High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/44524/2024allowed

Amit v. State Of Haryana

2024-11-28Ms. Justice Kirti Singh10 pages

CRM-M-44524-2024 (O&M) 1

"#$#%&'())( *#

,- %

& ./+( +0 +

" # $ %& '''''

0 +1( , 2 ( #

! )

*+," -, .

/ ! 0

! 0 .

12 ,,3

44-,

5 3 !

43+6

)

/ %& (

! 12 .

! " #$$$ "% &'()**+, "% -'()**,, & .%& $/01#//, && ! '" () ,2/ &" & ( & "&&.

"" && & " %& &" 3 1& ""

4 (!!5&&.

" ""

" "& #*/*,/%&

"& &."

" &".%. &.

")&% &. & % &." & &

" %. &.&"$*(6 "% & &" &.

&' **+, & & & & "& 6 6& "&) & & & " & "& ".

% &

& & & & & "&

CRM-M-44524-2024 (O&M) 2 &" % &) & & " && 7 " & & )4& &" " "" & ) #*/*,/ " " & & % &&) " & &

" "%."&""

" " " %& &"

8 &" &" & ) ## 3 1& ) " .&",2(6 " & #29# ( : & .

" %& &"

8 &" &" &)## 3 1& ".& .& " & &.

4 (!!5 " " ""&"&. .& ). & .&.&& ) #*/*,/"&% "&& ; & %

" &.% ) .& " ,2 (6 % "." "%& """" &" ) & "." " %& " &

" %& &"

8 .& .&& &" "&)## 31& ".. #2 "") " & ) #*/*,/%&

"& & ;& ".

" )

& .&",2(6 "." "%&% """" & " ") &.

% ) +9<<2<<#*< ;&6 .. & & 1&& " % .%& +2<*999#29 &%.".&=." " ) " "% &' **+, & && "& && "&"

& & .%& *2 ) *#)#*)*2*> & ) & " ; & 6 . . & & 1&& && ") &&%."" "& "&&.% ;& 6 .. & & 1&& ) 6.& "&

"." ." %' " . .

% """"" &%"&)% "& &&& & " & &) """ " ) ; & &%

"&. "& "." " %& & " .% "&%. &."" " % ""

CRM-M-44524-2024 (O&M) 3 " & .

" " " " (6 ) .& "&% .&& 0; & & ) #* /*,/ " "&"." ." "&&)6.& "& "." "%&&"

8 .&& &" "&)## 31& " & &.& "." " %& #> % ") (!!5 & . "

% " " . % ? ( ) 4 >2*#) "& & "& " & &"%&.

&. " & &

& % ) +9<<2<<#*< % ) +$2$2#>*** & - - 6&.

& & " &&% "&.

4" % "&%.& .& (6

".%& & &" . & & & & . #> &%% " % & & & & " & & " & &% & " &" % . " 8@," " " & &

8@# &&! "#$$$% & " & """" " &.

&& : && % .""%&" """ "" ;& "A"" 1 & " % " " " & " && " " "

;& " ) "." " %& % " .& " ** (6 % " """" #> &%% "4 (!!5 7 #22 - ? ( ) 4 >2*#) & & " " " &.

"% &' **+, ")&& "&"B".%& %& " & &"".

%" &&")C.&&" &".

%"" " &&.

"&%."" & " ) D7 (6!!

#29# @ 8 ( 6 *#)#*)*> +)*2 - 7 & % " " () >>9 *#)#*)*2*> .& **(6 @)%

( ." "%B" 6 &" @ . #+*/@ " & "& .& " C

& & &) & &""% "&.

! & - "& & &)

CRM-M-44524-2024 (O&M) 4 & " & "% &'**+,"& @ " ) C& .&& " " " " & 1" <2@ ( " && %.& " ) " &%.".)E ,

12 % ! .

% !

(

0 &!44

-6&

& . .&

% !

) & /

0 & ! 44

-6&

0 0

4-6-* 0 .

! % ! .

8 !

0 !

,: !

! 0 .

6 )

, $5 6$( 5 +

!#$5

+7 "# 2 /

2 ,2($()9: ;

4,-:-,8

CRM-M-44524-2024 (O&M) 5 $) " & & " >+ (6 & ." & &" F " % .

&) ."

#" "" )&"*&D & " & & & &"%

&."% &" . " %&"" " &" && &".") & && &

" " " &." . & .& .& & *# ". ". ". %& ." && ".& %& & .& >+G#HG%HGH(6 )I % . .&

3# , $5<$ "

$ $=7, ; )

,:! ( )

-+- .& )

+7 "# 2/

2,2((;

>5 ** !+ 2* % %# +5 #45 6$(5 +

9 E4& & " &% &."" %. &"." ."&

") "=. . A &"" " &"" "&." & & "" " &"&&%& "% ".%' ".&" % %""" . @&& .&)

CRM-M-44524-2024 (O&M) 6 " "

" " %&")

G"H "

" " " ")E + $ %=??

* % ,$ 6 ,$=$ 5 +

A $ %B 21 +/ ,2( ($(;)C;1 !

"#!

! % ((;

9 #) & & & &" "

& ." .& " *#GH@*9 (& 6&.

" "& .%"" #9<, G& "& J(6 KH C ()#<@*2** 29)2#)*2** & "&

.& 6"&-.&"% 4"? ) *)

" & & & &" & &"& & "

&. """" " " " % " % ") 6.& "& ##, % " G#22 ) !H " &&&&' """" &") &&&"" %."&&&.&") >)4& &." & &" &.

&."&&) $)" " :& ""% .

& "&%&) ." &

" &"% & & "" &"".% .& ."

&&& & ") &" & ") & "

".%" >+(6 ) ,) ".&.""

%. .A &"" " &" " & &

CRM-M-44524-2024 (O&M) 7 & " &" % ".%' &" ""% "%& .&) /)

" & " &" & . & " .& (6 &&

."." ""% & "." ""&"=.""

) +) &"&.&&& &%& & .&& .

& ) % %" "

%""."""% ) <) """ " %&") 9)"&".

& .& " """ ") 3

-6-+- .& )

,#*#% 2 77

2 ())9: # ! $ >7 2 0,#$5%

, D 7 2,=$* 6$( %#% %!# >1 ) 8

. 9 E &) "

"'. && *,)2#)*2** "" % .& - &"

& % .& - ()##+@*2**)

"."" #<)2/)*2*2 & & "& " ())?) & ()2*@*2*2 &" " ."% .& " < *2 *+7 *< &

*9(&6&.

" "& .%"" #9<,) " & % % &' " "% ) 4 & -&) " 8.& & & ". & -&) ' & &0& &&" )

CRM-M-44524-2024 (O&M) 8 "& " &."" && .".& %

.& "&% ".) 4&& &D GH

% &. %& & .&

"&) G%H& .&"

& "

% ".%' ".""& .& & & ") GH

&"."" %&) GH & "

& %

&%" &&) "

&"&")E 4-

-4-+- .& )

7 <) =6:3>-

># #$5!5#4 ,-D % 6$( 5 +

A $ %B 2> ) . 9 E" && &*9)2+)*2** " ." "".

." & 4" ? " &"%"& ") & "& &&% ) &"" & % C) ))()/#* *2*2#+)#2)*2*2 .&*#GH>+ (6 & "& ? 4" ? ) 6.& .&"&

&& &".& ."& &2#& 2+ " " 29)2/)*2**) & " & & " " """%A) & "& ") "& &".& % &

&."" %.

CRM-M-44524-2024 (O&M) 9

.A &"" "&"" & &% &) &"&

&%& "% ".%'.&" % %""" & .&) "" "&" &")

G"H "

"" ")E 44 (

& !

0 !

4-6-* 0 &

! (

(

0 &!44

-6&

& 8

4! )

0 0

;

! ;)

, *+#%B58$(+

, , !

$5 %! % ,1)';+@( 4

4 A

& ! & .

& 0 ( ; )

E3!=2

5* % % =2 - %! ,$ 8( (+( - 4 %! % ,@1 ):: ,#*#% 29;. 0

&( !

& 0 !

B &

CRM-M-44524-2024 (O&M) 10 4,

0 &

& #

0 .

0 B

& .

) > & 0

(

.& !

9 <2= (

<22= (

<= <222= (

! )

;

<2= (

! 8 !

! ! 8

<= (

& / &

& B

! ! !

0 ! ) &

4* ! . ! & ! .

! ) 46 %8

; !

! ) 8

&! .

&! !#

<= ! & ! 0 + '())(

0 A

0> D > A

D >