← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/1065/2018dismissed

State Of Haryana Through Secretary, Home Department And ORS v. Mahender Singh

2023-03-14Mr. Justice M.S. Ramachandra Rao,Mrs. Justice Sukhvinder Kaur6 pages

-1IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANAAT CHANDIGARH **** Reserved On:27.02.2023 Pronounced on : 14.03.2023 **** State of Haryana through Secretary Home Department and others ... Appellants

Versus

Mahender Singh ... Respondent **** CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.S. RAMACHANDRA RAO, HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE SUKHVINDER KAUR.

****

Present:

Mr.Hitesh Pandit, Addl. A.G. Haryana.

Mr.JaiVir Yadav, Sr. Advocate, with Mr.Nitish Sharma, Advocate, for the respondent. **** M.S. RAMACHANDRA RAO, J. 

  



 

    

  

      

        

     

   



  

 

 



  

 



 

  

  "#$ 

 %&

   '() ( *      +  ,& 

( . 

   

-2- 

 /

0() ( *.     &  &



 "1

 

$2 /  

&  

() ( *     " 1

 

 $2  3  /  

(0(* ( * 

  $2 /  

 ((* ( * 

 / 

  

 )(* ( *

2     

  5    



  

 $

   +  

 /   

      '() ( *   + ,& (    

 $2  3  /  &  

  ( * 6&

"7 / 

&

# ()8 9

":

& 

"7 / 

  &  

 ('(  ((' &   &

 $2 3 / 

  



 (0( ( '       

   

         &

 

 

 



 

5 

 

 & +

"

$  

-3-     



 

 

 %&

  +  ,& 

 (    

 

 %&  

 

       !

  



 &       

 

4+ . 

5



 

  2 ;

 )(* ( * 

  ( *

  0 

    

 2  

" 7  / 

 

4+  

<  

   



 -2



 

 2    +  ,&2%&

( 

 ') ( *      /

 

0) ( *  &  "

  1

 

  



0 * ( *   

 (* ( * 

 

 )* ( *

< ' 



 +

  

  



  ( * 

 $2  3  /  &  

6&

"7 / 

&

# ()8 9

":

& $

 ;

  &   

   

 

 )(* ( * &

  

 

  

.      

 &

 2

-4- 5

 

$2  &

 $

  +  

3

/ 

 & 0



<&

2& 3 ;

 =2  ('(  ( ' (0( ( '    

;

 <

            +&

  

  &    5   2

 3

; 

   &    

  2 

 ,& 22

 &     

2 < !

>

                                               

 

        !



 

        

        "#       $               



       % 

       % 

                                                        #                  &  #                   #   !



  

                              

                                         % 



'    #       

        

  #    

  

      "      #  

    "   

  (2012) 3 SCC 563

-5-

  (

      

  )       

 

     

    

             



         "               

 

             

                                "      

   " 

  #  # !



                  * #           +   

           8 +&9  

            !!

    +"#   +&

 

  :      +&

>

,   &                       -

$      #             

     $                            

    



 

    #    "                  

                    # - % 

     



 + $  

    & 

  

 

  2

2   





 



  5   

 +

 0

 "

$  $ & 



&

  

< &    

   !

 2021(11) SCC 506

-6-

 

 

&

 



2  3





    

 &  









5

       

 ?&

 

 &; &  +

"

$  8

!" # 

$% '

"

"

# (")!! *" ++ 

" ),!- $ )- " # '"+)0 -



 5



  <   

4+ 

 

      &  

       

+ 

  



 +  



6&

   $ 

    



#'# .

 / 0 .

.



1 23 '4/5$0 3.

.

# %# %

1 23  - < 4

 > 6 -   > 6 3(2020) 13 SCC 745 4 (2020) 11 SCALE 688 5SLP (Civil) NO.11989 of 2020 dt.22.1.2021