← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaITA/322/2018dismissed

The Commissioner Of Income Tax (Exemptions), Chandigarh v. M/S Markandeshwar Educational Society, Ismailabad, Kurukshetra (Pan: Abtm5217g)

2020-01-20Mr. Justice Ajay Tewari,Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan6 pages

      

 

 

 !" ## $ %&%'( )#*+ , 

  ! "   !#! $%&%'( 

$%'%&)*+,-!%'.$!(+'/.'01'&%, $()% +22%,,+'(  -

*./.0!/ )%  $%3%'1%  )+&  .,%/  ()%   +22%+,  +0+.'&(  ()%  $/%$  /+(%/

4

52+&&%/6*()%'78%+922%,,+(%$.61'+,-)+'/.0+$): &)$(-  ()%  $.61'+,;  +,,<.'0  ()%  +22%+,    ()%  $%&2'/%'(=&7.%(* :)%$%.'+ (%$$% %$$%/(+&()%&7.%(*;+'//.$%7(.'0()%88.&&.'%$

'78%+9:9%82(.'&;:

$&)$(-()%;(0$+'($%0.&($+(.'1'/%$ !%7(.' ()%'78%+97(- >?

:

$&)$(-()%7(;,,<.'0 &16&(+'(.+,@1%&(.'& ,+<)+3%6%%'7,+.8%/

 ")%()%$'()% ()%7+&%()% '6,%)+&%$$%/.'/.$%7(.'0()%$%0.&($+(.'(6%

  +77$/%/.'&(%+/ $%3%$(.'0.(6+7B $$%=%9+8.'+(.'.'

()%  ,.0)(    C1/08%'(    ()%  '6,%  ,,+)+6+/  .0) 1$(.'+22%+,



.'()%7+&% -

%%$1(#& D&$1&(- %%$1(-<)%$%.'.(<+&)%,/ ()+(()%$.61'+,71,/)+3%$/%$%/ $&%((.'0+&./%()% $/%$ %0.&(%$.'01()$.(*$% 1&.'0$%0.&($+(.'61(.( 71,/'()+3%/.$%7(%/ $$%0.&($+(.'&($+.0)(+<+*.'+&

817)  +&  ()%$%  )+&  (  6%  &+(.& +7(.'  $%7$/%/  6* ()% %0.&(%$.'01()$.(*<).7)<+&,+7B.'0E  ")%()%$'()% ()%7+&%()% '6,%)+&%$$%/.'.0'$.'0()% .'/.'0()+(()% +22,.7+'(&7.%(*)+&7'&.&(%'(,*+3+.,%/6%'% .(1D&

: ;:...+/; ()%7(+'/()+(()%'+(1$+,2$0$%&&.'

%'(+.,&+'/%'(.(,%& ()%%/17+(.'+,&7.%(.%& (0

: ;:3.;+'/'($%61((%/()%&7'(%'(.'.'().& $%0+$/E  ")%()%$'()% ()%7+&%-()% '6,%)+&%$$%/.''(+/C1/.7+(.'0'()%.&&1%

7)+'0%.'($+7B $8&%7(.'

: ;:...+/;(&%7(.'&

+'/  ()%7(6*()%&7.%(*2+$(.71,+$,*<)%'()% &+8%)+&6%%'7,+.8%/ $&16&(+'(.+,'186%$ *%+$&E # ")%()%$'()% ()%7+&%-()% '6,%.&$.0)(.'.0'$.'0()% +7(()+(()%8+.'

%82)+&.& ()%&7.%(*.&+//.'0(.(& ,%%( 3%).7,%& +'/()%$%6*0%'%$+(.' +'()%$&1$7% .'78%E # ")%()%$'()% ()%7+&%()%

 '6,%)+&%$$%/.'.0'$.'0()%& .'/.'0()+( ()%8+.' 71& ()%+&&%&&%%&7.%(*<+&7$%+(.'

+&&%(&  $+()%$  ()+'  '  $%/%2,*8%'(   1'/&  (<+$/& %/17+(.'+'/'%=

+7(.3.(.%&71,/'(2+&&81&(%$+& &*&(%8+(.7+7(.3.(.%&0%+$%/(<+$/&()%6C%7(.'&E # ")%()%$'()% ()%7+&%-()% '6,%)+&%$$%/.'.0'$.'0()%& .'/.'0&()+( &+,+$*+'/ %%&($17(1$% ()%&7.%(*<+&'(.'&*'7<.() ()%  .'&($17(.'&  .&&1%/  6*  ()%  !  <).,%  2$3./.'0 +

.,.+(.'  +'/ ().& .'

$+7(.'    $%01,+(.'&  03%$'.'0 %/17+(.')+&8(.3%& 2$ .(%%$.'0 $()%&+8%E #")%()%$'()% ()%7+&%-()% '6,%)+&%$$%/.'.0'$.'0()%& .'/.'0&()+( '%3./%'7%<+&2$3./%/3.&=+=3.&,+'/<'%/6*()% &7.%(*%97%2(+$% %$%'7%.'()%6+,+'7%&)%%(+'/()% +7(   2&&%&&.'    ,+'/  <.()  ()%  &7.%(*  $%8+.'%/ 1'3%$.

.+6,%E #")%()%$'()% ()%7+&%-()% $/%$ ()%22%,,+(%$.61'+,.&7'($+$*(()%%3./%'7% +'/  8+(%$.+,  '  ()%  $%7$/    ()%  7+&%  +'/  ()%$% $% 2%$3%$&%EF %7%&&+$* +7(&+$%()+(()% &7.%(*7+8%.'(%9.&(%'7%'



+'/ $'186%$ *%+$&.(+3+.,%/6%'% .(1'/%$!%7(.'

: ;

 ()%7()%+.8&+'/6C%7(& ()%&7.%(*<%$%(%/17+(%()%7).,/$%'

 &1$$1'/.'03.,,+0%&  G1$1B&)%($++'/()%$2,+7%&H(%/17+(%()% $1$+,7).,/$%'<.()()%,+(%&(+'/8/%$'(%7)'.@1%& %/17+(.'+'/(

I 2$%2+$%()%78.'00%'%$+(.'(6%78%0/+'/<$()*7.(.J%'&)% &7.%(*+.8%/(8+B%+'+,,+$1'//%3%,28%'( 2%$&'+,.(.%& $1$+, 7).,/$%'+'/(6$.'07).,/$%' ()%2$+'/<%+B%$&%7(.' ()%&7.%(* +(2+$<.()()%7).,/$%' 122%$&($+(+ ()%&7.%(*+'/ 1$()%$(2%'

&7),&+'/.'&(.(1(.'&.'1$6+'+$%+&'+22,.7+(.'<+&83%/6% $% ()% $$%0.&($+(.'1'/%$!%7(.' ()%7(-()%+22,.7+(.'<+& $%C%7(%/3./%$/%$/+(%/

?)%<).,%$%C%7(.'0()%+22,.7+(.'

(B.'(7'&./%$+(.'()+(%+$,.%$()%&7.%(*<+&$%0.&(%$%/1'/%$!%7(.'

: ; ()%7(+'/)+&'<83%/+'+22,.7+(.' $$%0.&($+(.'1'/%$ !%7(.' ()%7(1$()%$()+(()%&7.%(*)+/8+/%%92%'/.(1$% +//.'0  (  ()%  ,%%(    ()%.$  3%).7,%&-  ()%$%6*  7$%+(.'0  +&&%(&  +'/  ()+( ($+'&2$(+(.'<+&'('% ()%6C%7( ()%&7.%(*(<+&'(%/()+(()% &+,+$.%&2+./(()%&(+

<%$%'(.'&*'7)$'.J+(.'<.()()%.'&($17(.'& .&&1%/6*!-$+()%$&+,+$.%&2+./<%$%'()%,<%$&./% 00$.%3%/ ()%$/%$-+'+22%+,<+& .,%/-()%$.61'+,3./% $/%$/+(%/ 4

5+,,<%/()%+22%+,)%$.61'+,7'&./%$%/()+( $%C%7(.'<+&8+.',*'&1&2.7.')%$%<+&'7$%+(.' +&&%(&-$+()%$ ()%3%).7,%&+//%/(()% ,%%(<%$%&7),61&%&(<+& 1$()%$)%,/()+( ,%&&%$ 2+*8%'(   &+,+$* ( ()%($+.'%/ (%+7)%$&  '<)%$% /%8'&($+(%& 782$8.&%<.()@1+,.(* %/17+(.'$%&%'(+22%+,.&+0+.'&(()%$/%$

()%$.61'+, %+$'%/71'&%, $()%$%3%'1%$+.&%/()%0$.%3+'7%()+(()% &7.%(*  <+&  .'/1,0.'0  .'  +//.'0  '186%$    3%).7,%&-  %3%'  ()10) ($+'&2$(+(.'<+&'%3%$()%6C%7( ()%&7.%(* )%  7'(%'(.'  $+.&%/  .&  '(  <%,,= 1'/%/  )%  .'/.'0 $%7$/%/6*()%$.61'+,.& '( /.&21(%/()+(()%3%).7,%&+//%/<%$%

4 &7),61&%&3%'.

($+'&2$(+(.'<+&'(&2%7.

.7+,,*8%'(.'%/.'()% +.8&+'/6C%7(& ()%&7.%(*-()%&+8%<.,,'(8+B%+'*/.

%$%'7% +$$*.'07).,/$%'(()%&7),&+'/6+7B)8%.&+'%&&%'(.+, $$1''.'0 &7),&%&2%7.+,,*.

()%&7),&+$%.'$1$+,+$%+&)%&+ %(* &(1/%'(&.&  1(8&(.82$(+'7% )%$%.&+'()%$+&2%7( ()%8+((%$()+(21$7)+&% &7), 61&%&<.,,'(+81'((+8+&&.'0+&&%(&-$+()%$.(.&.' 1$()%$+'7% ()% 6C%7( ()%&7.%(*(2$3./%@1+,.(*%/17+(.')% 1'/&<%$%1(.,.&%/

$%/17+(.'21$2&%&)%$%.&'7)+,,%'0%(()% .'/.'0 ()%$.61'+, ()+(,<%$&+,+$*2+./<+&'(+(()%7&( @1+,.(* %/17+(.'-8$%3%$ ().&.(&%, 7+''(6%+7'&./%$+(.' $$% 1&.'0$%0.&($+(.'1'/%$!%7(.'

()%7((().&C1'7(1$%-.(<1,/6%2%$(.'%'(('(%()+(8%$%,* ()% +7(()+(()%&7.%(*<+&%+$,.%$$%0.&(%$%/1'/%$!%7(.'

: ; ()% 7(  7+''(  6%  (+B%'  +&  +'  +/3%$&%  0$1'/  $  7'&./%$+(.'    ()% +22,.7+(.' $$%0.&($+(.'1'/%$!%7(.' ()%7((.& $()% &7.%(*((+B%2$1/%'(/%7.&.' $.(&%, +&(<).7)&%7(.'<1,/6%8$% 6%'% .7.+, )%6C%7(& ()%&7.%(*<%$%'(/16(%/6*()%%97%2(

$()%6C%7(.'&$+.&%/+63%)%/%'.+,<+&8%$%,*'&1$8.&%&+'/ 7'C%7(1$%&)%$%.&'%$$$.'()%$/%$ ()%$.61'+,/.$%7(.'00$+'(

$%0.&($+(.'(()%&7.%(*<%3%$-.(<1,/6%'%%/,%&&(&(+(%()+(.' 7+&%()%$%3%'1%&16&%@1%'(,*78%&(()%7'7,1&.'()+(()%+7(.3.(.%&

()%&7.%(*+$%'( $7)+$.(+6,%21$2&%&-.(<1,/+,<+*&6%+(,.6%$(*( .'.(.+(%+7(.'.'+77$/+'7%<.(),+<.'7,1/.'0.'3B.'0 &16=&%7(.':;

 !%7(.' ()%7(

? &16&(+'(.+,@1%&(.' ,+<+$.&%&.'()%2$%&%'(+22%+, .'(%$ %$%'7%.&7+,,%/ $.'()%$/%$ ()%$.61'+, )%+22%+,.&/.&8.&&%/

-

*./.0  /1 2, /30 /30

8B ")%()%$&2%+B.'0D$%+&'%/

%&D ")%()%$$%2$(+6,%

%&D