (#'

# / #/### '(

*#(

((# ### "#5( # "* / # ""' *# "9 # "

/ "# D. " " /

# . * #'. ## " # # ' 8" # (4

. # ,

.#((( #( # #

(* #### #5(2

3 7 # #'(

. <

( , / " #"## 8 * # !A

# #5(

* , / # * ( ( "#5( '(

" / # ""' " * (# # # '' / "# ('' "/ (#" #" . "

( '. F "# ( ''+ #5( ( . *# " 69 # " 7 "* # (# @/( ' C *

* /( ."**" ' . / ## ( # 8" ,

. '(

/ ( .*".

( # #5 #

#/ #( ..

(# ( / 0# ###23 23/ "

. '(

#( /".## 2 # #"

# *

( #''3 / (# "

. '(

# ####2.32.3 . "/ .

( 5 * / "

. '(

# ### #

# '" ## #''*# "6 0 ' " / #( # '.##( '#( / '## ## ( / **.

( '' # # * "# /( .

( / # G .'.# #'( # / # < #

'/* <

'" ## '' #" # #5 /( .

( '# "

# ,

# #5 # " ( "( '#*

</( '.# *

*'(

# # # #' '(

" #

9 0 '# # '' ( # *

(

( !#" , , ( " ## ((# * # #*## '' ( #. #" #

'.# = ( 2## .3 '(

# '.# # # '(

'( " " / . " #

# "( '#* # #/ ## # *"

# " #'# .# '.#2= ( 3 "( F.< + #

. 0# # #" '' ( "

* ( / " */ ###

'####2 # ( 3 / # * /" # "

6 H # " % %- ( # "#( # * #' '(

( # #< '* " # #

/" / # *

/. # ( '' ( .#(

# # " * /" '' ( / /

/" ( '# # #< '#### #( 9

: - #"#( " . .#( #' / " ((.'#### #( .

/ # 8" "

# /# /( .

# # / " * <'*'#### ( " " " (

"2 '####

. '(

3 #

# /((

(# ' 5# * < " ## #( : 8# * * 5 #" '' '#### / # . " ' " # ( ( '(

#< " '* " # # 2# * * # '#### #( "3 % 8 # 2D8 ( "# (/3 *(/"" (# 2D8!3

. # 8"

// #7 # ( I*D8 /# ' . #* # # '

#/ "# / #'

, '#" # 8/# "##8 * '(

#+ //### A# (# '(

*#( # * /#### "#

, * - #"#( " (( # ( #( / #(( . "" "# '

8# * #'D86 '(

( #

(*#*

/ ## /" #/# " (("# / # '

* / # 8" * < # * " % (# # * ' #" "* * /" #

4 "( . '

/ # # "# / #( #' # % ":6 0 ' " 77 # * .

( # ( **.

(''

( #

4*#"## ( / # #*

/":7 # " 7 # #*

"# '

" /( * # "#. "8 ' "( # 2"3 # " 7 /"##'( '

* **

'#" #

"*# # "*

" 9 % 8 # * . # ' .

" ( 2F 3/#

. #!A (("#+

* 5 #'' / ##

4/ ## "# #/ "*D8/ #(#

4 * < "*'((# * " #"8 % (#/# 'D8!6 (/"" 7 #'' # *# ( #"#(( '

((/judgments$

.# 2%

" H"3

72932.(3 ::? 23 .# 2 3 :9? 23 .# 2" H" #"3- /I !" J

7 2.3 !" .# # $ !"

((

0# % # * ( "# (/ . "*'(( '4 (.

'.## ( / "#5( # *# #. # # # ( '(

#*##

" %0!

( #"#( '' #' 2'(

3 #( ' * '* % & .#'(( ) ( :7 667 # * "* . " "

F.( + ( . " "#5( #

('. / # "* (. "" # ( "# # * " # "*'((

8# * ##/ * / ## * # ("# (/(("#+

""##8 * / #" " 5#' '(

"8 (# # * "* / # .

( / # ((" "( " (( . ""

# .

( (## # *' '

? /. #" " / # *

# "#5( "

# # #5# #" ""

< "# / #(## (("#+ / # .

( . # *'

8/# "##8 * '(

2 '

66 " ("3 "

" , / # *# / # # ## "#5(

#( #( '(

(#/# ' "* % <2 '

6 " ("3 /"" / # ( ( , # # ## '# #

#< "(

" / #/ .

#''# "( #( 0# # * # . (( / #

((/ ' "" , '. / *#/ #

8 # * !AE * ( F / "( * .</, /(( /.

* </

#( #

# #

0# %!

# * .

" ,

#/"###/(.

"/#

/ #(. /( #/ ( # / #

/.# "#5( / ##'#

#( #( '(

- # "#( 8 "##8 * /. # "G' ' #

# D8 ;8 . "8 % !

' '(*#/# * #2 '( 3 / " ((

* ( # *' / , *#(.# " "

# /( . #(

*( "# ( '' "" #" 4 "

6 - #"#(8# * "

#'' / #.'. . "# (''

" *#

" . (# # #" ( # .#( ./

" #" "*#/( '. #" '' %!

# * '' ( #*##

: (

# *# % ( # "#( '' # # * # # " (. ""

. "* . " "# D. "" 79 ("

(. ". / "* /. .

( . / "* "

" (( #'. / / "* "#5( /, . #( (/ ''####6

# (( # *

" #'.##"

0 %

"/( "#

(/ ''" * # '' '#'". # ' '.## ( / '' ( #.# ((/

."# * *#(

( / *# "# ## ( "# (/ #' % #+## #" *# ( #"(#

9 0 * # ( (" *

# .

( # ( "" ' "#

# ""'

(*' ./

" # ,

"* '

* *

* *# # #

7 ; , / * # #

8" 2 #' #3

. #/ #8" 6

/. . /6

* # ( ('" # ".("* ( #/ . *5 '( '* '(

(< ( "# (/ /( # # (.

" " (( / # #+

# # '#" /### /*#

" = . "##/ . ( ( # , 8" # "" (" "8"# '*

" # '

' /# *2 ' % !

3 . "(

* @*'

"C /( #/ ((/ #/(( /*

"* # ( , #

#/ #.'. / (8 '( ( * "* * < "*" (" ' .#" #"#/ " ((

( * /( ## (( # / /(( /

'(( ( #

/ ( # ''

. '(

" "( # * # '' # #5

. # 2# ##3 (/''#/ * "

< /

(

( ( # ''

( #*/".( ((##

( 0## 5 #(

" ( ( " # #'" "

((

" # #

( # /# *' # # # "

# ' '# . . , '(

. #"##8 * # #

' ' / # # ' ' 2 # " ( #"#( #' '(

3 # " (( #'.

" "

# . " / #. / ' ' . / (#* (# / #(

# #'. * ' '# 2 , 3

: " # #

"* # 8"

. #' '(

# / # ( "# (/ * * % ."#

D. "" 79 . ''("

'#"

. ## (# / # "* "

/ " (# ./

" # "*/"# '# # ( "*

" " #/##"

/# "

##" ,

# ( * # # (.

( "

/ "<'* ""*# "# "

#0 ## / '#/8" #

/ # "* (# #/##

"* # "* (#

#'. .*# " D. "" 79 ##8" # "

(

#'. #*'( "

# # #5( 8"##/ .8"

"* # * ( 2 ( / ( 3

# 0 #/( .#"( #'.8"

# "* #/ , / # # * /8"

" 8"

" / #/8" ((

# #( #'

(

#"## ** (

. #"( '. * / # , /

8" # # ## * ( (" ( '

' # * ##'" "

(("

# "##8 * # !A #'" "

((

* , / # * ( '#"

( (((# ) .#( # . (#( '# 8" , 6

. / (( # ## * # " # *' # ## *

( /5 #"('. / ". " ( /" .#( #

" ' #" * / / " 8" #

##/(( . "/ #. #/#" * . ( # '.

" #5( ( "# (/ #

. '(

/ # .

( ( 8" , / # "* ( # '##" *8% #+ * # ("# . '

/ #(

" (("#+ #

" (0/# ** . # "

" /. ' / , . . #

"# #/ .

9 '

# "# /"

* # #' #* #'

3 / #'

(## * <.

( /(

"(( # ( "#.

( I #%!

#""(' / .

( #( *# "# #/

# / # "

/ "((" *# "69 *'" 7 0 /( ( *

# # "

5 "# '

# ( /# /

#"/ 6 * ## "# '

% ( ' * '* * "

#23 */"#'" "

((' '

2- / I 3 /"

((/#$

!! ! !

!" # $ %#& $''

( )*

!"( " +,& - $'' - "

+ / 0

!" 1 $ / 0

2 3' 4

#$+ ' (' )+ '

!" * )+

)+ 224

-& $

% "

! ! !!"

! ! !

& ' ! $

! !

! ! ! ! !

! !

( !

!)* +,-

. #

/ : A - #'# . ( # * (8" "* ( "

(# # ( ('( "* .

( #/. '"'( ( / 5 ( (# #. /(5#/(

' ''(

# '

# #

. " ( '

# ( / ""*# "# 0#" (

(

"* #

" ((8" # # " , # #'. * #" /* .#(/((( ""'

"/#

". "# #

4 ###"

# / #'

"# * 8 (* * % "8 ":6 0 '" 77 ":7 # " 7 0#'.## " "" 79

((/#$ +,( (( -)./00123 @-"5(56 012/ !!

' !

1 (+0 "7772 ! !

! !

! 3

! $

! $+'

'6+ "777* ! ! ! $ ! ! / +0(" )./45023 @

" #$

%" & /5( $ )./06123 @* ! ! ! ! !

! 4 '

!! !

! ! / 9 = .#( .# # (" "# "*'(/"# '

? #""

" # *' #* #

2D8 ' *" . "( ("3 2 K*<4

# # 8" "* #

*# 2D.# *'# ((( "' D8 /" # .

(

( / # " / # @2 $

24 $"

$ 6/ ."( (.# ( (/ // # @, C3 0# /# ("# #/ #

4 (# . "( ( .# ( # '

# # "* # " /(

(( ."8 :7 # " "# / # '

* #" '

* ". * L;$ # " %

# *

# " # ( "# '

/ # ( #

4 /. '# ( D8#/ * "# #/ ##

4" ( #( #

4M 7 0" ( #"#( #

" #" "* '

* #"*/ #'. ' #" /( ( /"' *. . # #

* * #

8" # D8 0## #/

" #"(

#((

"* /*

/. * < "* 5 # ( * # * #'" "

(( 0 . *# " ( # "#( .

* "

## 2 (( 3 /( "*#" # I (( ## #"##

. /( ((/# '' (# # *# "###

( "# (/ #' ## #"

% #5( # '' (# #*## %

)'!")

)##7% ." 4 89&7: