High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2197/2016dismissed

Satish Kumar Malik v. Videocon Industries Ltd

2017-02-15Mrs. Justice Anita Chaudhry9 pages

!"# #$%&%'(#)*+!*, -.

!"%&/0+1!*!2%3

4#*&+& 4%5#$''5+&"*%#&6"5

(7 6

. 8- - 88

!

" #

$ $ %$ &

'

( &

)!&"

*$*

+!

*# '

$ ,-./010%2 #

4 05 # # "

&

6 '

*!

" !

!

"

&&

'

!

!

& !

"

$ 2

. 7

'

#

'

&

" !

!*$

# *$

# " "$"

!" ,-./010%2 !

&'

$"

8!

! *$ " #

! '

* " &

&

" $

! *!

!

"" " "*$ "3

#

! "

"

"

#

!

"

#

"# & '

!*

$

!

3

"

$"

# "

" $

" !

!

"!

"

"

#

"3

*&!

" 2 7

! !!

"!

* " *

"

" #

" $ !

& %2,2- $

# $#

"

9 "!

.::2 #

& #

*!

3

& !" .:,.::2 "4 .::2

:.- "*!

$

; &

"!

)!

3

"$"

$ & -:::2"

" ;-::::2 $

"!

3 "

&

" ,-.,:2 3

#

"*!

# *! 3

!

"

&

/ ;

# * !

%1 , # * !

1. 0 # * ! /. "

*& '

(

!

.-0

.:::

& ,:

&

!" %:;%,:2# !

&

" $ .:::<"$

" $.:::

! 0:,2# * !*$

" $

!" 1.::2

! 0.-,2#

* ! !" 1,::2

&

! ::-2# * ! !" /-,2

! ,2# * ! !"

:1;,2

! /--,2# *

! !" 01::2

!

% 0;,2# * ! !" 1%0,2

&

! /;--2# * ! !" 0,;-2 !

;-: !

"

" $

/::2

"!

" ;;:;::2

1;;1,:2

"!

&&

"3 * !

*$

&$ ..*

8!

#

"* "

*$

" $ !"$

"

!

#

$"!

" $

" #

=

&

+! "

# &

! >

2 7

!9 3 ?

!$

!

" !

!*$

" " *$

! &

$" #!*#

##

!

#

@= . >

2 7

!93 ?"

!$ &!

& " !

!*$

" " #

@= ; 3

! A.

" #

$ ,-./010%

!

&

#

,

.5 !"

6

&! "

@ = % >

"

! #

@= , >

*$

#

!

*$

&

@= - >

* *$

" @= 1 B

#& ! $ &

!

*$

3 !

!*$

* #

!

B (B7

//3

!

$

!

!*"

'

+!

!"*

8! # & *$

#

#

!'

"& &

*

::%/// :,:-.::; 79/ '

$ ,-./010% &#

05 !"

6 #

&&*$

)!&" # *$

#

# "

'

+! "

# &* %A,#

!

- %<

"!

,-./-10% #

"!

# * *$

" $ 3 "

!

"

&&

! &

& "

" #

!

* !

*$

*

!

"!

# * #

# "

'

!

79>.2 79>.2/

" &

79?#

";:%/// .%:0.::

!" ,-./-10% * *

# 7

'

$ " & !

8! 79 79C &#

8! ( ! "" 792 79C2

!

*

!"*

8!

!*$

#! 7

9" ><

D!"

"

&#

7

!9

$ /// .::3 * "

:.- & # !

*$ " "/// .::'

$ *$

*

#

$ !" ,-./-10% &

** $ !

$ !

* &

$ & *$

)!& ,+" &

"

><

D!"

9"

& $&

* *! !

E

& $ "

1 /// .::

"& &

8!* !

"

E # *! &

"

:0:;.::%'

!

* $ "

*

""! *$

*

$ ! & $ #

:$ '

! &

*

+! '

& &

7

F B *!

""*

"

"

"'

&!

$ $& $

E

*

$

*$

+ !"+! F

!"

* * &

" 79 79 * . #

* 79 * ; #

&

.::2 :.- .:,.:: :.-9 .::2 *

# <"$ * *&

"79 * % #

9

"

-:::2 "

- "

"!

& ;-::::2< 79 * ,#

# & "

,-.,:2'

"

* &

$ #

&!

9

* $ #

!*

G '

+! !

& *$

+! "

0 '

"

# &! &

*

+ B

3

"

*

" +!

# #

!"* )! "

= :0..:-

*$

"

* !$ "

&"# *

& E#

& !&

"

!

* *

+ B

!&

$#

*$

" * "

'

*

*

3

& &

!

'

# * !

"

#

B (B 7

//

&# '

*!

! * !*

$

"'

$ '

!

9

* *! '

!

# &

"!

!'

/

!"* 9 #

& H "$

-:::2"

! &

# $ E #

" &)!

"

"!

'

9

! '

!&

# "

*$

( #

#

" & !"* *!

"# " !

#

!

"

!

" *$ "= $ !*"

*

#

$ !

"'

"

*!

! *

$ * 3 " $

& *$

+! *#'

& *

+!

"

"

" *!$,.:1

! >

&2 I 2J >

* I 2J