Jai Narain And ANR. v. State Of Haryana And ORS.




   
   

!"

#$ %&'(') * !+ % %,% !%!(%!&-', .//'00%!&* 1',*2* 3&%&'%,4%!%%!(&-',* .. '*/!('!&*   +  5

 3
 3
  5

 3
3"


,'*'!&+

,1 6,%73 !8-9(:)%&',&-'%//'00%!&* ;;;
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

 %!( &-' ,'*/!('!&* -%( &-' @%&', )2,*' %:% 0%A0' %& / !&* F5 %!( F5 *%!)& !'(A4&-' : * !%0%!%0  )',: ('*)-'7'@%&',)2,*'F5 !)7/'!*%& !A%* *!&-'32&-',!* ('G 00%$DD%&&-')*&  &-' A'!' ) %, '* ! &-' 8,2!( &-%& &-' 0'!8&-  @%&', )2,*' ! &-' ,&-',!* ('G 00%D$ >@%*C6%,%7@-','%*0'!8&-@%&', )2,*'F5!&-'*2&-',!* ('G 00%$DD@%*!04$6%,%7%!( &-','*/!('!&*)20(/,/',04 ,, 8%&'&-' ,0%!(&-,28-@%&',)2,*'F5 %!(&-','@%*!( ','!)'&-' , '0(0':'0 <B= @':',9 &-' //'00%&' 2,& ' &-' 32/', !&'!( !8 %!%0  )',,':',*'(&-' !( !8&-' : * !%0%!%0 )',-',(', 32/', !&'!( !8%!

%0  )',@%*%//,:'(A4&-'- '%!%0  )',A4 -0( !8&-%&%/',2*%0&-'6-%6%/0%!,':'%0'(&-%&&-','@%*%0'!8&-4 6%&)-%@%&',)2,*',7&-'-'%(2&0'&%//,E 7%&'04 !&-'0'!8&- 6 00%* $C''&@- )-2,&-',,%!!H 8H%8%0 8!7'!&%0!8&-': 00%8' A2!(%,49&-',','9&-' '0(*&-','*/!('!&*)20(!&A' ,, 8%&'(A4 @%4&-'%,'*% (%0 8!7'!&9A'* ('*9&-'*7%00-0( !826%7-%!( *!

,':',9A4%00@ !8&-'@%&',)2,*'!&-'%0 8!7'!&F59&-'*%7' @20(%0* !:0:'%(,% !%8'),** !8%**-@! !&-'6-%6%/0%!@- )- @20(!&A'&')-! )%004*2 &%A0'D/',%A0'9@-','%*!&-'&-',* ('9&-' @%&',)2,*'F5/,/*'(%!( 7%,6'(!&-'6-%6%/0%!@20(( ,')&04 ,, 8%&'&-' '0(*&-','*/!('!&*%* &@%* :'6 00%* ''&%@%4 ,7&-'7% !@%&',)2,*'%!( &@%*&-'*-,&'*&/** A0'%0 8!7'!&%!( )!!')&'(@ &-&-'0 !'(@%&',)2,*'%!(&-2*9@20( ,, 8%&'&-' '0(* &-' ,'*/!('!&* ! % A'&&', @%4  -'0'%,!'( - '%!%0  )', 2,&-', A*',:'(&-%&&-'*/&0':'0&-'-0( !8&-','*/!('!&*@%**2)-&-%&



)2!&,4*0/'@%*&@%,(*&-'(,% !9&-',','9 ,, 8%& !,76 00%&6 00% @%*/** A0'!04 %!%0@%&',@%*8 :'!,7/ !&F5&@%,(*F5
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

%0@%&', * 8 :'! ,7 / !& F5 &@%,(* F5   !)' &-' %2&-, & '* A'0@ -%:' )!* (','( %00 %*/')&*  &-' 7%&&', %!( -%:' *%!)& !'( &-' @%&',)2,*' F5!&-',&-',!* ('G 00%D$!)7/'!*%& !A%* *2!(',&-' %,4%!%%!%0%!(,% !%8')&9?C9!8,2!



& !&',','@ &-&-'@'00>,'%*!'(,(',/%**'(A4&-'%2&-, & '*A'0@%* -%*A''!2/-'0(A4&-'0'%,!'(", &2,&/%,& )20%,04* !)'!: 0%& ! /,: * !*%!40%@-%*A''!/ !&'(2& <#= )),( !8049&-'/,'*'!&%//'%0 *( *7 **'(  !"#
$%  
  &%'!   &%'!  %7 & 
"-'&-',*/'%6 !8D,'%*!'(+ '*D 
"-'&-',,'/,&%A0'  + '*D