High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/525/2017allowed

Union Of India And ORS. v. Vikas Abrol

2025-11-29Justice (To Be Nominated),Mr. Justice Rohit Kapoor16 pages

! " "#!$

"#!$ % "

"#!$ % " & & ' $% && ' & % &' % ( ! )* +' % , - *, .( ! ' ( /0' +!+

1%!2 3

,4%2

,5,%2 67 3 8 $* 0 9 * : 1%! 2

81% !$ $* 0 ' ;

7 ,4% 2 3 6 + -$* -

= . $* )'*96

!! $ $* >

+-$* )'*9$ 0

$ $* )'9$* * - $* ' ; ,4%2 3 6 +-$* . *$ -

! = - )'*9 6

'$.

* 0 '% /? $ @'%/AB ,$ '+2-+ * 3+ = - #

4 -# '%/+ = * % 0$ ' % 8 * - .

$0 - *

-*' % '% 0$ 8 - $ % 0$% 5 +- $ : $*'% 0$+

% * .$0 3

6 $* ) '* 9 8 - -

6 - )'*9 -0 % 0$% 6

6 8 / ) '* 9 6

6+ - $* = + # * ?B )'9 + 7 - 7?B , , ' ?% B + 3 - - * = *$ --- - *

8 6

6 . @

!" # $ % $&"$"

'()((*(+*, "' -$. / 0 $ $ $"& 1! )2 "'

0$ $!! $ 113% #"

$$" 1 #/ *4* 1

#/ *454% 0$ #/ )5 * 1 6"$" #/ *4+) $"1 1 7 #/ 1 *4+)8% 0$ # "

1$""3$/9 "$"

"1$'

#3. 11 1! "& 1

$ $"& 0$ $!! $ 113':

- $ . $

-# -)'*9* 7?

B 3 3

3 - $* - . $* *-, / *--$$ * / , ' *$0<

+ )'9 8 $ 3 +>* * : * = +- !

$* <

+ ,4% 2 3 6 C - $ - $* ' ;

7 8 -<

$* ' ; 70 +- . @;' "

"< 3""$" $ $$"< .$"& # " $"!" $" $3 0 $ 0" $" "

" $" # /$3 $"' 1% $3 " $"

3"" 3#" 1 # 1 &" 1 "$"' 6#/ 1 #/ )5 * "

) 1 *4+) #/% $ $ $ " $$"< 3 0#/ 1// #"

#/ )5 )' #/ )5 * "

) #"

* $&"$" 1! $3 % #"/ $ $ //0 0$ 0" $" # /$3 $"

$"$"& # $ % "$/ 11$# 1 $3'

) $&"$" // " "$/ 11$# 1 $3 $1 $ " # !$ . #% 0$ !$$"% " $"!"% 0 !

!""% #"

"!" 0 $3 ?#/$1$':

5' $"& 1 #/ )5) 1 *4+) #/% $ $ 3/ $$"< 3 0#/ 1// #"

#/ )5 ) 1 " $& / 0"&/ % "

" "$" $$"< /$3$" 1 .$"& # " $"!"% "!/ % 6/$3 "3 $" 6#"@ 6/$3 $3 $" 1 6#"@ ' " $&"$" " 33

"' "

" "0 3"" 3""

$$"< ?# 1 .$"& # " $"!" $" 1 6#"@ $3 $ " $" 33 "3 0$ /0 "

1# 3""

0" $#"3 1 @3$" $1$3 "

33"3 1 $&"$"% 0 13$"& $"?#$ ' $ " "

" 1#// 0 0$ / @3 $&"$" $1 $"?#$ $ "

$"& "

1# $1 ?# 1 $$"< /$3$" #& 3 ""/ . # " $"!" $" 6#"@ $$/ $3 / 3#/

" 0$ / 3#/ $"1! 6#"@

6/$3 $3 $$"< /$3$" 1 1 "3 $" 6#"@ 6/$3 $3 $ " $" 33 "3 0$ #/ "

// $"!" 1 $$" 6/$3 "3' " .$"& $!/ 3$"

" "

$" $0 1 / /!" $$"< $&"$" 0 33 "

$ $3 &$"& #$ 1 1 "3 $" 6#"@ 6/$3 $3% "

" 3"" "

> "$" #"

#/ )5 ) 1 *4+) #/ 0$ 11$3$/ A!"

)5'+')((;

"B# 6>,) 1 0 $3 $$" $ "$/ > "$" 1 $3 "

$" ' $$" "

*) 1 $3 $"

' ! 3""

"$ $! 1 # 1 B"

$"& !"

"1$' "

$0 1 13 "

3$3#!"3% ""B# 6>,(

*2',')(*; $ /$ / $ ': < 8$* - $ 3 - 3

+ - $* % + =- 0 D E$ ' ,

!" ##$ 6?'B',,6<+ ) 0 % D , , 4 ; , 2 7 C%& '

"&!"&' ##$ #(&' 3

) 0 D , 4 % ?,B2 C('

)(!" ##$ #(&'" 3 6

+$$

$* ' ; - >

: + - + +> -- -$$* 7?

. F 73 *$ :$* ' ; - '$.?B 7 3 + - $-- $ $* *+ = $ )'9 - $ - -- $ 7?B3 +- - -

8- $ '$.? B 3 - $#+- +

+-* + / - >

8 - # - 4++$ - $*'$.?

B 6 '$. ?

B 7 # / - > G8 / E$ ?B?B3 , / 8+'$.?

B-$ -*# / , / 5 / * 3 + # $ * - , / 8+-+ 8 = # - '% 0$ '$.?

B 7 # $** 3 - ' '% 0$ 7 8 +-+ / 3

$ 8 : . ' )29,(9)((D>6E6

"!" 1 "

$ A$"$ 1 6""/% 6# /$3 $"3 E 6"$" !" 1 6"$" E 6"$" /1 , / .

0 / $>**( ((,% )5 F#/ )((;

AA A # @3=> #"$"& 1 $3 " # !$$" 1 3 "$3/ $&"$" " 1 *>*>)((D

!/ &"

"/ $$/ $3 6"$" #/% *4+)'

GGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG $# A$"$$ 9 !"9 #"!#

$ " .$"& 3/$1$3$" 1! $ !" 0 !/ $" " 1 ,*>*)>)((,% 0 0 &"

/ "$" 3 ! #"

"/ $$/ $3 6"$" #/% *4+)% 0$// /$&$ / 1 3#"$"& 1 $ $3 #"

#/ )5) 1 $ #/ #"

$$" 1 6E8 'A'

')29*(92D>6 )4> 2>*42D% !"

1! $! $!% $" $#$" 0 #3 !/ # !$ 3 "$3/ $&"$"% " 1 *>*> )((D . # "0 $"!" $" "0 A$"$ !"9 "/ #"!#

! " 3"$ $" 3"#/$" 0$ A$"$ 1 $""3 "

$ $ 3/$1$ 1//0= $ // !/ 0 " $" "/ "!"

$3 $" $3 1 " #"!#

"/ "!" $1 $"& 3"

$$" /$

0" $" >D 1 'A'

)4>2>*42D% " 1 ,*>*)>)((, "

0 0 &"

/ "$"

3 ! #"

"/ $$/ $3 6"$" #/% *4+)% 0$// 3"$"# &"

! "$" 3 ! "

! #/% 1 # 1 3#"$"& 1 $ $3 #"

$ #/ #"

$$" 1 6E8 'A'

)29*('2D>6 )4>2>*42D% !"

1! $! $!% $1 #3 !/ # !$ 3 "$3/ $&"$" "

1 *>*>)((D% . # "0 $"!" $" " A$"$ !" 1 "!" 1 "

$ " #"!#

"!"% $" 0 $3 "$" 3 ! #" "/ $$/ $3 6"$" #/% *4+) /

B$ 1 !/ 0 " $" $3 "

1 ,*>*)>)((,'

$$ !/ 0 " $" $3 " 1 ,*> *)>)((, "

0 0 &"

6 3 ! "

"$" 3 ! 1 "/ "!"% " "$" 3 ! #"

"/ $$/ $3 6"$" #/% *4+)% " # !$$" 1 3 "$3/ $&"$" . # "0 $"!" " 1 *>*> )((D% 3"" //0 @$" / "$" 3 ! #"

"/ $$/ $3 6"$" #/% *4+)

3# " $ 3 ! 3 0''1' ,*>*)> )((, "

" "0 " 3"

//0 $" "$"

3 ! #"

#/' H0% #3 !/ 3" . "$" 9!$"/ "1$% 1! $# &"$I$"9!"% $1 !$$ / #"

#/ 1 &"$I$"9!"% 1 $ 1 $3 "

&"$I$"9!"'

$$$ // "/ "!" !/ 0 "

"/ "!" $3 $3 1 "

#"!#

"/ "!"% "

1 ,*>*)>)((, "

0 0 &"

"$" 3 ! #"

"/ $$/ $3 6"$" #/% *4+) "

0 # !$ 3 "$3/ $&"$" " 1 *>*>)((D% . # "0 $"!" #"

"!"J 0$// /$&$ / 1 &" 1 > "$"

"1$ 1 $

1 "/ "!" "/ #"!#

$3% " /$" $ $" #/ ,+ 1 "/ $$/ $3 6"$" #/% *4+) "

/ ':

8 ++: - : 8 : * - * $* 5 % ' 3 # - ( * , / $* $*, / - 3 *:* $

8 3 ,?B( 3

*$*3 -$ # - $

6$- - 0 $

6 * * = $ H = 8 < ',?B( 3

+ , / * $ $ $* 3 $ $

6# - '/ +- -$ $ . *$ , / , ! $*

$* , ?B ( 3

+ - 3 3 +- .

C*+'" ##,"#)( # #

'-#)#( # -# ).# ,# .

* "!" " 0 " !$

$" $3 $" #"

$" !"

0 // # "$// 0" 3"//

"!" "!" $" #"

3"// 1$""3

"/ "!"

"!"% // ! $ 1! $3 1!

1 #3 $" "

# @3 # >#/ , //

/$&$ / 3$ $!"

"1$ $1 "

% 1! #3 !

!$" % $" 33 "3 0$ 1 "/ "!" /$3 / $! K'

L6 ' > 1 $" // M $ $" 3 "!" !/ @$" 3$" 3!"

" $!! $ $"

" 0 $3 3#// @$" 3$" 3!"

J $$ $" 3 "!" !/ $"$$// @$" 3$" 3!"

" 1$&" $3 !

$"$"& /$" #"

"!"% 1! 0 $3 $ #"?#/$1$ $&"$" $ 33

"!"'

) $$" 1 # >#/ * // / / "/

"!" " 0 !$ $" @$"

3 #"

.$"&% 0 // #"

@$" 3"/ 1 "/

"!"

"!"9"$"

!$"$$" #"

@$" 3"/ 1 0 !

"!"9"$" $ !$"$$"'

, $ "$" 3 ! $"

3"// 1$""3

"/ "!" $" 0 $3 "!"

" $ % // "$/ B3$ $" $ 3#" $3 "

"/ "!" $"

1 "$" 3$ $!"

"1$ 1 $3 "

"/ "!" $" 33 "3 0$ $#

"/ "!"'

L6 ' >

!" #"!#

': 33 #$ $ , + *$* 8$ /

33 +$ , *-*$ * $* , / '/ +$0'$. +- #$* $* $*, /

! .0 ,

- 33 -#: , / *- $$*5% ' $ $

6 8 - + + * 6+ -

6 2 3

-$+ +

?B- $

40 ' ; - $* 2 ' ;

B3 + $+ $ * 4 + + ' ;

$ 7 ?

B 3 =-

40 $* =

E ?B()*+,-./+*'0,*+ 12)+*E?B*./&*3-./+*'0,*+

043*E ?B 4 - $ $$ 8 $ % D , 0 $* , ! 8$ 8 ) - G/ E ?B?B - , / * 8# * *$-, / 8 , %& '

"&/?B

8 0 $* , = D , 0 4% 2 7663 C&"& ( 0&!" #(&'"+-* 4 0 ('

)(E ?B - / $ 4+ + $$-$*% D , %& '

"&/ ?B D , ('

)(E?B

8 0 D E$ ' ,

E ?B : >* - * - $

+-- -# $* 0 D E$ ' , # #$ !"

1'"&

B6',, 0 ',- - $ >*

$ + , * : $* - > ',$ . C)*' " #/% $ " # "3 $" 3""$" 1 /" 3#"/ 1 "

" " $ 1 #/ D4 1 6"$" #/ " $ 1 ''% "

" 0 $ 1 3!/$"& ?#/$1 $"& $3 1 *( # 1 3!/$"& ?#/$1 $"& $3 1 )(

/#" $!"% "$/ & "$"

"1$' "

" 0 0 !$ $&" 1!

$3 #"

#/ *4 1 #/ 1 $"!" 1 & 1 $!" 1 #$"& #3 "#!

1 1 $3% !

"3 #"

#/% /$&$ / 1 $!" " "$/ & "

"$" #"

1 $$" #"

6"$" #/' #/ D4 "/ 3$ 3 # 1 3/3#/$" "

?#"$1$3$" 1 "$"

!#"' ''

)+'*)'*44;

" 3"1 "

$$"/ $& 1 "$" " !/ ':

D : = : $* * + - -$ . - $$ *-# $* ' ; $ - , > *+ 80 ' ; 8- ?,4%2 3 6 B -

4 E ,4% 2

)'*9+- : * $-

* , / $> * '/ 8$ - ' % 0$ '$. ?

B 7 -, / * $* 3 - '/ + ' % 0$+ $ $ *+ * > $

< ! *+ * * $ : * $- - * 8 $- -* * - $ $ $*

?-,4%2

B$*' % 0$ < $ %<:$- . @# "$$ $" 6#"@ 6/$3 // 1$B #"

/" #/% "

$"#3$"' $"3 $ $ 1 $"!" $" 6#"@ 6/$3 1 # $&"$"9 $!" 1! $# &"!" $3 #" "/

'9 AH% # $3 $" "/ ! 6/$3 3 6 6 0$// " 3#" 1 "$$ "$" #':

' +$ * $*% 0$% $

% 0$% = , / =(D!+ , ! % 9 '%/ - $ * + )'*9 ! *+ !! $*

' "#

+ $* $ -$*, $ +$* - + $ *

% ?B+ *+

& ' & 5

' 4# = I=2 4$ I=2