Balkar Singh v. Buta Singh
"#$ $'()(%* ++
",-".
122$,,"*#
3$.)4)
4#"
1+$)2%*5$*# %."6
%*78,$ .+ 4)#('$ + 9",("
.$)$*#
.+ :42(, 42#";
53%'"#$ "22$,,"*#+
<<<
0",,$*/$ (*)#"*# $/4,".
22$",
=45/6$*# 5"#$5 +>+;
2"))$5 55,+ ()#.('# 45/$;
$.%@$24.;
5()6())(*/ (3(, 22$", A > 420%,5(*/
=45/6$*# 5$'.$$ 5"#$5 + 2"))$5 (3(, 45/$
4*(%.
(3()(%*!;
4.40".)"0"(;
B0$.$8?
5$'.$$5 .$)#."(*$5
&.%6 '"4)(*/ (*#$.&$.$*'$ 2$"'$&4, ,"B&4,
%3$.
6$")4.(*/
C"*",
".,")
'%62.()$5 C0$B"# A
C0"#%*( %+D;
$'#+ ;
C(,,"
%+
6(*
D!;
)(#4"#$5 .$3$*4$ $)#"#$ 3(,,"/$ C".( C","*;
$0)(, 4.40".)"0"(;
()#.('# $.%@$24.;
+
+
%4*)$, '%*#$*5)
'(3(, 2$.6"*$*# .$)#."(*(*/
&.%6 '"4)(*/ (*#$.&$.$*'$ 6"**$.
2$"'$&4, ,"B&4, %3$.
2"."/."20
2,$"5(*/)
EF
2".#($);
&%,,%B(*/ ())4$) B$.$ &."6$5
90$#0$.
2,"(*#(&& $*#(#,$5 2$.6"*$*#
2."?$5 &%.G
+ 90$#0$.
2.$)$*# 6"(*#"(*"8,$G
+ $,($&+
+
0$.$"&#$.;
2".#($)
)486())(%*) "53"*'$5;
#.(", 5$'(5$5 ())4$)
&"3%4.
.$)2%*5$*#A"22$,,"*#
=45/6$*# 5$'.$$ 2"))$5 #.(", 5"#$5
+
420$,5 55,+ ()#.('# 45/$;
$.%@$24.+
+
%4*)$, '%*#$*5) =45/6$*# 5$'.$
%4.#) 8$,%B 5% #"-$ "''%4*# .$'%.5
'%..$'# 2$.)2$'#(3$;
#0$.$&%.$;
".$ ,$/",,?
4*)4)#"(*"8,$ ,("8,$
)$# ")(5$ 5()6())$5+
D+
0"3$ '%*)(5$.$5 )486())(%*) '%4*)$,+
56(##$5,?;
',"(6 0$
6$")4.(*/
C"*",
".,")
2"."/."20
8$,%*/$5 .%3(*'(",
%3$.*6$*#A$*#.", %3$.*6$*# 84# 0$ '4,#(3"#(*/
)(*'$ ,%*/ $".,($.
$*#.($) -0")."
/(.5B".() B$.$ .$'%.5$5
.(/0#;(*#$.$)#;
#(#,$
'%*'$.* B0"#)%$3$.
B(#0 )"6$+ 0$ %.5$.
)48)#"*#("#$ ',"(6 #$*5$.$5 54,?
)B%.* "&&(5"3(#
H+9 A;
.$(#$."#(*/ &"'#) 2,"(*# .$,($5
42%* '%2?
H+ !;
'%2?
-0")."/(.5B".(
"4*( > "..(
H+ !;
'%2?
-0")."/(.5B".(
"4*( "..(
H+ !;
'%2?
-0")."
EF
/(.5B".(
"4*( "..(
H+ !
8$)(5$) $H"6(*$5
".B(*5$.
9 "= C46".
9 ;
B0% 54,?
)422%.#$5
'")$ ",, 6"#$.(", ")2$'#)+
0$ "22$,,"*# 5$&$*5"*# 0"*5;
%.5$.
.$84#
',"(6 .$)2%*5$*#A2,"(*#(&&;
)#$22$5 B(#*$)) 8%H 9
#$*5$.$5 54,?
)B%.* "&&(5"3(# H+9A .$(#$."#(*/ $*#(.$
&"'#) B.(##$* )#"#$6$*#+ #.(", '%4.#
.$3$*4$ (+$+ H+
H+ ;
.$)2%*5$*#A2,"(*#(&&;
4#"
(*/0;
)0%B* '4,#(3"#(*/
,"*5;
%B*$.)0(2 $*#.",
%3$.*6$*# "# )#"/$ )"(5 .$'%.5 .$&,$'#$5 $(#0$.
&"#0$.
2".#($) 5$&$*5"*# $3$.
8$(*/
(*2%))$))(%* *%.
3($B
0"3(*/ 5()'".5 5%'46$*#".?
.$)2%*5$*#A2,"(*#(&&;
0$,5
8",5
"))$.#(%*
"* %.", 2".#(#(%* #"-$* 2,"'$;
'"..($5
B$(/0# ,(/0# .$3$*4$ .$'%.5 2,"'$5 .$'%.5
)0%B(*/ '4,#(3"#(*/
,"*5+ 0$ "./46$*#
/."8 2.%2$.#?
$*#.", &%4*5 B$(/0# B(#0
#.(", /.%4*5
0(6)$,& ',$".,?
2,"(*# 2.%2$.#?
I4$)#(%*
8$,%*/$5 $*#.", %3$.*6$*# 0$ %*,?
2.%#$'# ',"(6
)4''$))&4, $)#"8,()0(*/ 0$
'4,#(3"#(*/ ,"*5+ ''%.5(*/,?;
#.(",
5$'.$$5 &"3%4.
.$)2%*5$*#A2,"(*#(&&+
EF
>+
22$", 5()6())$5
22$,,"#$ .$,?(*/ 42%* 5$'()(%* %*78,$
$,0( (/0 C4,5$$2
%%5"
3)+
0.( ".$*5$.
$0,"B"#
%#0$.)
!
(3(, ")$) >;
.$,($& '%4,5
/."*#$5 2,"(*#(&& B0% 4*,"B&4, #.4$
,"B&4, %B*$.
5$'()(%* %*78,$
42.$6$
".#"2."( + C%#0".( 3)+ %0* ."/"*@"
!
(3(,!
2$.)%* B0% 0") ,%*/ '%*#(*4%4) 2%))$))(%*;
'"* 2.%#$'#
)$$-(*/ "* 2$.)%* B%.,5 #0"*
#.4$ %B*$.+ 22$,,"#$ 0$,5
#.4$ %B*$.A#(#,$ 0%,5$.
$3$* #0%4/0
%B*$.
2.%2$.#?;
3$)#$5 $*#.",A.%3(*'(", 84# .$)2%*5$*#
2,"(*#(&& 8$(*/ 2%))$))(%*;
'%4,5 (*#$.&$.$
5()2%))$)) &.%6 (,,$/",,?
&%.'(8,?+ 22$,,"#$ #%%- "''%4*# "55(#(%*",
"22$,,"*#A5$&$*5"*#;
B0('0;
))()#"*#
%,,$'#%.
."5$;
4.40".)"0"(;
&%4*5
5$&$*5"*#A"22$,,"*# %3$.
8$".(*/ $'#+ ;
C(,,"
%+
6(*
!;
84# %8)$.3$5 )#"?
/."*#$5
(3(, .$/".5(*/ "&%.$)"(5 /(.5B".( '%4,5
'%..$'#$5 "22$,,"*#A5$&$*5"*#+ * '%*#.".?;
8$(*/ /."*#$5 2$.6())(%*;
.$84##",
B"?
'%2?
H+A !;
>
H+A!;
H+A!;
>
H+A!;
H+AD!;
-0")."/(.5B".() H+A
H+A ;",, )0%B(*/
J7+
EDF
'%4*)$, "22$,,"*# 0") .$&$..$5
B0"#)%$3$.
)0%B $(#0$.
%B*$.
8$##$.
#(#,$ ,"*5+
+
* ,(/0# 2%)(#(%* *%#$5 $)2$'(",,?
0"3(*/ $)#"8,()0$5
#0%4/0 8$,%*/(*/ $*#.", (# ",B"?) %2$*
)$$- 2.%#$'#(%* (+$+
2$.)%* #0"* #.4$ %B*$.+ ''%.5(*/,?;
I4$)#(%* ,"B 64'0
,$)) )48)#"*#(", I4$)#(%* ,"B ".()$) '%*)(5$."#(%* #0() "22$",+
''%.5(*/,?;
&(*5(*/ 6$.(# (*)#"*# .$/4,".
22$",;
5()6())$5+
++
."=$)0