High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/2304/2017allowed

Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd v. Punjab State Power Corporation Ltd And ORS

2023-02-22Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia,Ms. Justice Harpreet Kaur Jeewan10 pages

!"#$%&'((

!$%$)%*#$%&((

! " & +

( ,(,(,- + ,( ,

- #$ % "&'

&( %) '*&'

&( %

' &'

+ , ----- (,(,/%#0/1/23/4(&

&( . $

& /0/12/+3 4 5$+673$2/+0

2 8 4 . 9 '. :

( +3+/2//2 ; +3/62//0 )

( 72

,+2,+/ ( 8<8 &

6,,312 72

(

( & .( .(

8<8 7 (

;

/1/62//, : $+

LPA-2304-2017 (O&M) 2

;

(. ;

(. . '

(

( =: +3/62//0 . 8 =: ".& ( ">&1/&71,<$ /3++2//0 : $7 ;

+3/62//0 ( " 8

(

+3+/2//28

/1++2//0:$,

( )

, ? .& ( +6/22//6 ;

(

..;

/3++2//0 8

( ((

( .

( ;

2@ '&

)

,+ ( " ( & +167 8

27/02/+2:$3

7+/32/+7 :$> . & .

,1,/ 2/+7. 2>/+2/+,:$1

. & 2//7 . 0/B

(",&,0&+13<$. /3/72//6

LPA-2304-2017 (O&M) 3 0 8C "D '

( ( 8<8

( 72

6,,312

,+2,+/ " ;& '

6+>6+

. ".&

(

( ",&,0&+13<$ '

(

/3/72//6 +0/02/+,='.& D ' "E (

+<7

"$ )) .

F9 G ( & 22/32/+, :$+0 6 ( H

+++22/+,

7/ (2/+,:$+>".&

( ; =

. &2//7

(+//62//7&

( & 3 8 ' . 4 .( ;

( > 8 '

. :

& (

( +//62//7

& 2. (

062( .&

. ;

+3/62//0

LPA-2304-2017 (O&M) 4 /3++2//0( &

( .

(/3++2//7 1

06 (2//7 #$ I

06 3 *$%%*53$% $6 )7728 3% #6/)25 $6 7/89%5: + 5 . . . (

. (

. (.&

(

. .&(

( .G &

' . & (( . (

. ( . . ; . (

.' &

. .

.: .

(( .& & # . (

. (( & &$

(

. (

(

( ' (

. .

& ' & (.

. . (

( & (

. &

' (

( .(

( . ' ( (

. ((.

.J +/ )

( %. A

; 1/23$! 3 5322!3 5#(4 /3!) < ( (

/#08/ . 05!/ <3#8)5 <35/!/% $97/%8 5#( $50! 4

LPA-2304-2017 (O&M) 5

3"32 = :

+,/32/// .

(

062&+3,!+30 (=

. &2//7& (( ' . ( &

( .

( 2 .

062 ( "

+3, ' (( &

(2. ( ".&

(2. (

( (

$ ( &

( 4 "'

(

# I+7E

+3, (=

. &2//7& ' ' (( A '&(

(( ' '(( & &

(

. . & +1,> ( @

. ( (

(( ( &2//7(+/$6$2//,(

( .

.&(+/$6$2//7& (

( .

(

. +/$ 6$2//0 '

2+$2$2//6& (

. (

( .& & . 2//> :$ +&3$+$2//1&

. .

( .

(

( 2*5!3*358 *54 (( ' '.?

. ( ( ( 2//7

LPA-2304-2017 (O&M) 6 (

( .

062 (=

. & 2//7

+3, ( (2//7 ' (( =' . ( 8 . (2*5!3*358*54>=/%#502*5!3*358*54 ( (

. :::: :::: :::: H (( ( .A K &

& $=

. (

( . (

(

+3 8 ' . (

. *54 3((4 50 2*5!3*358,)7728 *54>=40%*4507!$"3 3$%$6,*53$% ?' $6502*5!3*358*544 &

)

( ( & & (((? /%# (((?=? (

. (

( ( 2//7& &

.& .

( .@

062 ( 2//7 ' (

( ( ( 2//7 ( (5

633<2/// ( +> @.& ( .$ . 8

. 4

.@J ++ & (

(

+3+/2//2 ;

+3/62//0 ;

;

.& . $ ( (

(

062 (=

. &2//7

LPA-2304-2017 (O&M) 7 ( (

/3++2//0:$78&

. (

/3++2//7 +2 8 (

( :

@ 3 5/%5 %A3%! 4 B9! <3#8)5 <35!/% 3A/9 3935#/%#/%$50!< ( /0/9/5)22/0.0/%C /0/9B)22/D4 ,'?( ?

(

4.&2//1

&2/++

(( &( & ((8

. +>/72/+, (

(

& . ? & (& .

) "

062 ( 2//7 ".& : 8 (

(

(2.

06 2

. ?& .&

(

(2.

(

. (

(

. . $.

( . & . '

(

".&

(

.. $.

((

(

( .: &

( '. .

. ( '. (

LPA-2304-2017 (O&M) 8 . .&

;

' .2/+,(

(

4.&2//1

& 2/++ & ( & ' (

; .&

. ; . .' '. (

(

. +7 "'

/0/9/5)22/0 .0/% C

/0/9B)22/ )7!/

#$ I67 $

+ (

06 ( .

. . (

.8 .

(

( . . $

2 (

06 ( 6,8

(

( .

(

. I( J $

2 (

068

.. $ .

( . & . ' (

(

..(: . (

( .( I( J& (

(

062 3

062 '&

. (

. ( : .

( . ? .

. . $.

(

( .: &

( '. . .

.( '. ( . >.

(

( ( &

+>/72/+,(

LPA-2304-2017 (O&M) 9

4.&2//1

&2/++8

. '

;

8 (( +>/72/+, 8

( .

062 ..:

062

. ( : . (

062 (

;

( ? '&

. ;

' (

(

. .& ( '. (

+3+ (

&+167& (

(

; '(

? %

* H ' ( %. &+1>1, + #L I

+3+ (

&+167&

( ( (

(

(( '

;

&' ' ? .

; (

; (( & .

;

; . . ;

' (8 . &

& '

; ( ( ' (

; &

& '

; ( (

' (J ? &

(

( '.

; +>/72/+, 8

. . ; . .' ( '. (

& (

;

. (

. $

2 (

06 ( 1 5 :

% )' ;& '

'. .

8 . (

& (.& . ( H .J

LPA-2304-2017 (O&M) 10 +, 8&(

'& .

(

;

. ' ( '. (

/3++2//7 & .' ; .' ( '. (

& .

; . $+0/1$2/+>

/+/22/27 .

" *M"

+0 .& : '. .

/3++2//7

( (

.( ; &

(

".& . (

/3++2//7 ( ;

+3/62//0 . .&

. (

/3++2//7 .8

. (",&,0&+13<$ .

(

. . +6 8

'$ (,(,- ((

< # N 5" # N