State Of Punjab And Others v. Sanjeev Kumar And Others

    

!" # $  #   % 

# & #'' ()*)+ , & -./  01 )))2233 41- ,.5 6-71  01 )))2
**89

, & -./  01 )))2233 41- 51 ,':0  01 )))2
*%9

, & -./  01 )))2233 41-

.' 6-1  01 )))2

(  ;"
 ) !

,  ,  ,  ,  ;"
 ) !

,  #6  #
 



    
       




 


 !" 

   # $

%
!&&'(!&()'

* %
!++,!&()- 


  .

 # $   "

  # $

%
!+&0!&()-


 



 ) 2 $

 



  &) (0 &()'



$ 5  67

 $

 )+-   )-  

/ )&'

 ) )& ),9-



$  

#   3 "$  .

 .  % ;5 %  <  

6  =

7 

>" $ 3?7

6: 7

 ),+9 

>),+9

?7





# & .

$ 

$

  

 2 $

$



  %

A

 

 

   #  

),9-

),+9



 B   

$ $

   

$    @ 3 $ $

 #

  B 

 $ 

   @



=  3 $

!'

),+9

 $

!

% '

CNo cooperative society to which land has been transferred shall at any time before the last installment of price has been paid, except with the express permission in writing of the State Government, alienate, whether permanently or temporarily, the Nazool land transferred to it."

Provided that in granting permission the State Government shall have regard to the general interest of the Cooperative Society."

2 ),'(  



$   

)( 

 

  









  #

$   @

 

=  3 $



!'



),'(7

),+9

 $

!

C7.    ! [No Co!operative Society or the individual member of the Scheduled Castes, as the case may be, small, except with the express permission in writing of the State Government, alienate, whether permanently or temporarily, the nazool land transferred to it/ him for a period of ten years from the date they had Cooperative Society or the individual member of Scheduled Castes gets all rights title and interest in the said Nazul land. Thereafter its alienation shall be strictly restricted to the members of the Scheduled Castes only.] [Substituted vide No. 226!R!III!70/8405, dated the 28th October, 1970.] [Provided that in granting permission the State Government shall have regard to the general interest of the Co!operative Society or individual member to the case may be." +



),,)

),'(





$  

<

  

3



=  3 $



!'



),,)7

),+9

 $

!

Bar of alienation: No co!operative society or the individual member of scheduled castes, as the case may be, shall alienate or sell or mortgage the Nazool land and such land shall go down only in inheritance."





  $

 E

    #  3

 E

 

 # 

   

$

 2 %

  

= 
*9* A $  

$

#  @



$  3

 



5

 

)

  $ $ 



    3 $  

$ #

$

   %  6: 7

),'(



),,) 

>),'(E),,)

?7 B

3E

  

$ $

$ 

$ 

$  3

* ),'(E),,)

 $ #

$ $

 3

@



 

3E

 void!ab!initio $  3 ),'(E),,)

- 

$ # 

$

.F
6
2%7!+(-+

&())



3E    $  3 ),'(E),,)



 $ 





 @

 $    

 

3E





 

  $ @

$ # 

$

.F
6
2%7!+(-+

&()) , 

 #



$













5  67

 $

# 

5  67

 5   &) (0 &()'



 

 ),'(E),,)





3E 

 

),'(

  #

3

+ #





)( % $ 

 67 

3

$  

 @



 #

 @  $

3

$ 3E  =   

3E 

 @

  @

 #    



$ $

B  

3

    &) (0 &()'  $    $ 

 #

 

),9-



$$ 



)) % $ 

 !" 

$  3   #

A  

$$ 

# 

$ $

$

  

 A

 

 



   





)& % $   67

 



),'(

   

$ $ $    #

 ),'(E),,)  

#  B 

  

  

<$    

 $ $

  @

#



3E   

    

$3



 

 



 $   



$



!!"  # $

#% #

 & $

'(

   %)*  #  

  # $# #    " +

$ 

$3 8

3

 $ #3 )0 F

 $  

    $ 

  )D A



 

$ 

$



 







9

3



$$ 

 



)+ 2 $

 







$

 

2  $ 

$  

 

    #



3    3

),'(

),,)  #

# $$ #

# 

 

 

 #

@

$3 

)9 A



 B 

$3 

 

$$ )'

2 $

 #

$  

<$

 @

$ $

 = 

8 



  

 



),'(E),,)

 



B$



  @

$3   $ #3







$ 3  

 

),'(E),,)



 $ #3

  $ #3 )- B A



 

 $3 

 ),'(E),,)



  $ $ ), 2

$ $  

$  

),'(E),,)  

 



 3

),9-  ),'(E),,)







 B$

<$



 $ #3



&((9



  <$

 



 $

 

),'(E),,)





 3



&((9 

  

&((9 <$ $

B  $3 





$ $

$$ &(

$

$



 

 



$

A





B  $3 

 

3

$ $

 

),'(E),,)

  $ #3

 3    

),'(E),,) 2



 3  $

),'(E),,)  

  $ #3 5 

$ $



 

  

),'(E),,)

  

5  @

#

$

$ $



&) G# 



$

    $ 



!!"  # $

#% #

 & $

'(

%)*# 

 

 3  $

A



  #

$



$

$ $

  $

),'(E),,)

&((9 && 2 

),'(E),,)

$

 $  $

$

#

&0 % $ 

 $ 

   !0(



 $

!

C30 A right came to be vested with the petitioner society on transfer of the land to it way back in 1958!59, which was followed by a formal order of transfer that came to be issued by virtue of the provisions contained in Rule 11 of the Rules. This vested right, it is well setttled proposition of law, cannot be taken away by the amendments brought about in the rules retrospectively. We need not support the aforesaid observations by judicial precedents, the same being, as mentioned above, settled by now.

However, we will only make a mention of one judgment on the issue in Garikapati Veeraya versus N, Subhas Choudhry and others (2), wherein after holding that right of appeal was not a mere matter of procedure but was a substantive right, it was further held that a vested right of appeal could be taken away only by a subsequent enactment, if it so provides expressly or by necessary intendment and not otherwise.

 litigation at the time when the Act was passed." &D  

 #  $ 5 

),'(

 2 

&((9



),'(E),,) <$

 $  $

$ 

#

&+ % $ 





 3 B$ )& (+ &((9 " $ 



&9 2 $

 3 $ 

  

  $

$ #

 2 

 3  

$

   

# "   $ 3   $ 

<$

$

$ $

 $



$  3 ),'(E),,)

 $3



$ 

$ # . 

$

.F
6
2%7!+(-+

&())





$

 3





3 &'

% $  

 

3

  3  # &- 2 $

 #

$ 

$ $E 



 

% &, = 

# 

 

 $

 



$  3  

   

  $





  <$

$

$ $

 

C  3H

 5  3

 

 

$ $

# #  

# 0(



 0) 





$

$   0& 

$

$ $ $

 

  

$ 5  

#

$ 

<$ 



3

$$  3 

= 

$

3

  #

 3 

 

3

 3  

3

 0D .

$  



3

  0+   $ 3

  $

$ $ 

,  ,  , !



#6  # !



> ? + aarti Whether speaking/reasoned :Yes Whether reportable :

Yes