← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4080/2013allowed

Amit Arya v. Kamlesh Kumari

2016-02-08Mr. Justice Fateh Deep Singh15 pages



     

  

 





   

         !"#

$% "!!    

  ! "# $%  &''((   )%*! $%  & '   

 +&& '   (('' ,-. ((/&0!", 1

 2.   &'    1

 +&& &0!", &!(. '  &"1

$% "!!&     

   

                  

 

 !

" 

#  

       $    

%&

'( &) !

  

"   

   # 

 ### #   

      

 & ##&#  

 "    *   &  #

#  

           

 #

#

   "

"



+   ,-.

,/01-.  ,1/  2  #1  # 

!

 



.

!

 .

!

   !

3 # 



 #4-$    #4"

 

     #2 #   

  #2 #

"

#2 $5 "

       #     

2 1   

 "

   &4 #    5  &   

 "



"

  "

   #  #    3$  



" 

   2#   #

 ###( 4   .

!

   #    # 2 #

+   !    ## &

 +

  

#  #  &



4617         #        3##   

  & 

       -$  

        2     

    1  #  /$          

 "2 #  

 #2#   #

"    "

"

 

      ##      #     "         



       #   (         

 "

         

 "



! "

#





 #     #  (   4     .

!

   $  "     "

           ##  #  (   4     .

!



       !"

# ## & 

 #  #  #         ##          & "     #  ##

"

 87    

  



     

    

 

  

   



  



 

 

  !"

    

   

     

 

   



    

   

     

 

   !  



 "   

 



 #



  !#  "$%%%%%

&'     (  )*+ 

          

&



 )))%%"

    !



,   



-   

 !

  !

  

 $    

   .

  

 /   

 !  0' !

 

 *     

    

    &  

 . ' ! !!

 1 

  

%         &

  #  &

 

   " 2  92 



' 9)   &  :2  -  &# 

   2   #    9 (  (   '

9)%  (   '

9) ;

 & '

9)   &  :2 

#  &    #      #  # #   &     

%   " , # & # 

    

  #  

 "

#"

## # #      "

  2

# & # 

  #



  #40$"  " #  " 

 "

 # 

     

2  

# %   * 

&

        

%    # 

""

 

" # & #     

        

%  

" ## #         

      &  # 4 #    #  "   <-=   #  #   



> #     * 

&      

  %       

      #    

 1

 ##



# "

 ! &    

3   "       

 "

2   # & # 

      # 4 # 



 #4-$"

      #2 #   %   "

 &  # 

 

# 

      2    ?

  #4 "

  %  #    &#   

 &      

  # # %   " 

  ?

    &&# @"  

    ## #    

 

%     

"

 & ##&  #     #   AB C# &    &

    #   ""



"  

  #    

   ! #  ""  #  %  

 

 # 

 ### #   

%   #     & #         87 ),  #"#   

"

     &    &     

 ##1

  )        

    

  #   # #        #     

2  

$ )   

    :2   "

       

  #     0 #  #2#2 # 

       # 

 "

 

"

  #  #    5

       

  ## & :2           !             $    ## & "

        

%   ),# "

#   "    "

  ###  #    

:2  %  # 

 "

     

  %  

 & # #  

%        

#  7   # "



    

"  ## #

  

 &   

 " 

 2 #      "

  #  #   5 #  

  +D   ( %  #5  

"## #   &  "   #

 &#    & #     "    &###  & #  &*      

  

    2        #   

    

#  # ?

   "

   # #     ###

4 # # & # 

 *        #+D  ( %  !"# $%  & '

  '&( %  #             %  

"      # ###   

  

%  # "

#      #  

 5 #  

    "

&"

   ##.

!

$#2   

# & # 

   "

 

 "  #   (     # 

 # #  0 #$ 



#  -$ !&

  "

  

"

  #  #                    #   ##   

 #     

2    

       $  5   

  "   &    

   

  

#    #  "   #   #### *        #+D  ( %  ) * 

    +&   $ ,'

         #   #  ##&   #

# 

  

  

2 $"

      !## #       %     

 

 & ##  *   #

   #+D  ( %     

 -$*   +&   $ , 5 &   #          

?

 #

"  #  E     



   # 





 

  $%  &



 '



A

          #   

  %    #  ### "   

%     

 # 

 ### #    

    &      "#   

      2 #   ""

  # 

     & &"#   #      

   

 

  &#  2 

 

$ "

        #      

 &  

  +D  ( %   

( > D '  )#  

'6)#     &  #     #  ?

         #   !     &#( # (#4 #  -/    

'6)#   #

"

     " & #  5 "

# 

 ## #

  ### #     &    &!  & 5 "

        

  

2    ### #  

5 "

    #  

%    #    &

#"     ( %    ( > F '  )  

%    "  

 # 

 #  "

  #  #   #   

 :2 "

  # 

   0 #  #2#2 #

     &   ## & :2  !#  ##$  

## & "

       

%  *   ?

 

"# & &

 

 & "    

# & ##  #   ### (   "

  #   0 #  #2#2 #



   "

  

/"  #  #    

   #    5    #

#&       #          2 "

#    5 #  #        #    "

#    :&  "#   #

# 2   

   

   

"  ! & #" "    ####       "

#     #          

        #        

  #  &             #   

       5 (  .

  F '  ) +F (  %    #   # #   

#&    

   #&  

   !  &

  #                            5"

           

     $  "    !  "  ! &

#        " " #   

%  #"   & &    #    (#  #

#  

%    ## & :2         

  

 

%  " 7    &" 2 

  

 # #   

%  5  &"#       

%     

#7   #      

3##    !  &    &

   &    2 #   !"  

  %           #          # "

#   "  

 "

  # ## #    

5     

!    %  

 & #  

 #   #   

%  

%  

" #    

  #!  #  

%        

:& "

  

%  #  ,   #   # 

 # ##     &!"

#

"

    

  "        

%   #   

    # 

!## #       

   ##

#  

%   5&"#    

&  ##  #    #             7 #   #     

%  " 

&

   &    #  

%  #  "  "

   

    

"   %      # 

     &  "

  #  #   #  

?

 ### #    

   " 2       $"   .

!

" 



   

 2?

#  #    + #         

 #       3###  #  " 46+ &   ## &  :2      $  

         :2 & ;

  .

!



   3##.

!

 $

 2     

 #

     #



  #                              3  

     ##$      &"#

     

   87 (   (  

& 



  



 )*

(   (  



   

 

 6' " %/&, - &''(( !(-!''  .-  #   (  + $  &  !,   7&.    &  ,     !"" '!&/ $&  ,  '!&&''((  /  '      &  2&(  ,'(7     3    7!    "   &( 2& '  &(7&.&  %87 ' % &&/('   &2&( 6(*   3  " "&(7!9 " 2!. &    $ &&7, & &!. :&   "& +  &%  + :&    "&  +   &  '  &     3$  &$  &  /  6,(&6!,  &% & ,$& "&.!  $&" &( 6(*   "   &'( '!!  "& 7,  $ &&'&&

((&   3$&/'  

2&(,'(76(*; " - % & "  ;

(( &/ "& %   2&( 

  3;

(( "

!  &% / .   -  % & '' ;

(( &&"

 -!, ( "

/&&/ &%  +&(,&&& ''  &"

!   -!, $ *  &'   6(*2&(

  3'  %87 $&'  /  .-&, ,$<!,.   2& %87  .  - .- :&    "&    &%    &,  ,$  <!,.   &    .

7,  . %   & '  &&/'  

&2&(    3  &'! ' 7! "  "  "

(  %!  &''(( =  & !, $&,  && '  &' % %87  ((!   !

 &% !.-&''(( ' %&    /(( "

'  ,&'  &" ,    3< (- &$&''((  %("( !' & '  (( "!'

&   7!& (  3

 3   >  '  & $& '    !"&( " /&'(&  , -   2&''((  (&! # ! -  ( &  -  ,& 7   "   &(+& &   !,  &'    (-? &!&    '  '(    .(     ' ..($  &  ,    (-    !

& "(-(  %!  &''(( &(&&''((  (/- ,  - /(( "'  ,&'  &" ,  :!

(  & '  &  !&& ''((  &(( " ((  " , (($&   (* - (  &. " , (($ %/  !

  (/(/  >*  @ !' 2&  

.-!

(  & '   & " , %  , ! "& 0 .   " & '(-&("( .- & '  /!(,*,  & !&'(/  & '(-&&" ,   (( &   -$&'( (-

 && , -    2&. "$& '   

* -&     ,&. % , > *  @ !' 8% & /$& '  & &(( " &0!", '.-&''((:! ((/ "( % (  % -/&& .((/ (-!  "!.  &" ,  ((A! & , $!

(  & '  & , -!.,

(&   " &''((:! /& " (.(- & '   '-!.(  &,!

    , -( " /&    : % (-$!

(  & '  &!.,&& '  &( -', &  $$ & (!   ,'( /&&0!",   '.-&:!  ''( 2&  "'( & '  && &" , /  (( %/  '(- &("(  &''((  

 ,   &  !    '   '  ,     /     &(( "    ((  &" ,  &("&  (/  >*  @  !'  :!

(  & '  &,!., .-/- , -'(& &''(( @(,  ' '  ,  ((/$    /!(  !    "   & &'       %      & '   &  ,(-2&&!.  & '  / ,'(-  &; ! & 2( 0  &,' -& /!

!'.! 2&'!'(& (-' ' -/&& '   &  ,(-  &, % ,($&- /!( . ' &%    &(  2&'(  " & &'   %  .!'

<!&'(/  &/  ,  " ((- (

 ''( / (*, ,  '( "> .   - !&    /& '' !

-&''((   % & ,$ !(''( & '    -'  '  ,  &" , $ &'     <& ' &.   > %/ /&&. !&  .%$&''( ((/$0!",   '.-&''((:!   & & (:!   2& '  &((.(.('- & !"&!  *&( #!"  

,& .,.