← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1745/2016dismissed

Bhasha v. Dalbir Singh & ORS

2018-08-10Mrs. Justice Anita Chaudhry7 pages

 

      

   !

 

   !" " ##$$ %&

$( & )"*"&

 #*

"

   !

$( & )"

##$$ %&

+

"&')", *"&

 #*

  #  $%  %&

% -&  &.

"/0'#1*2 

&"##$$ 

*

&"& #* 

 &&'3 1 &*2 4 "

&("

"5"'$$1*2 

&"##$$ 

*

&& #* 

 %&

%' !7"

.'*)8 

*

 "$$ * *

# * (""##$ &&

)' 8 *" $&*9 & ##$$:'&"*$ *

# * (""##$ (7

88.'*)8 ;"

*&*#

"

:'&1"<' $4

4"

"&

& $$4     =>""&  &$    #

  (7  47  

#& )&8 $7(* *8&$7")&'* "4& "2 $*"#&#&7 && ) )&8 $$ ('( &"

' ?

-$

$*  &

#& )&8

$$**   4"& $* <' 4 )&*( $*" &   1@#& & &$ $

*&  1 1@ " 8 & ) )&8 $$1#$

"*# * '8

 11@    &   87  *  &)  *  &  A '   * &)

& $**4

A*   -$

#$* "" 4    "  

    "  '(  )

&&  $)  4 "  ($   $

*& *A# 8#*'7 ('"* * *

8#& #& &8" &#& -$

8&5*"

#& B"& &1)2

"*  8*A ' " $**   ('"* $$* * 8#&  2     1$"')""#$

)  &8 * #&  *8*"&#78  11@4 *.

*   -$

'&"&#$* ""&

4 ) 2"*   $$ )'#"*  8*A '" $**  

$*4&  8*#$**" "#$

"*5" &"'8( 8#&

@

)'& #4&

&7 ""

($ "4""

"2 )#4&&  )&8 $$*

*'#& 22* C"'

)'& * "'8( 8#&

"* 4&( *(7 &'*;4 '&"&

 #$**"/ &$ " "*"* " &"'8( 8#&

*

)'& "2( 2&* )&8 $$;

'&"& #$**"/ &$ 8#&

*'#"* ""7&" 8 #& 14""2 8#'& " "$**1"& &1 $**

4&)&)

&*  4 $** *  

$** ;4 '&"&#$**(7"#$

"** $#78  11@4 *.

* ,&*& $:'& && &* )

* )")&8

#&2**#78  11@ & 87

$ #&2*1 * $ *)&&$

#& " $$4 ))&'* ** $#78  11@" (#&2*

"&

& # #78

#$

4 &*7*4 $$ )#& &8"

#& "

 ""*$7$5"

"

'1$"')"1"4 #7 8&" $5"

B 1":'&&*&*"*'($ "& 87(& '**(7"*  $)4 " & " &  D C4 

& ##$ 4&#& &&*(7"#$

*

*(7*  ,&*9 & ##$$:'&"$*"" #$

4 &*7*4 $$ )#& &8"

#& *

$$ &*7*4 $$ )#& &8"

#& 1"42&1":'& & )&&$

#& ")&'*""#&#&7 " $&*7( $* * * 14"&

#

"#&#&7C"'

1".'*)8#

*(7"$&*& $ :'&&*& )& 2&7 *'($ "& 87$)4 " &

4

&8* C"

:'&" "&*$&* '

$ &"#& $)"

*4 "" &($

 )"&')"".'*)8

*(7" :'& ($4*#" #7 "& &*#&2 **(7$&* '

$ & "#& && 

4"&

( )*

#'* ,&* '

$ &"##$$" '(8 *""$&* & ##$$:'&" '*"")&8

#&2**" #$

&*7*4 $$ )#& &8"

#& C"& &1 "$&*9 & ##$$:'&&&* &

))&&$

#& B '(8 *"8&$7( '

"& $** "2( A '* * * " (")&'* &   " 

 #&     )&8    $$  B '&"&  *&4  ":'&" $****  4 $**  *        $  **    #&  *& 8  ( &  "  '( )

&&1#78" (8* "

'()

&&;

 " "* * ""&4 7#& &)&8

$$;

'&"&

)

"/ &$ 4 4 

" )&8 $$**   A '* "#$

/ & $

 $   4 

  $$  "  "&  $  **  A '*  2'&  

* * ;

$ " "*  " / &$ "* "**)2"8 8#&

" $**

( ) A '*  8#&714" "*&*     )&8 $$ ; "

& '8  1#$

( *(

'$ ,'

4A8 "(

* * * 

!

* * * &#&2* &" $$4 ) & / &$ 1 )4 

$**

* * 

$ " )4 

)&8

"#$

#78" (8*( &"'()

&&

 * "2##&* "4 

(A($ )"#$

 &

A8 "8

*'"&'"C" $8' &4"

"""& $** "2(A '* 8   E11@;

"

)"$7'$ 5$7"4 "'7#& &)&8 $$ * & $7* * #'& " *"#&#&7*"$ 4 "' 85 )7#78" 8 A ' $**&( &" &)

& '"& 7 4$'

*&"<' $4 ;"

*&*#

"

:'&1  

#&2*

$ ""#$

"*&* )&8 $$*4 $47 &*7 *4 $$ )#& &8"

#& 1'$

"&& & "&

&

#& ")&8 (* *$7 ")&'*""4& #& 22*& "2 $*"#&#&7

8$ '$



#&2*"" '( <'#'& " &

&(

*#'& " & ;

&" '( <'2* #&2""7 &(

*#'& " & ;"#&  1* * "2 ##*

"4 

(A*'(1 E "#

$  )&

#& " '( <'#'& " & ":'&

* ""

 &

&

&2$'($

*& 1"87 )* "*&

& "*

"& ) $  E "#

$ 

A& * '*&  = 



 

 

 

     

                       

     



   

 

    

                 

 

    

  

 

     

  



 

 

       

         !     

  

  

     

     

 

  

      



  

            



  



 

       

              

       

                 

            "

#        

          

             $ ;"#&   

*&$ &1* * "2 $*#&2" 

  F &  #78     E11@ 

"4    (  # * 

*2  "*"

)4 *" 8 A ' $ ** ;2 4"& 1<' $4 &8*&$ &

4&*

"##$$ ;87(

*"* * "2 " ##&1$"')" #&

&#&1* *" (#& $$7

&2*** * &"'

(**4

$ ) "'

 ;2 4 " & *1

 

$*(7"#$

$$4*4"& 



$*(7"*

*

* $$"#* )8

$$'

##$



71&*

# * 2 4 "(2 *.'*)8  

%&

%!



   >""&#5 )@ * + @ >""&#&($  + @