Jagtar Singh And ORS v. Jasbir Singh And ORS





    
   




 





 

 
! "
#

 



     


 
  $ 
% 
& #
' (
)

 



 

 
 

 "
 
#*
 
 + 


'
,
#*
 
-"

(
)
.",

 

/

 

)
 




 

 
 

'
,
#*
 
 
-"




(
 *
 

" 

 
$ 

 
(

 (
 
#



#*
  


 
"

$ 


*


  
 *
' 
' 


*
,"

(

 
 

,"



0 
1
, (
, 

 
0  (
"

) 
2 
3"

"(
"#45 #(
6 

 
,  (
*

"

 
 
,

,
 

7"


 



//1(
)
'




,"



0 

, 
'




 
,
 8"


9 .
8"

;
1<

 
 



)

'

#*

 
,"



0 
1
, 
'
 

%  8"


<(
#
  

  (
"

)
=0'(


 ,



 

#'
 

 

 


)

 
#*
 

 
"(
, 


 
>&'





 
)
#

 ?
' 
 
) 

 )
@"
  




A
# 


"
#*



'
 
# 

8"


<
'
 
' *



'


) 
 
"

#
:%  <(

B"


$'
 *


&'
 
 <

0


" )


,"


9') (


  

 
"

 
 
 " "



"
"
 *(

)
 

$'
 *
'
 )
"
 
 
= (

 
  
 


#*
 *

"

, 

)
B"
'
 



//1
@"


,"

(


0  
 +C+(

 
,

;
1(

)

 





 
,"



0 
1
, (


0  
 1+ (



"  *(

(


"

: 

<


 *
 

"
 
 

'
 

6 

"
'
 
#*
 
-)
"
: 
)<(
,  (
)
.",

 
C





 



 

 (
#"
"


 *
 


#
: 
<
 


*


(
)
 




"  *(



#,
' 
 
D *
 *,# 

'
 ) (

# 
"






 

#



" 
-"

(



'" 
#
 ) 
 
"
*

 
"

&"
 
: 
<
 


, ,



' 

 
"(
'


'
"
# 
 
'

 



#*




 
,
*
A
 ,
 
, ,(

'

 
 


)  *
B"
 
$'
 *


&'
 
 <

 
 

B"




' 
) 

"  *(
 

'
(
 
 

C

 
#*
 
-"


'

(

 

'
,

'  '
9') (
'





,

0'
 (

,)

 
"


-$-

)'





 


, 
&"
 

 
'
,
#

,# 




'

@" 

 

 
"

 
#
 
 

 
' B"
#*
 


  
6 "(
 
"

A
 
'


,
 

# (

;
(

'
 
 
 

B"
#*
#
: <



' 

 
 

."





#*





 

#

."

, ,
#'
 
 
'

)



-"

(
'


'
'

" *


7"

(
 
 

B"
#*
 




'  *
 *
@"

 *
 *

 





7 

;
1


 



 )(
 *
' 

B
 

 D

 
 
,

"

 
)


 (
# 
"

 *
 "
 
 

"
#*
  


 
 

,,

"
#*
 


,


(

@" *
 
.",

 



#

 
#
 
'
 
) (
,
""#
"
#"

: 



 
<


#
 
 *


 

(
 
" 
#
# 
<

"

"
 
,





7 ,
'



"
=0'(
 
 ",
 
#
,

 
,

-"

(


 
 

B"




#
) 
'
@" *


"
- *(
# <


#
 
' *(

 "

" 
 '*



 ,


, ,
' 
 

"#(
 
 



//1(
B"

# 



(
' 
  
) 
)
.",
EB$ (
#"

 
,
'
, ,
#'
 
 (


 
 

 

6 "(
 

  
 
 

'" 
 
#0

 


B"

 



//1
EB
(
 *
'
  *
"

 
#*



)
 



(
 
 

B"





' 



,
%
 #*(
 
"#@"
 



" 

)
*
) 
 





 *
" 

#
  
' 
  
7"




 
"
 
"

'


 
 



' 
B"



 

# 

 1+

 
>&'

)
# ?
  
 

C

'



 (
 
 



' 
B"





 
."
 
 
 *

A
*
)(
 B"
 
 




'
 '*
"#.

 


(

 (

*(

 
"

*
"


 
*
 

 
#*
 ,
'

#*
 



7"

(
)
 (

'
",


,,
 

,
'


)

#'
 
*
 
B"
  




'
 '*
"#.

 


 



#*




"

(

 "
  

:EB$<
 '
 


,"



0 

, 
'
 
#*
 

:# <


 


: <


",

(

+4
,  *(
)
 

:EB$ <(

 
,"


'



#*
 



 





,
 

(

+4

D
  *(

 "
 
 



//1
:EB2+<
 '


,"


'
 



;
1


",

/(

+4
=0'(


,"



0 
1
, 
'
 





@"
 
"(

'
 *
, ## 
 
,

'
 


",
 /(

+4


//1

)
B
* 

(

+4
 (

 
 
 

B"
#*
 


 


"


 
*
 
 (


(
' 

 ,
 


,
 


" 
  



 *

7 (
 


'
 
 *


 

 

"

 



;

 

#  
6 "(

 *

 
)# 
 "
 
" 
#
 F
  
#*


'
)

, 

 "
'
# 

#
,

= 
"

 + 


,  *
 

"#,
 
' 
)

" *
 
'
#*
# 
D
#
 *
0(

" 



* 

,

 

 '
 
 
#*
 
# '
' 

 *



 

"



,
*
, 
  *


 ",
'
)
6 "(

@"

'(
,"

*
"#
@"
 '(
 

 
6 

#
)

, 

  *
,

 



.
 

!  "#$
   
0
+

GE

 # 
D