← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2360/2016dismissed

Ramesh Chand v. General Public & ANR

2018-05-07Mr. Justice Arun Monga4 pages





     



 !""#$%$&' ()*+

,"%-- &.

//"00 &!

1"2%3% "&"2 0 340$#  &!-"2  "%/&."&!%  !"#$%&' ()%)(*$

2"%"&!'

2 5 0$6*"&$2.7# !"8$!-

2 &.""/-300*.7# !"* 2!-" //"00 &! &"2!-"2"%/&."&!% 99999 )(*$+& //"00 &!:/0 $&!$$%$& ";30 2"#&.//" 0 ; $&%!!-"

<3.;,"&! &.."#2""+)=*8-"2"4(!-"%3$!2, &. !2($&<3&#!$& $0". ; $&%!!-".""&. &!%%""6$&;2"0$"#22"#!$&. !"4$2!-*- % 4""&.$%,$%%".4(!-"!2$ 032! &. $2,".4(!-">8"2//"00 !" 32!7$."<3.;,"&! &.."#2"". !".= -"%3$! 2","&!$&".8 %$&%!$!3!".4(!-"/0 $&!$&!-" /2",$%"!- !-$%. !"4$2!-8 %?) %/"2!-"2"#2.!-"2";$%!"2 !-" ";$%!2 2$2!- &." !- 2$. 4 .*43!8 %82&;0(2"#2.".

$&!-", !2$#30 !$&#"2!$$# !" %=? %8"00 %$&!-"!-"2#&#"2&". %#-02"#2.%4( 2.#-0.3# !$&*-$8 &$:.""&. &! -"."/ 2!,"&!8 %2"@3"%!".!2"#!$(!-". !"4$2!-*43! 00!-""2!% 8"&!$&7 $&;$7$&;# 3%" #!$&!!-"/0 $&!$!$&%!$!3!"!-"%3$! ""&. &!  :"&"2 0  340$#  8 %  /2#"".".  "A:/ 2!"



""&. &!: 2.#-0.3# !$&8 % 0%/2#""."."A:/ 2!"

0 $&!$%!"//".$&!!-"8$!&"%%4A % B: &.423;-!& 2"#2.4$2!-#"2!$$# !"A *%#-00" 7$&;#"2!$$# !" %A  &.%,"

, 26"..#3,"&!% -"!2$ 032!*&!-"4 %$%!-" 2","&!$&"."7$."&#"* .$%,$%%".4(!-"%3$!4(-0.$&;!- !%$&#"!-". "4$2!-$&!-"#"2!$$# !" 8 %?)*43!$&!-"!2 &%"2#"2!$$# !"!-"% ,"8 %,"&!$&". % =?)*%!-"2"8 %.34!2"; 2.$&;!-"4$2!-#"2!$$# !" &.!2 &%"2 #"2!$$# !"  A   &.  A   $%%3".  &  ?+=  &  !-"  , !2$#30 !$& #"2!$$# !"*8-%"/-!#/(/3!2!- % 26:*%-8".-$%. "4$2!- %=? 0&;8$!-!-" //" 0* ))C):2/0 #$&;& 2"#2.  !-"  $&2, !$&  . ".  =  4! $&".  3&."2  !-"  $;-!  ! &2, !$&#!%3;-! %&&"A32" :4(8 ( ..$!$& 0"7$."&#"* /27".!-". "4$2!-!-" //"00 &!:/0 $&!$ %?)*$"*!-""&!2( %  /"2  !-"  4$2!-  2"#2.    1$00 ;"   &%8  8 %    (" 2  ?)

  -" 2","&!$&".  /$"#"    "7$."&#"  $%  "%%"&!$ 0  &.  &"#"%% 2(  2  !-" .<3.$# !$&!-"0$%*2*4!-!-"32!%- 7"&&:%3$!"!-" //"00 &!: /0 $&!$  % 2"0"7 &!  .#3,"&!%  - .  &!  4""& 423;-!  &  2"#2.  &0( /-!#/$"%8"2"!-"2"- 2, &./2"<3.$#"830.4"# 3%".$&# %" . "4$2!-$%#22"#!"*2*$&!-", !2$#30 !$&#"2!$$# !"*$!$%,"&!$&". %=? &.$&!-"/2$, 2(%#-0* %=?)*8-"2" %!-" #!3 0. " 4$2!-$% ?)-" !!"%!"#/$"%A : &.

02" .(&2"#2.*8-$#-8"2"%3$#$"&!!/27"!-". !"4$2!- &.*!-3%* /2 (".2%"!!$&;: %$."!-"$&.$&;%3&."2#- 00"&;"4(."#2""$&;!-"%3$! - 7"-" 2.!-"0" 2&".#3&%"02!-" //"00 &!* //2 $%".!-"



/ /"2  46  &.    !-"  7$"8  !- !  !-"2"  $%  &  2#"  &.  ,"2$!  $&  !-" %34,$%%$&% 2 0$6 -"2"- .4""& %/ !"0$!$; !$& !!-"4"-"%!%$,$0 20( %$!3 !"./"2%&%%""6$&;#22"#!$&. !"4$2!-4(, 6$&;!-",(3&;"2 !!-"&"2"#2.".$&!-"2"#2.!-"%#-0-" 2","&!$&".%3$!- . 4""&$0".$&&# %"!-". !"4$2!-$%=?)*!-" ;"!-" //"00 &!:/0 $&!$830.- 7"4""&C(" 2%*2*&"A/0 & !$&- %#," 2!-$&&!;"!!$&;!-". !"#22"#!".$&$!$ 00( !!-"!$,""&!"2! $&$&;!-" ".3# !$&*.32$&;!-"%#-020 !"2&-"$&2, !$&4! $&".3&."2!-"

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

$&;%    #!  &.  0 8  22$7".  !  4(  !-"  32!%  4"08  830.  &!  42$&;  !-" %34,$%%$& 2 0$68$!-$&!-"2" 0, ! "& 40","!2, .$"2"&!/$&$&!- &!-"&" 22$7". ! -" //"00 &!$%"%!//".!#0 $,!-"2"0$" !4"0 !"%! ;" $,$0 27$"8$%! 6"&4(!-$%32!

,-. 

/

. 01233455 2#    

6%  21



235 +."#$.".&?)

2!-"2" %&%%! !". 47"*&;23&.2$&!"2"2"&#"$% , ."3!//" 0%! &.%.$%,$%%". 67+-   )(*$

853 &'9:% *323501 ;5

 <5;

*323 2= <5;