← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2159/2016allowed

Preetpal v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2025-09-15Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma14 pages

    



    

 !"#$# $#$%&$'

() *+ ,+  "-$ (.

$!/#/()* 0 0 

  



  

 

  



  

 

* 1 2 0

                   ! 

"

 # $$$$    

%"3 %







&

''  

&  '  

&  & 

 

'' ()'  * +  )

()'    ,-,**,%.& & )

()'  %.,%*,%- 

'

  &  /

 

    0 1     



2

& 

   

  '     %3,4%434  5  ,4,4*,%0  

&'

 

  ' +

&'

 &  & 

 

6

  # 

 %*,4*,%0

  7  %*,4*,%0    &'

   

 

 8   ' +

         &  

     





 )"    "7!6

 #  

   "0! %4,4*,%0 -

  

:

)  '



      &'

 

  &  

    '  

 0,,4*,%0 .  

  )

)0,,4*,%0

&   2   & '  



&  2 ;) 

!"  ()'    %.,%*,%-



    '

)             & 



  ;)  " 

 )

)()'   %.,%*,%-

&   ;) 

!"  <



    /    )

()'   %.,%*,%-

&  2 ;) 

!"   )

)  = 



;)" 

&

  '' ()'   ,-,**,%.&  &  

'

  &  /    

 ) 





   

3 =   

             

&'





  '  ,4,4*,%0&&

    &  

          '    

 

9 



  ' 

       %*,4*,%0  +              0,,4*,%0 (

) 8 



 

   '



9

&    '& 



 

 -0*/1

 )

& >    2 4

  

)()'   

 ' 

  ''  ' &

  



/  

     

   



   !"

 

     ! "

#





  #$%!"

%,

  & %%    

     & 

 )  &

 )

'

 

'

 

 %* 6  

     

 $   %0 ?%/2  '&) ''     8   ' &  @A/* %*,4*,%0 

8   &



 





 )"    "7!

  6

   #     

      "0!

 

  

@A/%!      %4,4*,%0    &  

   

 



   )  "       "7!    6

  # 

   "0!



8  





  '   @A/ 0!0,,4*,%0

&  "7 @A/7! 

8    ' ' 

 



@A/-,7%,*,%0&  "0  "7

'

)8   



   '  &

    

     0,,4*,%0  @A/.!      

      '  @A/<! **%%*,%0 @A/3!    &@ 6 = 

8    '  @A/4!    

# ' 8 @A/%,!6 



/A'

 &'

   :

))

)  

 %7   A'

 ?/*





/A'



 '

& '  &

 ' 

   %-

'2: A'

 ?/*    %*,4*,%0 

8    '  &  "7  "0

  @A /3! %. '

  

9

       '   

)   ,4,4*,%0  '   %*,4*,%0 %<

0,,4*,%0 

)  

%*,4*,%00,,4*,%0 

) ' 

 

 %3 6&  -0*/1 (&  

  '/6





 +

'

   / &%&'(' ( )*    (



 +, (( -.

(/ * 0 (0 (/*/ 



,/  / (0  * ', * 0 )*    (

(1 

,/  / (  

 

/*/   '2 

0    /   (  (  +    

    + 

 + +    + ,

 (+*

*   0 / ((

3

  

 +

    )*     (

 

    (        3(  + 

' #4  *

( /*  + 



     ( / ( 

#'#6 '' ''7 '

'

6*+ +,  / ( +          /           3( +  +  

 0  



 *  +  3( + +' 6*+ +    )* 

 (

/*  *

( ,    8

  +(

 (                 

( 00

 +, ( (  * .

(/ ' $  4  .

(/   *        +    + +         )*'   (

 

1/  + 

 +   

$'# 6 '' ''7 ' 06 ,,   

  + ( + 3

+/%(   +  .

(/ *

+ + ( )*'  (

+ (

3

+$$( ++ 1  (+ +

  '4 , // * ( 



+

  )*    (

,  

( + ( )*  

   +  

*

'

! )*    (

0,

 + + 

+/*   (

           /   (0  



+ +,+,/ 3 ,

4  *   ('6*+ +

,+, 

+    + + +  '

6*+ + 

,+, 

+    + ++  '

%4 ++ 8 8 / (  )*    (

 / + 



  + 

+  + + 

 '#! 5 *

* 

07

+  

 3

+/* ( .

(/ * 





     (    3    (    

  / +/ ('

  4         / +  /*/ , // ,

  *

 '!6 5 *

* 

7

'

  4 

 

    (     )* 

 (

, )*   *  /   +    (          +(    



9+ 1/, +    

1/*

( ':

%4  &  '  '*, 8 

) 

'&)

) 

  

 ' 



)

)  '



) ' ''':8



) 

) 

 



 '  )

)       8 

) '

 '  '   

'  

' 

, *,

  



     '  ''     & '

  ' *%   @A/*





     '             :

)     '   )  '  

9'

&'

  8 ' -0*/1 

 

 ' 



)

8 &)   ** @A/7

0,,4*,%0

8 ,4,4*,%0   '  

 



)



  %*,4*,%0             8        ' 50,,4*,%0

   / B;

<6

6 ='><==?;3 * 

1 +,.

 + #>(  * / +     ''

'   *  +  (  +  * *

 ( ,       $>''#>$  '='    * +  (  ,(

 )   6  / ' ,  ,

+ +''#>$ + 

%'$#@ 7

8

/*/

3

 '  

%'$#@ ,

 (      3( + 

'

''#>$   



   ,/    /   (          +    <

''#>$'C *0

   

 

    0,,4*,%0  

 

 @A/- & 

  '  @A/.

,7%,*,%0



&6

 # 

 







     

  

  

    &     

  ' 

   )    0,,4*,%0 0,,4*,%0 *7     '

 

) 

  

  '   %*,4*,%0  

               

      '       0,,4*,%0 

 

  &                  

 

 

9    

       '    %*,4*,%0 

 ,7%,*,%0D@A/.



 

/ B6

  (   ='#$%< + +8 8#>$   + * '

#'

       6

  6  ='  ><==? ;3 *



1+ +$'>'#>$,+, *

( + 

+ ++

+'  +(+ + ,'

''  $>'>'#>$  *+      +   ='>$< 8#  + + $>'>'#>$'       

  * +  *+   '  ='

# %<  + +  #'>'#>$       +   ,  /  

/   +':

*- '

    

)      

      '     %*,4*,%0         &

  

  ' ,4,4*,%0     



)

 

 *. >

)0,,4*,%0











) 

  '  %*,4*,%0      

       '   

  %*,4*,%0 

 ,7%,*,%0



( '' 

 

&

 +0,,4*,%0

   ) 

 

&

  *< " '

)()' &  

  / *</  E& '2

  

  F%4<3 6 '2!.47G 



   / &%' ,

  /   

     

/ '    '

A * A / ,+,( 

    * 0+    * ,        (       /'

4/   



( 

)*   * +    '   )*  * (,0 +  + * <   0  (    ,           + / /0/*  * < 0

(  +  /    * + * < 8 

  +0,   + (    ('    B +/ / 0, 

 (  +  +   6*     

 #    

   /*

/  / 0 /

   * +    + + , 0,* 0 .

 '  

,/ + +++  + 6 + 0  /    /   8  ,0 +  0 ,+, *1 +  '@ 0  ( ,/0  /  +    // 

  +  

     + + B +/ ( 

 *  * + ,, + +

 * ,+,0    +   ,+, ':

*</1  E& '2

  ! "

#   F%4<3 6 '2!*0-7G  



   / &'   + '*'= / C

D '0 #

!$ 0    1+, * 

+; (



* / 'E    + ,  * ('@      +

 +         +  

 +   )*  -         (

'  2       

+ ,  +)*   *,



++ +/0 ,+,

 *

( 0 + ( /*   / '2  , +,   *  5F *'9 + $  %'4

     +

  /,  + (

  ( , 

/* /     0    

   *    +          '9+

+

(/

   *    +      1     

    /(5 (   /+

    +'  @                 

/ )*   *,1  

+  *

(+ ,+, , /

 + '4  0 

0 0+

 '      +          .

  , ,    8

!

!

,* ++ ,   ,   + +   8

!

!

 , '  * ,, * 1  (0 0+ + ,   8

!

!

,* + ' ( 

(  )*  *,+,

  /*

(       ,

  ,

 +       )*     +   (,/

  / + ,+,/   +

(, (  '

4  0   , +  +  .

,   8

!

!





* +'  (  + ,   )*  ( 

(

' * 0, * 0     +3      */   ('  4  */ (,  ( (   ( +

('4  (  ,+ 



++ + ,+, '40 0,  (+ + , *

+

 ( ++ 

+ + 1

 '  4     

  '  4  / +

 + + 

,G A# .



 +,  )*  *,/*    (

  +  ## * (/

( + /   (   ,+,  +  + ('4 .



+ + 

(+ 

  +  )*   * /'4

, +0  , * 0      5        / /*  )*   *0+      ,+,  /*  (0 + (   +

/ + 

 , 

       /           + ,  ,/

(/* '

 E            

   * +  ( )*   )*   *0( ,+,   +  +    +    0  *+ +    )*  *  +/

'A #'          / +

       + (  + / + 

    + , 

  /     + ,  , /

(/* '     + 

/* '4 

 +  +  

   ++ +

+ 

1/*

( 'E +

,  + /++* + ' 

 , //+   / +/* (  3    /*

( 'E

/,/'  + / ,  + 

 /   

-    

+'  0  , * 0  

+  +  +  /   /     /   

          1      (

*

5 0, +       +,+, 

-0    + 1   +(+*

 / ,  +'4 + ,1  /  (, +   

 'H    +   ++  

':

2 *3  E& '2

&()'          &  & 

       

 '

) ' E   ' 

 *4  E& '2

)*#+   

, * -  ' &    '& 



6    '  '  ,4,4*,%0

    %*,4*,%0 

0,,4*,%0    

)         

  %*,4*,%0

  '  

 0,  &  & E& '2 &()' 6 

 

'



()'  %.,%*,%-

   ) 



  0% >  &  )& 2 ;) 

!" 

  

 5( 6(%7 (

"89

 

  

& 

',%%,*,%0 



'  0*   '()'   ,-,**,%.



&



;)" 

&



 ()'   %.,%*,%-

&  2 ;) 

!" 

 00



)

 ()'   %.,%*,%- 

&  2 ;) 

!" 

 

'    & :)  :;:#- -<=  

   

    E   1/<  +GI <= E   

GI <=