M/S Karan Bus Service (Regd) Fatehgarh Sahib v. State Transport Commissioner Punjab And ORS
!"#"$%&
!" #! $
!& '
(
( )(% % % * +,,--( . ((/,(011 &2*!(% + ,!( ' 3( -
!"#!$
!&'
(
()(% % % * +,,--( . ((/,(011 &2*!(% + ,!( (% )( *+ *(
, * )( *
, (4 2% 5&! (%,,--( " --- /% (6 ( ,,- ! 0- 7 (% (( (( ((%!!2! 1(!(! 8 ! 9 & !!*:(%-! -;! & !3%
%(%3 , ! *:(%,,--( "% *!
!)(% -! *(% (%,,- 11&! ( ! 1, !!!(! 9
&(%-! -;! %!
!(%3 ( ,( (1 % - !
!(! 8 & 3%
* -! < &*(%(%,,-* !
!!*:
112! 1(#3&(% (* ! ! 1
= (% (( 2*& (3 ,( %1& 1-:& /% 2* !3: %1!, !/,(0,( %1 3,,!*:(%>1(! ?' (%(.%
- (& (% $-! (" -(% % (% %1 3 ,*- %! ?
! < & , -:& *( (% !
! (% 2* !3: , ! /,( 0,( (5 (% ,( 1(%, (,( (1 (% ! %1) 3 %1 3 ,*- %! *: (% >1(& (% - /,( (% ( ( (1,:,1 (3 (6
- @( :3 %1#3&(%,10( (2! 1(!! -,,-9 < ( -" < ? !! ( --(1,:( ,1 ((%(3% (% ,*-
! 3 , - (
!
-:& (
3 ,*- %!*:(%(% ,,-
( - ( ,1 ( 3 (% (3 ( ( , ! -: ( ,( , (% 16,(%-(!,,-
3 !,(((% !(
/3,1 (3 (%(( ,3 (!(, ! /,(0,( #3&(%((3,1 (1 !6--((! !!&(3 (%,,-
&1-:&' % /,(0 !( -!( -# %3:((!
-! ,,-* (%((/,(,,--(/ *-!
&(%/ *-
,(!(% !,,-!1 ((!(%1((( (( /,( 011 ( ( (% 1 (3 ,1 (&
( -- -:
(((%,,--()(%!,!*:(%/ *-3 ( 1,-1(!&( -# %3:((!& (%,,--( * (% / *-& ,, %! (% 0( ! 0A < 8
53 &(%
-,,-
(&1-:&( - !
( (!& ! 0A 9 ?
& - -! (% ! !(!
(% 0(( !(%! (%/ *-!!
(! (% (( /,( 011 ( ! (% - 1 -- (%
-,,-
((%(%(%(3,,--( 3% (% / *-%!,!!!(!
&, -- (% ,,-
(& (% !,(1(& ! ! !(! ? 9
& (! (3 ,1 (3 (%(( , ( - !((!( ((% !!&!(! ? 9
&(%,,-3
-!*:
" ' %/,(0 !( -B
"( -# %3: ( (! ( -B !
" , ! /,( 0,( & ( - ' (%,! : (%,,-&,1 (3 (%%- ( , C( 3( !
,,--( 6
" -((-:&
3-:!,!( (% !,,-.
?&(%/ *-
,(!(% ! ,,- ! 1 ((! (% 1(( ( (% - /,( (% 6 /% ,,--( -! (% ! ! * (% 0( !0A< ?
?&3%
%%33!
!*:(% 0( !!&(%,,--(% , !,
- ( * (% ,1 0( ?
& 3%
3% - (
<
(% ,1 0( *! (%( : (53 --**2 (((%
-( 1!(% (%!(%( %--*,! (%,,-#3& ?&(% ,1 0( !
! (% ,
- ( (% % - *(: 3 (!((%,,--((%(
(3( -- !*::*C(!
(3(- *(:(1(%,,, 1( (%13% -& (1 (% ! ,! *: (% / *- !(!
?& 3%
% 3
1! *: (% 0( 3% - !
(% 3 , ! *: (%
,,--( 0A< ?
?&(%((/,(011 & 2* , 6 (% 1(( ,! ! !(!
& ! 3%
% (% ,1 ( 3 (! , ! /,( 0,( & ( - =( 3 (% ! !(!
( 3%
%(%,,--(
-!,,-&! (%(.%
- (& * (% (( /,( ,,--( / *-& 3%
% 3 !
! !!!(! * ( 1*! !!& (%,,--( ", !3 * (% 0(&3%
%% *!
! ! 1, !!!2! 1(!&(%&(%,,- A%%!-! - (%,,--( "!,! (% ! DE
& (% ,,--( " %! -! (% ! !(!
( !-: -: :& & (% ,,- 3
-! < ? !!*:(%-! - (%,,--( "* (% -! - ;! & (% , *! , ! - (( ! (% 2*(.%
- -& &(, : %,,- 8 !: -(% %&,(% (%,,--( "(%1-&(%(% % (%2 !
( !(%!-: (1 9 (% (( (& ?8& , !!
( 3 !1((!& *( ,,-
31!/% (%,,--(* (%/ *-& -! - ;! - * (% 0( % * (%( (% ,10(3% -!
(%,
-(
?& !
(!*&%! (!- *(:((%,,--((1 (%,,, 1
!*::*C(!&(%,,--( % *( ! (% (
! ,: (% ! !(!
?
-! (%,,- < ?& ! (%(% 1 3 3 (% - (( ,,(-:& (% ! ,! *: (% ,1 0( !(!
?& !(% (& * 1 !!1 (!*:(% ,,--( "4 . /"$01 0 1 2 $
31 2 1 14 ## 56 "02 31 , 7 $ "$ $6 1 #$ "$ 1 1 7"
2 2 # 8 2 *4 !"
9 /
"
"$ "# "#8"## 7 / 1, " 2 4 "
"$ 1# 1 001" / 56 $6#35# :3 $ 1 1, 2 6 1
9"5 1 6 8/
2 44141"
138 $ "$ #3!2 !
# #, 2 5# 1/
"$ 8 "$ 2 1 1 4 ## 56 2 "02 31 7"99$ !8 "$ 2 7 6 2 4 "
"$ 1#; * !
(% !& ! ( *& (% - (%( (% , ! *: (% ,,--( ( (% ! ,! *: (% 0(
1 (% ! !(!
?& 3%*: (% / *- %! 1 ((!(%1((((% -/,((% 6 & 3 !
! )(%& ! (%,! : (% ! (% (( /,(011 %!,! %!!(!
&3% - !
, (%1(((%,10(-:*!(%((%,,--( %-- * ( - *(: ( 1 (% ,,, 1
! *: : *C(! (%!
!(%,10( !(%!-:(%(%!
! (% 13% - ( , ,,- ( ! !(!
: %*( 31! (% !(2((%(& (%!!(!
-(%((%,,--(% 3,(:( (% !!! (3,% (%1!(%(56%-!(%(( /,( 011 %! ,! (% ! !& (% % *2 ( ( (% !
(%,10( ?
!-((&
(%,,--(%!(%,( ( -(%!!(!
3 (% (% , *! , ! - (( & *( (%: % ( C( (% ! ! *:
- ,,- ! (% ( .%
- ( =( ,,(%( (%, !*:(%,,--(3,!
* (%,10(& ((% %(3 ((%!
(% &*( (%
( 1 , ! -: : %! *: $* -:& (%
-! *: (% ,,--( 3!
!*: (%,1 0( !(% !!!*:(% 0(3%*:(%!!(!
?,!*: (% / *- 3
1! 1 (( (% 1(( 6 & (% ,,--((% %( -(%!!(!
*:3: ,,- /%& (%,,-
-!
! 1 ! !
(!-: -: :&!,,-
31!5 !( !-:
- (% ! ,,-& (% -: ! (% (*- - (%( (% ,,--((% -! %3(!
(%,,- ", !*: (% ,,--( " $ * , (!-: 5!& -! - (% ,,--( " -!( (:(% !(%3
(% - !! *: (% / *- - (% -! - ;! 3 (%
(:((% !
! 1:1( - -- - (: =(%35 (%*&3!
!!( ( 3 (%(%
1, !!!2! 1(!!*:(%-! -;! /% ,,-* ! ! 1 (
!
-:!
! <+1"#2$ (31 1"= <13$
99"= 2" 3# "! 3 0 &
> $ A%(%,5 !4 FD A%(% ,(*-4 $