← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/2190/2017dismissed

Surender Kumar Saini & ORS v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2018-01-17Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain,Mr. Justice Mahabir Singh Sindhu6 pages

   

      

 ! "#$#% $ &'( )(* + !, - ./0(!)(01/2&0.& ! &!)'3(0+ 455(66&!'+ 7(0+/+ .'&'(  &08&!&&!)'3(0+ 44(+5!)(!'+

,

9 .

 . 

9 .

." 0(+(!', 0...3(:3&;&'<)=*&'( 0'3(&55(66&!'+ >>>    

3&66(!?( !'3 + !'0&*/0'&55(&6 +'0)(0)&'() 5&++() @8 '3( 6(&0!() "0 ' /0' ) +2 ++ !? '3( ;0 ' 5(' ' ! 50&8 !? 0 A/&+3 !?  0)(0)&'()#!!(B/0( C  5&++() @8 '3( .(*0('&08< &08&!& )(*6 ! !? '3( 50&8(0   '3( &55(66&!'+C5(' ' !(0+ 0 &)D/+'2(!'!'3(5+'+ !'3(5&8+*&6( $$E0!(+'(5@(6;

 55(66&!'+C5(' ' !(0+ ;(0( 0('0(!*3() ! '3( 8(&0  02 '3( &08&!& .2&66 .*&6( !)/+'0 (+ &!) B50' 050&' !  2 '() 3(0( !& '(00( (00()'&+F'3( 050&' !93( 0*6& 2@( 0('3("0 '

/0';&+ 0?0&!' 5&8+*&6( ($E -$&+;&+@( !?)0&;!@8 '3(2&''3(' 2( '3( 00('0(!*32(!' !0('0(!*32(!' !'3(8(&0< '3(&55(66&!'+C5(' ' !(0+;(0(&55 !'()&+ 6(0:+ !)

(0(!')(5&0'2(!'+ /!)(0'3( &08&!& =(0!2(!'= )(&55 !'2(!'6(''(0+!!(B/0(+C &!) C- !'3(8(&0% !'3(5&8+*&6( G$E#$

HI



0 (=&!*( '3(&55(66&!'+C5(' ' !(0+@( 0('3(6(&0!()"0 '

/0';&+'3&'3&= !?;0:()!3 ?3(05&8C+*&6( ($E -$&''3( ' 2( '3( 00('0(!*32(!'<'3(8/?3''3&=(@((!&)D/+'()&?& !+'5+'+ *&008 !?'3(+&2(5&8+*&6(0!(+'(56;(0(6 &!*(;&+56&*()!'3( 56 *8 0 &)D/+'2(!'   0('0(!*3() (2568((+ ( !!(B/0( C$ )&'() %%&+&6+!'3()(* + !@8&6(&0!(). !?6((!*3 /0' !

"#$$  !*&+(' '6()&+7 D&8&1&/6=+.'&'(  &08&!&&!) '3(0+!!(B/0(CG&+&6+)(* + ! - /536) !? '3()(* + ! '3(6(&0!(). !?6(/)?(

 3( &55(66&!'+C5(' ' !(0+ ;3 3&) @((! &)D/+'() ! )

(0(!' )(5&0'2(!'+ ! '3( 8(&0 % 5/0+/&!' ' '3( 0 0('0(!*32(!' ! < !=:() '3( D/0 +) *' !   '3 + /0' @8 ;&8  "  -$   G ;3 *3;&+) +5+() = )(0)(0)&'()- #; '3&) 0(*' !''3(

 .(*0('&08< =(0!2(!'   &08&!& ' *!+ )(0 &!) )(* )( '3( 0(50(+(!'&' ! '3(&55(66&!'+C5(' ' !(0+/0+/&!''3(0('<0(50(+(!'&' !

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

HGI  &  &0& ! 1&/+3 :9+ *&+( ./50& &!) '3(0 *!!(*'() *&+(+ !=6=()&)D/+'2(!' 0('0(!*3()(2568((+ 02)

(0(!' 050&' !+ 3( = + !(!*3!' *()'3&''3(&)D/+'2(!' (2568((+ !+& )*&+(+ 3&)@((!2&)(+/@D(*'''3( 0 6 !?&

)&= '+'3&''3( 0&)D/+'2(!';/6) @(*!+ )(0()&+ 0(+3&55 !'2(!'&!)'3&''3(8;/6)!'*6& 2@(!( ' 5&+' +(0= *( 0 '3( 5(0 ) '3(8 0(2& !() /'   +(0= *( &+ & 0(+/6'  0('0(!*32(!'    '(0 3&= !? &**(5'() '3( *!) ' !< '3(8 */6) !' '/0! &0/!)&!) 25/?!'3(*!) ' !3( = + !(!*3 /0'3(03(6)'3&''3( *3&66(!?(''3(*!) ' !&++/?3''@(2&)(<;&+@(6&'()<'3(*!) ' ! /?3' ' 3&=( @((! *3&66(!?() @( 0( &**(5' !? '3( 

(0 2&)( @8 '3(

=(0!2(!'(+ )(+<&660('0(!*3()(2568((+;33&)@((!&)D/+'()3&) 0(*( =() 0('0(!*32(!' *25(!+&' ! &!) ;(0( !' &+:() ' 0('/0! '3( 0('0(!*32(!'*25(!+&' !<*!+(A/(!' &668<'3(*!) ' !6& ));!@8'3(

=(0!2(!'&55(&0()'@(D/+'

()&+'3(0(;&+&@0(&: !'3( 0+(0= *( 0&!? !? 02';' /08(&0+ ('3(5(0 ) 0;3 *3'3(8;(0(/' +(0= *(

 3(&55(66&!'+C5(' ' !(0+;(0(0('0(!*3() !'3(8(&0&!) ;(0( &)D/+'() ! &6'(0!&' =( 5+'+ ! '3( 8(&0 % ;(=(0< '3( D/0 +) *' ! /0';&+ !=:()!68 !'3(8(&0G (& '(0&?&5  +(=(! 8(&0+ &!) '3&' ' !68 & '(0 '3( )(* + ! ! 7 D&8& 1&/69+ *&+( +/50&



0 (=&!*( '3(&55(66&!'+C5(' ' !(0+@( 0('3(6(&0!()"0 '

/0';&+'3&'&66 '3(2;(0(?0&)/&'(+&''3(' 2( '3( 00('0(!*32(!' &+&6+&''3(' 2( '3( 0&55 !'2(!'''3(!(;5+'+<'3(0( 0(<'3(8 /?3' ' 3&=( @((! &55 !'() ' '3( % 5+'+   !+5(*'0+< C5(0&' =( .* (' (+&+;(0(&)2 ''()68=&*&!'(+ )(+<'3(83&)6(&0!''3&' G5+'+

H#I !'3(5&8+*&6( $E -$J$#$E-;(0(&=& 6&@6(&''3(' 2( ;3(!'3(8;(0(&55 !'()@8;&8 &)D/+'2(!' !'3(8(&0%!!(B/0( C3(8 /0'3(050&8() 0&)D/+'2(!'!'3(@&+ + +(! 0 '8 !&?( ! '(02+ 6&/+(  = '3(!'

*&' !)&'()%%

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

 !'0&C*/0'&55(&63&+@((! 6() !'(0&6 &!'3(?0/!)'3&'& *66(*' =( 0(50(+(!'&' ! 3&) @((! 2&)( @8 '3( &55(66&!'+C5(' ' !(0+ ! G% 66;()@8+(=(0&6'3(0+'0(+5!)(!''0(+6=('3( 0 ?0 (=&!*( @/' ' ! &=& 6< '3(0( 0(< ! '3( * 0*/2+'&!*(+< '3( &55(66&!'+C 5(' ' !(0+ !=:()'3(D/0 +) *' ! /0'@8;&8 "-$ G;3 *3;&+) +5+() = )(0)(0)&'()- #@8'3(6(&0!()"0 '

/0' !5/0+/&!*( ;3 *3'3(*6& 2 '3(5(' ' !(0+;&+0(D(*'()= )( 0)(0)&'()#@8'3( .(*0('&08<'3(0 0('3(0(;&+!)(6&8 3()(* + ! '3(6(&0!()"0 ' /0';&+ !)(0?&' ! '3()(* + ! ! 7 D&8& 1&/69+ *&+( +/50& &+ /53(6) @8 &  = + ! (!*3< @(+ )(+< '3( )(* + ! !$  3&)@((!(00!(/+68&556 ())D/+'2(!' 2&)(;&+ !)(0?&' ! 6&/+(  = '3('

*&' !)&'()%%

H$I ;3 *30(A/ 0()(6 ? @6(5(0+!+'@(*!+ )(0() 0&)D/+'2(!'!'3(@&+ + +(! 0 '8 &?(('*

   "(3&=(*!+ )(0()'3(+/@2 ++ !+2&)(@86(&0!()*/!+(6

0'3(&55(66&!'+@/'0(?0('/0 !&@ 6 '8'&**(5''3(+&2(

  !)/@'()68<'3(&55(66&!'+;(0(0('0(!*3() !'3(8(&0 /0+/&!''56 *8!!(B/0($)&'()%%<'3(&55(66&!'+C5(' ' !(0+ ;(0(&)D/+'() !)

(0(!')(5&0'2(!'+/!)(0'3( =(0!2(!'  &08&!& ! '3(8(&0%6 *8!!(B/0($)&'()%%!;3(0(+' 5/6&'(+ '3&''3(0('0(!*3()(2568((+;/6)@(&55 !'() !'3(+&2(+*&6(0!( +*&6(6;(0'3&!'3(!(+'3(83&)@((!;0: !? !3(!680 ?3' &55(66&!'+C5(' ' !(0+ ! '(02+   '3( 56 *8 !!(B/0( $ ;&+ ' @( &55 !'() ! &! (A/ =&6(!' 5+' 0 !( +'(5 6;(0  3( 5(' ' !(0+ 2& !'& !()&+' *+ 6(!*( 0+(=(!8(&0+&!) !=:()'3(D/0 +) *' !

/0' !68 @8 ;&8  " -$   G ( +(=(! 8(&0+ & '(0 '3( &**0/&6 '3(*&/+( &*' !& '(0'3( 0&)D/+'2(!' !'3(8(&0%3( &55(66&!'+C5(' ' !(0+ &5&0' 02 )(6&8   +(=(! 8(&0+ ! &550&*3 !? '3(

/0' !=:()'3(D/0 +) *' ! /0'@8;&8 "-$ G!685/0+/&!'''3()(* + ! !7 D&8&1&/69+*&+(+/50&66'3( &55(66&!'+C5(' ' !(0+ ;(0( &55 !'() ' 0/5 F 9 5+'+ ( '3( +&2( *&'(?08 5+'+ !;3 *3'3(83&)@((!;0: !? !'3( 050&' !&''3( ' 2(   '3( 0 0('0(!*32(!'  3(8 &**(5'() '3( '(02+ &!) *!) ' !+  &55 !'2(!'&''3(' 2( '3( 0&)D/+'2(!';3 *3;&+

(0()''3(2&+5(0 '3(56 *8 =(0!2(!'&!) ';&+!''3(*3 *( '3(&55(66&!'+C 5(' ' !(0+'+((:&55 !'2(!'&?& !+'&+5(* *5+' '3( 0*3 *(3( &)D/+'2(!' '3(0('0(!*3()(2568((+@( !?&!(' 2(2(&+/0(;3 *33&) (!)(); '3'3(&)D/+'2(!' '3(0('0(!*3()(2568((+< ';&+!'5(!'

H%I '3( &55(66&!'+C5(' ' !(0+ ' *3&66(!?( '3( +&2( &!) '3&' ' &' & @(6&'() +'&?( '3('(02+&!)*!) ' !+ &)D/+'2(!';(0(!'&**(5'&@6(''3( &55(66&!'+C5(' ' !(0+<'3(+&2(/?3''3&=(@((!*3&66(!?()&''3(' 2( '3(

(0;&+2&)(&!)!'& '(06&5+( !/2@(0 8(&0+3(56(&'3&' '3(8 /?3' ' 3&=( @((! &55 !'() &?& !+' % 5+'+   !+5(*'0+  C 5(0&' =(.* (' (+&+;(0(+'&'()'3&=(@((!&)2 ''()68=&*&!'&''3(' 2(  '3( 0 &)D/+'2(!' + &6+   ! &=& 6 + !*( &)2 ''()68 '3( &55(66&!'+C 5(' ' !(0+) )!' /6 6'3((6 ? @ 6 '8*!) ' !++' 5/6&'() 0&55 !'2(!' ''3(+& )5+'+

    :(; +( (=(! '3( 56(& '3&' '3( &)D/+'2(!' ;&+ !' ! &**0)&!*( ; '3 6&/+(   =   '3( !'

*&' ! )&'() %% !!(B/0($ (K(6 ? @6(5(0+!++3&66@(*!+ )(0() 0&)D/+'2(!'! '3(@&+ + +(! 0 '8 &?(L< + !&=& 6+ !*( ';&+3 ?368@(6&'()3( &55(66&!'+C5(' ' !(0+;(0(&55 !'()!'3(6;(05+'&+5(0&=& 6&@ 6 '8 =&*&!* (+

   0'3(0(&+!+&+&0(0(*0)()&@=(<;(&0( '3(*!+ )(0() = (; '3&' ! *&+( ;3&'+(=(0 + 2&)( /' 0 !'(0 (0 !? ; '3 '3( ;(66C 0(&+!()0)(0)&'() 5&++()@8'3(6(&0!()"0 ' /0'

   **0) !?68< !) !? ! 2(0 ' ! '3( &55(&6< '3( +&2( + ) +2 ++() !6 2 !(  

   

!   

!  - &2 '  "3('3(0+5(&: !?J0(&+!(), (+J  "3('3(00(50'&@6( , (+J