High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/49612/2022dismissed

Baljeet Kaur v. Dilbag Singh And ORS.

2022-10-28Mr. Justice Deepak Sibal5 pages

!"#!$%&%'() *+!! ,- ! % %'! . %*/0%'01'# 1!& !&2'#!' & ( 34 ,4

!&!' ( 1/% 1- !*5#6$ !5" 1!2! % %'! 7777777 ,458 49 1!2! % %'!"%*!#$:2*%' /!"! 1!##% %'*1%!"-#%$%* 0%& !5%-; &1%/8"&1 5 1!%*- 9&2!<1%$1&1!<& /!%'0 1&&!# '# -!# /= 1! 1-&/'#!&2'#!' > '# 1%& ":%*= :!:/!&"/%'0%'0*!&&#<= 1!*&$:2*%'!# 1 1!1-&/'#<& 16%'0'!? :% *""%'# 1 <1!'&1!$'"' !#1%:<% 1&-$1"$ 1! 0 '0='#06!1!/! %'0& '!" 1!%'$%#!' &%'1!$:2*%' <&" @'<1%$1# !5$$#%'0 1!5" !&1!<& -'!#- ":1! : %:'%*1:!'#<&0%'0'1!&$ =5&1!<&& 22!#/=1!1-&/'# '#1%&":%*=:!:/!&" !1!&$ =1#$:! $:2*! 1* 5!&2'#!' 0#!!2,-'#!

&2'#!' :'#!!2,-$-01 1*#"1!": 1!:&'#!&2'#!' A '#1%%'01$-01 1*#"1!*!0&1!!" ! !&2'#!' %*/0 %'01 06! 1! /! %'0& '# 1! 1-&/'#!&2'#!' >-;% %'01 %!# & '0-* !1!B1!'&1!%&!#'*:51!" 1! C-%'01'#'!0&%%'01%6!# 1!&2 '#'&!!%'0 1!: 1! 2! % %'!3&1-&/'#'#1%&":%*=:!:/!&"*!#": 1!&$!' '&-22 "1!$:2*%' 5 1!2! % %'!*!#2!*%:%'=!6%#!'$!5 " !$'&%#! %'"<1%$15 1!%*- <&" 1!2%'%' 1 1!**!0 %'& :#!/= 1!2! % %'!<% 1!0# 1!%'$%#!' ' @<!!"*&!

& 1!%*- "-'# 1!**!0 %'&/= 1!2! % %'! /!60-!'##-/ !#

DE 1!2!&!'$!" 1!$:2*%'' 3&" 1!' 1!&2 "$$-!'$!&#-%'0 1! $-&!"1%&!?:%' %'/!"! 1!%*- 1!1#' 0%6!''=!&'"1%& 2!&!'$!1!%*- *&"-'# 1 1!2! % %'!1#' /!!'/*! 26! 1!"$ 1 &1!1#$:2*%'!#/- &-$1%'$%#!' 1!2*%$!1!!"!'# /!$-&! 1!%*- <&" 1!2%'%' 1 1!!<& !'#!'$=/= 1! 00%!6!#<%"! 2!%'1!$:2*%' ** 1!:!:/!&"1!1-&/'#3&":%*=5% #%# ' "%'# &-""%$%!' : !%* &-::' !&2'#!' %*/0 %'015 !&2'#!' :'#!!2,-'#!&2'#!' *+%'#!,- "$! %* 1!2! % %'!"%*!#!6%&%'2! % %'0%'& 1!"!&%##!" 1!%*- <1%$1<&**<!#'/= 1!##% %'*!&&%'& -#0!

5%-; 1%/8"&1 5 1! !6%&%'*- 91!!&'%'00%6!'/= 1! !6%&%'*- &! &%#! 1!#!" 1!%*- <& 1 1!%* - 1#<'0*=$'&%#!!#!&2'#!' :'#!!2,- /! 1!:%!# &%& !" 1!2! % %'!3&1-&/'#'#!&2'#!' /!1!1-&/'#5<1<!! *%6%'0 &!2 !*= ": 1! 2! % %'!3& : %:'%* 1:! !&-* ' *=5 1!

!6%&%'*- #%!$ !# 1!&%#!&2'#!' & /!&-::'!# "$! %*

!&2'#!' &'#$1**!'0!# 1!#!# !#2&&!# /= 1! !6%&%'*- /="%*%'02! % %'-'#!!$ %' /!"! 1%& - 1%&- <&" 1!2%'%' 1 1! !6%&%'*- 1#<'0*= $'&%#!!#!&2'#!' /! 1!:%!#&%& !" 1!2! % %'!3&1-&/'#'# !&2'#!' /!1!1-&/'#&*& 1!"$ 1 1!=/ 1<!!' *%6%'0%' 1!2! % %'!3&: %:'%*1:!&% <& 1!#:% !#"$ 1 !&2'#!' <& 1!2! % %'!3&1-&/'#3&!*/ 1!'#!&2'#!' <&1%&<%"!&*& 1 1!=<!!*%6%'0%' 1!2! % %'!3&: %:'%*1:!$$#%'0*=5 1!#! " 1! !6%&%'*- # !#5/!%'0/&!#'<'0"$ &5<&&! &%#!'# 1!: !<&!:% !# 1! !6%&%'*- ""!&1#!$%&%'5%'

$$#'$!<% 1*<

D>E &#%!$ !#/= 1%&- 5 1! !6%&%'*- 1!# 1!!6%&%'

2! % %'"%*!#/= 1!2! % %'!"!&1/- " !&&%0'%'0#%""!!' !&'& 1' 1! '!&0%6!'/= 1! !6%&%'*- %'% &!*%!#!# !#5-21!*# 1! #!" 1!%*- # !#A 1-01<1%$1!&2'#!' &5'#

1#' /!!'&-::'!# "$! %*-$1#!" 1! !6%&%'*- %&-'#! $1**!'0!%' 1!%'& ' 2$!!#%'0& 4!'!#$-'&!*" 1!2! % %'!&-/:% & 1 %'1!$:2*%' 1! 2! % %'!1&%&!#&2!$%"%$**!0 %'&0%'& !&2'#!' &5'# <% 1 !0# 1!:16%'01&&!#1!"/%'0%'0*!&&#<='#"0%6%'01! /! %'0&&*& 1 ' @1!1-&/'#'#1%&":%*=:!:/!&5<1%$1 %'$*-#!#!&2'#!' &'#51#<=*%#1!'#0%6!'1!/! %'0&!&-* %'0 %'&!6!*%'+-%!&'1!2!&''&-22 "**!0 %'&&1!1#1!&!*"& !22!# %' 1!<% '!&&/?'#1#*&2#-$!#0&%%'01&B)&*&1!" 1! C-%'01&B 1!!"!5 1!%*- &*& 1! !6%&%'*- !!#%'' &-::'%'0!&2'#!' &5'# "$! %*

!&2'#!' %& 1!0'#: 1!" 1!2! % %'!3&1-&/'# 2!-&*" 1!2! % %'!3&$:2*%' '# 1!2!*%:%'=!6%#!'$!*!#/=1!$*!*= !6!*&60-!'#-'&-/& ' % !#**!0 %'&F-!&2'#!' &%' 1!&:!

'&2!$%"%$# !5 %:!%'$%#!' <% 1!0# 1!**!0 %'&0%'& !&2'#!' %&"-'# '1!$:2*%' 5 1!2! % %'!1&**!0!# 1 %'##% %' 1! 1-&/'#5!&2'#!' &'#5<1!1!1-&/'#3&/ 1!'#1%&<%"!5<!! *&1&&%'01!"/%'0%'0*!&&#<=&*&0%6!'1!/! %'0& - 1!5 1!

2! % %'!**!0!& 1 ' @5<1!'&1!<&0%'0'1!&$ =&1!<& <=*%#/=1!1-&/'#'#1%&":%*=:!:/!&%'$*-#%'0!&2'#!' &'# '# 1 " !1!&$ = 1#$:! $:2*! !1* 5!&2'#!' '# !&2'#!' $-01 1*#"1!":1!:&'#!&2'#!' A$-01 1*#

D E "1!*!0& 1!!" !5!&2'#!' 06!1!/! %'0&'#1!1-&/'# !&2'#!' > %!# & '0-* !1!B1!'&1!%&!#'*:51!" 1! C-%'01'#1%&"%!'#0&%%'01%6!# 1!&2 '#'&!!%'0 1!: 1! 2! % %'!3&1-&/'#'#1%&":%*=:!:/!&"*!#": 1!&$!'!

!&2'#!' %& 1!2! % %'!3&1-&/'#3&/ 1!'#!&2'#!' %&!&2'#!' 3&<%"!?$!2 1!"!&%#%'$%#!' # !# @ 1!

**!0 %'&F- 1!:!"-'# /!0!'!*560-!5-'&-/& ' % !#'#:'%/-& "& 1!**!0 %'&!0#%'0 1!%'$%#!' ' @%&$'$!'!#5/ 1 1!

%*- &*& 1! !6%&%'*- 5" !0%'0 1-01 1!**!0 %'&:#! /= 1!2! % %'!&*& 1!2!*%:%'=!6%#!'$!*!#/=1!16!#%&/!*%!6!#1! 1!!&'%'00%6!'/=/ 1 1!- & %6! &-$1$'$*-&%'%& 1 1!!%& 0!'!* !'#!'$= 1 '00%!6!#<%"! 1! %:!"%&%'0: %:'%*#%&2- !5 !'#& 2!%'&:'=" 1!":%*=:!:/!&"1!1-&/'# - 1!5/ 1 1!

- &#%#' "%'#' 1!!$#'=$:2*%' :#!/= 1!2! % %'! 1!2*%$! <% 1!0# 1!**!0!#%'$%#!' ' @:!#%$*!6%#!'$!%'&-22 " 1!**!0 %'&"/! %'0&G& '0-* %'<&!6!'2#-$!#/= 1!2! % %'! 1!2!&!'$!" 1!2! % %'!3&" 1!&*&1%&"%!'#':!*=0&%%'01 1! &2 <1!! 1!2! % %'!<&/!%'0**!0!#*=&&-* !#<&*&#%&/!*%!6!#&%' 1!%!6%#!'$!'!?2*' %'<&0%6!'/= 1!:& <1=<!! 1!=2!&!' 1! &2 1 %:! 1%&- $'$-&<% 1 1!"!$'$-!' "%'#%'0&! -'!#/= 1! %*- &*& 1! !6%&%'*- '

1!-2!:!- 1&1!*# 1 %': %:'%*#%&2- !& 1!!%&' %'$!&!# !'#!'$="%:2*%$ %'0 1!!* %6!&" 1!1-&/'#'# 1 1!- & <1%*!!?!$%&%'0 1!%+-%&#%$ %'-'#!!$ %' &1-*#'*=C! 1!

*'0 !::%"%$ %'&" %*/&!#'&-$1 !'#!'$= <&"- 1!/&!6!#

DAE 1 1!-2!:!- 1#"-'#%'&!6!*$&!&"*&!%:2*%$ %'"!* %6!&" 1!1-&/'#%': %:'%*#%&2- !&/=<="0!'!*:'%/-&**!0 %'&:#! 0%'& 1!: 1!!"!5 1!-2!:!- 1-01% &+-#0:!' &<'!# 1! - &":2$!!#%'00%'& 1!!* %6!&5%'*<&'#":%*=:!:/!&" 1! 1-&/'# <1!' ' 2%: "$%!$&!%& :#!- 0%'& 1!: 1! !*!6' /&!6 %'&%' 1%&!0#!#&-'#!( H@ 1! /6!:!' %'!# #!$%&%'& $*!*= #!:'& ! 1 1%& - 1& '-:!-&%'& '$!&!?2!&&!#$'$!'6! 1!:%&-&!"!$ %'

) '# 1!

%'$!&!# !'#!'$="%:2*%$ %'0!* %6!&" 1!1-&/'#%': %:'%*#%&2- !&5 <% 1- '*=&%'0 1!*'0 !::%"%$ %'&" %*' 1!$:2*%'' &<!**& 1!$$-&!# %&"- 1!:'%"!& ": 1!&%#+-#0:!' & 1 "*&!%:2*%$ %'/= <="0!'*:'%/-&**!0 %'&:#!%' 1!$-&!": %:'%*#%&2- !5%"*!" -'$1!$;!#<-*#!&-* %':%&-&!" 1!2$!&&"*<1!!"!5 1%&- /=<= "% &+-#0:!' &1&<'!# 1!$- &":2$!!#%'00%'& 1!!* %6!&'#%' *<&" 1!1-&/'#<1!''2%:"$%!$&!%&:#!- 0%'& 1!:I B1!' 1!"$ &" 1!2!&!' $&!!&!!'%' 1!*%01 " 1!"! /&!6 %'&:#!/= 1!-2!:!- % %&"-'# 1 1!2! % %'!3&1-&/'#3& / 1!51%&<%"!'#1%&0'#: 1!1#/!!'2!#%'/= 1!2! % %'!' 1! & !'0 1"60-!

5-'&-/& ' % !#'#/*#**!0 %'&&*& 1 !&2'#!' & '#<!!&-01 /!%:2*%$ !#' 1!& !'0 1"'%'$%#!' <1%$1<& & 0!# '6%!<" 1!"!#%&$-&&%'5 1%&- %&#%&%'$*%'!# !?!$%&!% & %'1!!' 2<!&-'#!!$ %' &! &%#! 1!$'$-!' "%'#%'0& !$#!#/=/ 1 1!%*- &*& 1! !

!&2'#!' &55'# "$! %* %&:%&&!# ) D ,4E &1:&1! B1! 1!&2!;%'0G!&'!# ( !&G B1! 1!!2 /*!

(!&G