High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4435/2013dismissed

Mohinder Singh v. Malvinder Singh & ORS

2016-04-25Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan12 pages

"#$ %$&'(')*

+ ,')%$-')., //$00")# 1$-(2( "03')%$-').,")%#,$-( $(/)%$)#( * 45 65

-$($)#* ($$#'2/#"7%3&"#$7 -#,$"//$00")# - ,"-8"7%3&"#$7 --$(/)%$)# 9,$#,$-#,$$/-#$-( 0&"0)$:(/"/$-8";<$"00:$%#($$ #,$=2%.8$)#>

<$-$ $--$%##,$$/-#$--)# 9,$#,$-#,$=2%.8$)#(,20%<$-$/-#$%')#,$%'.$(#> 65 7 8/2.)$%')#,$/-$($)#-$.20"-($&)%"//$"0'(#,$ -%$- %"#$% +

7 /"(($% <; #,$ 0$"-)$% %%'#')"0 '(#-'&#

2%.$7 ,")%'."-,7 "

'-8'). #,$ =2%.8$)# ")% %$&-$$ %"#$%

?7/"(($% <;#,$ 0$"-)$%'3'0 2%.$ 2)'- '3'(')7 ,")%'."-,7")%"0("##,$("8$#'8$7-$3$-(').#,$ ')%').() '((2$7 -"8$%)

@7")%%$&'%$%#,$("8$') "32- ="'<6"2-="'<6"2-,"% '0$%"($/"-"#$"//$"0'3'0//$"0

7:,$-$"(,')%$-').,")%,"(,'').0"

,"% "0( '0$% ") "//$"0 '3'0 //$"0 @

<$ -$ #,$ '-(# "//$00"#$ 2-# "."')(# #,$ =2%.8$)#")%%$&-$$%"#$%

?7/"(($%<;#,$0$"-)$%'3'0

2%.$ 2)'- '3'(')7,")%'."-, ,$<-'$ "&#( #,$&"($"-$#,"#,')%$-').,")% ,"(,'').0"/0"')#'

(,"% '0$%"&'3'0(2'#<$"-').

?? -(/$&'

'&/$- -8")&$ &)#-"&#<;:"; /(($((') ".-$$8$)##($00%"#$% )(,-#7#,$/0"')#'

(&0"'8 #,"# ?A7$&#- 7,")%'."-,7:"("00##$%)0$"($ ,0% <"('( <; ,")%'."-, %8')'(#-"#') # ( ".%'(, 6"2-7 %"2.,#$- ,-'=8$-').,7-$('%$)# 2($ ?7$&#-@ 7,")%'."-,7")%6"8"0='#').,,")%'')$B2"0(,"-$(73'%$ "00#8$)# 0$##$- ? 5

%"#$%

?A ,$ /(($((') #,$("'%('#$:"(%$0'3$-$%##,$8)?A?A 6"8"0='#').,,")%'%$ $)%")#$C$&2#$%"-$0')B2'(,8$)# %$$%%"#$% ?AA")%.#'#-$.'(#$-$%')#,$

'&$ 2< $.'(#-"-7,")%'."-,7)A ?AA73'%$:,'&,,$-$0')B2'(,$% ,'(,"0 (,"-$')#,$("'%('#$') "32- 8# ".%'(,6"2-#'(

2-#,$- "00$.$%#,"# ".%'(, 6"2-7 3'%$".-$$8$)# ("0$ %"#$%

7 ".-$$% # ($00 #,$ $)#'-$ ?A7 $&#- 7 ,")%'."-,7##,$/0"')#'

(,$("0$/-'&$:"( 'C$%"#(+0"&(

(

:$-$ /"'% "( $"-)$(# 8)$; ,$ 0"(# %"#$ - $C$&2#')")%-$.'(#-"#') #,$("0$%$$%:"( 'C$%)-<$ -$

@A??,$/(($((') #,$("'% :"(#<$%$0'3$-$%"# #,$#'8$ $C$&2#') #,$("0$%$$% #'("00$.$%#,"#6"8"0='# ').,,")%'%$ $)%")#7)&8').#D):"<2#$C$&2#') ".-$$8$)# # ($00 %"#$% 7 '0$% " &'3'0 (2'# "."')(#

".%'(,6"2-%$ $)%")# ")%#,$,")%'."-,%8')'(#-"#')

-%$&0"-"#')##,$$

$&##,"#,$:"(:)$-##,$$C#$)# ,"0

(,"-$ ') #,$ ("'% ('#$ $ "0( (2.,# /$-8")$)# ')=2)&#')7 -$(#-"')').,")%'."-,%8')'(#-"#') -8"&#').)#,$<"('(

-$0')B2'(,8$)#%$$%#:"(&0"'8$%<;#,$/0"')#'

(#,"##,$;,"3$ "0:";(<$$)-$"%;")%:'00').#/$- -8#,$'-/"-# #,$&)#-"&# ")% # /"; #,$ <"0")&$ &)('%$-"#') ( 7@

')&$

".%'(,6"2-%'%)#$C$&2#$#,$("0$%$$%7,$)&$7#,$/-$($)#(2'# :"( '0$%<;#,$/0"')#'

() ?? #&8$(2##,"# ".%'(,6"2-,"%%'$%) ??

,$-$ -$7,$-8#,$-="'< 6"2- "( :$00 "( "%,2 ')., '-"7 ,2(<")% ".%'(,6"2-7 -8:,8(,$:"(0'3').($/"-"#$0;7 :$-$<-2.,#)-$&-% $ $)%")#7="'<6"2-7')#,$:-'##$)(#"#$8$)# &0"'8$%#,"##,$".-$$8$)##($00%"#$% '( "D$")%(,"8 %&28$)# ".%'(,6"2-,"%0$#2##,$/-/$-#;# ")%08

$ -$ ,$- %$"#, ) ??

7 #,$ /-/$-#; :"( 3"&"#$% ")% /(($(('):"(,")%$%3$-#( -'#"86"2-,$/(($((')

/-$8'($(-$8"')$%:'#,,$-2)%$-0&D")%D$;#'00#,$%$"#,

".%'(,6"2-")% -8,$-7#,$ -&'<0$/(($(('):"(#"D$)<;#,$ /0"')#'

(')&))'3")&$:'#,#,$0&"0/0'&$,$ '0'). '3'02'# ?%"#$% ??

<;6"8"0='#').,,")%'"."')(# ".%'(, 6"2-")%#,$-(:"()#%$)'$%#:"((#"#$%')#,$("'%(2'##,"# #,$0$"-)$%2< 2%.$/"(($%#,$-%$-7%'-$&#'). ".%'(,6"2- %$&$"($%")% "0='#6"2-#8"')#"')(#"#2(B2-$."-%').#,$(2'# /-/$-#;#'00 2-#,$--%$-(#:"((#"#$%#,"#/0"')#'

&"8$') &)#"&#:'#, ".%'(,6"2-")%:")#$%#,$0/,$-')#,$0'#'."#') ")%(2..$(#$%#,"#".-$$8$)##($00%"#$% <$/-$/"-$% ")%2($%"."')(#6"8"0='#').,,")%',$/0"')#'

("0(.##,$ /:$- "##-)$; %"#$% ++?? ")% #,$ 0$"($ %$$% %"#$% ? ?? 00 #,$($ %&28$)#( "-$ (,"8 ")% :'#,2# &)('%$-"#') ".%'(,6"2-:"()#D$$/')..%,$"0#,")%) #,$"((2-")&$ /0"')#'

7(,$$C$&2#$% "D$%&28$)#(# &)#$(##,$&'3'0(2'# '0$%<;6"8"0='#').,,")%')-%$-#(,: ,'(<)"

'%$7/0"')#'

"0(."3$#,$%$&0"-"#')2)%$-#"D').)

??#,"#,$:'00)#8'(2($#,$("'%%&28$)#(-2($-#"D$ "); <$)$ '# #,$ ("'% %&28$)#( ') "); 8"))$- :,"#($3$-

0"')#'

"0("%8'##$%#,"##,$("'%/-/$-#;(,"00-$8"')2)%$-

/,;('&"0/(($((')")%:)$-(,'/ ".%'(,6"2-")%#,"#,$ (,"00)#,"3$");-'.,#7&0"'87')#$-$(#-#'#0$3$-#,$("'%/-/$-#; ,$("'%/0"')#'

2-#,$-%$&0"-$%#,"#,$,"()#/"'%");#,').# 8# ".%'(, 6"2- :$3$-7 #"D'). 2)%2$ "%3")#".$ #,$ ,$0/0$(()$(( ".%'(,6"2-7/0"')#'

0%.$%") %"#$%

")%#D -&'<0$/(($((') #,$("'% :'#,#,$ ,$0/ 0&"0/0'&$#'((#"#$%#,"#%$ $)%")#7<$').8#,$- ".%'(,6"2-7,"%(2&&$$%$%,$-)#,$<"('( #,$9'00%"#$% ??#'( 2-#,$-("#$%#,"#="'<6"2-"0(%'$%")%$C$&2#$% ":'00%"#$% ?? "%,2').,'-","%)&)&$-):'#,

".%'(,6"2- "%,2').,%$ $)%")# ')#,$:-'##$)(#"#$8$)# "0(#D#,$/0$"#,"#".-$$8$)##($00%"#$% :"()# $C$&2#$%<; ".%'(,6"2-,$("0$&)('%$-"#'):"("0(%$)'$% 6"8"0='#').,,")%'%$ $)%")##D#,$/0$"

#,"##,$(2'#,"(<$$) '0$%<;/0"')#'

#.-"< ?A7 $&#- 7,")%'."-,,$".-$$8$)##($00%"#$% '( "0( " "0($ %&28$)# ,$ /0"')#'

'( "0-$"%; "&'). &-'8')"0 /-&$$%').(<$ -$#,$,'$ 2%'&'"0".'(#-"#$7,")%'."-,7) "&&2)# ,"3').<$$)0%.$%"."')(#,'8) "&#7 ?A7 $&#- 7,")%'."-,7,"("0-$"%;<$$)".-$$%#<$(0%<; 6"8"0='#').,,")%'")% ".%'(,6"2-') "32- 2-')%$-6"2-7

+ ")%$$/').,")%"#/"0').,$#& 6"8"0='#').,,")%',"% "0-$"%;$C$&2#$%#,$".-$$8$)# # ($007 9'007 /:$- "##-)$;7 ')%$8)'#;<)%') "32- ("'%3$)%$$( ".%'(,6"2-,"%"0( $C$&2#$%#,$".-$$8$)##($00%"#$% A@?@?")%-$&$'3$%(

0"&(')"%3")&$"($"-)$(#8)$; -82-')%$-6"2-$#&")%') /"-#/$- -8")&$ #,$("0$7,")%$%3$-#,$/(($((') #,$ .-2)% 0- # #,$ /2-&,"($- "

#$- .$##'). '# 3"&"#$% -8 ")%08')";7??

8#2-')%$-6"2-$#&,"3$"0-$"%; '0$% "(2'# -(/$&'

'&/$- -8")&$"."')(##,$0$."0,$'-( ".%'(, 6"2- ,$,"%"0( '0$%"(2'# -/(($((')"."')(#,')%$- ')., /0"')#'

"( ,')%$- ')., ,"% $)#$-$% ')# 2)0": /(($((') #,$("'%/-$8'($("

#$-<-$"D').

#,$0&D( #,$ /-/$-#;')%'(/2#$)

-8 #,$ /0$"%').( 00:'). '((2$( :$-$ 8"%$ )

@???* E 9,$#,$- %$ $)%")# ".%'(, 6"2- $)#$-$% ')# ".-$$8$)#) #($00#,$$)#'-$ ?A7 $&#- 7 ,")%'."-,7 ') "32- #,$ /0"')#'

9,$#,$-#,$/0"')#'

("0:";(:'00').")%-$"%;")% (#'00:'00').")%-$"%;#/$- -8,'(:)/"-#

&)#-"&#>

9,$#,$-#,$/0"')#'

'($)#'#0$% -.-")# (/$&'

'& /$- -8")&$ #,$".-$$8$)#- -#,$"0#$-)"#$

A -$0'$ >

9,$#,$-#,$(2'#'()#8"')#"')"<0$')#,$$;$(

0":>

$0'$ F

-8 #,$ /0$"%').( 00:'). "%%'#')"0 '((2$( :$-$ 8"%$)?

* E 9,$#,$-"3"0'%".-$$8$)##($00:"($C$&2#$% <$#:$$) #,$ /"-#'$( ")% ".%'(, 6"2- )

'((2$'(/-3$%7:,$#,$-#,$/0"')#'

'( $)#'#0$%#-$0'$ (/$&'

'&/$- -8")&$"(/-";$%

9,$#,$- #,$ (2'# '( <"% - 8'(=')%$- - )) =')%$- )$&$(("-;/"-#'$(>

9,$#,$-#,$(2'#'()#8"')#"')"<0$')#,$/-$($)#

-8>

$0'$ F

-8 #,$ /0$"%').( 00:'). "%%'#')"0 '((2$( :$-$ 8"%$)

@* E 9,$#,$-8# ".%'(,6"2-$C$&2#$%"9'00%"#$% ?? ') "32- ,$- 8#,$-="'< 6"2- >

9,$#,$-8#="'<6"2-$C$&2#$%"9'00%"#$% ?? ') "32- ,$-%"2.,#$- -'#"86"2-> 9,$#,$- 8"--'".$ ".%'(, 6"2- ")% "%,2

@ ').,'-":"(%'((03$% <;&2(#87'

(7 '#( $

$&#> F ,$ 0$"-)$% '3'0 2%.$ 2)'- '3'(') ,")%'."-,7 %$&'%$%'((2$"."')(#="'<6"2-((2$(# -"8$% ) @???")%'((2$(")% -"8$%)?

7:$-$ %$&'%$%"."')(##,$/0"')#'

(((2$( -"8$%) @???")% ?

:$-$%$&'%$%') "32- #,$/0"')#'

(((2$ -"8$% )?

:"("0(%$&'%$%') "32- #,$/0"')#'

(<$').)# /-$(($%((2$) :"(%$&'%$%') "32- %$ $)%")#(((2$ :"(%$&'%$%"."')(##,$%$ $)%")#(<$').)#/-$(($%( (2&,7#,$(2'#:"(%'(8'(($%<;#,$0$"-)$%'3'0 2%.$ 2)'- '3'(')7,")%'."-,73'%$=2%.8$)#")%%$&-$$%"#$%

? ."')(##,$("'%=2%.8$)#")%%$&-$$7="'<6"2-"(:$00 "(,')%$-').,$#& '0$%#:($/"-"#$"//$"0(<$ -$#,$ '-(# "//$00"#$2-# ,$"//$"0 '0$%<;="'<6"2-:"("00:$%:'#, &(#(7 :,$-$"( #,$ "//$"0 '0$% <; ,')%$- ')., $#& :"( %'(8'(($%:'#,&(#(7 3'%$=2%.8$)#")%%$&-$$%"#$%+

7 /"(($% <; #,$ 0$"-)$% %%'#')"0 '(#-'&# 2%.$7 ,")%'."-, ."')(##,$("'%=2%.8$)#")%%$&-$$ #,$ '-(#"//$00"#$2-#7 ,')%$- ')., ,"( '0$% #,$ /-$($)# -$.20"- ($&)% "//$"0 :$3$-7)-$.20"-($&)%"//$"0,"(<$$) '0$%"."')(##,$("'% =2%.8$)#")%%$&-$$ #,$ '-(#"//$00"#$2-#') "32- ="'<

? 6"2- ,"3$#,$0$"-)$%&2)($0 -#,$/"-#'$(")%,"3$"0( &"-$ 200;.)$#,-2.,#,$ '0$"(:$00"(#,$0:$-2-# '0$

-'#"86"2-,"%%$)'$%#,$$C$&2#') ("0$%$$%")% -"#,$-&0"'8$%#,"#'#'("(,"8#-")("&#') $"3;-$0'")&$,"( <$$)/0"&$%)2)%$-#"D').%$&0"-"#')%"#$% ??C 7 $C$&2#$% <; /0"')#'

,$-$ "-$ #: :'#)$(($( #,$ ".-$$8$)##($00%"#$% '$,"85"0")% "0#" ,"85"0")% "0#" :$-$ )# $C"8')$% # /-3$ #,$("'% %&28$)# ,$ /$-2("0 #,$ -'.')"0 '0$ (,:( #,"# #,$ ("'% ".-$$8$)##($00%"#$% '( %2<'2()"#2-$,$-'.')"0 ".-$$8$)# # ($00 '( (#"#$% # ,"3$ <$$) 0(# ,$ (2'# %"#$%

?? :"( '0$%)0;"

#$-#,$%$"#, ".%'(,6"2-) ??

)0;/,#(#"#&/; #,$".-$$8$)##($00%"#$% :"( $C,'<'#$%7:,'&,<$"-(8");&2##').( )#,$ '-(#/".$7#,$-$'( &2##').3$-#,$:-'#').-$."-%').:)$-(,'/ 6"8"0='#').,,")%'

")% "

#$- (&-'). '#

7 '# '( 8$)#')$% #,"# 6"8"0='# ')., -$0')B2'(,$% ,'( -'.,#7 3'%$ -$.'(#$-$% -$0')B2'(,8$)# %$$% %"#$%

@?AA,$)7#,$-$'(3$-:-'#').3$-#,$-$&$'/# #,$$"-)$(# 8)$;7:,'&,,"(<$$)8"%$ -8(7

') :-%(")% '.2-$("0(2&,&2##').'("#($3$-"0/0"&$("#/".$

#,$".-$$8$)##($00%"#$% :$3$-7)#,$ 0"(#/".$ #,$("'%".-$$8$)##($00%"#$% 7#,$$"-)$(# 8)$;'(8$)#')$%"((0"&,$-$"-$('.)"#2-$( ".%'(, 6"2-)#,$<"&D #,$ '-(#/".$-$."-%').-$&$'/# #,$$"-)$(# 8)$; 8"); &2##').( 8"D$ #,$ ".-$$8$)# # ($00 %"#$%

%2<# 20)$ #,$:'#)$(($(##,$".-$$8$)##($00 %"#$% :$-$$C"8')$%,')%$-').,"0( "'0$%##$00 :,$)#,$%&28$)#:"($C$&2#$%,$)7(#-").$0;$)2.,7/0"')#'

&0"'8(#,"#)? ??78# ".%'(,6"2-$C$&2#$%"0$"($ %$$%'),'( "32--$."-%').,"0 (,"-$ #,$("'% ?A7 $&#- 7,")%'."-,7)8)#,0;0$"($ (

,$ -$&$'/#C '("0(/-%2&$%<;/0"')#'

7(,:').#,"#

".%'(,6"2-'((2$%"-$&$'/# (

,$0$"($:"( -#,$ .-2)% 0-/-#') #,$("'% ,$/,#(#"#&/; #,$("'% 0$"($%$$%:"(/-%2&$%")%#,$-'.')"0'((#"#$%#,"3$<$$) 0(# ,$/0"')#'

"0(/-%2&$%#,$&/; C %"#$%

A?? #(,:#,"##,$-'.')"0%&28$)#(,"3$<$$)0(# #'(#<$)#$%#,"##,$-$'()8$)#') ".-$$8$)# ("0$')#,$ 0$"($%$$%C 7"00$.$%0;$C$&2#$%)? ??,$ "&##,"# #,$($%&28$)#(<$').'8/-#")#%&28$)#(7:$-$)#/-%2&$%') -'.')"0")%"-$"00$.$%#,"3$<$$)0(#')(2(/'&'2(8"))$-7 -"'($(%2<#("<2##,$.$)2')$)$((

,$)7 #,$ /$-2("0 -$0')B2'(,8$)#%$&0"-"#') %"#$%

??(,:(#,"#,')%$-').,/0"')#'

$C$&2#$%#,$ ("'%2)%$-#"D').")%%$&0"-"#')##,$$

$&##,"##,$".-$$8$)## ($00%"#$% ")%#,$0$"($%$$%%"#$%? ??-$."-%').

,/&28 0"# ?A7 $&#- 7 ,")%'."-,7 "-$ )0; /"/$- #-")("&#'):'#,,'8")%(,"(,'').0"$2)%$-#D#,"#,$ (,"00)#8'(2($#,$("'%%&28$)#(-2($-#"D$#,$<$)$ '# -8 #,$("'%%&28$)#($ 2-#,$-(#"#$%#,"#,$%$()#.$#");-'.,# -#'#0$3$-#,$("'%/-/$-#;")%#,"#,$,"()#/"'%");#,').#

".%'(, 6"2- ,$ /0"')#'

%$&0')$% # .'3$ ,'( (/$&'8$) ,")%:-'#').('.)"#2-$(')#,$&-'8')"0&"($#'#0$%"(

7 -#,$/2-/($ &8/"-'() ,')%$-')., /0"')#'

)$3$- "//$"-$% <$ -$ #,$ 2< $.'(#-"-7 ,")%'."-,7 -$C$&2#') #,$("0$%$$%-')&"($7#,$-$:"( (#"#2(B2-%$-7 -$C#$)(') #'8$ ,-' 6 "C$)"7 $/2#; 3$-)8$)# C"8')$-

G2$(#')$% &28$)#(7 ,'80" 9 /')$% #,"# #,$ %'(/2#$% ('.)"#2-$()#,$2)%$-#"D').%$&0"-"#')%"#$% ??"-$

,')%$-')., ,$0$"-)$%&2)($0 -#,$"//$00")#,"(-$0'$%2/)#,$ (2<($B2$)#/:$- "##-)$;C 9 7:,'&,="'<6"2-,"% $C$&2#$% ') "32- -'#"8 6"2-7 :,$-$') -$ $-$)&$ ,"( <$$)

8"%$#,)2-'). #,$("'%".-$$8$)#(:'#,#,$/0"')#'

)&$ #,$".-$$8$)#'#($0 '()#/-3$%7#,$("'%-$&'#"#')'( ),$0/# #,$/0"')#'

)#,'(&"($7#,$ ')%').( "&#(,"3$<$$)-$&-%$%<;

#:2-#(<$0: -8#,$/$-2("0 #,$$)#'-$0:$-2-# '0$"( :$00"(#,$ ')%').( <#,#,$2-#(<$0:7"8 #,$3'$:#,"#) B2$(#') 0":82&,0$((#,$(2<(#")#'"0B2$(#') 0":"-'($( ,$ ')%').( "&#(,"3$<$$)-$&-%$%<;<#,#,$2-#(<$0: #$-.').#,-2.,#,$ '0$7"8 #,$3'$:#,"##,$-$'()'00$."0'#;

-/$-3$-('#;')#,$("8$#<$').(7%)# ')%");.-2)%# ')#$- $-$')#,$ ')%').( "&#(-$&-%$%<;<#,#,$2-#(<$0:7 ')&02%').#,$ ')%').-$&-%$%-$."-%').9'00') "32- ="'<6"2- <;#,$ '-(#"//$00"#$2-#((2&,7#,$-$'())$$%#$0"<-"#$0; %'(&2(( #,$ $3'%$)&$ #,$ /"-#'$( )($B2$)#0;7 #,$ /-$($)# -$.20"-($&)%"//$"0 "'0(")%#,$("8$'(%'(8'(($%:$3$-7'# '(8"%$&0$"-#,"##,$5( %$&$"($% ".%'(,6"2-:$-$<-2.,# )-$&-%)0;#-$/-$($)#,$-')#,'(&"($")%#,'(=2%.8$)#(,"00 )#<$#"D$)#<$" ')"03$-%'&#"(#:,'(#'),$-'##,$/-/$-#; ".%'(,6"2- 65

+ (=D(