Sukhwinder Pal Singh And ORS. v. Punjab School Education Board And ANR.




   


    

 !"

$$%%

"# &

##

'

()!!) "!!

 !"

$$

"#



 !
"

#$%&'

" #( )$

'&&
* &'+

'", #$%&'

 !
"

#$%&'

" &"#'"

%'+  '%

"*$ + ,-,.,

/0!)

"#, &"#'"

%'+  '%# 3, #"

"



1 

# 4!1" .

""

"

#"" !

 /

(9

"!%

"$ '

)!!) "!!

:

 1"

"!(

#" !

;/

  )) %"

    "  ' "     37,33,573=  %     > !,3?8=3!1573@/

<!1 , 5, 19/"< 9( !")

/!

0 

)

#/



$)<$!

!"

##""

/ 1 ""!#

 ##

!1 > "!1+ <#"!(

<<<!1"

%#

#  # 

0#   1 !<  "<  "!  "< <##(  "!  "

)!"

"#,

"!1

#!1#

91!

! !1A9

"!1 !1" ""!, ""! !37,33,573="

<#!1' "!1" "




 
 




 

  !%

"0 %!

"!!1" "

# #1!!#*$


 

   

!""#$%&

""

   
 '   

     



  

    

 

 

  

    

 

  

 





    A,

"!%



)) %"

" 37,33,573=

<!1 0

56,33,5738" 1!!

<#*$
   

 

    

 

      

   

              !   
 '  

  

"     

 

    

    

  !   
 '     

     

#$##%$#& '   

#$##%$#&  

 ( 

 )  *   

 

       

    

           + )

 *  

  



  

  

    

   



    ,

  

 *  

 



 

    

  

  



  

 

   

  - %

 C, .

)!#

 1!

#0 "9

(9

 !"##"

 #"% !)

#! <#

 !1" " #-. %-/  )

;,#%

)!#

1

0 % "#-. %-/  )

;1 0! !1"

#  !"  !9  <<<  !1  "  % 9  #)

<##(  "!  "

)!"

"#("" 

)"!#

#"!(  0  "%

" <<<!1"

!1"

)1 )"!

# "!)

0# 1 !<"< "!"< <

<##( "!

, 
"#

"#) )!) %"!1

#) #/"

#!'#"1) "! 0   "!

"#"

"!1 !1" ""!(90 " !1"

56,33,5738, @, 0 

)!#

"# "  "  0

#

(!!/

!1" )!#

0 " #"

#"!"<

", =, ## "

"!" <!1 D 91!

D !



# (9"

# (

)!#

" #-. %-/  )

; )"< (

 !%

#@8

@6!1" " )

!) 



*$
./

 







 



 

 0      1

       )

  )                 

 

 

    

     

 

      

"      

            

        

  

*        2  ( 



 





 0      1

3

4%   





!""#$%&

   

   

   ,    

     

  

5

6!





    

       

         

  *



      



    

       

             

 

       

           

     7    

 

       

           

2 

     

    



    

   



  

    

 

 

  )    

  

   

     8

 

 

5





            





3

4% 

 (   ) ()*+, *)- , *./0. * ))*( ***( ( 1)-1)*-2 1(*1 .).1 1 1)-"(* **-  32 1 1)*-* 1) .9

   (



   

    

       

 

      

   . *  *  ..1 1 1)-"

(**.   *)-"(* 4

 *1)*-* 1) 8, 

9  "  %

 ! "    

  "!  "  "

1!1<<<!1%

! #"%

!"

 "!"

B"

,

<!

/"

!



)"!### "

"!% 9< "!1 #"!" "

"%

"

#, > 1"

"!( )!#!

"" )"< !(9" "#-. %-/  )

;, 6,  1 )" ( ##"

"#)!"

 %

33!1"

"!1

"!

!( <

,
" ) )

!1"

)

#!

 !

###C?77$37/=67E3677:, ;E5C7:% )

9;

!1



$)<$!

!

 !

( ###C?77$ 37/=67E3A77:, ;,
" #1

!

#

9% 9 "!"

"#" <<<!1"

!1"

)!"

 #<)

)

 

 #,=877F$

#"" <<<% #)

!1 #,C?77F$ 

$)<$!



( 

 #,=577F$

#"" <<<%

!1 #,C?77F$,
"

%9 1

"#"!"

"!"

#!  "!"

1!

$!") 1 )" %!#"!,##)/" 

"!

)!

"#"

#

)"1 (9% ## "

56,33,5738 (9 <!19 " " 37,33,573=!

  9%  ! > !,3?8=3!1573@, ?, >

#!

""" 0 "

 (9"

 "



(9

(

 !"

""

5<!"#,
" !

#"!"

9 " D #"!!1

#!

# !91

<!

1#  

(9 9!1 ') "!" # # 

)"

"!(

,
#)  " "9

#< #!

1

   < " #% )"!1

9!"

"!1"

 0  "

#)) </

#< 9(

#"

)"

"!1 !1" ""!,
"

") <""

%!#"!!11 )"#"

"#

9  



#(9"

 <<<!1" #)

B"

"!"

)!"

"# #%

"! !(9"

% " #-. %-/  )

;,  </ ##)/!1"

"#"!(



5<!"# #!"

  1! ,   +!1) "!  !1  "  ' "     37,33,573=  0

<% 

56,33,5738(9"

"!" 1!

$ !")  B"

"#%

)"9

0 , 37,

#!#

)!

 (!0 /!"

"!" < ""

#

, %%

##<## ,

#( )$

'&&


&"#'"

%'+  '% &'+

'", #$%&'

#$+"

 )9 >

#%

 F

#! * #F!

>

%!

* #F!