High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/194/2016dismissed

State Of Haryana Thr. Its Secretary-Excise & Taxation Department Hry Chd & ORS v. Arun Kumar Gupta

2016-01-27Mrs Justice Sabina4 pages

!"# $#%&'&() !"# $#%&'&() !"# $#%&'&() !"# $#%&'&() !(*!+, -.

!(*!+, -.

"!"# !+,!(!!($"/#+'

00#11!("'

2#+'*'

+*(3*4!+*0"!

#'0($#("

) ) ) ) 5 6 5 6 5 6 5 6

+#'#(")

+#'#(") +!7& !+"!0&(8/.!+,!(! 99999 99999 99999 99999 .

. #'0($#("/!$ &1#$'*&" +$#%1!+!"&("/!"/# :!' #("&"1#$ + !++#!+' +#7&'#$ 0!,;'%!1# !($ "/# 0!,4#(" $&

#+#(%# 1#!7##(%!'/4#(".8+!"*&",!($ 0#('&( /#%!'# "/#+#'0($#(".&(<+&# .:!'"/!"/# /!$=&(#$"/#'#+7&%#' "/#!00#11!("'!'!(('0#%"+ :# > - #'0($#("+#"&+#$(!""!&(&(8"/#!8# '*0#+!((*!"&( ( ?

" "/# "&4#

+#"&+#4#(".+#'0($#(":!'8#""&(8'!1!+,&("/#0!,;'%!1# @>

; >

? $!"#$

? :!'

+#8&'"#+#$!8!&('""/#+#'0($#("*($#+"/# +#7#("&(

++*0"&(%". AA #'0($#(":!'%(7&%"#$<,"/# "+&!1*+"!($!00#!1!8!&('""/#'!4#:!'0#($&(8&("/&' *+" #'0($#(" :!' 01!%#$ *($#+ '*'0#('&( :#

?!($+#"&+#$ +4'#+7&%#(?

"!"#

/!$!%%#0"#$"/#+#%44#($!"&(' "/ !,44&''&(.

:/#+#<,. 0!,;'%!1# "/# +#'0($#(" :!' +#7&'#$ +4 >

; >

" ?

#'0($#("

:!' 8+!("#$ 0#('&( :#

&( 1$ 0!,;'%!1#.

:/#+#!'./#:!'#("&"1#$ +8+!(" 0#('&(&("/#+#7&'#$ 0!,;'%!1# 00#11!("';$# #($!("'&("/#&+:+&""#('"!"#4#("

!7#++#$ "/!" "/# +#'0($#(" /!$ <##( 01!%#$ *($#+ '*'0#('&( 7&$# +$#+ $!"#$

? !($ +#"&+#$ ( ?

/#0#+&$ '*'0#('&( +4

?" ?

:!'(""+#!"#$!'!0#+&$'0#("($*",!($&( 0*+'*!(%# $&+#%"&(' "/&'*+".

B0#('&(.1#!7# #(%!'/4#("!($%44*"!"&( 0#('&(:#+#+#1#!'#$" "/# +#'0($#(" 3##0&(8 &( 7&#: "/# %(7&%"&( "/# +#'0($#("&("/#%+&4&(!1%!'#. B%*"(0#('&(:!'

&40'#$7&$#+$#+$!"#$?

("/#01#!$&(8' "/#0!+"&#'. 11:&(8&''*#'

:#+# +!4#$<,"/#"+&!1*+");

C D/#"/#+"/#01!&("&

&'#("&"1#$"!$#%+## 4!($!"+, &(=*(%"&( !' 0+!,#$ + ( "/# 8+*($'"!E#(&("/#01!&("F

#1&# G

!+"&#' 1#$ "/#&+ #7&$#(%# &( '*00+" "/#&+ +#'0#%"&7#01#!' +&!1 *+" 7&$# =*$84#("H$#%+## $!"#$ ?

:/&1#$#%+##&(8"/#'*&" "/#+#'0($#("/!'

/#1$!'*($#+); C+"/#+#!'('$&'%*''#$!<7#."/#'*&"

"/#01!&("&

'*%%##$'!($&'/#+#<,$#%+##$!($ !$#%+## +4!($!"+,&(=*(%"&($&+#%"&(8"/# $# #($!("'"0!,&(!%%+$!(%#:&"/+#7&'#$0!, '%!1#'

B0+7&'&(!10#('&(""/#01!&("&

"#+%!1%*1!"&(8"/#'!4#"&11"/#$!"#/#:!'0*" *($#+ '*'0#('&(.

*("&1 %(%1*'&(

$#0!+"4#("'H=*$&%&!1 0+%##$&(8' !($ &''*#

&(!1 +$#+ "/#+#(. &' 0!''#$ &( !7*+ "/# 01!&("&

!($!8!&('""/#$# #($!("'*+"/#+."/# $# #($!("'!+#$&+#%"#$"0!,"/#!++#!+'""/# 01!&("&("/#+#7&'#$0!,'%!1#!'!001&%!<1#""/# 01!&("&

!($!1'+#7&'#"/#+#"&+!1<#(# &"'/# $# #($!("'!+#!1'$&+#%"#$"0!,"/#$&

#+#(%# 1#!7##(%!'/4#(":/&%/<#%4#'$*#""/# 01!&("&

( "/# +#7&'&( /&' 0!, '%!1# /# $# #($!("' !+# !1' $&+#%"#$ " $#0'&" "/# !4*(" 8+!"*&", &( "/# &I#$ $#0'&" &( !

(!"&(!1&J#$<!(E(,#!+1,<!'&':/&%/'/!11<# +#(#:#$ +4,#!+",#!+*("&1"/#%(%1*'&(

"/# $#0!+"4#("H=*$&%&!1 0+%##$&(8' 0#($&(8 !8!&('""/#01!&("&

G /# '!&$ =*$84#("H$#%+## :#+# *0/#1$ <, "/# &+'" 00#11!"# *+" 7&$# =*$84#("H$#%+## $!"#$

&(!(!00#!1 &1#$<,"/#!00#11!("';$# #($!("' #(%#."/#0+#'#("!00#!1<,"/#!00#11!("';$# #($!("' /!7#/#!+$1#!+(#$"!"#%*('#1!($/!7#8(# "/+*8/"/#+#%+$!7!&1!<1#("/# &1#%!+# *11, /# %!'# "/# !00#11!("' :!' "/!" "/# +#'0($#(" :!'("#("&"1#$" +#7&'#$ 0!,;'%!1#H0#('&(

!'0#++#%44#($!"&(' "/ !,44&''&(<#%!*'#/# :!'&(717#$&(!%+&4&(!1%!'#!($/!$+#4!&(#$*($#+ '*'0#('&( +4

? " ?

/# *+"'

<#1:+&8/"1,/#1$"/!""/#'!&$!+8*4#(" "/#!00#11!("'

:!':&"/*"!(, +%#!'(%#"/#+#'0($#("/!$<##( +#"&+#$ +4'#+7&%#:# ?

./#:!'1&!<1#"<# 8+!("#$"/#+#"&+!1<#(# &"'!'0#+"/#+#7&'#$0!,;'%!1# #'0($#("%*1$("<#$#(&#$"/#<#(# &"'!7!&1!<1#" /&4(!%%*(" +#;

&I!"&( /&'0!,;'%!1# '*<'"!("&!1K*#'"&( 1!:!+&'#'&("/&'%!'# :!++!("&(8&("#+ #+#(%#<,"/&'*+" &'4&''#$

!(*!+, -.

4!/!7&+