← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2286/2016allowed

Rajinder Singh And ANR v. Paramjit Kaur And ORS

2023-11-28Mrs. Justice Amarjot Bhatti16 pages

    

   !    

 "

 #

$%&'%(

)*)+,)( -% .. +-%-/%0)( -% .. 

 

  

   

    12 .

 

  





   !



      !

# $ %%%% 

 "

.

 # & " 

'

 ()$*

+ 

  ,  -- "         "      . / "



0"

1/  

2

#,+""#3 ! + 

0" !  #



!

" 

   " + " /  



!

 !&

 /  



"  

 /   

1"

/  . / +  #4 ! + +  + +   "  /

   - +

$

 "  &

 0 

 0 / +   "   . / 0/ 



0"

  

"

 .

 

"" +

#,  +""#3/

 -  

   "

  "       0" !  



!

 " +    !5

" - " +  . / +  + +!

$6(,$(($1! +"

"

 "  



    . / 



 0  "

 

 

0 

 +   "   . /



/  "



0"



"  "  +  7 

 - 

0   "

 8""# $ 



    !

 "    

  



             

   6(6$(,    /0  

  9 : !  

 +  /0    

4(($(, /0 -!9 )9 !* :   " ""+   $ " " 

   +

   " #4;$

/ "

4 0 6<;<= >

++ +7+  #

+ "/ 7" /"  0/0 ?

 #  

    " 

 ! +

& 0 6<=<<   #   +  

     

    "

   +   "  !

>

+  +      7   4;$   /  ,=    7   ;,=86<,

/ " 0 6<;<=& 0"

 

 /0  + 

 

     7 ! +

 "" /

""

  ""

 0"

   + +   # 5

?

   '

 : & ""+



    " "



++

   0  #@$/ " 

  !

+ 

+ 

/ / 7 + + "" /"

0 / 

+ /0/ /



0 6<=<<& "" +

 " 0    #@$ 

A    "

""/ 0

""   

   !

   &      

 /   

  "

  / 0+

   0

 "  0 !



7  

/   

0/ / 7&  

"   " "".

"

 



 /0  # 

   "! "

/  0

!



 !

3 +" /  0/ 0+

 ""

    0 "  4 #

+ !

  &   # $

 " +   +  

 0/



/0&   

0     /   7  &  ""  !

   

   +   

;(,$((+ "  "/  

"/"

 0+

/ /0"

 &    ,(A0   / "  

 

 " 0  7 #   7  +   "    

  '  

    +  /    

/  !

/

+ 0  / 7++ 



1+"

/ 0 " 0+ + 

   ++ / 7

!  +



+ + "  +

"

$3C$(C + "" 7 /

"

 0  +

+ "     +7 

& 

0  /

 /

 7/00

 "  01+  "" +

 " 0

  # $   " ""&  

""

0 "

/0  0  !



0   ++    /0  #$/0+0"



 ! 

1+

 #$ 

 0   !



0 

  

     

           0

   !

    

0      +    /   &

, ""



0   

  "

 1 +/ ""    

" ! . /  + +

- " / 9 $ - : D 0

 !

 

+ 0

"  " +  0"    ""+

+

   #4 

0 !

$6(,$(($ +  + +   #4. /

 3          "        "+     +

  - $<($(,   



         



    

   





    !

   

  "          # $ % 

, 1

 !

  ""#$   ""#

  !

   + /B D D4



!

0 



 "   

"

"" B  D$ 

D3 !

 EB

!

& / ""

:  D,    E 0'

 ! - 

-""

: D;&

"

  " "" 

 ; 1



/  ""   #$

7+

 "   + /BD

;

 0+ "" !EB+  



"   +   &   B

1

   "D$&

"

"   + 

" - !

$$($(, = D  

   /0+0"

 "" !

  0



EB4EB$(   EBD8 < "



  !

/0  "

/            "  /0    ""  +    !

  

4(($(,5



"   

""" -! #<"(($$(, + +  !   

6(6$(,5



"  





   /

" 8"" 6 1!



  !

/0  "

       !

     

"0  &  

  

     8""  " 0 

   

 

,--"  " 0"(6 0

" 1   

/



 

 0"-   0"(6 0

"





  

0

"

 0/    0/

 + "

/0 8""      "     8""  "

   / 7 "" /"

 0  /0   ?

  #           

=   " #4;$

/ " 0 6<;<=1  " ?

# #3=+ "  7  "   ! +

& 

#3 ,    

  ""

  0   # 5

?

  # '

 : & +



    7"

 "/"  0&

"

# $ / " 

 

/ "

 / 7

 " 

"

  +

   +"  #



"! "

 #$

/ 

7A .+

      +    ""

     "    ""    

/"  # -0   /    1  

   /           "  ""

B   ""D  D$ 

 ""D4 +!

" "  &  " 

0 A  !



EB EB$& 

 " 8"" B  D;  E 0'

 -'""

:  

0+ 7  /



E : + !



$,(;664



4((;664EBD;8-

 #3;>  (3A0 +   " /

 EBD;8 . /      "! "

>!  



$((,66;



 $3(,66;EBD;8

 #3=  $((

< AF +   " /

 EBD;8>!    "! " 7+

& 

 " 8""



EBD;8- +



 "  7 

 "#3; >1



  "A  



+

"  

+

+   

    ++/  +



EB4 EB=  0" +  EB,8$     

#8  #

  "

" /"  #    +  7

7+

&  - / +!

"  

      

   $,(;664 



   4((;664 EBD;8-+   0+

+ 7+  



"  "! ">/ &

"   !

/0  -   / +  

   "   &

   /0  

 8""  +  + 0  

       "  /0  

""++ 0  " 0/0 - " -! 9 )9 !* : +    

4(($(,  

/0""#4 , ++ 0

 /0    

6(6$(, - "   9

: 1 0

 

  

 8""07 0/

   "

""07 0/

 0 "  ( '    

      

  

8  # $

 7 /0

6  8""+0/&

 !

 +   + 7 ""

/" 0 0  #   "

# $

   0     

 

    



!"  

 G %$-% -3 %($'

'%( -45)+* ,)+*/* 6'*',$ --7.

-/*$%8

-0$)49 24(.

%( -45)+*H +

+  "

 "  &  

   

  '

      (

       )&   

 " 8""/0/ - / + "0" '   7+

  

+ /BD  !



$((,66; 



   $3(,66;  EB      "!   -0  "

/ " 0 66;6=EB$  0"/ " 0

$((($EB4  0"/ " 0 $((;(=EB3   7+

 0  "

+

    /  #4;$.



 0"

 ": -

$4(3$((4 7> +    0  +       7 

B      /0  

 8""  &  

 +       +  



"

 "  #  7>.

 

  

0  "       6(6$(    -  -#;38  $(;$(( G   

!

   7+

H





  3$(83$483$,83;483;383;=8,(;843  "  1-    +    0  +

A 

"

   

 0" 

( $;(3$(4-  #$"(=$(+ +   /0  

9 : + 

EB; EB=



!

0& 

   +

 "    /  "   &      "

   

 "1

   "  -: I :  B

D$+ !



 0"    # EB$8+ 



" 7



0A 1 

  

 ""+

 



"  -01 "   0!

/ A 0

  "

 !

  &





EB6 EB



!

0&

0 0 

+0

 

B

"

 0" /"  0&

 /

" 0/0

     8""  

 "  -0!

 0  /0" 



  &  0!

 !

"- / +&





  " 8""+

    07 0/     1!



  !

/

  !

     

"0  5 0  1  +    +  

 " 8""

,--"

 " 0"(6 0

" 



   

 ! +" !

   +  0  /0"" !"

 #$    "

  0 / 



0

 

   

"

7   ! +  0

 "(6 0

"       / - ,6;;-$(;   "

0 $ 1!

 

 - "

"0 8""

    

" 

     +

  

" #4;$

/ " 0 6<;<=  >

++ +7+  # /  "" /"  0/0 ?

 

)  # * 

"0

 /0

"! "

/   #$ 0

!

 

  !  "

/ /  0/ 0 +

 ""

  

   # $"



  0     "     &    "  /0    ""  +  - " -!9 )9 !* :    

4(($(,& +

/0 " "" 

    

   

  "

   

 

 +  /0    

6(6$(,/0 - "   9 :  #+ "



"  





  /



/0

    8"" 

  !

0+



0

/!

+ " 7" /"  # -0

  +      +  /0       +

       

8  #& +0 ""

$ !

  1

 / B

" 7  

 " "" B  D  D$ 

D4+  0 

0 A  7 "" /"  #   D

 " 

0  EB$/  

"

    "".



0 EB

0/  

". / 

    #  0 66$E 

. / +    

0      "      /         +  + +!

$6(,$(($D

 

  / - / +  "

   +

 !



/0 B 0+  / 

 

"0" "" 

 +

 !



    "     

  "  . /       #  4  

 +  + +&

/ - / +  

0 "

  EB EB$ "

    ""



!   

8 " /

 ""

  + 

EB4 EB=&  +



  !

0+/   +

 +  EB,8$ !

"

  0"

!

 B D,.+

 /"

  

  /   

0A +  7 "/0 +

?

  #

 

 + 

A

   /  

B

"  71       !

B 1

   "  -: I : D$

4 + !

 0"   # 

'

 5

?

  :   0"   EB$8& / 

 0+!/ +   #  

   +  /B 0"  # +



"

/ 7+    1+"   #/

 " 

/  EB EB $ 

 /0 ""& / 

!/ +

8    #      $  +  +    &   0   !

" /01

   " D$+/ 0 





"   " 

"    #

   / /

   EB

 /0 8"".+

 "   +  

+  +

 0 +  EB&   

  

     

 ""+ " 7"

/"  #       "" B   E 0'



! - 

-""

:  

0+ 7  /



E : D;+ !



+

 

$,(;664



4((;664

 /0. /

  "! ">/ 

  #3;>  (3A0 + /  JE #3;- #     + EBD;8-     " /

 EBD;8&

"

 

$((,66;



$3(,66;

 /0

3  "! "

/  7+



 #3=  $((A0 + /  JE

 D  

0">/  # 

  

+ EBD;8+   " /

 EBD;8>

""

 

  0     

0 /0. /   "! ">/

  !  

   $,(;664 



   4((;664 EBD;8-      "  /

    EBD;8     7  

"

+  

 "



 "/

0       

0  /0   "$((A0  "! "

/  7+

+ /  

/!

!

$((,66;



$3(,66; +  EBD;8    " /

 EBD;8>    -   / +  !

 "    

 

/  

"

 

  

/   + E

  7

">/ /00 7++ 0  "  ++&

 + !

/

 ""

 

$,(;664



4((;664EBD;8-+   " /



EBD;8+

 /0 / A !

    !

/

 7++ 0

+  E

  1   



 +

    # . / "! ">/

 &

  "0 +  

/    &

      

   +    

 +  0  " 

!

  !



7



, " /   !

     #     + /B  "0" 

 "  0  +0  "

        !

 "

 

+ "  7+

D

  " 

"

$((,66; 



$3(,66;

EBD;8    " /

 EBD;8>"!

+   0

 /0+"

 " 

     

+   +

A   +  +!

/ 

!  1! +"0     - / +" 



"

 " &

+

 / 

/   

 "! ">/

+ 



"

" 7+  E



  

0!!

  0 /

  /

0  +   /0       

    "  &

"  

!

/0 +- / +  " ""+  

  "   

0   /0







  

  "

""

7

 

   ) 

  */ 7 "" /" 0 

 0 "  

$((,66; 



 $3(,66;

 /0

8  #    "! "

8  #$ 7+



0     !    ""

       "    ""    

; /  "      #  +   A  

 "  "  

     0 "  



  

0 +      )*"0  )*  "   " 



!

"

 + -  / +/  / 7

A

 $<$($4 

  

 D

 7

  D

 /  8#