High Court of Punjab and HaryanaITA/497/2018allowed

Navneet Jhamb v. Assistant Commissioner Of Income Tax, Central Circle,Faridabad

2020-01-29Mr. Justice Ajay Tewari,Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan8 pages

" #$!" !" $%" & !

"# $ !

"#%# &'(')* (+,-./+#0&.1#').&,23+*'4.*- &+)5&''*#.)6-7+),+1,23+*' &*-'+55'88+)* &+9'),'&7(-.1#').&#*+),.)60)('8 & *-'&'2')0' '(()**+$

:*-.(3;;)&,'&1*-&''+55'+8(<'+&.)6( =1 +),>?

+&'<'.)6,.(5(', +((.;.8+&.((0'.(.)282', -'+(('((;')*:'+&(.)282',+&'

>@ &*-'(+/'

3)2').')3'1 +3*( &;

+&'*+/') 884.)6 (0<(*+)*.+8A0'(*.)( 8+4-+2'<'')38+.;', BC.D $-'*-'&.)*-' +3*(+),3.&30;(*+)3'( *-'3+('1*-'

-+('&&',.)8+4) +3*(.)05-8,.)6*-'&,'&( 5+((',<:*-'"4'&0*-&.*:+),.)3) .&;.)6*-'

+3*.) ", .) ;+/.)6 *-' +,,.*.)

( 11

E@+(0),.(38(',.)3;'+88'6',8:<'.)6

5& .*)(+8' 58*;'&'8:)*-'<+(.( 3)9'3*0&'

+),(0&;.('(+),4.*-0* +):<+(.(F C..D $-'*-'&.)*-' +3*(+),3.&30;(*+)3'( *-'3+('1*-'

-+( +88').)'&&&.)(0(*+.).)6*-'+,,.*.)(;+,' <:*-'+),CD)*-'<+(.( 8('5+5'&( 4-.3-4'&''2'))*<'.)6*-',30;')*(4.*-.)*-' ;'+).)6 #'3*.)> ),.+)2.,')3'3*1

C...D $-'*-'&.)*-' +3*(+),3.&30;(*+)3'( *-'3+('1*-'

-+( +.8',*3)(.,'&*-' +3**-+**-'", -+,;+,'*-'+,,.*.)()*-'<+(.( 3+8308+*.)(*+/')

&;8(',30;')*( 0),,0&.)6('+&3-.)4-.3-*-'

55'88+)*4+('2'))*;')*.)',+(+<0:'&&('88'&1 4-.3-.(**+88:5'&2'&('+(+),4-')*-'('88'&4+( E(),;'&.3+)8'3*&.3+8("*,1+),*-'50&3-+('& 4+(#-&."%'&;+1*-')4-'&'.(*-'33+(.) &*-'

+(('((''E+55'88+)**(-4+):5& .*&8((+&.(.)6 &;

*-'('*&+)(+3*.)(.)-.(&'*0&) .)3;' C.2D $-'*-'&.)*-' +3*(+),3.&30;(*+)3'( *-'3+('1*-'

-+('&&',.)8+4+),) +3*(.)3) .&;.)6*-'

+3*.) "4'&0*-&.*.'(.) &+;.)6*-'+(('((;')* E(?>.)2.8+*.) 5&.)3.58'( )+*0&+890(*.3'+), 5+((.)6*-'.;506)',&,'&<:&'3&,.)6.)3&&'3* +3*( +), .),.)6(+),4.*-0*3) &)*.)6*-'')*.&'+,2'&('

;+*'&.+80(',+6+.)(**-'+(('((''FG

-06- )0;<'& (0<(*+)*.+8 A0'(*.)( -+2' <'') 38+.;',1:'**-'5.)@5.)*',3)*&2'&(:.(

> B$-'*-'&*-'+,,.*.);+,')+330)* 0),.(38(', '+&)',5& .*)(+8'+),50&3-+(' 5&5'&*:4)',+), (8,<:*-'&(308,<'(0(*+.)',1'(5'3.+88:4-')*-' +,,.*.).)*-'-+),( *-'50&3-+('&)*-'<+(.(

('.H',,30;')*-+(<'')('*+(.,'G > -' +3*( *-'3+('+&'*-+*)

?1('+&3-+), ('.H0&'4+(3),03*',+**-'5&';.('( *-'+55'88+)*1-'.(5+&*)'& &'+8 '(*+*' <&/'& 3)3'&)1 )+;'8:1 '8.+)3' (*+*' 6')3: '&*+.) ,30;')*(+),8('5+5'&(4'&'('.H', &;-.( &'(.,')*.+85&';.('( *.3'0),'&#'3*.)?> *-')3;'+I3*1 =C &(-&*1!*-'

3*!D4+(.((0',1&'*0&)4+( .8',,'38+&.)6.)3;' 1>1

E@5+&*

&;*-'&+,,.*.)(1*-'(('((.)6

.3'&;+,'+,,.*.))+330)*

0),.(38(','+&)',5& .*)(+8' .),0(*&.+858*(+*2.88+6'-+&(')*8.1 '-(.8 +88+<6+&-1 .(*&.3*+&.,+<+,-'8+),4+(4)',<:E(), ;'&.3+) 8'3*&.3+8( ".;.*', C-'&'.)+ *'& ,'(3&.<', +( !*-' ('88'&!D +);-+)#.)6-4+(*-'+)+6.)6 .&'3*& *-'3;5+):*4+()*', *-+*E('8.+)3'(*+*'6')3:4+(+55.)*',<:*-'('88'&*+,2'&*.(' +),5&30&'<.,( &(+8' *-'8+),E(")2'(*;')*(CD"*,(-4', .)*'&'(*<0**-','+8,.,)*;+*0&'1*-'&'+ *'&58*(4'&'(0<('A0')*8:(8, -'(('((.)6

.3'&3+;'**-'3)380(.)*-+*+3*0+8(+8'3)(.,'&+*.) =58*(*+<08+*',.)*-'+(('((;')*&,'&4+(;03-;&'*-+)*-'

.60&'((-4).)*-'&'6.(*'&',(+8'@,'',(-'(('((.)6

.3'&&'8:.)6 05)*-'8('(-''*('.H',1;')*.).)6*-'+;0)*&'3'.2',.)3+(-+), 3-'A0'(3+8308+*',*-'5& .*+),,.2.,',*-'(+;'.)-+8 2.(@+@2.(*-'

+(('((''+),+);-+)#.)6-1+)+6.)6 .&'3*& *-'('88'&@3;5+): -'+(('((;')*4+( .)+8.(',)

-'55'88+*'0*-&.*:2.,'

&,'&,+*',

5+&*8:+884',*-'+55'+81-4'2'&1(0(*+.)',*-' +,,.*.)( 5& .*0&*-'&+55'+84+( .8',<'

&'*-'&.<0)+84-.3-4+( ,.(;.((',) ?=

1-')3'*-'5&'(')*+55'+8 "'+&)', 30)('8 & *-' +55'88+)* +&60', *-+* *-'

&.<0)+8'&&',.)(0(*+.).)6+,,.*.).)(5.*' *-' +3**-+**-'+,,.*.)( ;+,')*-'(+;'<+(.(1.)*-'-+),( *-'50&3-+('&4+(,'8'*',<:*-'

&.<0)+8+),.)3+(' ?

@@," ,"- . !

" /#1 +), *-' +55'+8 .8', <: *-'

&'2')0' 4+(,.(;.((',<: '8-..6-0&**.((0<;.**', *-+*) +,,.*.)4+(;+,'.)*-'-+),( *-'4)'& *-'5&5'&*:1.''.*-'&*-'

('88'&@3;5+):&*-'+)+6.)6 .&'3*& ? "'+&)',30)('8 &*-'&'2')0','

'),',*-'&,'&+), +&60',*-+**-'+,,.*.);+,'.)*-'3+(' <0:'&4+(,'8'*',)*'3-).3+8 6&0),1;&'2'&*-',30;')*(4'&'('.H', &;*-'5&';.('( +55'88+)*+),*-'(+.,,'8'*.).( )-'85**-'+55'88+)* = -'&'.(),.(50*'*-+*)*-'<+(.( *-'8('(-''*('.H', ,0&.)6*-'('+&3-1*-'+,,.*.)4+(;+,')*-'<0:'&+),*-'(+;'-+( <''),'8'*',"'+&)',30)('8 &*-'&'2')0'.()*.)+5(.*.)*,.(50*' *-'+2'&;')**-+*)+,,.*.)4+(;+,'.)*-'-+),( *-'('88'&

-'&.<0)+84-.8','+8.)64.*-*-'+2'&;')* *-+**-'&'.( ,'8'*.) +,,.*.) ;+,' ) <0:'& (*+*', *-+* *-' (+;' .( ) 3)('A0')3'1+( .*4+( ,'8'*',)8:)*'3-).3+86&0),-'&'+() &'3&,',.(+6+.)(*&'3&,+),)*58+0(.<8'-'&'8'2+)*5&*.) &,'& *-'&.<0)+8.)*-'3+('

'8E

@@012 33! ,4$ 4-.3-4+( 884',.)3+('( *-'& <0:'&(18./'>?> '8E

J12% 5 "!3"

? )3"6)6 ,4 #0

"$>?E '8E

J!$ !" 78 12 "3 4 '*3 .( &'5&,03',<'84 B=$' .),*-+**-'(('((.)6

.3'&-+()*<&06-*'2') +(.)68'4&,&'6+&,.)6*-')+*0&' ,30;')*+),-4-'

-+(3)380,',*-+**-':<'8)6**-'+(('((''!(+),);)': *&+)(+3*.)-+(<'')*+/')58+3''-+((.;58:&'8.',05) *-'&'+()(&'3&,',4.*-0*(-4.)6+):+558.3+*.) ;.), )-.(5+&* = )*-.(&'6+&,4')*'*-+*.*.(+8()**-'3+('*-+**-' ('88'&-+(;+,'+):(*+*';')*&-+,+33'5*',*-'&'3'.5*

);)':.'3)(.,'&+*.)2'&+),+<2'*-+*,.(38(',* .(+8()**-'3+('*-+**-'('.H',,30;')*(4'&'.)*-' -+),4&.*.)6 *-'+(('((''&*-'('88'&&4'&'('.H', &;

*-'5&';.('( ('88'&+),50&3-+('&",;;.((.)'&

)3;'+IC55'+8(D-+(<&06-*0*2+&.0(,.(3&'5+)3.'( .) *-' ('.H', ,30;')*( &'8.', 05) <: *-' &'2')0' +), (*&./.)6 '+*0&' *-'(' +);+8.'( .( *-+* .) *-' ('.H', ,30;')*(1.*-+(<'');')*.)',*-+**-'.;506)',58*4+( )*(8,-0(1*-'4&/.)6+),*-' .60&'(;')*.)',*-'&'.) 3+)+*<'(*<'(+.,*<'*')*+*.2'&'I5'3*',+;0)*-.(<: )(*&'*3- .;+6.)+*.)3+)<'*&'+*',+(3)380(.2'5& ( );)':*&+)(+3*.)(&'2'&1.*.(+)+,;.**', +3**-+* *-' ,30;')*( <'.)6 &'8.', 05) (-4', +330)* +( ) >

14-.8'+(5'&*-'&'6.(*'&',(+8','',*-'58*4+( (8,) >?

),'&*-'3.&30;(*+)3'(1*-'('+,,.*.)(

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

.3'&1 &)+/08+;+),)*-'&>?

C#D14-'&'.).*-+( <'')-'8,*-+**-'<0&,') 5&2.)6.(*-+* '2')0'4-') *-'&'.(+88'6+*.) 0),'&(*+*';')*)3)3'+8;')*.)*-'

3)(.,'&+*.)(-4) =$'+8(58+3'&'8.+)3'05)*-'90,6';')* *-')!<8'

5'I0&*.)*-'3+(' 2(%7+8:+)+(0),+&+;.)

D C#D.)4-.3-+88'6+*.)( );)':

*&+)(+3*.))*-'<+(.( ))@3)2.)3.)68('(-''*( 0), ,0&.)6*-'30&(' ('+&3-+),3) 8.3*.)6(*+*';')* ('88'&14+(,'8'*',<:*-'&.<0)+8C*4-.3-1)' 0(*-'

330)*+)* ';<'& 4+( *-' 5+&*:D +), *-' (+;' 4+( +

.&;',<:*-')!<8'.6-0&*+),)!<8'5'I0&*G $-.8','8'*.)6*-'+,,.*.)(1*-'&.<0)+8&'3&,',*-+**-'

.60&'(;')*.)',.)*-',30;')*+**-' <'(*<'(+.,*<'*')*+*.2'&

'I5'3*',+;0)*-',30;')*('.H',(-4',+330)*+()>

4-.8'*-'&'6.(*'&',(+8','', *-'58*4+(,+*', >?

*4+()**-'

3+(' *-'&'2')0'*-+**-'3.&38'&+*'4+(;&'*-+)4-+*-+,<'') ,.(38(',0)+330)*',3+(-4+( 0),*<'5+.,<:*-'<0:'&**-'

('88'&-'&'.()(*+*';')* *-'('88'&&'6+&,.)6<*+.).)6*-';)':+), *-'&'

&'*-'+,,.*.)4+()*(0(*+.)', *;+:<')*',+**-.((*+6'*-+*.*.()* *-'3+(' ,'5+&*;')**-+**-'5&5'&*:4+(4)',<:*-'+55'88+)*&E('8.+)3' (*+*'6')3:-'3+('('*054+(*-+*+5+&* &;*-'+;0)*;')*.)',.) *-'&'6.(*'&',(+8','',(&*-'5+:;')*&'3'.2',<:3-'A0'(1*-'&'4'&' 3'&*+.)3+(-*&+)(+3*.)(4-.3-4'&',.2.,',<'*4'')*-'+(('((''+),*-' +)+6.)6 .&'3*& *-'('88'&@3;5+):$.*-0*-+2.)6+):A0+&&'84.*- *-'.((0'*-+**-'&';+:<'+5((.<.8.*:*-+**-'+(('((''308,+5+&* &;

3;;.((.)'+&)5& .*.)+(+8'@50&3-+('*&+)(+3*.)<0**-'<+(.3.((0' 408,<'*-+*(;'3+(-+;0)*408,-+2'<'')5+.,<:*-'50&3-+('& -'+,,.*.) ) (+., +330)* ;+,' ) *-' <0:'& )'2'& 4.*-(*, *-' (3&0*.):.)+55'+8-'&'.()*-.)6)&'3&,*(-4*-+*+):+,,.*.)4+( ;+,'.)-+), *-'('88'&&*-'+)+6.)6 .&'3*& *-'('88'&@3;5+):

&*-'+88'6',3+(-+;0)*&'3'.2',)*-.(<+3/6&0),1.*408,)*<' +55&5&.+*'*-8,*-+*)8:.)*'&;',.+*&:&*-'<&/'&3+)<'(+,,8', 4.*-*-'+,,.*.)( -'3)*')*.) 8'+&)',30)('8 &*-'&'2')0'*-+**-'&8'

*-'+55'88+)*4+(;&'*-+)*-+* +<&/'&+),-'-+,'+&)',5& .*+8( ,'()*')-+)3'*-'3+(' *-'&'2')0' &*-'&'+()(;')*.)',+<2'

-'+55'+8(+&'+884',-'A0'(*.) &;08+*',.)5+&+

*-'90,6;')*.(+)(4'&',.) +20& *-'+(('(('' 7'(()**+8 79(:&8 ;+(;+(

;/ $-'*-'&(5'+/.)6E&'+()',

'(E $-'*-'&&'5&*+<8'

'(E