High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/28255/2019dismissed

Pawan Kumar And ANR v. State Of Haryana And Others

2022-02-03The Chief Justice,Mr. Justice Arun Palli11 pages

! "#$#%& ' %)*+ , %- , . ##% ,$ / ,$*$ ,1 % %!- ,$ . $2%! %$

, $ %& 3,/#4, +0#%5-6!7"

,- 2 ##% ,$ 3, %4*, 3# 86 !!8 !7"

% , 86 ,1 % (#- 3,0 *, 9-3 56$$#$ %!7"

% , 8 ,1 % 3,+ ,/#7 455 ,( 86!7"

6 3,0-#7 , $- ,6!7"

,, $2%! %: ;-

, $ #! 2, $ %" #$ 9 #%5 , ",! ! -,*5- 7#! "% , %"#%5 $#%" - 2," !#%5$ , 9 #%5"%!*" !#%7#,* 8*,< ====

- 2 ##% ,$ - 7 #%74 ! - (,# >*,#$!#"#% -#$ *, - , 91 "- 88 %5#%5 - %# #"

#%$ !

%! ?

#$$* ! *%! , 0 "#%$ @ %! A - B %! "C*#$##% "6 @ - 7 *,- ,$*5-!#, "#%$, 8 $ - "%$,*" ! , - #,8 "+2,#$ !#%)- $, ?';

<6 ?@ ;

<$#* !(#-#%- , 7 %* $ /#88 5 D#, !6 -$#8 #$,#" *,*5, + % - 5,*%!- "C*#$##%2," !#%5$C*

, $ #!8 %!$ %!$ 2$ ! #% 7# ( 0 "#% @ ;< #5- #, +2 %$

, %$2 , %"1 #%- B %! "C*#$##%6 - 9#8# %! $ 8 + % "6

';- , #%

,, ,, ! $E- "

'F<691"% %!#%5 - - 2 ##% ,$"%#%* !9 #%- 2$$ $$#% - 8 %!-*5- - "+2 %$ +*% - 8, !1 9 % , " #7 ! 91 - +

, -

%%*%" + % ,!% @

@ #$ - "

$ - 2 ##% ,$ - ! $2# - 7#%5 "C*#, ! - %!60 -

#8 ! 4 - 2$$ $$#% - 8 %!- 2 ##% ,$ (- - 7 9*#8 - #, $-2$G,+$ % - 8 %! #% C* $#% , #% "%#%**$ 2$$ $$#% 8 %! #% C* $#% -*5- !+# !81 - 2 ##% ,$- 7 , " #7 !"+2 %$ ,! !C* - 8 %!#%C* $#%6 -( 7 ,6 - "8 #+ *%! , 0 "#% @ ;< - "

' - $ 9 % + #% #% !%- 5,*%!

#8*, %- 2 , - 0 4 - 2$$ $$#% - 8 %!#%C* $#% ' %,! ,$*22,- "8 #+6- 2 ##% ,$- 7 28 " !, 8# %" %- >*!5+ %2 $$ !91- 0*2, + *,#%- "

$ #8 ! $

"% %! - - ! 2$# "+2 %$ +*% #% - 57 ,%+ % , $*,1 #$ % #8 "

%% 9 - 8! 9 C*#7 8 % - "+2 %$ #% 2 #! - 8 (% ,$G2 ,$%$#% , $ !,#+

"# - , 8# %" 28 " !#$"%, ,1 - 28 !#%5$ - 2 ##% ,$ $- 1- 7 $*5-8 2$#%5%81%- 5,*%! %% 4#%5 2$$ $$#% %!%% ""*% %%2 1+ % "+2 %$ #% # $#+ 18 (- $%($ % $ "- %5

,- 2,%*%" + % - >*!5+ % 91 - %$#*#% %"- - 0*2, + *, #% - "

$ !"

# $ % &

$ '

()(-#"-#$- 5*#!#%58#5-

,! "#!#%5- "

$ - %!$*

#" + %#%- - >*!5+ %% (-#"- - , 8# %" - $ 9 % 28 " ! #

- $9 % H2, $$817 ,,*8 !91- %$#*#% %"-#%" $ !"

# $ %

- "%"8*!#%5 2 , 5, 2- $*++ ,#D#%5- 2,#%"#28 $ ,#% ,2, 228#"

9#8#1 0 "#% @;<

'#$, 2,!*" !- , #%9 8(& *+ , " -

# - ### - $ - /

- 0

# 1# " -$ - .

1 . . . --"% 2 0 " 1% # - / 0

-$ - $ -( - 1

* 4 1.

# 1 * 4 * 4 3 #

5 0 -$ -

. - - -"% # ### - $/ -

1 # 1 .

/ 1 / # 1

%/ - # 1 / 1

3 2 6 6 # - -$ -

- # 3 5 - 7 " " 1 . # % -

. - - -

5 -$

- (

1 # . " - $ -

0 -& $5 $ - ( 1- -

/ - $ 10 9 7 - #

5 0 - 7 . # % -

0- -"% # / #

@ $ - 1 :

- - -

5 -$ -( ; 1 # " -$ - (/ #

# 5

7 %# 7 - # 3 0 % # 1% 0 # & .. - # . 0 - - 0 # /

# 5 0

-$ - ) 3 " -$ - 1 - -

< 3# - 0 $

- ( #

1% .0 -5 =## #> .

1 0 ) - $ - (/

" "0 " -$ - /

3 " - "0-

- 0

" -

% # - -" % # 1- $ - # - / 0-

5 0 . % 3 - 1 - #

1% 12 # - -"% ( -$ - 0" . - 5 0

% - 0 -

0 0 -- #

- $ - / / ""

#71

# 0

. 5 0

- # - 0 0 # - - # % - "

5 4 @ % $$ %" 6- %$#*#% %"- - 2 H*,- $"8 , ! - "8*!$ !*9C* - (,!$I2 #!J#%0 "#%@;<6I! 2$# !J

""*,,#%5#%- 2,7#$0 "#%@;< %!, !- (,!I,J*$ !#% 9 ( %9-- "%#%5 %"# $ 0 "#%@;<

' I%,J , $ I %!J 0#+#8 ,816 - H2, $$#% I2-1$#"

8 2$$ $$#%J ""*,,#%5#%- + #%0 "#%- 8$9 %"8 ,# # !+ %I!, (#%5 %"-% + JGI D% +"- J - $ 9 % ",1$ 88#D ! - , $ 4#%58 2$#%569-- "%#%5 %"# $(#88- 7 9 $ #$ # !, 2,#%"#28 $ $8 #!!(%91- 0*2, + "*, , ",1$ 88#D ! $*%! ,& ;

< % 88 -$ "

$ $ (- , #% - "C*#$##% 2," $$ - ! 9 % #%## !9*- ,!- $%9 % %%*%" !*%! ,0 "#%

@6%- !

"++ %" + % "

@6- , #$%8 2$ 2," !#%5$

%!- $ + (#88"%#%* 6-( 7 ,6(#-- ,#! ,- "+2 %$ #% - $ 9 ! ,+#% ! *%! , - 2,7#$#%$ - "

' 88 -$ "

$ $ (- , #% - ,! *%! , 0 "#%

@- $9 % %%*%" !2,#, "++ %" + %

'6- 2,7#$#%$ - "

' (*8! - 7 % 9 ,#%5 , 228#"

%! - 2," !#%5$(#88"%#%* #%, $2 " -$ "

$ $6 $# " @- $%9 %, 2 8 ! ;9< - (,! E,F *$ ! #% 9 ( % 9- - "%#%5 %"# $ 0 "#%@;<

'#$9 , $* 4, * 4 (-#"- + %$ - $ 4 8 2$#%5 - "C*#$##% 2," !#%5$ 9- - "%#%5 %"# $ +*$ 9 *8 #88 ! %#%5- , 916- # - 2$$ $$#%- !9 % 4 %9*- "+2 %$ #% ( $ % , " #7 !6 - , (*8! 9 % 8 2$ 0#+#8 ,816 # "+2 %$ #% - $ 9 % "" 2 ! 9* -

A 2$$ $$#% - $ % 9 % 4 %6 - , (*8! 9 % 8 2$#%5

- (( )

-80# ;"< $

, $- $2 " "+2 %$ ,- 8 "C*#, !#$ "%" ,% !6- 0*2, + *,- $"

5,#"

8819$ ,7 !- - H2, $$#%2 #!#%- + #%2 , 0 "#%@;< "

' ! $ % #%"8*! ! 2$# "+2 %$ #% #% "*,- #$, C*#, !9 2,7 !#$- - "+2 %$

+*%( $ %! , !(-#"-- $9 % H28 #% !#% - - %! ,#%5 +*%(*8!+ %- +*% #$ + ! #8 98 - 8 %!(% , %! - (*8! 9 !#$"- ,5 - 98#5 #%+ 4 - 2 1+ % %!#%- 7 % $*"- 2 ,$% "

%% 9 2 % 8#D ! , - !

*8 #% + 4#%5- 2 1+ %-#8 , ,,#%50 "#%'

;

<6'

;<6 '@ - " @ %! "+2 ,#%5 - + (#- - 2 , + ,# 2,7#$#%$# $ "#%?

'6 - 2 H *, - $ "8 ,# # ! - - %81 "%$ C* %" %%2 1+ % "+2 %$ #% #$ + 4 - 2 1+ % #% , $ $ 2 , 0 "#% '@ - " @ 7 % - 0*2, + *,- *,- ,"8 ,# # !- %" - 2 1+ % "+2 %$ #%- $9 %

, !G %! , !*%! ,0 "#%'

;

<6 - "C*#,#%5 *-,#1"

%%9 2 % 8#$ ! ,%%2 1+ %

$- +*%- $, + #%*%2 #!!* , *$ 8 "" 291 - 8 %!(% , "8 ,# 1 # *,- ,6 - 0*2, + *,-

*,- ,9$ ,7 !- # 8 %!(% ,- #8 !- , , %" , -#5- ,"+2 %$ #%- "

%%"8 #+- - ( $%2 #!-

+*%

? ;!< -#8 , !#%5- 2,7#$0 "#%@

' 9 2 , 0 "#% @ ;< - "

'6 - 0*2, + *,- $"8 ,# # !- #%"

$ 6-

, ,2 1+ %- $9 % + ! 9* % ! 2$# !6 8# 9#8#1 2 1 +*% 8%5 (#- #% , $$*9$#$$ %!# %! 2$# ! ,+ >,#1 -8!#%5$

, #7 1 ,$,+, 6"+2 %$ #%*%! ,- "

' - $9 2 #!- 8 %!(% ,$ $%- !

%# #"

, 8 "C*#$##% *%! , 0 "#% @ - " @ 5 ,!#%5- ! 2$#6#- $9 %"8 ,# # !#% >*!5+ % - , - -#5- , "+2 %$ #% 88(6 - +% 1 $-*8! % - 7 9 % ! 2$# ! (#- - B "C*#$##%88 ",,#%- , $*,1,#%- *,(#- , $2 "+ >,#1 8 %!-8!#%5$6+ %#%5- , 91# #( ! 2$# !#% %1 - -, +! $(#-, $2 "+ >,#1 -8!#%5$6 - -#5- , "+2 %$ #% (#88 % 88(6 9* #% , $ *%! , 0 "#% '@ - " @ (*8! 9 - "%$ C* %" ; < $, 5 ,!$- +! 4#%52$$ $$#%6- 0*2, + *, - ! "8 ,# # ! - !, (#%5 #%C* $ , 2,G+ +, %!*+ (*8!+ %- 2-1$#"

82$$ $$#%- $9 % 4 %- 8 ( (#-, 5 ,!7 $#%5 8 %!- $%" #%9 %, # , -8!- %" - 2$$ $$#%- $9 % 4 %*%! ,0 "#%

A @6- 8 %!7 $$$#%- 0 %!- , "

%%9 %1!#7 $#%5,8 2$#%5 ;

< -#8 "+2*#%5 - 5 2 2 ,#! #7 1 ,$ 9 ( % - !

,! %! "++ %" + % - "

'6 %1 #% ,#+,! ,$*9$#$#%5#$9 H"8*! !(-#"-+ %$-

, H"8*!#%5- #% ,#+,! ,6- 2, , C*#$# 5 22 ,#! 1 ,$#$%- , 6- 2,7#$#%$ 0 "#%@;<"

%% 9 #%74 ! ;5< - %F98 *,- *,- ,"8 ,# # !- # "C*#$##% 8 %!- ,8# ,9 %"- 88 %5 ! %!- "C*#$##%( *2- 8!6 (-#"- + %$ - 2," !#%5 $! "%"8*! !6 - *+9, 88 2, "#% 0 "#% @ ;< - "

' "

%%9 #%74 ! $#! $%, 7#7 $ 8 %!#+ 9 ,, ! "8 #+$ ;-< % 2 , ''?6 - %F98 *, - $ + ! # "8 , - - 2,7#$#% 0 "#%@;<

'#$+ %9 #%74 ! 91 - 9 % #"# ,# $ # 8 %!(% ,$ (- ( , , ",! ! $ - #+ #$$* %" %# #"

#% *%! , 0 "#%@ @%1$*9$ C* %2*,"- $ ,6 -8! ,,- ,(#$ 6"

%%#%74 - 2,7#$#%$ 0 "#% @;<

%, $2%$ - $$ ,#%$+ ! 91- 2 ##% ,$ ,$ 4#%5 2$#%5 "C*#$##% 2," !#%5$ *%! , 0 "#% @ ;< - "

'6- , $2%! %$- 7 #8 ! $-,, 28191( 1 %

7##% 8#5- - 8 (8 #!!(%91- 0*2, + *,#%- "

$ !"

#$ % &

3,%4*, 3# 86 8 ,% ! !!##% 8 !7"

% , 86 ,1 % ,#%5 % 9 - - 0 "% %!$- - 2$$ $$#% - 8 %!#%C* $#% 4 %91, ",!#%5 D% +"- A!

@ $ !- - "+2 %$ +*%(#-, $2 "8 %!#%C* $#%-

8, !19 %, " #7 !91- 2 ##% ,$6$+*"-$- - 1- 7 8$

#8 ! , , %" $ *%! , 0 "#% - B %! "C*#$##% "6 @ $ 4#%5 %- %" + % #% - "+2 %$ #% #$ -#$ "% %#% - #% 7# (

, $ #!%% - "%#%5 %"# $+ %#% !#%0 "#%@ ;<

'#$ *8 #88 ! $- 2 ##% ,$- 7

#8 !2#% * %1#% "#%%- 2 , - 0 #- , , 4#%52$$ $$#% %! , , 2 1+ % "+2 %$ #% (-#"- #% $$ %" #$ - *"- $% G9> " 0 "#%@;<

' *,- ,$*9+#$- - 8 %!#%C* $#%#$7 ,1+*"- $$ %# 8 "-# 7 - 2*98#"2*,2$

, (-#"- # ( "C*#, ! $ #

"$ - 28 %%#%5

+ , (#! $ ,7#" , 8%5(#-A + ,$(#! $ ",!#7#!#%5, ! 0 ", '

@6 + ,(#! $ ,7#" , %!A + ,(#! #% ,% 8, 2 , - 22,7 ! ! 7 82+ % 28 % %! -*$ "

%% 9 , 8 $ ! ,+

"C*#$##%2," !#%5$ A 1 28 "#%5 , 8# %" % - 2,#%"#28 $ 8 #! !(% 91 - 0*2, + *, # - $ 9 % "% %! ! - - , ",!#%5 D% +"- #$ 7 8#! +! 4#%5 2$$ $$#% - 8 %! $*"- 2$$ $$#%(*8!"%$,* 2-1$#"

82$$ $$#%*%! ,0 "#%@;< - "

' *,- , $#%" - (,! I,J *$ ! 9 ( % - "%#%5 %"# $+ %#% !#%0 "#%@;<

'- $9 % , $%,G %!9-- "%#%5 %"# $*%! ,0 "#%@;<

'$- 889 *8 #88 !$#+*8 % *$81(#-#%- 2, , C*#$# 5 22 ,#! #7 1 ,$,+, 9 ( %- !

,! %!"+#%5#%

" - "

' $

, $ - "

$ - %! #$ "%" ,% !6 %% - "%#%5 %"# $+ %#% !#%0 "#%@;<

' , *8 #88 !

$- 2$$ $$#% - 8 %!$ %!$ 4 % %!- "+2 %$ #%$ %!$ #!- 2 ##% ,$

? , - 7#%5 9 $( ! *, -*5- *8 "%$#! , #% - ,#7 8 "8 #+$2* ,-91- "% $#%52 ,# $ $$ $$#%5- + #%$- *"-$% - 2,#%"#28 $8 #!!(%91- 0*2, + *,#% !"

# $ %

6 ( , - "%$#! , ! 2#%#% - - #%$ % 2 ##% ! $ ,7 $ 9 !#$+#$$ ! #% 7# ( - "

5,#" ! !$ %! - 0 - - 2$$ $$#% - 8 %!#%C* $#%-

8, !1 9 % 4 % 91 , ",!#%5 D% +"- A !

@ %!-*$- 8 %!#%C* $#%$ %!$7 $ !#%- 0 , 88 #% %$ %!2*,2$ $%-#$, 5 ,!- 8 (8 #!!(%91- 0*2, + *,#$"

5,#"- %" 2$$ $$#% 8 %!#$ 4 %6#7 $$#%- , ,+ 88 %"*+9, %" $ %!(-$ 7 ,, #%$- 2$$ $$#% - 8 %! - ,

,6 - $ 9 , $ , $2 $$ , %! - $ % ,#5- 2$$ $$ $*"- 8 %! *,- ,6 $#%" % - "%#%5 %"# $ 5 $6 - 2$#%5 "C*#$##%"

%%9 "8 #+ ! ( 2," ! H +#% -

$2 " "+2 %$ #%6 (-#"- !+# !81 - $ 9 % , " #7 ! 91 - 2 ##% ,$- , , 6$ "%!"%#%5 %"1 8$5 $ %!( "",!#%581 -8! - #% - "

$ - %! %% - "%#%5 %"# $ 2,7#! ! #% 0 "#%@;<

'#$ *8 #88 ! %!-*$- , #$%8 2$

"C*#$##%2," !#%5$#%- "

$ - %! % "%$2 "*$ (- - $ 9 % !#$"*$$ ! - , #% 97 %! #% 7# ( - 2,#%"#28 $ 8 #! !(%91 - 0*2, + *, #% - "

$ !"

# $ %

( - 7 % - $# #% -8! - #%- #%$ %"

$ %% - "%#%5 %"# $+ %#% !#%0 "#%@ ;<

' , *8 #88 !6"*28 !(#--

"- - 8 %!#% C* $#% #$ 7 ,1 +*"- $$ %# 8 , "-# 7#%5 - 2*98#" 2*,2$ $ #

"$ - "%$,*"#% , !$6 - , , 6 - #%$ % (,# 2 ##% #$

- , 91 !#$+#$$ ! %! 2 %!#%5 228#"

#%6 # %16 8$ + - $ +

% ,#+,! ,6# %16$ %!$7 "

! ;/0)< 0 ;BB< 9,* ,1 '6 %!> - - ,$2 4#%5G, $% !

$G - - ,, 2, 98