High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4475/2013dismissed

Sumer Singh Saini v. Municipal Committee & ORS

2015-05-26Mr. Justice Rajesh Bindal3 pages

!"#$% &'()) $#

*+,-

$. ( &/0/'1 2

,1 3 4, 4 % 0 '.1 ,%$5 06 6/7$'8(9&$. %.6 $)) ##$'. $: 06 /'($# 6 )#$/'./

6$0 /# ( .6 )% 0 '. $)) $# /7)"!'/'! .6 :"(!7 '.0$'(( &% 0 ;.6.6 &"%.0; #<8<6 % ;=.6 % #/

) %7$' './':"'&./'<$0( &#/' (.6/7 /# (.6 0"/. %) %7$' '.

$'(7$'($.%=/':"'&./'% 0.%$/'/'!% 0)'( '.0$'( %7)$%5/'!

.6 /%9 6/&# 0/'.6 )$00$! >!$#/% 0.%/&./'!/'!% 00$'(".!% 00..6 6"0 .6 $)) ##$'.$'(.6 %/'6$;/.$'.0 .6 #&$#/.=,$'($.%= /':"'&./'<$00"!6..% 79 & 7 '. (#/'. #'.6 (%$/'$006<'/' .6 0/. )#$'6 .%/$#&"%.(/07/00 (.6 0"/.< 9 %8.6 # $%' (#< % $)) ##$. &"%.8<6/# !%$'./'!.6 % #/ 7$'($.%=/':"'&./'(/% &./'!

% )#$& 7 '. & 7 '. (#/'. #</.6$3?$$#/3. '0"% % #< (/%.= <$. %/'.6 (%$/'8(/07/00 (.6 &#$/7% !$%(/'!) %7$' './':"'&./' @6/# /7)"!'/'!.6 :"(!7 '.0$'(( &% 0 ; #<( &#/'/'!.6 % #/ ) %7$' './':"'&./'8# $%' (&"'0 # %.6 $)) ##$'.0";7/.. (.6$..6 </(.6 .6 0.% ./' %'. .6 6"0 .6 $)) ##$'./07 % #= ../0$( $(0.% .</.6') '/'!'.6 .6 % 0/( 6 .6 %% 0/( '.0 .6 0.% .$% )$%5/'!.6 /%9 6/&# 0/'.6 0.% . # $9/'!'0)$& %/'!% 00$'(".!% 00..6 6"0 .6 $)) ##$'.6

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

B" 0./'$0< ##$0 %7.6 %$('.6 .6 %0/( 8.6 )#.; /'!&%' %

'($'.0>% 0)'( '.0$'($'(.6 %% 0/( '.0 .6 ( $(0.% .

7"0.; )$%5/'!.6 /%9 6/&# 0/'.6 0.% .8.<6/&6.6 $)) ##$'.8<6/0 .6 /%' /!6;"%8/0;: &./'!. '.'#=;: &. (..6 )$%5/'! .6 /% 9 6/&# 0;". 9 ';: &. (..6 & 7 '. (#/'. #'C</( (%$/'<6/&68 $&&%(/'!.6/78% 0.%/&. ( % #< (/%.=<$. % 6 # $%' (&"%.

; #<!%$'. (.6$.% #/ $'((/% &. (% 0)'( '.0$'( .% )#$& .6 & 7 '. (#/'. #</.6$3?$$#/386< 9 %8.6 % #/ ) %7$' './':"'&./'

<$0%/!6.#=( &#/' (8$0/.<$0 "'(.6$. 9 '/ .6 &$%0 .6 %% 0/( '.0 .6 0.% .$% )$%5 (/'.6 0.% .8.6 $)) ##$'.6$0$&& 00.6/06"0

%7.6 %0.% .$'($00"&6'/'&'9 '/ '& /0&$"0 (.6/7 6$0'. )%("& ($'= 9/( '& .06<.6$..6 % 6$( 9 %; '$'=)%;# 7/'&$0 6 <$'. (."0 6/0!$. /'.6 0.% . %.$5/'!".$'=9 6/&# 8$0/0 0"!6..; &#$/7 (6 &"%.; #<6$0;0 %9 (.6$. 9 '$ . %)$%5/'!

&$%80)$& /00./### .'$0/( .6%"!6<6/&679 7 './0)00/;# . 6$0 "%.6 %; ''./& (;=.6 .%/$#&"%..6$.'.6 %% 0/( '. .6 #&$#/.=6$0&7 %<$%(.0"))%..6 &$0 .6 $)) ##$'.D)#$/'./

0)/. $9$/#/'!))%."'/./ 0.# $( 9/( '& 86/00#/.$%=0.$. 7 '. <$0'% &%(6 $)) ##$'./00.$. (.; $0 '/%&/./? '8<6% ./% (

%70 %9/& 6 (/0)". </.6' /!6;"%0'.%/9/$#/00" /0'.$6 $#.6= 0/!'$0.6 ' /!6;"%0$% A) &. (.#/9 $0$ $7/#=0.6$..6 =&$';

6 #) "#. $&6.6 %/'&$0 ' (

' 9/ < .6 $ % 0$/( $&."$# 7$.%/A ' % &%(8 /' 7= )/'/'8.6 % /0' %%%/'.6 :"(!7 '.0$'(( &% 0 ; #<0";0.$'./$#B" 0./' #$<$%/0 0/'.6 )% 0 '.$)) $#6 0$7 /08$&&%(/'!#=8(/07/00 ('0 B" '.#=8.6 $&&7)$'=/'!$))#/&$./'0 $% $#0(/07/00 ( *$: 06 /'($#- "(!