Suraj Bhan And ORS. v. Shiv Dutt And ANR.












 

 





 !"

"#$%$&'
(&"
)
 (* +
, &

!,"*% --".. &!% /"*%(% ,$0
(!!

&!,"*  "%-&1"&!% 
 !"#$%
&' ()%)(
*$+&',-%  2,"!,"*
"-*!"*%

.# .
- -"*%
3 4
5"
..6"1
!
%""
!,"
+(173"&!8  
5"
*""**"1
!
!,"
"-*!"*%
*
&!8 9 2,"!,"*
!,"
+(173"&!
%,(.1
5"
*"-*!"1
$&
!,"
$7"%!8

*"%"&!'

*:,-* )
"&$*
10# !"
6$!,

*&;$!
$1, )
10# !") *
!,"
--".. &!%

* &+
: (%,$;)
10# !") *
!,"
# 0" !*% <<<<<







































)(
*$+& !$#"

3!$&

* &+
: (%,$;)
10# !")
6,
$%
&
!,"
# 0" !)
##"-!% &!$#"
&
5", .

!,"
*"%-&1"&!% --".. &!=1""&1 &!%
*"
77*$"0"1

!,"
+(173"&!%
&1 1"#*""%

5!,
!,"
(*!%
5".6)
6,"*"54
!,"
%($!
*
-%%"%%$&
54
6 4 
%-"#$$#
-"**3 &#"

!,"
7*""3"&!
!
%"..
1 !"1
>>)
, %



5""&
1"#*""1

*:,-* )
." *&"1
"&$*
(&%".
%%$%!"1
54

*&;$!
$1, )
10# !"
*
!,"
--".. &!%)
$&
%(--*!

!,"
7*(&1% 
--" .)
* $%"1
!,"
..6$&7
%(53$%%$&%'=  ,(7,
$&
!,"
6*$!!"&
%! !"3"&!)
!,"
"?"#(!$&

!," 7*""3"&!
!
%"..
1 !"1
>>
6 %
13$!!"1
$&
*"%-"#!
 . &1
3" %(*$&7

; & .%
!6
#*"%)
7*""1
!
5"
%.1
*
!! .
% ."
#&%$1"* !$&


9
. #%)
5(!
$!
6 %
%! !"1
$& !,"
7*""3"&!
!, !
!,"
" *&"%!
3&"4


>
. #%
6(.1
5" - $1
5"*"
!,"
(5
"7$%!* *@  !
$%
.%
-." 1"1
&1
# !"7*$#
# %"
!, !
!,"
--".. &!= 1""&1 &!%
*"(%"1
!
##"-!
!,"
" *&"%!
3&"4


>
. #% %
7*""3"&!
6 %
&.4
$&
*"%-"#!

&"
#*"

&1
&!
!6 #*"%


. &1
,$%
 #!
, %
&!
5""&
&!$#"1
&1)
!,"*"*") *" 1$&"%%
&1
6$..$&7&"%%)
3(#,
."%%
-*0$%$&%

"#!$& 
#

!,"
-"#$$#
".$"
#!)
9
*
%,*!
A9 #!B
, 1
&!
5""&
#3-.$"1
6$!,@ ,"
%#*$5"

!,"
7*""3"&!
&1
!,"
*"#"$-!
6 % (&1"*
$&7,
10# !"
,"
! *7"!
1 !"
*
"?"#(!$&
&1 *"7$%!* !$&

!,"
% ."
1""1
6 %
9)
5(!
!," *"%-&1"&!%
1$1
&!
--" *
5"*"
!,"
(5
"7$%!* *
,"

.

-."

!,"
-. $&!$%
!, !
!,"
(5
"7$%!* *
6 %
&!
0 $. 5."

&
!,"
1 !"

- 43"&!

!,"
" *&"%!
3&"4)
$")
>> , %
!! ..4
5""&
%, !!"*"1
$&
0$"6

!,"
"0$1"&#"
5*(7,!
& *"#*1
!, !
&
!, !
1 !")
5(!
C=
% ."
1""1%
6"*"
*"7$%!"*"1 54
!,"
(5
"7$%!* *
A.6 4%
5""&
*" 14
&1
6$..$&7B
$%
!," 5 %$#
$&7*"1$"&!

"#!$&


9
#!
*
%"";$&7 %-"#$$#
-"**3 &#"

!,"
7*""3"&!
!
%"..
,(7,)
!," %($!
6 %
$."1
&

>D)
5(!
&#"
!,"
 #!(3

" *&"%! 3&"4


>
. #%
, %
&!
5""&
-*0"1)
!,"*"*")
!," (*!%
5".6
(7,!
&!
!
, 0"
"?"*#$%"1
!,"
1$%#*"!$& (&1"*
"#!$&


9
#!
,"
*"%-&1"&!=-. $&!$% , 0"
.%
6*&7.4
1"1(#"1
!,"
%! !"3"&!

(* +
, &

2=D
*"7 *1$&7
!,"
.."7"1
13$%%$&

##"-! &#"

,$% %$7& !(*"%
&
7*""3"&!
!
%"..

&1
*"#"$-!
@ !
$%

# !"7*$#
# %"
!, !
!,"
%$7& !(*"%

!," --".. &!%
6"*"
! ;"&
54
!,"
*"%-&1"&!=-. $&!$%
54
6 4
 * (1
%
!,"
$&!"&!$&
6 %
!
%"..
&.4
&"
#*"

. &1
&1 &!
!6
#*"%
!,
!,"
(*!%
5".6
, 0"
.%
5""& $&.("&#"1
54
!,"
1#(3"&!%
?E)
?
&1
?F ,"
--".. &!%
, 1
1"-%$!"1
#"*! $&
3(&!%
!! ..$&7

> . #%
!
- 4
!,"
. &
* $%"1
7 $&%!
!,"
%($!
. &1
%
!,"

/

1#(3"&!%
, 0"
&!
5""&
-*0"1
$&
##*1 &#"
6$!,
. 6 &1)
!,(%)
(*7"%
!,$%
(*!
*
*3(. !$&

!,"
%(5%! &!$ . G("%!$&%

. 6
%
#(.."1
(!
$&
!,"
7*(&1%

--" .

* &+
: (%,$;)
." *&"1
#(&%".
*
!,"
*"%-&1"&!= -. $&!$%
%(53$!%
!, !
!,"
$&7*"1$"&!%

"#!$&

#

9
#!

, 1 5""&
-*0"1
54
5*$&7$&7
&
*"#*1
!,"
$1 0$!
1 !"1
9
!!"%!"1 54
!,"
?"#(!$0"
7$%!* !"
&1
!,"&
!"*
!,"
"?-$*4

!,"
! *7"!
1 !") %($!
6 %
$."1
&
>D
$&#"
!,"
--".. &!=1""&1 &!%
, 0"
&! 1"&$"1
!,"
%$7& !(*"%
&
!,"
*"#"$-!
&1
!,"
7*""3"&!
!
%"..)
$!
# &&! 0.!"= #"
&1

! ;"
(-
!,"
-."

&&=- 43"&!H*"#"$-!


>
. #% ,"
--".. &!=1""&1 &!%
, 0"
 $."1
!
-"**3
!,"$*
- *!

!," 7*""3"&!
6$&7
!
!,"
#, &7"
$&
!,"
0 .("

!,"
-*-"*!4
$&
!,"
3 *;"! ,"
7*""3"&!
!
%"..
#." *.4
-*"%#*$5"%
!,"
*"
&1)
!,"*"*")
!,"
-." 
%"..$&7
&"
#*"
. &1
$%
&
!"*!,(7,!
&1)
!,(%)
-* 4%
*
$*3$&7 !,"
$&1$&7% 
, 0"
," *1
!,"
."

*&"1
#(&%".
*
!,"
- *!$"%
&1 --* $%"1
!,"
- -"*
5;
&1

!,"
0$"6
!, !
!,"*"
$%
&
*#"
&1 %(5%! &#"
$&
!,"
%(53$%%$&%

*,-* )
*)
!,"
*"%-&1"&!=-. $&!$% , 0")
!,*(7,
* .
&1
1#(3"&! *4
"0$1"&#")
-*0"1
!,"
$&7*"1$"&!%
 "#!$&

#

9
#!
$& %3(#,
%
!, !
!,"
--".. &!=1""&1 &!% , 0"
&!
5""&
5."
!
5".$"
!,"
%$7& !(*"%
&
7*""3"&!

0

*"#"$-!


$&1"-"&1"&!
"0$1"&#"
, %
5""&
."1
!
1$%5".$"0"
!," #&!"&!%

!,"
*"#"$-!

&!
, 0$&7
*"#"$0"1

>
. #%
&
!,"
-*"3$%" !, !
!,"
. &1
7*""1
!
5"
%.1
6 %
&.4
&"
#*"
&1
&!
!6
#*"% 7*""3"&!
!
%"..
, %
.%
5""&
-*0"1
!,*(7,
!,"
!"%!$3&4

%#*$5"

2=9
(&1"*
$&7,
10# !"
&1
!!"%!$&7
6$!&"%%
2=D
(3"*
$&7,  35"*1 *
0"&
!,"
%(3



>
. #%
, %
5""&
-*0"1
!,*(7, 1#(3"&!%
?E)
?
&1
?F &
34
0$"6)

!,"
$.$&7

!,"
%($!
$33"1$ !".4
!"*
!," "?-$*4

!,"
! *7"!
1 !"
%,6%
*" 1$&"%%
&1
6$..$&7&"%%
,"
-*"%"&! # %"
%G( *".4
 ..%
6$!,$&
!,"
- * 3"!"*%

!,"
* !$
1"#$1"&1$
#(.."1
(! 54
!,"
&I5."
(-*"3"
(*!
$&
12
3 245655
 47 473+  8/ 

191 0..
"%-&1"&!=-. $&!$%
, 1
5""& *" 14
!,*(7,(!)
$")
*3
!,"
1 !"

"?"#(!$&

7*""3"&!
!
%"..) 1(*$&7
!,"
-"&1"&#4

%($!)
!$..
- %%$&7

!,"
1"#*""


1
&!
$&1
&4 $.."7 .$!4
&1
-"*0"*%$!4
$&
!,"
$3-(7&"1
+(173"&!%

&1
1"#*""%
," $&1$&7%
*"&1"*"1
54
!,"
(*!%
5".6
*"
5 %"1
(-&
!,"
* .
&1 1#(3"&! *4
"0$1"&#"
,"
% 3"
*"
##*1$&7.4
$*3"1
 %(5%! &!$ .
G("%!$&

. 6
*$%"%
*
1"!"*3$& !$& --" .
%! &1%
1$%3$%%"1 & +   )(
*$

354 &',-%