Baljinder Kaur & ORS v. Major Singh & ANR
! "
# $
%
$
&''
!""## $%& ' () ***"+,- *
(
)#* '"
+
"
* .% '%*/*'*'&0 #1+2 %3 * '%*.% 3 #1+2 1 %%"+* * +
"
,"
*, % #-
43"% #3 5#+56 7++
3&%%+8%%++56533/&%5#92+ 0&+8:+ +;*;* "
+563/&%/2#&+8,&%
2- 93%563&#+56%"+* 9 +%+%"569 6""%%:
8%: ##+ +*
* 93%8 +: &%8;< # %# &##6+ #+33 +3"# +0&+8: + +**
"
+563/&% %&+81.
93%56 3 ##+56++ 30&+8:"
+
56 3 # %+ % # /&% 3 5 +:+ =" % <3 * 777, ;-* * 43 5% 3 "# 7%"+ * % 3 ++ =&+ 8%:##+ +*
* 93%8 +: &%8;< #:
%# & ## : &%8>< #?:
%# < #;:
%# "%3%3 %
39 7 &* ;7 * 77>,; -1 39 7
&*;
7@>@1 * 77 ,; -1,; -1 77>7,?- < # ? :
%# 1 39 7 * >@7
@@1 *
7 ,@ ;-1 ,@ - 39 7 * 7 >@ 1<3 * 777, ;-& +93%2& 2## 8'
<"&% 43# % 2 #& 5# +% 1 ;1 7 + 3 "%"+2+%%2+ 1 1 7 %:6 8%+ 8%8%+3 #++ >** >*)92%13+ =+ ** >** >1%"+* %+3&58% % 1 #8935 #+% 5&++ * ++&%&"%=& +%8% 3 # ++*43% % #8 #9 %2+3:93336 %"#693%5636%&+=&3 #++38%&+3 %:69 "
+3:*A ##63"# #+&% "569 6""%%:
8%:##+ +
* *
43&9 +563++ * + #+ 9% :93%5636 +:+3=& 8%: ##+ +*
* *)92%1++ ++3
%8 %+8%" 1 1 7 %:6%:3"#
+"# ++3 3 8%:##9 =&+93 &% 3"
%3"# 3 3 %:69&#+5"
+3 2%6=+ 6**>*
* 15&23 + 61"# #+ < 6"
6:++ *433% 2%: 3"# 9%++589%8* + *# +:%8 8 < #+ "
% 9% : 8 3 # : 3 "%* 35 %2 #"# +83"
%1##98&9% % :+563# %+% #/&% * B33% 3 "# #+ % " 56 9 6 " "%%:
8%:##+ +*
* C ..
* B33%3"# 9 % +6 +9##8 +##% +6 +9## "%%:3"
% 8%:##C ..
* B33%3"# #+%"%:
0& "% 6+%C ..
2* B33%3&3"# :
5#C .
2* #* >* %+%"%23 1"# %+395= .B + "%2+ =& 8%: ## + + *
* ,=&%. - +"6#8 # =*.+ + ** > %"#6 + =*.>+ +;** > + + =*.3 &# +%6 % *) #= :+.B &%+%83
893 D.B &%+% &:
% :" $+%1 93 #+ 3 :" "
"% 933 9% &+ %
=& D.B(** 1+2 38 %3 35193+"+3 3+ +33
3%&++ .B>3:
#
:"#6 <.
"%+&+3 &::+ %%+ "% 933 :& 1>1 79 #68 +"+35 < &++ * *
* 3"%2+3%#2 +&: =*.B>7E* * 33%3 +1++ + %+395=
B B*(%3' #1'
8% +'%8 8 < +"+3 ++ * <# *># %:3% < # +5 %8<3 * 77>7:*, -
77 :, - +3"%2+"6:%8 8++ =*
+"6 : & =* * @* % 3 %8 3 &# % 3 "
%1 3 # %+ % # /&% +++ ##3& 2&%3"# ++%+3&% "569 6""%%:
8%:##+ +
* *43++ 9%+%+=&
+8%8%+3 #++ 2&%3"# %28 35 #+% 1 ;1 793=:3* ;* 8 88%2+1++ "%%%+ # 3 0&+8: ++%+ +;*;* "
+563# %+% #/&%* ?* 43/&%# %+ %&+8.
%3 %8533 "
% +883%&833%%+3 %:+3+8 %%++563# %+% #/&%="%8 %+8<3 * 777
, ;-* /F= # 9 "
%#6 "+ F& <3 * 777, ;- +&3 =9 +:+2+0&+8: + +**
43 7++ 58## +3 2#+ 3"% #*
3 23 %+3&#%3"
%*
* 43&#%3 93#%%83 %8&:&5: 3 33 ##883:"&8+0&+8:#693%8 %+"
% 3&# +5 %8<3 * 77>,; -1 3 :9 9+ 56 3 + % 3% 9 =#&2#6 9+ "+56'
83 83 2+%:
+ =*.*43&#%3 &%3%+3
+:+#6 % +'
83 +5%3% * *43&#%3 3 &%3%
%8&+3 %:3"%& # 1&#+5 #6:
+&3 3 ++&:5 %88 &%73&:5 :"%'
83* 3%383%%+ "%23 '
832%%+ 8%:##3# 5 %8<3 * 77>,; -3%"+*43&#%3
&%3%&5:3 3&3:"&8+0&+8:"
+56 3/&%5#9 %# 5#5 +93%8 +5 %8 <3 * 77>,; - +&%3%:
+"% 6%3 3=13
##+563 5 ##9+*
33%3 +13&#%3%"+93#&""%8 3:"&8+0&+8:&5:3 533/&%5#9 %%++&%%+8%8 %+8=& 8%:##
+%83#63#+3 3=&3 + 8%: + &##6"%2+ +F?% #/&%+%+3&3 %"+ +3 /&% #% %:+3 ++8
%:
<8"%"% ""% 32+ # 5#3 %%+193%8 %+%&# +="<3 * 777, ;-*
3 2+%+3&5::
+56&#%3"
%*
>* "+7"# #+ & % " 56 9 6 " "%%:
8%: ## + + *
* * 43 =&33 + 8%: 9 "%2+56 8 9 :#6.B &%+%83* 2.B(** 1 +2 +3 3 + 8%: 9 + +563: 3%&++ * "+7"# # "%2+3=& 8%: 19335 %38 &%
+3 #= :+.B 1&%+% &:
%1 :"2+%%:
93:3%+ :""
"%9%"&%3 +%=&3
% + 8%:* 2 B B93# %83 95= +:+3=& *
* %883%&833 + =*.12+3 '
83 9 %%++ =#&2 9% " <3 * 77>,; -1933 #"
%3&"%"%6* A%:3 "%& # 12+3 3&833 : '
83 %835+6 8%: 15&3
:5 %88 &%73&:5:"%'
83* 3 3"
%3 7++
=&+ 8%: 53 # '
83 58 3
%6*3%9 %3 7++
% 8%:### +5 %8<3 * 77>,; -9339 =#&2#69+ +"+56'
83*43& 3 :"&8+ 0&+8: "
+ 56 3 /&% 5#9 % & 5#93%8 +5 %8<3 * 77>,; -*43& 3=&3 56 2&% %"+ * 93 %8 %+ & # + =" % <3 * 777, ;- +<3 * 77>,; - +&##6"%2+ + 33+8533/&%5#9 % %:+*
@* 3 #83 3 52+&1 3 "% # "
%#6
##9+F& <3 * 77>,; - +30&+8:+ +;*;* "
+563/&%/2#&+8,&% 2- +3 0&+8: + +**
"
+ 56 3 /&% % &+81 .
% +F& # +5 %8 39 7 &*
7 >
* 77>,; - "% :5 + % 3 6 % %2& 2## 8'
<"&%43# %.
;* 43 # ++"+3 % +%:* +
"
&'' " $
- .
./ Whether reasoned / speaking?
Yes / No Whether reportable?
Yes / No