High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2072/2016dismissed

Dhbvnl v. Shashi Bala Chhabra

2026-01-22Mr. Justice Pankaj Jain6 pages

!"!

# $ %% &

)"

%%%%%% ** ++#"

)"-"

("(!

+ ((.)

%%%%%% "* # # / $

0' /% 1

!

"#

$

%%%% 1

%

3)+4 !" & '$" ( ' "

)

"& "'

' *"+ ,

-.(

'

"

+ ((-/01 &

2 .

0 0 3 "

"

" 1 456 7

"

0 0 0"

, 8

'

' & '

# 11,4/- "

&"

'' "& # 9000/-

&"

*

7$" "

'

'

!" &"

# 4,4/- ":"

'

(" ; $"

& 7$" & 7" " !"

$$" :""

" "& "

' "& $

' &'" ()# '

!"! # .

0 0, " " - =33 ) "

00 "

>?

' ' "

' &

"'

@

4, 00

$$" !"

!"

"

'

' & " 00

>?

4 " "

&&

!"

>?

"&' &"

'

' 41"

*

"

&

"

!"

>?

7$"

"

,

" &'

'"

"

.

$ $ >?

"

, 40

,0 < -

>?

" "

, 40

,0

&

& &"

"

, ) '& & " '

'

" & ' & $"

>?

'& &"

:"

&

00 $ $ A. >?

&'

'

<

$" '

" "

,

40

,0 !

' ) &

,$

$" " 00

"

'

, 40

,0 & '

" & '

$"

!"

"'

"

,

!"

"

>3?

'

" "

, 40

,0 '' $" !"

&&

>3?

7

' $" "&&'

" " $ $& "A.

>3?

7 $" & $ ' "& &

& '

'

7&

&"

:" &

&

3

& >3?

7 &"

' & $$" >3?

7 ' & ' $" !" /

&"

' "&":" ) B " '

,4 !"

$$"

' " ' " ' & &

, 6 & '

'

' $"

""

, 00

!"

,4

00 ' $" ()# ' "

' "&

"

) ()# ' "

/ '

"

$"

"& $$"

" # " '(

" B "&$" (-+.(!

% ,"%

/%% #)2 5 5 3-*)

-)4 7 "&$" "

= 33333 7" :"' 3 &' - 34 8(

"-

9!,

!#+!:

)"

"* !+ )!.-#+"

!,!+

-)0"

;-)!"! !

# 6-" .

( +

.

< +-

!

!"

=-

:

>(

!,!+

-)"

> -+ # )6++:

!# "-!% - ( *) ,!"!

#2 ( > )2

#

< +-

"

>(

*) ,!"!

#"

*)! -+) (,

# .

#

6*+!

>!(

"- ):

)!.-#+ ("

#

!#

#

)6!:

>!(

-#6 #+ *)!# !*+

;-! !+ *)

-) % 34 8(

!"

<*) ""

.)

;-)!"! !

#

-)2

<6!#!

#

" (

*)! -+)

!#

=- :

"-

! !

# :

!

*) ,!

6:

.

+ ,# .- !"

#

!"!,

"-"!#

;-)!"! !

#

!,!+

-)% 6 3 3 " 3& &

"

"

& & ' " :"' &' )

'

' & ' " ' :" "

' & ' "

& &'

" '

>?$

"

" " 7"

"

8 * $" :" & 7" >4? 6 '

' '

"

&' "

"

& ' & '

;&

"

&"'

&' "

>,? 6

"

& ' " 3

3

& '

"

>9?C"

&

&

' "

"

"

3

"

)

"

&"

3& " :"'

>.? 3 " !"

" ' "

'

4

E &"

F & "

,>? & "

9 00

7& &"

" ' $&& 8

'"'$"

,0 00

"" 8

' >#&

" ?200, 01 00,

!

!

" #

#$

% &&!

'

()#

' '" 7 :"' '

!"! $ %& ' .

+ " ( & &

&

3 1

%% 6 /

G 6 # +