High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4239/2013allowed

G.S Gill And ANR v. State Of Punjab And ANR

2015-12-07Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan16 pages

!" #$%& % % ''() *

+,-. %/ '0/ 1/2 "2340/ 56 +,-. %/ '0/ 1/2 "2340/ 6 +,-.

2/4'/'70 '0/ 1/2 "2340/

-( 8$9 -#

: 9%" "/( -/0'077/;<'/=<;'0< -2 2-/:2;'70<=<

/0'0 -//2<'' "234<

//'0 >00/0// ;/?@4; 0327?A

4/ //0///

>00/0327?024//'0'7A : 9%" <# $@0'327?<;''

56 <'

6 <'

/''7 2 0/ 327? / < 4@0/ '='#27+#2'/%'=''.<#0/ 0/''

0 '0/'

/ '='2'0 '/2'4/'7 '='2' 5 ;

'4@%/ '#4'/:2/;'

%/ '2/ ')) 0'7'/'<'/'7 %2@ ??''/2?7'//< #0/< /7'/ 0

) )< 2@ B2 4@

-0"'/%</7/'7?2/'7*/)C +00'.< 2@''0'<'2;'0'0/=2 ='7%22/<0'%'/'#0/0/' ; 270 0

0 0 ''

/ ' /< 0 4'

) )<2@B24@ -0"'/%'

=2/ ''

/7/'70' D2'/' / /?'32';270 ;0 0B2

) )< ' =2/ 0 ''

< /7/'7 ?2/'7*/)C+00'.<'2;'0'0/=2 ='7%22/<0'%'/'#0/< //'

@/0#'247'//<?2/</ 2/7'/ 0<='// *) )0 '4@0 ''

;'?'4@0%2@ ??''/2?7'//< #0/< 02'4/'7 '='2' ) ; '4@%/ '#4'/:2/</7/'70/

) )< B2 4@ < /7/'7 /)C)?/+00'.<'2;'0' 0/=2 ='7%22/<0'%'/'#0/< 04' '?'/ 0 0'/2' 4/'7 '='2'2?4/ 5$

; '4@ 2/4'/'70 ' 2/0'70 '< %/ '<'?'70 -0"'/% 0B2

) ) / ?2/'7 C?/+00'.5C ?/<'2;'0' 0 ='7%22/<0'%'/'#0/?

;/'0'2' 0 2'< -0 "'/ % /0/2702 ';/'?<?''70 '? 0''

'24?'00+ .

043''

02' 0''

// 'D2'///4/7'/

;=/<000/2'0 7/20;/0' 047?0$4-/2 % -0 "'/ % ' @ ?7'7 0

'/ ?0$4-/2%0'?'/ 20'D2'43';C0 ';/=2 2/'6 '='"/2/< 6+'0/8 "

8.0 0//

*) ) < 4@ 0 #' 24 7'//< ?2/0%2@ ??''/2?7'//<#0/< /'=@<;/ ;

2// 0 ;/ 2/< / 7'7 0/270 0 =/'2 /='' 07'/'09'?''<00 02'/;'0''?''7/0/0

0 ''//7'/0

) )0// *) )<4@0#'24 7'//< ?2/ // < 4@ 0 %2@ ??''/2?7'//< #0/< / 2 4 '7 /'7 0 ; 0 /' ; 7/0

00''

/0 '0/<243/7'/' ;'032 B'% ; 2/0///' /?''7<

2/0/'72<07'702//'7@/

* 0/7=/0'D2' 77/'= 4@ 0 '327? / 0 ;/ 2/<0 "234 0/270 %2@ ??''/< #0/< ; %/ ?0 $4 -/2 % 0/270 -0"'/%/0= '0+;=/< 0 /2 0 // 0; 0 ' ; ' @ 4@ 0

=/?"/40 0 "234@. 0 / %'/' #27< #0/< =' / 327? / ) <;0'0 327?/ <4@0/

'='#27+#2'/%'=''.<#0/'?'02' ;'07'0'327?/<0// /72/0=4 '4@0''

, 0=/@2<0/'/2 /0 0 /72 0 0 //' 0' /@/ @ / /7'/' 02/')) 07'/' < 60/'/20 2/0//720 0'B2'?'4@0B2<0 /7'/'720/'@0// 20/7'/' 0 ?04 2/0//7200/%'/'#27< #0/<;4@0 0/'00-0 "'/%0;/'0//@<B'

5 7'@/ /04 ' 0;4/=4@ 0/%'/'#27<#0/<0-0"'/%; ?B20 0?0//@

@/0/ /<0'7/2<0327?/ 0;/ 2/;//=/ 0= 0/ 0 / '/ 2 / 0 </''= /<"234<0= B?'0;/ 2/// '4@0/'/2 /0 0'';0/00=4 074@?4@''/D2'//?';00/ -0"'/%;?B20/ / 0 ;/ B2 '2 4@ 0 B200=4074@@ 0 = 0?0<0/ /<0 ''7 0/ %'/'#27<#0/</4@0'7 0/' /2/@0'? /7'/' 0< 0''

//D2'//=;00/0//@04 ' /7'@/ /04 ' ' 2/0/ /720'0<0'/'?2;' 0/2700D2 /*C)?/< /?@ ;/'<=';0D24/'7

) 6) 5

* <5 * 5;/' 0/270'

/0D2</;$C $/</0 7/<#0/'?'/@</7/'7 ?2/'7 C?/5C ?/< 6// ;/'0/270;0D2</;$C $/</07/<#0/</?@

//;/'0/270'

/0D2</;$C $/</0 7/< #0/ 7/'7 ?2/'7 /)C)?/+00'.<;/'/ ?@<='0D26) *6 *0/ ;/'0/270 '

/ 0D2< /; $C $/</07/<#0/0@?;//=4@ B?''704C

''0/ /<0/@/04?

/'7'0327?/ 0;/

2/ 0/'/20/ //=/'2 /=''/7/'7/7'/' 02? '

0 7'/' < 6< /=' 4 / ;0? 0 2?'4/ //7'/' ' 0 7'/' /=' / D2'/@ 4 / /7'/' 4@ /7'/'720/'@<;0'0'//22/(

D2'/@4 //7'/'4@/7'/'7

6 +.+ . BBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBB + . 0/7'/'7

'/00/2F +.D2'/;00//202?;B2 4@ 0 / 4@ ;0? ' 2// 0= 4 B2G +4. ' @ 0'? 0 ''@ 0 / /'7 4 / 0'? 7'7 0 0@ 0= B202?G +. ' 0 @ / /'7 //'=< '7 /7< ' @0'? 0 /'70 20//H ' * 07'/'/=' //2/ ?''' B2'/'=@/=' 0 0 B2' ' ?'< 0 /7'/'7

'/ 0 /7'/02?<'/''*65'2'= ' * 07'/''//22/( * "/2/ ?'' ' B2' /'=@F +.+. 0 / B2'7 0 2? //@4 /0/7'/'7

'// /@C;0'?</'

040/;'' ' 00@/0/0@//0?=4< '

0@?'0B2' 02?</ +4. '

'0 @//'74@ //'=< '7 / 7< 20 //'=< '7/7?'0B2'</ +. '

0/B2'702?'< 0' //'= / '7 / 4 / 0

/7'/'7

'/ ?' 0 B2'< 0 /7'/'7

'/0/7'/02?'/ ''*65'2'= + .

BBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBH 0/'/2 /0 02/')) 0'7'/'<' / 2/7'/2?4@07'//<0 '='2'' ?')) 0'7'/''2/( E)) 2'' // / 24@7'// +. >0/07'/// 2//02? 4/7'/<2/') //' )5<@/'?'72/202?</0' //'=<'7/7<?@<;'0'0'/@@ /0?C'7 0// / 2<''2'0

'=' 2/< ;'0' 0 '?' ;0 /'7' 32/'''''20

'';0'002?' 2704/7'/<2' //'/'70 2?4/7'/'20

'42@ / / /7'/' ;'0' 0'/@ @ / 0 '7 20/ + . 0/=''''24'+ . + . ')*0<?2'?2'<@ 2?/ //7'/''/;'0 @ 20 /< < ;'0'7 @0'7 ''0'<02?04/'=4 '=''202'H 04/7200/7'/'

;/ 204' '

'',

,6 ,/=2

0'7/0<)6 6)-?,

,6 #,/=2 56 0'7/0<

' /72 0 0 ' ??,'

''=//'0/='' 07'/' < 6 0/'/20/'20 20/'@ 0' 2/'

65 +"234.

6<;0/''?'/';0'00/7'/' 0 /7/'70 %/ ;/ 22 '/2' 0 =/?;4/=2/( E ' / /? 0 /2 0 =/'2 /='' 000;/ 247'// 7'// 0= 4 /@ ' ?/ 4@ 0 / /='' 0= 4 ?20/''70247'/// 2/7'/ 2? '

0@ / //@ B2 / / / 0 243?/ 0 2? @ 4@0//'/'32/''' 07'///0 247'//0?@40247'// / 2/7'/2?2/ 0< '

''0/'' 0'??=4 //@2

''''

@0?G'

02?' / ;'0' 2/ ?0 0 '

B2'G2/ 6'

02?'/ / /7'/' ' 0

' 0 247'// ;'0' ;0 24%'/' 0 ;0 / ? /' 0 //@''2G2/

02? 4/7'/'/4@0/B2'7' / '?'7 2/ 0 ? / 4@ //'= / '7 20/G2/ *'

0247'// '' '420''@ 0/,/ 0@//0?=4</20// /?'0B2' 02?</ //20//4?'//2' /''/'

0/4@;0?02?2// 4 B2 ' 0' //'= / '7@'B2'0/'/='''0 /D2'/'7/20/''70247'/// 2 /7'/ 2? 42 @ '/2' '2 4@ 0 =/? 0 7'//< //''7 / /0'4''7 0'? /? /7'/'7 2? / 5 0 / / 7'/' 0 4 '= ;'0 0 7/ 2/'=/07'// 2''7'0 ?C 2 ' ;'0 0 < "/=' /0?/?'0/'024 7'// 0 7'// / 0 /' 0 2 0@ /; 0'/ 20/'@ 0/ /? 0'/ ;/2'/=/4@00'/2/@

2' 2 4 2/' 4@ @ B2'= '/2' '2 4@ 0 =/? / 0 7'// /2' 4@ 0 =/?

7'//<"'<;/;0@;'0232/''' ;/ 4''7 0 247'// 0 24 7'//'/30/@/ 0''/ / /7'/'72?42@/?/ 0 '''

''@ 0' 0 ?'4=04 2 '/=' 0'/7'/0@42 '/2''24@0/04//0'?

/? /7'/'7 0 /'7 0 //' 0/'7'2''2'H %'=''$0 0' 2/'! "

6+ ."9#)04/=2/( 07'/' ' '? / 0= 4 '

'@ 2?/ 2/ ' <

< 6<

* 0 /;0'024 7'///07'//?@/ 2/7'/0 0/ 2? /D2'/ 4 /7'/ 2/0 0 ;0//='0024 7'//,7'// / 2 /7'/ 0 ,/''7//@0;/0' ;0'0''D2' ;'0'0?' 07'///247'//C0B2 04'00'/0/;/0''/ 0 //@ ;0'0 ' 243 ?/ 0 =@ 0 7'2/< ' ' ;'?< 0 0270'//?C20/='''0 20/''707'//,247'//?C/4 ' 0 ;/0' 0 //@ 270 4

/ //'@?/0/='' '

0 ?;/ 0 7'/'7

'/ ?C 'D2'/@ 4 / /7'/' 2? 0 7'/'7

'/00/'70?C'D2'/@;00/ /202?;4@0/4@ ;0?'2//0=4B2' @ 0'? 0''@ 0//'74 / 0'?7'700@0=B202? 0 @ / /'7 //'=<'7/7' @0'? 0 /'70 20// >02?'/ //7'/'<0 7'//,247'//00;/C' ' @ 0'? 0 0 /D2'' 0 /='' ' ' ' <

< 6 * 0= 4

2 ' / / 0 / 2/ 24 '+. ' 0<0;? 07'/'7

'/D2'/;00//20 2? ; B2 4@ 0 / 4@ ;0? ' 2//0=4B2' @0'? 0''

@ 0//'74 /0'? 7'700@0=B202?' 0 @///'=<'7/ 7<' @0'? 0/'70 20/ / '@@ 0/D2'/? 0' /='' ' ' '< 0 24 7'// 0 0 ;// 20/7'/' 2?0 7/200;/0' 0//@'''2 0/ /<2/0<'0/0247'//0

@;// 20/7'/' 0 07/2 '2;/0' 0//@/0 7'//0@20/'@/?00 247'//'/'70'?/=' 2/2'@ 400/'='420;/0' 0 '2 0/ /< 0 //

5<B2/"

5B2/ " </'44'H 0/'/2 /0 0'0'<0'/''/= 0'? 0 ''

;?'4@-0"'/%<;00B20 0 '07'0327? / / '=' #27 +#2'/ %'=''.< #0/< //2@?'0? 0-0"'/% < ;0/ 0 /2 0 ;/ 2/ ' 0; 0 0 ?? ; ' @ 40 4@ 0

=/?"/00-0+ .' '707/2 /'0'70;/ /@ 0/ /<0'?;'//@?' <0-0?'0'? 0''

20<0' '?'/@/'00/7'/' 0'02 4// ;< 0 D2' ;2 /' ;00/ 0 ;/ 2/27'0?/' 0''00

* 024/7'/A ? 0=';0'0'<0/@/; / /7'/' 0';0/0'' 4@0-00407 0/ /<'?@=';<0 ;/ 2///'7'7'0D2';00/0 -0;?B20;00/0 / / 7 '@ / 4 ' 0 %/ 0/ /<0 ''7 0;/ 2/'0'/7// /=/ /0D2' '?'''/<0 ?;;'04@0;/ 2/';00 /?0 C;7<02'/;'0''?'' ='; 0/='' 07'/'< 6< '24=<0;';4@0' 2/< '24=<?

0=';00#'247'//< ?2/0%2@ ??''/2?

'/? /2 0 /7'7 '2'< 0 / /;0'?27327?/ ) < 4@ 0 / %'/' #27< #0/< /

5 0/4@'0327?/ < 4@0/ '='#27+#2'/%'=''.<#0/</ 20 D2@<0'?'/@/24 /0' 2/' ; 0 0/270 #' 24 7'//< ?2/0%2@ ??''/2?7'//<#0/< /'//7'/00/

) )< ;'0'/' 0'/@@< /?0 '7 0/ 327?<2430@'70/@/7'/' 0/7'2/'70''7'<-0"'/%<B2< '<42'0;/'?<00?'0'? ''

<0/ /< ///<// B2;'4''2 +: 9%" .

# %

) * 3C