State Of Punjab And Another v. M/S Rajguru Transport (Regd)




    
        

" 
# $"

$ "%& '()



 
  


  
 

  
# $"

*!$ "%& '() 



  
!"
 
 #!$
%&
' 
  (
# $"

*%$ "%& '()




  ) 


 #
%&
 
  *
# $"

*+$ "%& '() 



  
% ! 
+$
&
!, &
-!!#
% ! 

  .
# $"

, $ "%& '() 
 
//!!

&


 

  
' #
"








  0

# $"

,"$ "%& '() 



  1+



&
 












 

2
# $"

, $ "%& '() 



   ,
%

  3
# $"" *$ "%& '() !
!


































  




     (   -#(  .
 /
.0 1
  .
   -#(  .


 ##
1 

 4

P.Chidambaram, Senior Advocate, with Ms. Anusha Nagrajan, DAG, Punjab, for the appellant in LPA-1066-2018.

Mr. Atul Nanda, Advocate General, Punjab, with Ms. Amanat Chahal, Assistant Advocate General, Punjab, in remaining LPAs.

Mr. Rajinder Sharma, Advocate, for the appellant in LPA-1104-2018.

Mr. Puneet Bali, Senior Advocate, with Mr. Vibhav Jain, Advocate, Mr. Uday Agnihotri, Advocate, for the respondent-Rajguru Transport Regd.

Mr. Ashwani Kumar Chopra, Senior Advocate, with Mr. Brahmjot Singh Nahar, Advocate, for the respondent in LPA-1248-2018.

Mr. Gurminder Singh, Senior Advocate, with Mr. Gurnoor S. Sandhu, Advocate, for the respondent in LPA-1247-2018.

Mr. Rohit Kapoor, Advocate, for the respondent in LPA-1249-2018.

 
 !
 #
!
!

# 



"!
#  #!

!

#

 #!



!

# #
!

"! 

5555

/
.0 1
  .


6




!

7# 



 
8


%

 
 !




 
 

(9.93
 
$



&
"!
+!#

+!
!!

!
$

 +
 +
 

 +
# 
!#
! 
$

  !!&
!

  
# /! #


#!!


-!"!!

: #

!

!

!"!
;!
!!

1 
.230

<<<

!$ "
 
 
"



&
  !


# #


= !


!"!


!


!
!

#


 
#! 
/!




#
+
> 


;


 
#




!
!


 


!


#

#
+!
!!


+!

!/!
!#
! 
$

  !!


#!

39(


  
!#
#&
<33
!


 


?
<33
#@
+
!
A +"&
"!




"
&
 
!!


"

!/!

+!+
+!
!$


!!



 /!
 $


!/


 +
# 
!#
 

 !
  !$


; &


,
$

 
" #
B &

&

 !!



 

!$

!




!!

  
 
#!

/
$
!


 


(
## !

$&
 
" #
B &



!

 #!

 /
-
/
!

&

 
//!!

&

&
 /!



 
"
!




!
!


!/

!#
 
 

!
/!
+
"!= 


#!

39(


<33
#&

  !!

! 
!#&


> !
 
!


$
! &


 
!

!/!
/&


!

!"!
;!
!!

1 
9<0

9
 

#

#
/
; &







/
!

# !

 
!

+!#


!#
+ 

! 


#!
$

  !!
 


!


 

!$


 

 /!
!
 
!

 ! #$
! 

*

% 
 ! 
#


!



 7 !!


 /!

!

#
 #

# 
!
 
$



&
$
"

#!

!

 !



/


 !
  !$
+!
!$

,



! 
!

# !


!
 !!#!

 
!

.

 &
!

"!+


/ 
/
$
 
" #
B &

&



 
 ! 
#




 7 !!


 

  

 
!


#


 

/
 /


!!


!

!"!
;!
!!

1 
9<0
9
 

#

#
/&



! 

!



 +!

/47

























 !
  !$

! 
!#&
!


> !
 
!


$
! &

+!+

"!!

= !




#!

39(


<33
#


 


 

 /!
!
 !


!

!#
 
!

 ! #$
! 
; &




 !$
+ 



/

 

!$

!


#!

/
$
!


 




0

A +"&
!


+,


#   



#
+

!
 


"!!!$

 +
!



# 
#!

&
+
"

 #
 
7/!&
7!

!/

 

$



&
+!#
!
## !

$
7!

C
!
/
#

!


 


 
 

! 
!
$

 
 


=
 $
!


/!


#
 
 &

  !!
+ 


!$

=/!




! 
!

# !

 
!
 




,

#!!


!

##  #
+!
+
+! 
!

!

 #




$

!/




!


: #&
+!#
!

$
#&



!




2




## !

$
! 

!


 "
/











C
A1'D
)A






ACDE
)F C D







 F1
%%C












)F-BD

0929
"!


;
,!

 G1
;
 
G1