High Court of Punjab and HaryanaITA/72/2018dismissed

Pr. Commissioner Of Income-Tax (Central), Gurgaon v. Smt. Meenu Satija

2023-09-27Ms. Justice Ritu Bahri,Mrs. Justice Manisha Batra11 pages

!"#$

#$% &' (# ) * + #*,&+#- (

% !"#$

#$% &' (# ) * +/*+&+#-(

!"#$

#$% &' (# ) * +/*/ ./.(

.# &

!"#$

#$% &' (# ) * +/*/ ./.(

.# %

!"#$

#$% &' (# ) * +/*+&+#-(

0 !'

# !()*#+,-+

- '

!()*#'+,-+

#1 ,*)&

%& +#.'

& %

#/#"

$* ,*2 /3/%+ .4 #% 5#/,*+/#& %.4 #% .,*&'2 3%.4 #%

#/ .#"

#&/%*"

$ * / -&.'

*70%78%79%7:%0:

0;<# '#/

=& 5. # 4 4.#/ * % # >'#2

*70 0;<* 0* / ##" *70 0;<$%&.+# 09;

!#%:9%/ > .' ##/ ..#.07*;7*0;7

.>3#/

!#>&%//?@%5/% 5/>3" *0A:;BB0;7$ .>3#/

+ #*,& +#-' ##/ ..#.9*;C*0;7%/ >#.>3 > 4'

&.1 ?9* /&

# . # #/ # .# # #/ #

5 #/

#0;;0;% .&./> 4.

.'3%#/ # % 5 &. #> ># B'/# #/ . #/5#/ // &#

> B'/# . #/ # ' #

&' > B'/# # #/

>3 #/

3* . & #/ .

D> +&

&# #/ E/ .3 # F#.*4 * % #."0;;<$C;7 C0* /

4.>3#/. ,& > >&#/ +&./, "0;A$A<

C 0;9 "

& $ . #/ . D> +&

&##/ E/ .3 # F#.* "

&$% #3 >' 43.# // >3

& B'/# / &/ #/ #3 #/

.#/! #' // . #/ ##*+ 3% #3%/ 54% >'

# #/

#/ ## > & >&& B'/# . ..# &.>

.>33'#/ 89"0$"4$

#/ 3>* .'3%#/ . #/.

>.5. .#.# >=& /.. ' &.

5.*@ C* #/ # #/ # % ;A*;7*0;0 /5

. &##/>&

,B #/ &

#/.# *&'#/ /%.

& 5

G..#/ #% #&.+# 8C"$"$ #/

&.#

<*;C*0;C=&'/# /#&

5#/ ## #/.'

#34## #/ 4 & 3%5//#/ /5 .&#.* .

#%#/

./#&

#30;0 0;C 00*;<*0;C.'

*<%0%A;B* / #% # &.+# AC"0$.A0"$ #/

!# '5#/ =& 5

&.#

;8*;0*0;A* # 4

#/ # % +/* - / +

.% **% . +/* 2 &#% **% #/ &#/ G. ##4 >/

%##..#/

# # */#&

*<%0%A;B5

#.* A*

! #

# .

%#5 #.>3#/

#$% &' #/##/

A 5 . ,B #/.4#*F#.* &'#/3&. .# %#/

3/. ##.%;%A::& >

07*;C*0;05#/ &# .# >353 #G#

/ & &#. 4 &#*#

#.#/#

5 ##.# &# . **# ##.#

# #/

0:*;C*0;0H0A; / 4&

*;B /*3 3' &

! & %:90%#/5

#5#/ &# .#/ 89"0$"4$"$ #/**#53###.* 8* & %#/ 2#4& ,B

#/.4#*F#.*5 &#.%5//

*C:*7B=&#3

/*/# #4& /.>3#/

*8*: *.#/4& 4.>3#/

#0;00;C

*7*C: ***# #/ .'

*/& %## 5#/5

*0*0 * / 2# 4&

&#.&. & I #/

*A%C%A8%78B"

*C:*76%;%A::$%5//5 4.

.&'#/

#0;00;C>3, *,&+#-* .'3% #/ 89"0$"4$"$> 2#4&

4.>3#/

* # .'#/3.

'& .>3#/

% .&.+# 09C #/

#%:9.#'#/* *#

&##/

>3 2'..#

*A%C%A8%78B&.+# 89"0$"4$"$ #/#5

. 9*;C*0;7"!&0$*' ##/ .%#/

. "

#30;00;C$> #/>&%5//5 5.

4. ..#.07*;7*0;7"!&C$>3/ .'#/##/

89"0$"4$"$ #/

!#%:95 &. #> ># #/5 . #/5#/

&# .#/5

' #4 4.*#5 &#//.#/# #35 43.

&/ #/ #3 #/5

.#/! #' .' #/ ##.

..# &.> .>33'#/ 89"0$"4$

#/#* 9* / 4& / /'. #/ . .#. 07*;7*0;7 "!&C$ #/ 5' &> ##=& 51 "$ J/#/#/ # .#/&

# #/

.5%#/ D>5 -& # ..#'#/ ..#

*A%C%A8%78B .&.+# 89"0$"4$"$

!#%:9 4'%;%A::>

#/.4#*F#.* .# ' #/,2#)&

*C:*7&#.&. & I #/

! & %:90* "$ J/#/ #/ # .#/&

# #/

.5%#/ D>5 '/#5.#'#/ ..# ' '#/ ##/#

& >3 .4#' / &

&##

# .#

#/#5#/ #/

# * "$ J/#/ #/ # .#/&

# #/

.5%#/ D>5 '/#.#'#/..# ' ' #/ # #/# #/ # > 5

. # # . # > . 3 # &

&## . # / > .

3 # # . # #4&

* "4$ J/#/ #/ # .#/&

# #/

. 5 &/ . # # # > ##3

9 '.. #4#'#/'

#/ #/+# 89"0$"4$"$ #/#* F. & #/ .#/ .# #/-&.'

.>3#/'/

&# E#2

" #$ %& '0;0;+

FEA:<%5/#/

5 .4.&''.#/>&

* . #/ #&

# 3 0;00;C 0<*;:*0;0.'# #

*C%00%AC%CC;B* /. G&

# &.+# C0 #/#5 .&#.#/

0*;A*0;..&' /%

&# %

. # 5 G.*/

/..

##.

*0*;C &.

#/ 4# 3 * 54% #/

#. #/ ..#

. #/ #&

#30;0;0* / #% &#3 .'

&.+# AC"0$ #/#5##.*/

' %4.

..#.;9*;C*0;A%/.#/##/

/.4.%;;%;;%;;;

&.>3,B ,.&# .,. &".$ 4#*F#.*/

' 4 2.#/ 89"0$ "4$ #/#.##.#/#

& .

. #/ 2# 4& #/ > #

*0%A:%;;%;;;B*/

.> #/

!" $%5//5 5.4. ..#.;A*;<*0;8 #/' &.#/# 4 4# #.. #4 4

#.#/ % 89"0$"4$ #/#5 >#

..# 5 '4 .# &

*0%A:%;;%;;;B* / 4&5#> #/

7 #>&*/>&%4. ..#.00*;*0;9%>3 '

#/. '4>3 D>#/+&

&# #$ # '080 897%/.#/# 89"0$"4$

#/#5 ####.# #/ # #&# #/ ..

#/ .>3#/ 4&*/ 4&%#/ #% /.

#/'/

&#* /'/

&# E#2% #'

'#/ &'/#/ .% > 4.#/##/

.# #/5 % 5/#/#/ 2#4&

&#. & .

& #/

!# &.> ..

& +# 89"0$"4$ #/#*#5 /.#/##/> 4 .

# # #5 #' % #3% 5/ #/ #35

4.5#/ &# .# . .3%5/#5 4. .#

#/#/ 2#4&*/

& >3 #G# 4 5 3 # #/

* /5 5 / &.

#/# 3.% 5// .#/ */# # &.

4>5#/#/

3 .#/ .

& .. # &#3/' # # #&#& #/

3*%#/5 ..# ## # #/ # 2'#& .#/# # &.

4>5#/ #/

3 .#/ */5 # .# #/#> /.># .5#/## # 4.#!%5// 5 >-# #/ =& */45!

.>3#/

!" $ 5 #/>&5 &/.

#/#.//0.121/03/4504./ /465/74//0/80/0. 00/60605. 89"0$"4$"$ #/#

< 5 ####.*3%#/ .>3#/ 4&5 .

.* F. & #/ .# &#/ .# #/-&.'

>3 D> #/ +&

&# (") $ * #

!'0;;:"$+

089%5/#/=& .# 5 5#/ ## * #/# %#/ #

3 ##.'/# /# 4 '

.. # &> > &/ *#5 /.#/#

'/# 5 #.

.' #&.+# A"$ #/ #!#% :8< #/ # .#/

35 #/.># ' ##!* 7* F. & #/ .# . # #/ -&.'

.>3 D>#/+&

&# +,-- ). / 0*#" !'::< "+ $CA;* #/# %#/#5 &> #.

3* /#

/. .#&

#3 :70:7C% :7C:7A.:7A:78. 5.

5 .4 >#&.+# CC #/

!#%:95 .*/

' &#/ #3 5. #/ . >3 #/

3* +&> =&#3%#/

'&#/ #3 #.

#/> /# #/

3 #/# #/

3 /. . # &

#/ .4 #># 4# /#G# &#>3

'&#/ #3 &..#/##/

&#.# . #>&# # >3#G# .#/& %#/

&#/ #35 #/45#/##/ 88"$"$"$ #/ #.# #/ ## % #/.4 #># 4/.> &# . . #>&# >3 53 .4.. # * /

&#/ #3

. .&.+# 8A #/#5#/.5'#/

: .4 # ># 5. * ' # #/ . .% #/

3 .%5//5 5.>3#/#&#/ #3.

#/# .4 #>#5 & #.*/ 4& 5#> #/>&%5// &.5#/#/45#2>3 #/ ##&#/ #3*/ #%#/ 4& .> #/'/

&#*/'/

&#% #! '#/ CA"C$"$"$.+# 88"8$"$"$ #/

!#%/.#/##/

& &#.. #>&# # .#/ %#/

##&# 3=& CA"C$"$"$ #/#/.>4 #.* /'/

&# 5.> #/#/=& #/'#4. 4 &

#/ 4&*'''4.%#/

.> D>#/+&

&#* D>#/+&

&#! .#/

45 #/ -&.'

. %#-

#1'":0$ 7*#/ -&.'

#%#/ /

. #

& /4>!.>3#/' /

&# *#/ >/.#/#

&#=&# #/ 4&

&. #>'.. 4.>3#/ * #3455

#2 >3 F . &. . F . +& % 5/ /. #/# #/ 5 .

?# # @5

5/#/G3.#/

&##/#5 # ./.

>##. /4>.# */ #% D> #/+&

&# .# #/. '4

%#-#2 " 34!- '":09$ C:8%5/#/

&# .#5#/

3%5///.'&. #>&#. # *# ...# # # #/ # .. #>&##

#/ .3 > #/ 8K.>#& 2*/

2 5 .&3

&.% .# 4.' #/# #/

3 '/#

; .

.#/ 2 ### .#4# */=& #/# & . 5 %5/#/#/> .#/

.>#& 25

#//.

.5 % #/ %># &#!*#5 /.#/##/5/ # # 5

?> /3@ #G# # .4 4.

#*#5 &#/ > 4. &.1 ?7* &45%#/ ##.>3F .33

4 #/ # 4 3 .#/ */ # .

>3#/

3 3>. #>&#. .4..

#.>3 #/

3 # 4 5// 3 > & . # #/

3D 5 2 % >&.'

/3* /# 5 > #/

3 # 2 ' # */ #>3. &##/##/ 5 > #

#/ > &'/#> &##/ #

2' #& #/

3* F25 % #/ & &#. # # ..#> #/

3 '.%#/ 3>#/

3# .

#>3*/ 5

> # #/ /# .*/3 3> #

.#3 >3

& > * &# #/ #/

##/ # 2'#& #/

! /#

3%#> .

#/# #/ /4 4. 3

3*/3 3/4> #.> #/#/

*&#% #/ > # #>##. . #>&#

#.'# #/.# 3 4 &.

3# #

*@ <* / #% D>#/+&

&# .# #/-&.'

. 5!'1 " #$ # *' ":9A$80 897%5/& #.3#&/%/. .#/ 45!

.>3) &# .%3. 4# #/.

45#2>3F .&..F .+& * D>#/+&

&# /.#/#?#/ #'#& .#/

35// 3 #.

&> >.#.#/ 4 5>

&> >.#

3*@ /# # #//.

5 #3

5//%

5>.4. &#&*3%#/

5 5.>3 > 4'#/##/45 #/'/

&##/# >

&#. # . #>&# & &#. # #/

3 / 5 4 >#

4&.%5 # #* :* #/ # #/ #"

$%#/# #/> 4 .

-&.'

% .# >3. & #/ .#"

$% 4 & #/ .#

* ;* F. & #/#/ #>># #3 -&.'

.>3 D>#/+&

&#%5/#/#

/ >/.# >

#//.

% #/ # %#/5 . #>&# # / * * 45 #/> 4. &

% ' &. . &##

# #/ &'. ."

&##3%#/ # **

*70%78%79%7:%0: 0;<% .>3#/ 4&%.

.* "

$ ",+ $ 07*;:*0;0C -

1 B