← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/55/2017allowed

Gurcharan Singh v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2020-02-17Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma,Mr. Justice Harinder Singh Sidhu7 pages

       !     

  

 

    

 



 !

" #$  %" &  '(& )**   + " '

, #      *     "

#  $ %$ &  #  $   $$ 

  -  .& / 0 )

   -

* 1. #  ))% , #      $$ &   3&4



 )** & 

  (   & 0"(5 6

    7%" &  '(& '

, #    7/&

# & / *    # &   / 5   3&   &   & / *   

1(



  *        5     5 " ( 

 969  3&      )" 

 5 & 4

)"

*  5 %   , #  , / 

*  !8 -

  ) / 

:;* 5  &, ( &

"

 5 /

*  4

     &   "   ) 8" ;    ;   $9 $9 *

 # 

 & & / , *  ;   < / 

  & &  & ( !

 , *  & 

%<& ( &,

, * )5   9

(7&    

7 3&

 , * 

)5    &5 ( &    5 % ** & *   &

.



  "

# '"(



( &

 

3& *    !

 , *  & /& & %  )** , * ,

  969

"

(

   3&    

 / 

 9/& , *  / 

5 3& # # & "

5   **



4

)"

*  5   ( & & " ( 5, *  ; /& & 

  , & 



(    5!

 , *  &  

 9   ,   ="

  &  &  8   5    / 

 > :;* 5  &

 **  59 & * 

& (

5   

#  #

5   5&*   9 3&    **

.



  "

# & '"(

9 & / "

 

 

 & &

/ " ( 5, *  /& & & 3& 

)"  *  5   

 99   & & (

*   5* &    !8 -   ) / 

 /   9   3&  5    &  **    

'   5    969/  &

  

 $  & ( " &  &

 



 / "

&5 9 & /  ( & (

*     5  &   #  ?8*  "   "  

 "

  "

 

#  &  -   .

  /       "   &

%  < "

   )((     & / *   /& && 

5 ,

 & **  6 <   &  & , #  %   5* #

 

      "  * #5  :          "     &

     " 

:

*   3& #( "      /  &   "  "

"



 



 *  "

 $ 3&  ( "



0"  *   " #

8  *     <  

 & 



  (    5     &    5*   

5*     #  "

"      

 (   ="  5  (   *

" "

&            /& &  *

 

  3&

*      (  5 

   

 

  

 # &

   5 & .

 ( ( &   / &

 5   ?8*  "  &  /& &       ( 

( &"& 

 

   ( *   

     3&  "

 /   8 5    $)*+,-  -.)+  /  $+)+0   )12)*)& 333($( 4 &

8     (  )<<-'  &  #   *    /&  /   " ( (       %< & ( &  

*   3&

'

, #  /  &  &   & ( 

  "  1       " 

  *    /   



( &

   / &  &  & "(& & *  "

1 &   )<<-'   " 

*    "  /         ( # *

"      *    #    &   5  #   / 

  (   *  *   &    

  %<  

*   '& / & 

    

 5 < / 

  "  

        

  

  



      

!



    

  !   

   "# $"##%  

!       

   



   &  $  "##%     

     ' 





  

   (   '       )

     

  $ *          '! +         

  +   

            



   '    '    



          

    

                       

  

     

    '

!

                ,   

       

          !

        

    

             '              

 '              

          -  .       

    

 

   '   

 

       

  

       

           

     &$"##%  

/  

        '    

    

 

       !     



      

    

 

  + 0                         /    

   !



     '          

  '      '     

  '    

     !1    

)

  2  '

3 )4-"&& "##% "#5"###     

  

     !



  



 

   +   

    

 

 %    

 !     + 6  0    

 

    

  /

        

    

      !         -  .  

 

  

  - 

7  <  &  *  

   #  &  **    (  &   

"

 5* 

  $9 $9/& 

  &  &  /   , *      *     ,  

  

5 , *  )5  , /   (    5!

  , *  &  %< & ( &,   969 !

  , * 

"

(  3&      / 

 9  /&   , *  ;  /  

5    3&   #   #  &

"

5   **  

 

 4

  )"  *  5 ="

 (     & (   *       9  -   .



   & & / " ( 5  3& 

4

)"  *  5     

   99    & & (

*   5* &    !8 - ) / 

/ 9  <  &  

  8*  #       &

55"    9  5 & '

"

 < 5  

;

"5;

*" # '"(

@- A)5    & 

 

"

 

5 #  : (  

(B & *  

5  # &

 *

  

%  , *    4 !

 , *  & "

&

(B , * < /  & 

"

 !

 , * 

- &  & 

5 , *   /& &

 

**      " (  5         3&"  "  &  : & 

 

   ( *  

      

"(& & & 

 " *

      *  " ( 5   #(   "

&  :

 / "  #



 #:< "

  /&

# *        "* #5  :     "  &        " 

:

*     )

(#  & **   3& 0"(5   4 '( C"(    3& *     

**    :

   :  " (  !

  , *  &   "

    %$     $$  

    

0617)12

&

(  & '* 1(:  D & 

: